ipl-logo

Double Effect And Physician Aid In Dying

1301 Words6 Pages

Technological advances have prolonged human life and changed not only what it means to practice medicine, but what it means to be alive. In some cases, patients turn to their physicians to assist them in dying. The purpose of this essay is not to promote physician aid in dying or even provide a stance on the subject. Rather, the purpose is to make readers question when it is morally permissible to “kill” a patient. Through defining the doctrine of double effect, physician aid in dying and exploring the types of medical cases where killing a patient is morally permissible, I argue that there is no moral difference between physician aid in dying and the doctrine of double effect.
Originating from “Thomas Aquinas’…discussion of the permissibility …show more content…

While the doctrine of double effect is legally, clinically and ethically permissible, physician aid in dying is not legally or clinically permissible in all 50 states even though the result is the same, i.e., the death of the patient. This point will be further examined later in the essay, for now, it is essential to define physician aid in dying. “Assisted dying is typically used to describe an action in which an individual’s death is intentionally hastened by the administration of a drug or other lethal substance. This may take the form of either assisted suicide or euthanasia” (Volker, 2016, 30). Physician aid in dying (PAD) can therefore be defined as a licensed physician providing a patient with a lethal dose of a drug that the patient may use to end their own life. Furthermore, patients in this definition are terminally ill and request the aid of a physician voluntarily. Keeping this in mind, I will now move towards exploring the types of cases where it is currently permissible to kill a …show more content…

male that had a cardiac arrest. While Phil was successfully resuscitated, he sustained severe brain damage. After three weeks in the ICU, he remained dependent upon mechanical ventilation. He was unresponsive, but not dead by neurological criteria. After several meetings between his family and clinicians, they agreed to withdraw the ventilator and let him die. The attending removed Phil’s endotracheal tube. Phil developed gasping respirations, 8 times a minute and appeared to be struggling. The physician then administered doses of morphine, 0.1 mg/kg every 5-30 minutes, titrated to Phil’s comfort. After approximately two hours, Phil developed bradycardic arrest and died (Altered Clinical Case from Class on Sept. 28th).
What makes this a case that passes the doctrine of double effect is the use of titrated morphine to relieve Phil’s pain. While death was foreseen, the clinician’s intent was not to hasten Phil’s death, nor was death the means by which the physician sought to relieve Phil’s pain. Based on this, the clinician’s actions are morally

Show More
Related

Hill Bosscher Case Summary

1039 Words | 5 Pages

Thus, the patient must resort to using complex technology, machinery, or other’s cooperation to end his or her life. The issue is further complicated because the machinery and technology that would be used by patients to end his or her own life would most likely be produced by the collaboration of doctors. In this sense, it is like the doctor is aiding physically in the ending of a patient’s life (154). This is where it becomes difficult to draw a line between physician assisted suicide and euthanasia. It also follows, that the reasoning we would use to allow physician assisted suicide would also be the same criteria to allow

Read More

Dr. Fletcher's Arguments Against Physician Assisted Suicide

1841 Words | 8 Pages

Since Oregon began allowing physician-assisted suicide of the terminally ill in 1997, more than seven hundred people have ended their own lives with prescription medications in the state alone (NPR.org). Physician-assisted suicide is not only becoming a topic of controversy in the United States, but foreign countries as well. Supporters of the issue believe that competent people who do not have a chance of longevity should be able to choose their fate. Opponents argue that terminal diagnoses can be inaccurate, or that the person with the illness may not be capable of making informed decisions. Assisted suicide refers to the act of one giving another the “Instructions, means, or capability to bring about their own demise.”

Read More

Physician-Assisted Suicide Cons

764 Words | 4 Pages

The topic of Physician-assisted suicide, or physician aid-in-dying, is a highly debated topic, especially when it comes down to whether this action be legal or not. The definition of Physician-assisted suicide can be defined as the act of intentionally killing yourself with the aid of a medical professional, such as a physician. The practice of Physician-assisted suicide still remains illegal in forty-five states excluding the states of Oregon, Vermont, Montana, California, and Washington. Although states have tried to make this practice legal, the practice of Physician-assisted suicide has become a crime in most. The practice of Physician-assisted suicide should not be illegal.

