ipl-logo

Tiananmen Square Protest Analysis

3265 Words14 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Aftermath of the tiananmen square protest

TIANANMEN SQUARE PROTEST

Evelyn Fung
World History B2
May 6th, 2015
Mr. Bisset 2,377 words

Deng Xiaoping’s economic reforms created many unexpected problems, including improved living standards as the gap between the rich and the poor widened. The new policies admitted only Western investments and tourists but also including Western political ideas. Increasing numbers of Chinese students have studied abroad and learned about the West. In Deng’s view, the benefits of opening the economy exceeded the risks. As Chinese students learnt more about democracy, they started to question China’s lack of political freedom.1 The causes of the Tiananmen Square protest include the death of Hu Yaobang, political corruption, economic …show more content…

Chai Ling was one of the most radical student leaders in the Tiananmen protest. A documentary controversy started about her view on the Tiananmen Square protest through footage from a documentary titled The Gate of Heavenly Peace, shows viewers parts of an interview between Chai and reporter Philip Cunningham from May 28, 1989, a week prior to the Tiananmen Square Incident. In the footage, Chai makes the following statements that she wouldn’t stay in the Square herself. She declared “her situation different as she was on the government’s blacklist and she doesn’t want to be destroyed by the government. She stated to not know if people would find her selfish, saying that people should continue the work she started. That a democratic movement can’t succeed with one person.”3 This can be inferred to a hubristic act as her excessive pride caused her downfall which can be compared to Oedipus Rex. His excessive pride as king of Thebes caused conflicts between others and his own downfall involving harsh punishments. The only slight difference is that Oedipus realized his wrongdoings, he punished himself by blinding. But in this case, even after Chai realized her wrongdoings as being a leader of the Tiananmen Square protests, she still continued to live her life without any shame or …show more content…

China reported that about 500 to 2,600 people had died in clashes on June 4 and that many of the dead were soldiers of the Peoples Liberation Army. China insisted that there was no massacre of students in Tiananmen Square and in fact the soldiers cleared Tiananmen Square of demonstrators without any shooting. The Chinese government also declared that unarmed soldiers who had entered Tiananmen Square in the two days prior to June 4 were set on fire and lynched with their corpses hung from buses. Other soldiers were incinerated when army vehicles were torched with soldiers unable to evacuate and many others were badly beaten by violent mob attacks. For seven weeks leading up to June 4, the Chinese government was extraordinarily restrained in not confronting those who paralyzed the center of China’s central capital area. According to the Chinese government’s verdict, it is inferred that China’s government was acting as the victims, as they denied having done any wrongdoings. This can be compared to the “comfort women” during WWII. “Comfort women” were basically women from various countries that were forced to “comfort the Japanese soldiers”. They were abused and raped day till night, but Japan denied this until today. The Japanese government denied these efforts during WWII, which is similar to the Chinese government during the Tiananmen Square

Show More
Related
1347 Words | 6 Pages

“A Long Way Gone: Memoirs of a Boy Soldier” is a moving war story about the author, Ishmael Beah, and his life growing up in the african country. Sierra Leone is the setting during the civil war which spanned from March of 1991 to January of 2002. Ishmael provides a stance against child soldiers, and has stuck with that view ever since he was rehabilitated. This book presents strong first hand encounters and vivid war stories. This helps prove the argument that child soldiering is a cruel act, and by using rehabilitation, victims would be able to return to regular life.

Read More
1989 Words | 8 Pages

The government at the time was in a desperate bid to shape their relations with China so that they can improve trade. Covering up the real information about this incident could have been a desperate move to maintain the relationship between the United States of America and China. Nokes is particularly successful in explaining the massacre with relations to the racism against the Chinese immigrants that was particularly famous in the Pacific Northwest. He provides a short chronology of some of the anti-Chinese attitudes to make the readers understand just how deep the cruelty against the Chinese was. He goes on to mention that the cruelty against the Chinese people was also going on in other parts of the United States such as Washington, Wyoming and California.

Read More
586 Words | 3 Pages

Political freedom was not something that can be found under the rule of Mao. Mao believed in socialism, dictatorships of proletarians, communism, and Marxism-Leninism of Mao-Zedong thought. His work “The Little Red Book” contained all of his ideals commonly known as Mao Zedong thoughts. Within the cultural revolution set forth by Mao, but upheld by Deng, all of China had to refer to “The Four Basic Principles -1979”. They go as follows, “ 1.

Read More
624 Words | 3 Pages

On June 5th, 1984, two years after Chins death, the federal prosecutors charged the two white males of violating Chins civic rights. The defense lawyers won a federal retrial for these two murderers in Cincinnati. The two white men never spent a full day in jail even after the second trial. Chins case was never brought to justice because of this his mother returned to China in noticing that the justice system failed her

Read More
1395 Words | 6 Pages

Despite the good that Xiaoping did for China economically, he was far from being a perfect leader. The handling of 1989 Tiananmen Square Protest and Massacre still showed the terrible side of the Chinese Communist Party. Following Xiaoping there was a time where it seemed as if China was starting to open up more. This would change under the leadership of President Xi Jinping. Xi Jinping took over with a vision of a new Chinese state.

