ipl-logo

Grades And Degree By Kevin Steves Summary

1028 Words5 Pages

The author, Kevin Steves claims in his article “Grades and degrees” that we should stop the sham of objective grading and return to the apprenticeship model of education and degree award, he also offers various reasons in support of this position. In my paper I shall summarize and evaluate the argument.
Kevin emphasizes in the first paragraph of his article that our present system of awarding degrees at college and university level relies mainly on grades and he believes this explains why the current system is not efficient and uniformly impossible to assess a student’s ability to succeed in his or her future chosen field. He mentions various reasons/evidence to support his claim; he talks about the main question teachers should ask themselves …show more content…

According to Kevin this style is inconsistent and he reaches the conclusion that if we continue to interpret the grades in relation to one’s peers then there will be students with poor or excellent performances regardless of how badly they perform or how well they understand the material. Apart from highlighting the problems of our current grading system Kevin also mention possible solutions to them. He mentions the possibility of judging the grades based on the aptitude/ understanding of the material but he also found some issues with the idea like the fact that professors have different ways of presenting the materials in the same course. Other issues including the style in which the examination will be presented for example essay/ theory questions, multiple choice, oral, charts or the use of computer graphics. He explains that the way the material is presented to the students or the way the examination is structured matters a great deal because all these procedures frustrate attempts to a uniform system of grading and interpretation all the grades and the important question he highlights is “what exactly the student good at?” is it the testing process, understanding of the material or the act of understanding the way the examination is structured i.e. graphs, multiple choice, oral or …show more content…

I found this premise not clear and very vague; I did not understand the correlation of the letter grades used to represent excellent-poor to the statement of the excellent or poor student not understanding the material or performing badly. I believe that argument is weak and could have been presented in another way for example some students might do bad on the exam not because they did not understand or relate to the material but because of the conditions surrounding examinations such as overconfidence, pain attacks, nervousness, etc.
I agreed totally with premise involving the same material being presented in two different ways by two different professors and this is true professors are different some believe in theory testing, others believe in oral testing or just participation in class so this makes it difficult to rely solely on grades. For example, hybrid classes are harder and require a lot more reading than the lecture classes so a B in the hybrid class can be an A in the lecture class. I believe this premise presented here by Kevin was reasonable and

Show More
Related

Making Graduation Meaningful Summary

375 Words | 2 Pages

The main argument made by Marc Tucker, in his work “Making Graduation Meaningful: A Real Qualification System for U.S Students,” is that qualification systems provide more social mobility for students. More Specifically, Tucker argues that these systems prepare students for a better future and career by providing common curriculums that produce high expectations. Tucker address, “A common curriculum produces common expectations. Second, common exams set to a common curriculum reinforce high expectations (Tucker 5)”. This demonstrate that a common course of study will allow students to have similar beliefs of high quality.

Read More

A Brief Analysis Of Joy Alonso's Two Cheers For Examinations

621 Words | 3 Pages

However, Alonso bases her argument on inferences she has drawn from her own personal experiences. For example, a professor will not always admit when they have failed to teach a topic, or acknowledge when they are grading with frustration behind their red pen. Alonso’s conclusions would carry more weight if she were to base them on research. Overall, Alonso has constructed a strong argument about the advantages to examinations that accounts for the different points of view teachers and students

Read More

How Not To Get Into College, By Alfie Kohn

1346 Words | 6 Pages

In Alfie Kohn’s essay, the argument of grade expectations being too overvalued rests on a chain of assumptions, but can be argued. Alfie Kohn’s essay portrays that he wants students to find a variety of different purposes in school, and questions the idea of grades being too centralized. In detail, Alfie Kohn explains how students go to school not for the right reasons, but for the wrong reasons instead. For example, the author writes, “They’d scan the catalogue for college courses that promised easy A’s, sign up for new extracurricular-activities to round out their resumes, and react with gratitude when a professor told them exactly what they would have to know for the exam so they could ignore everything else” (para. 8).

Read More

College Scorecard By Annie Lowrey Summary

680 Words | 3 Pages

Annie Lowrey’s article published in the Slate targets the Department of Education and the American government. Published in 2011, Lowrey and a couple of others quoted in this article are very effective in populating positive votes for development of a College Scorecard.1 But the actual requirement of a College Scorecard has not been discussed efficiently. How do we reason the necessity of anything? By questioning its efficacy and productivity, substantiating the need by documenting physical or virtual need expressed by the provider as well as consumer. These are the methods primarily.

Read More

Into The School Grinberg Summary

964 Words | 4 Pages

Grinberg also points out the varying opinions given by parents of the new systems; consequently, a couple of parents are seeing the benefits to the detailed insight and a couple of other parents claim they rather keep the letter grades. In the end of the article, Grinberg acknowledges the common goal schools that use the new grading system have with the schools that rely on traditional report cards, the common goal schools share is to use a system that communicates to the parents on student learning on an ongoing basis and see academic progress among the students. As a student who went through years in the education system using a grading system that integrated both the traditional based system like report cards and standard based system with teacher commentaries, it would be ideal if there was a system that balances the traditional grading system and the standard based system. A combined system would provide parents the convenience that the standard based system provides with the use of technology and detailed feedback with communication between parents and teacher while maintaining the letter

Read More

Grade Inflation Gone Wild Rhetorical Analysis

1070 Words | 5 Pages

Imagine blowing up a balloon, with every exhale of breath the balloon gets bigger. Similar to a balloon, with every year that passes grades inflate. In “Grade Inflation Gone Wild” by Stuart Rojstaczer, he discusses how the grading system has changed over the years. Rojstaczer’s overall purpose is to increase awareness of grade inflation and persuade his audience to take action. He argues that “changes in grading have had a profound influence on college life and learning” (2).

