ipl-logo

Explain Why Minor League Owners Should Not Have To Pay Minor Baseball Players

994 Words4 Pages

The pay of minor league baseball players are viewed differently by different groups of people. The owners, some fans, and minor league players who made it to the major leagues say their pay should not be changed. However, those who are career minor leaguers and other fans say that their pay should be increased. There is a bill that might be passed by Congress that will exempt their pay from minimum wage rights. The Major League owners should not have to pay their minor league players more money because that would add to the team’s payroll and their positions are viewed as an apprenticeship. The owners of major league organizations should not be forced to pay all of their players more money because their positions are viewed as an apprenticeship. …show more content…

In the article “Congress' 'Save America's Pastime Act' Would Allow Teams to Pay Minor-Leaguers Less than Minimum Wage,” Mike Axlsa explains the payroll that the teams should follow to add the $300 per player. He writes, “At any given moment during the season, there are about 4,500 players on minor-league rosters. Paying each of them an extra $300 per month would equal another $8.1 million total for the season. That's about one-third of what the Atlanta Braves will pay Adrian Gonzalez to play for the New York Mets this season” (Axlsa). He goes on saying that there have been multiple lawsuits trying to get their pay up but it has not succeeded. Axlsa even claims that MLB teams do not care for their minor leaguers well being. In the article, “Federal Budget Bill Could Affect Minor Leaguers’ Pay,” David Waldstein disproves that by explaining that organizations give out $25,000 in bonuses per year to about sixty of each organization’s players. He says, “Teams also pay lucrative signing bonuses to many, though not all, minor leaguers. According to M.L.B.’s 2016 figures, about 1,850 players received bonuses of at least $50,000,” (Waldstein). If the organizations did not care for their players, why would they give them …show more content…

He writes, “Minor Leaguers are not required to be paid minimum wage or have other basic protections even part-timers at fast food restaurants are entitled,” (Calcaterra). He goes on saying that the owners are greedy and the players will go on strike for better pay. But, in the article, “Baseball’s minor leaguers pursue their dreams below the poverty line” Kent Babb and Jorge Castillo quote a former minor leaguer, Wilmer Difo, who was in the minor leagues for seven years before getting his short shot in the MLB. Babb and Castillo quote Difo saying, “In reality, I just wanted a chance,” (qtd in Babb and Castillo). Difo also says that many minor leaguers don’t make it to the major leagues but they all say it is worth what they

Show More
Related
623 Words | 3 Pages

Have you ever wondered why National Football League players, known as NFL players, make so much money? I think NFL players should continue to earn such high salaries for the reasons that follow; they entertain millions, risk getting life altering injuries, and create loads of revenue. To put the second reason into perspective, getting tackled by a 300 pound defensive lineman is comparable to getting in a car accident at 30 miles per hour without a seat belt on (Wisconsin Trooper Association). That can happen to just one player upwards of 20 times a game. National Football League players, known as NFL players; deserve as much money as they get because of how they entertain people.

Read More
275 Words | 2 Pages

Should College Softball Players get Paid? Should college softball players get paid? College softball players should not get paid because they are there to play and have fun also they are there to want to play, not to be forced to just have the money. The pure love of the sport gets lost.

Read More
391 Words | 2 Pages

Players should also get paid because of the amount of money they have. Some college athletes aren't as rich as others, so colleges should give college athletes money so they have a decent amount of money. A college athlete would be putting a lot of energy and work into playing a sport. Some athletes families aren't as rich as others either. If colleges give athletes money, athletes will probably send some of their money back home with their families.

Read More
1065 Words | 5 Pages

So should they not be paid accordingly? These athletes deserve to be paid for the blood and sweat they put in to make it to the next level. By taking a stand together for the pay of the student-athletes the future of college sports is

Read More
1015 Words | 5 Pages

Next, if the hours these athletes were put in, they would be making a large some less than minimum wage for an average employee. Division one college athletes on scholarship should be getting paid because of the mass amount of money brought into the university by their play, they do not have time to work jobs during their four years at school, and it is indentured servitude. Young superb athletes at the division 1 level are being used for their talents and gifts they have to offer.