Read More

Why Is Physician Assisted Suicide Wrong

849 Words | 4 Pages

Jacob Bresler Mrs. Singleton Honors English IV 4 May 2015 Physician Assisted Suicide: Right or Wrong? Physician Assisted Suicide, or PAS, is “suicide of a patient suffering from an incurable disease, effected by the taking of lethal drugs provided by a doctor” (Merriam-Webster). Most people cannot dictate whether PAS is an ethical, legal, or emotional issue. However, the fact cannot be denied that these suffering patients do not deserve to continue on suffering; they should be able to make their own decisions regarding their own lives. Deeming Physician Assisted Suicide illegal

Read More

Physician Assisted Death Argumentative Essay

814 Words | 4 Pages

Physician-assisted death is the practice in which a physician provides a mentally competent patient with the means to take his/her own life, usually in the form of prescribing death-dealing medications. It first became legal in the United States in Oregon in 1998. It is now legal in four other states: Washington, California, Montana, and Vermont. In order for one to exercise their right to die this way, the law states that the patient must be at least 18 years old, be mentally competent, be diagnosed with a terminal illness that will lead to death within six months, and must wait at least fifteen days before filling the death-dealing prescriptions. This controversial practice has raised the question of whether or not it is ethical for a physician

Read More

Physician Assisted Suicide Pros And Cons

1049 Words | 5 Pages

Physician assisted suicide has been a controversial topic in the medical world for centuries. Physician assisted suicide (PAS) is the act in which a doctor provides their terminally ill patients with the knowledge and means to commit suicide. Doctors must inform their patients on the lethal drugs that may be used and the process of the suicide. Physician assisted suicide has been legalized in a few states throughout the United States including Oregon, Montana, Vermont, Washington, and Bernalillo County in New Mexico. Although many families and doctors agree with the idea of physician assisted suicide, even more people disagree with “mercy killing” because it exploits the doctor's hippocratic oath and may violate the constitution.

Read More

Arguments Against Physician Aid In Dying

1230 Words | 5 Pages

Physician aid in dying in those with chronic/terminal illnesses has been a long debated bioethical issue. It’s important to address what exactly physician aid in dying entails when trying to address whether this is an acceptable medical prescription. Ethical principles involved include those of beneficence, non-maleficence, autonomy, and justice. Those who may reason for or against this, may argue differing ethical perspectives on each of these ethical principles. Arguments for this topic may address the idea that the patient has the right to end suffering.

Read More

Physician Assisted Suicide Essay

798 Words | 4 Pages

Geertruida Postma, a Dutch physician in the Netherlands, was the first to openly practice a physician-assisted death in 1971. The patient was her mother. She was found guilty of murder, but her penalty only consisted of a one-week suspended jail sentence and a one-year probation. This minimal sentence made other physicians more comfortable to come forward about doing the same (“Euthanasia”). Fast forward 29 years, and in 1990 Jack Kevorkian, also known as “Dr. Death” assisted a woman named Janet Adkins, suffering from Alzheimer’s, end her life.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Legalizing Physician Assisted Suicide

1591 Words | 7 Pages

Physician-assisted suicide also, known as assisted suicide, involves a physician who provides a person with knowledge or means or both to commit suicide. In physician-assisted suicide, the physicians provide counsel about the lethal doses of drug needed to end life, and prescribes such lethal doses or supplies the drug. The physician is involved indirectly in the life ending process in the physician-assisted suicide. There are many issues that have increased concern in response to this controversial topic. If a person wants to end his or her life for any reason is in the state where physician-assisted suicide is illegal, then he or she may have some legal options to hasten his or her death, including cessation of medical treatment and refusing to eat.