Read More

Jerry Farber Grading System

762 Words | 4 Pages

The Grading System: Completely Necessary Grades are an important part of the school system. Grades set the extraordinary students apart from the ordinary ones. In Jerry Farber’s essay, “A Young Person’s Guide to the Grading System,” he argues that grades are the only motivation students have in school. Farber even calls it “phony motivation.” He argues that students do not actually learn anything.

Read More

Five Obstacles To Grading Reform Analysis

1214 Words | 5 Pages

Five Obstacles to Grading Reform Furman Blue Notre Dame of Maryland University In "Five Obstacles to Grading Reform" by Thomas R. Guskey, the author argues that education improvement efforts over the past two decades have focused on articulating standards for student learning and how educators must combat five traditional obstacle to changing those standards. Education improvement efforts over the past two decades have focused primarily on articulating standards for student learning, refining the way we assess students' proficiency on those standards, and tying results to accountability. The one element still unaligned with these reforms is grading and reporting. Student report cards today look much as if they looked a

Read More

National Curriculum: The Evolution Of The Contemporary Education System

1606 Words | 7 Pages

The educational achievement of pupils within the contemporary educational system has the potential to produce an education system based upon equality of opportunity and meritocracy, although it is unclear whether this applies to all pupils in the current system as there is a percentage of pupils who have not gained 5 A*-C GCSEs including or excluding English and Mathematics, therefore perhaps the contemporary education system has failed to produce equality of opportunity and meritocracy for all pupils and has only succeed at reaching a certain amount of pupils for reasons to be unknown and can only be speculated upon. Within absolute and relative achievement there are anomalies which can only have been produced by a lack of equality of opportunity and meritocracy as some pupils have had a limited development or progress in some ethnic groups which would suggest that equality of opportunity and meritocracy has either not been successfully implemented or is not in effect for those groups of

Read More

Summary Of The Article 'Making Graduation Meaningful'

444 Words | 2 Pages

Regarding an article published in Education Week, 5/7/2015, by author Marc Tucker, “Making Graduation Meaningful: A Real Qualification System for U.S. Students”, he states “A qualification system defines key gateways. Tucker believes the American education system has lower education standards and as a result our high schools are graduating lower educated students. As a graduating senior of the class of 2016, I disagree with Tuckers opinion concerning the real qualification system. Every student should be given a second chance to improve themselves, not every student test high on the first time. Students today, have a lot of pressure put upon them to succeed in life; their parents want them to have “better lives” than what they had.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Traditional Grading System

721 Words | 3 Pages

Schools use traditional grades such as homework, tests, and quizzes for many reasons and here is three of them, number one is they use traditional grading systems because that is just what they are use to, the second one is teachers can grade many items to determine what you have learned instead of just one simple grade, and the last one is the grades that a student may get are more accurate with more grades. If you have a bad grade you can use several other items to make that grade up unlike just one single grade where if you fail it you fail the class. A math professor by the name of harold osborne did some research on the subject and proved that 70% of students learned the items faster and more efficient with more grades and items to complete. Using several grades to determine if a students fails or not is way more efficient than just the one grade deciding their future. The traditional grading system is what most schools use and what they have always used and they should not change that to a new system that they would have to learn all over again.

Read More

Standardized Testing Argumentative Essay

699 Words | 3 Pages

Do standardized tests and grades accurately measure how well a subject is learned, or do students just cram their brains with what they are taught for the standardized tests? Covering a small sample of the topic is not necessarily learning it, but rather ingesting the information and regurgitating it for a test and then forgetting the information right afterwards. Different learning styles also come into play here and many instructors fail to teach in ways that all students may understand, leaving some students ill-prepared and with the possibility of testing poorly, or even failing. It seems that over time, the original concept of being in school to learn how to learn was lost, and the need to know how to be tested was found, resulting in lower test scores, less individual creativity, and the overall diminished desire for students to want to learn and attend school.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The Grading System

678 Words | 3 Pages

To hold students to a standard based grading is a more reflective and accurate form of grading. The only concern with it all that I have is that I do not want students to feel like they are being observed and watched over like an object of study. And the article on www.neatoday.orgstates this concern as well, a comment made by Alfie Kohn, says that “standards-based grading “may even make things worse by getting kids more focused on the details of how well they’re doing –rather than being engaged with what they’re doing. ”Which is my concern and point exactly, some students make “fake” they’re progress or how they act about in class just to get a good progress narrative report or some may not even learn material at all due to this fact of teachers watching how they perform. Some students tend to get nervous and feel pressured when they are being watched and

Read More

The Benefits Of Fixing The Grading System

685 Words | 3 Pages

The concept of this grading method is based on the students understanding and how they demonstrate it. If they have a full understanding and can demonstrate they’ll get an A if not then the grade will go down based on how much of an understanding the student demonstrates. However, with this grading system, a student can learn what exactly a teacher is wanting to read or see, and they focus on those elements without focusing on the whole lesson (493). As a student myself there are many times that I look back on my education and can say I fell into the habit of learning what each teacher was looking for and only focusing on those elements. Although I was learning everything I should have been, I was learning some important aspects of the subject being taught.

Read More

Reflection Of A College Course

749 Words | 3 Pages

I was wrong. After not doing so well on the first two exams, I could not figure out what was wrong. I reached out to my professor who agreed to meet me and go over my exams. She told me that I must use the text book rather than the lecture notes. Ever since I have used the text book my exam score had increased by thirty percent.

Read More

More about Grades And Degree By Kevin Steves Summary

Related Topics

Open Document