Read More
622 Words | 3 Pages

Getting paid in college would help teach these players some responsibility before they are rewarded a big NFL/NBA contract. Players could make just enough money to be forced to make choices that can pave the way for more responsible decision making when the financial stakes become high. Many players will learn the value of money and the responsibility that comes from holding down a job. College football player’s should get paid to play because these players put themselves at risk for injury, college football is a job, not p.e, and it will help players adjust to college socially and economically. Colleges and the NCAA can make money selling jerseys and other souvenirs that might include the likeness of players, yet the actual players never receive a

Read More
886 Words | 4 Pages

Minor league baseball player train and practice for a long hour and non-stop for 60 to 70 hours a week and only get paid 1,100 to 2,150 a month per player. Critics may argue that they would have an opportunity to get into the major league from the minor league, but the chance of getting into the major league and how long it might take is too small to consider. The chance of getting

Read More
1706 Words | 7 Pages

Rather it focuses on playing for money, which is not ethical. Money is important but ultimately these individuals are there to play a sport and gain an education, not to become rich. These individuals are not employees and paying them would then eliminate many people playing for the right reasons, because they love the game. An article published talking about how much the sports industry has changed over the years says, “Some fans say college athletics are more interesting to watch because the athletes play purely for the pride of their school and hopes of some day being signed to a professional organization” (Jones, 2012). These athletes make watching college sports more interesting because they are not there for the money, and quite frankly should not be there solely for the

Read More
567 Words | 3 Pages

The first reason why college athletes should not be paid is because the sport that they play is not a job, it is a privilege. College athletics is something that only a handful of people get to experience. You’re lucky to be able to even play a college sport, let alone get paid for doing it. Some people don’t realize how lucky they are

Read More
1073 Words | 5 Pages

A final reason they should not get paid is that it will cause division amongst the team. "When one athlete is making a considerable amount of money, while the other is not, there will be conflict" (Price). Let us say one athlete is the quarterback while the other is an offensive lineman. The quarterback is a much more popular position. More people will notice and pay for gear with the quarterback's name than the offensive lineman.

Read More
978 Words | 4 Pages

The million dollar question; should college athletes be paid? This is an immense debate, but if you were to ask me, I would say yes, college athletes should be paid. There are a plethora of reasons why college athletes should get paid. College athletes should get paid because of the amount of time they put into their sport, the amount of money everyone else is making off of them, and their overall importance to the school. There are a myriad of reasons that people can argue the opposite way, but, the reasons they should get paid definitely outweigh the reasons they shouldn’t get paid.

Read More
1538 Words | 7 Pages

College athletes deserve to be paid because they are the only ones not being paid in the college sports industry. The National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) generates eleven billion dollars annually, some of which could, and should go to college athletes. “USA Today reported last year just how much money the top 10 coaches in college football made. Nick Saban from Alabama topped the list earning roughly $5.5 million in 2013 alone” (Seibold). The coaches are making millions of dollars and the players aren’t.

Read More
1489 Words | 6 Pages

The argument made by these two professors state that Division 1 players qualify as employees under Federal Labor Laws. Since players are under this law, the McCormick’s feel players should get financially compensated due to the physical rigors and balance education simultaneously (Cooper, 2011). It’s unbelievable how this couple thinks Division 1 athletes should get paid. The privilege to attend a university that is costly on full scholarship should be more than enough. Furthermore, student-athletes received stipends as an allowance assist with their livelihood.

Read More
796 Words | 4 Pages

can all agree with me that they get underpaid compared to athletes. The money that can go towards better causes such as donating to the homeless, donating to charities, helping people, etc goes to people playing a game. Do you think that watching a game is more important than helping people that are in poverty? I didn’t think so. Also, athletes didn’t get paid this much before now,

Read More
468 Words | 2 Pages

Argumentative Paper : Athletes Are Overpaid Did you know that the highest paid Cubs player will make 19 million dollars, the average pay is 6 million dollars, and the lowest is $417,000. Even the lowest pay is pretty high. Athletes are being paid a ton of money,and it’s getting to be too much.

Read More

More about Explain Why Minor League Owners Should Not Have To Pay Minor Baseball Players

Open Document