Read More

Essay On Physician Assisted Suicide

702 Words | 3 Pages

Meghan Wong Period 5 2/12/15 Proposal for Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide (PAS) 1. The controversial issue I have chosen is about the current ban of euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide. Euthanasia, sometimes referred as “mercy killing,” is the medical term of a physician administering any lethal agent to end a patients’ life. The two main types of euthanasia are active and passive; active euthanasia is defined as the physician directly administering the agent to the patient, while passive euthanasia is when the physician purposely withholds whatever life support the patient is on. Physician-assisted suicide, on the other hand, is similarly related to active euthanasia; the physician provides the patient with euthanasia though medicinal means, and allows the patient to be in-control of his death.

Read More

Hastening Death Critical Analysis

653 Words | 3 Pages

This is significant because this supports the fact that this is not an instance of killing to the patient, but by withdrawing the artificial support for the patients, it “allows for the patient’s disease to complete its natural course” (Jansen, 106). In addition, one’s dignity of being worthy of honor or respect can be an important feeling of one’s self. Susan Behuniak portrayed the point involving dignity to the pros of hastening death by mentioning a statement from a patient in the Montana constitutional that depict the terminally ill point of view. This patient had mention that if there comes a point where his suffering is unbearable then there should be an option for him to die peacefully by taking a pill for that purpose (Behuniak). He also mention that it is his life and decision so having “the right and responsibility to make that critical choice” should be available for him (Behuniak).

Read More

Essay On Physician Assisted Suicide

690 Words | 3 Pages

We know that the role of the doctor is always to save a patient’s live. What if the only way to save save a suffering patient’s life is their death. The highest ethical imperative of doctors should be to provide care in whatever way best serves patients' interests, in accord with each patient's wishes, not with a theoretical commitment to preserve life no matter what the cost in suffering.... The greatest harm we can do is to consign a desperate patient to unbearable suffering—or force the patient to seek out a stranger like Dr. Kevorkian.(2004)

Read More

Essay On Physician Assisted Suicide

852 Words | 4 Pages

Physician assisted suicide is when a physician provides the means required to commit suicide, including prescribing lethal amounts of harmful drugs to a patient. In the United States alone, there is great controversy about physician assisted suicide. The issue is whether physician assisted suicide is murder or an act of sympathy for the patient. The main point is that terminally ill patients should have a right to physician assisted suicide if it meets their needs and is done properly. Physician assisted suicide is an appropriate action for the terminally ill that want to end their life in peace before it ends at the hands of the terminal disease.

Read More

Physician Assisted Suicide Speech

1141 Words | 5 Pages

The practice of physician-assisted suicide is not a modern phenomenon. A young woman suffering from cancer became the first person known to die under the law on physician-assisted suicide in the state of Oregon when she took a lethal dose of drugs provided by her doctor in March 1998. The Oregon Death with Dignity Act passed a vote in November 1997, and for the past twenty years it has been a response to the progress of modern medicine. The issue of physician-assisted suicide has been the subject of the heated dispute in current years. Many people worry that legalizing physician-assisted suicide is opening the floodgate to non-critical patient suicides and other abuses and will decrease the value of human life.

Read More

Deontological Ethics: The Ethical Ethics Of Assisted Suicide

1252 Words | 6 Pages

Assisted suicide is a rather controversial issue in contemporary society. When a terminally ill patient formally requests to be euthanized by a board certified physician, an ethical dilemma arises. Can someone ethically end the life of another human being, even if the patient will die in less than six months? Unlike traditional suicide, euthanasia included multiple individuals including the patient, doctor, and witnesses, where each party involved has a set of legal responsibilities. In order to understand this quandary and eventually reach a conclusion, each party involved must have their responsibilities analyzed and the underlying guidelines of moral ethics must be investigated.

Read More

More about Double Effect And Physician Aid In Dying

Related Topics

Open Document