Read More
551 Words | 3 Pages

In this essay “No one died in Tiananmen Square” by William Lutz, it is evident that the events displayed confirm the warnings that Orwell shared in Nineteen Eighty – Four. This essay resembled the novel by George Orwell in many different ways, both exploit the government to manipulate the mind of an individual over the actual reality and both governments overuse and abuse there powers. In “No one died in Tiananmen Square” the government uses violence to stop the peaceful protesters. This is similar to 1984 because the totalitarian government in Oceania uses violence if they do not obey the rules of Big Brother. A quote from 1984, from part 2 of chapter 10 displaying violence for commenting thought crime is “One of the men had smashed his fist into Julia’s solar

Read More
747 Words | 3 Pages

In the article, “China Censors: The Tiananmen Square Anniversary Will Not Be Tweeted” it wrote, “Tanks and soldiers were sent in to control the crowds.” In 1989 some students were protesting against the Chinese government, and it got out of control and people were injured. People all over the world were reporting on this topic. This may emphasize why we need to censor the world, so violent protests will not occur. This is the opposite though, without protests no change will occur.

Read More
501 Words | 3 Pages

Nanjing Massacre is one of the most representable incidents in the history of the Japanese militarist invading China during the World War II. December 13, 1937, Japanese army captured the capital of the republic China Nanjing over six weeks. During this period, Japanese Army murdered Chinese civilians and disarmed combatants numbering an estimated 40,000 to over 300,000 people. After World War I, Japan 's expansion in China by the Anglo-American powers curbed. China 's northern Expedition weakened the Japanese economic in China, and urge the Japanese government to adjust its China policy , the annexation of Northeast China to speed up the pace.

Read More
563 Words | 3 Pages

All this leads to is “major losses to public assets and to the interests of the states and people,” (Buckley). In a Chinese Former Official Faces Corruption Trial by Chris Buckley presents a leader named Zhou Yougkang who is very corrupt. He took advantage of others to gain power which hurts the government. Hurting the government affects the people in their everyday lives. That is why the people of that Society had put them on trial for ruining their government.

Read More
765 Words | 4 Pages

In the article, it reads, " Criticism of the government isn't tolerated, and people who speak out are routinely imprisoned. China's government throws people in jail if they are caught talking poorly about the government, or using a VPN (virtual private networks). " People are thrown in jail, just for talking poorly of the government. Talk about cruel, and

Read More
1875 Words | 8 Pages

For the CCP (Chinese Communist Party) has subjected Tibet and Tibetan buddhism to countless horrors, including the exile of the 14th Dalai Lama, the destruction of Tibetan Buddhist temples, and the massacre of many Tibetan Buddhist Lamas. Free Tibet wishes to gain international support in protesting for the autonomy and sovereignty of Tibet from China, and emphasizes emotional and tragic atrocities as significant reasons. The simple understanding of the location/headquarters of organizations aimed at freeing Tibet are considerable in and of themselves, such as Free Tibet which is based in London and shows the international issue that Tibet has become. Additionally, protests organized by Free Tibet often take place outside of embassies or conferences of international matters, such as the recent protest, “Protest of Tashi Wangchuk” (Russell), outside of a Chinese embassy in London regarding the detainment of Tashi Wangchuk, a Tibetan language advocate. This highlights a complex understanding of the necessity for international repercussions and pressures on the CCP, as clearly this tactic has significantly aided the Tibetan movement as the CCP has recently made small steps toward greater autonomy for Tibet within the Chinese government.

Read More
902 Words | 4 Pages

Jasmine Ware Ms.Johnson Period 5 28 February 2018 Wealth inequality: a growing issue in America Wealth inequality all but gave birth to our nation. Between taxation, navigation acts, and writs of assistance, the colonies were engulfed with laws that caused disparity and created social classes, leading to the colonies separating from Great Britain during the revolutionary war in 1783. Inequality has been rampant throughout many parts of the world. It also has been widely prevalent within the United States. When it comes to inequality, not many people think of it in terms of wealth.

Read More
755 Words | 4 Pages

“Civil Disobedience" is an essay written by Henry David Thoreau who was an “American transcendentalist society in 1849” (“Give Me Liberty”, chap 9). In this essay Thoreau argued that people should not allow their government to override or weaken their consciences because they have a duty to avoid allowing any agreement to authorize the government to make them the proper workers of discrimination. An evidence that gives us this form of information is “The government itself, which is only the mode which the people have chosen to execute their will, is equally liable to be abused and perverted before the people can act through it” (“Civil Disobedience”, par 1, pg 1). Thoreau meant that the government sometimes proves itself useful and that it

Read More
1004 Words | 5 Pages

On the other hand, it leaves a kind of profound thinking about the typical ordinary Chinese ideology and how great is the impact of such a decision on people’s

Read More
1319 Words | 6 Pages

Secondly, the Cultural Revolution and the chaos and disaster this had on the Chinese population, especially through the “Down to the Countryside movement” and finally, the Cult of Mao and what the idolisation and glorification of Mao meant for the future of China. Mao’s introduction of the Great Leap Forward policy and the impacts and effects this had on the Chinese population as well as its role in the introduction of the Cultural Revolution played a key role in shaping China into what it is today. The plan’s failure lead to Mao’s loss of power, which resulted in Mao introducing the Cultural Revolution in China. Unfortunately, Mao’s five-year plan was a disaster, and caused the death of an estimated twenty to forty

Read More

More about Tiananmen Square Protest Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document