ipl-logo

Five Obstacles To Grading Reform Analysis

1214 Words5 Pages

Five Obstacles to Grading Reform

Furman Blue
Notre Dame of Maryland University

In "Five Obstacles to Grading Reform" by Thomas R. Guskey, the author argues that education improvement efforts over the past two decades have focused on articulating standards for student learning and how educators must combat five traditional obstacle to changing those standards.

Education improvement efforts over the past two decades have focused primarily on articulating standards for student learning, refining the way we assess students' proficiency on those standards, and tying results to accountability. The one element still unaligned with these reforms is grading and reporting. Student report cards today look much as if they looked a …show more content…

Computerized grading programs help teachers apply different weights to each of these categories (Guskey, 2002a) that then are combined in idiosyncratic ways (see McMillan, 2001; McMillan, Myran, & Workman, 2002). The result is a "hodgepodge grade" that is just as confounded and impossible to interpret as a "physical condition" grade that combined height, weight, diet, and exercise would be (Brookhart & Nitko, 2008; Cross & Frary, …show more content…

The only logical way to comprehend how a student learns is to use a combination of teaching methodologies that will allow a teacher to develop a system that will enhance a computerized grading process. The computerized system we use in Charles County does allow a teacher the freedom to explore various ways to assess successful learning outcomes for our students.
Reflecting on the current grading system for Charles County schools it is important to realize grades are defining factors to student achievement. If teachers want students to be better learners then various teaching methodologies will be the standard measure of student achievement in the future.
My perspective is that school boards, state testing coordinators and federal regulation should allow schools to develop grading modules that will allow a true reflection of student learning. The current grading system will not measure if a student is learning academic content through standardized test. Practical application and theory is the best measurement for school districts to realistically, measure if student achievement. Teachers and administrators must create a mindset that will allow growth and academic motivation to empower students for a

Show More
Related
437 Words | 2 Pages

In Brent Staples “Why Colleges Shower Their Students With A’s”, he claims that professors in colleges in the 1990’s are changing their grading on students assignments so much where that they are just passing out good grades when students don’t even deserve them. Colleges have started to change the whole grading system over the years just to make it look like the students are doing better. For example, “In some cases, campuswide averages have crept up from a C just 10 years ago to B-plus today” (Staples 1). There are many reasons as to why they day this.

Read More
258 Words | 2 Pages

In “From Degrading to De-Grading,” Alfie Kohn criticizes current grading systems and their alleged harm to students. Kohn first lists three main problems with grading and then adds seven more. In summary, grading results in students showing little interest in learning, students choosing easier assignments, and less creative students (p. 254-255). The next seven points expose grading as unreliable, distracting, and tedious. Grading also incites cheating and ruins relationships between students and teachers (p. 255-257).

Read More
936 Words | 4 Pages

In "Are Grades Really Necessary?" Catherine Rampell discusses elite prep schools' interest in terminating the traditional, letter-based grading system. She explains these schools' desire to support a less punitive scheme which displays "qualitative, soft-focus descriptions of skills that students have 'mastered.' " Rampell agrees that this desired system may make students more appealing to colleges; however, she believes that without displaying a student's GPA, the new language will prove insufficiently "informative." Therefore, I am in entire agreement with the author that students should be given letter grades to inform them of their respective strengths and weaknesses and to promote fairness in the school system.

Read More
1000 Words | 4 Pages

The Failure of Grading in Public High Schools Most people in life that go on to be publicly known or have a successful business after escaping the jail that is high school, are actually the students that didn’t make such good grades. The school grading system trains you students to reach for an unattainable goal, has untruthful promises, has many flaws, causes mental issues in students, leads to cheating, and makes students not even comprehend what they are learning. The grades we get are supposedly the only thing that tracks how a student is doing in school. With that, a student has the mind set that if they do, everything right and good like they’re supposed to they’ll get rewarded with an A grade. Sadly however, the real world hits hard

Read More
2086 Words | 9 Pages

Kohn believes grading is a harmful thing for students because it is more of a game with competition. He views grading as something that does not lead to improvements in performance but holds students back from doing their best. He states, “A school’s ultimate mission, apparently, is not to help everyone learn but to rig the game so that there will always be losers” (Kohn 2). Kohn relates school and grading to a game. A game where students begin to try to outdo one another rather than focusing on their academics.

Read More
1070 Words | 5 Pages

Imagine blowing up a balloon, with every exhale of breath the balloon gets bigger. Similar to a balloon, with every year that passes grades inflate. In “Grade Inflation Gone Wild” by Stuart Rojstaczer, he discusses how the grading system has changed over the years. Rojstaczer’s overall purpose is to increase awareness of grade inflation and persuade his audience to take action. He argues that “changes in grading have had a profound influence on college life and learning” (2).

Read More
1028 Words | 5 Pages

According to Kevin this style is inconsistent and he reaches the conclusion that if we continue to interpret the grades in relation to one’s peers then there will be students with poor or excellent performances regardless of how badly they perform or how well they understand the material. Apart from highlighting the problems of our current grading system Kevin also mention possible solutions to them. He mentions the possibility of judging the grades based on the aptitude/ understanding of the material but he also found some issues with the idea like the fact that professors have different ways of presenting the materials in the same course. Other issues including the style in which the examination will be presented for example essay/ theory questions, multiple choice, oral, charts or the use of computer graphics. He explains that the way the material is presented to the students or the way the examination is structured matters a great deal because all these procedures frustrate attempts to a uniform system of grading and interpretation all the grades and the important question he highlights is “what exactly the student good at?” is it the testing process, understanding of the material or the act of understanding the way the examination is structured i.e. graphs, multiple choice, oral or

Read More
1010 Words | 5 Pages

I realized the author was referencing my style of assessment when he described the traditional music teacher’s grading system. Since I teach grades 2-12 and much of my day is spent teaching very large class sizes, I tend to rely solely on visual and auditory formative assessments and base my summative assessments on overall effort, participation, and attendance at required performances. I am constantly making “mental notes” of how engaged and self-motivated individual students appear to be while we are preparing for upcoming events. This has left me with scoring and grading in a subjective manner. I do administer written tests relating to music theory, instrument families, music history, and composers, but much of my students’ final grades result in their daily participation and effort based on individual patterns and trends throughout the class period.

Read More
745 Words | 3 Pages

The letter grade system is the typical grading way. Now in days, it’s stressful for students to concentrate on education, Farber says that the students get to stressed out with letter grades, also he believes that students can’t expand their knowledge in school. He states that, “We’re grade junkies” (Farber 385), he is convinced that students can never learn without the letter grade system to keep them going, also he is convinced that students shouldn’t be graded on their qualifications. There’s only so much a letter grade can do to help students grow their

Read More
745 Words | 3 Pages

Throughout Robert Frost poems; “Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening,” “The Road Not Taken,” and “Acquainted by the Night” are poems that have a different mindset between the three poems. Frost poems focuses more on the journey the character has in the poem, rather than where the character is going to or coming from. As a reader, we learn more about the character’s decision rather than what route the character’s take during the poems…. In the poem “Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening” the speaker is stopping by some woods on a snowy evening.

Read More
748 Words | 3 Pages

This is a key part in schools today because it’s enforcing a higher bar of achievement for teachers and students (Catapano, 2018). Implementing standards into a school system that are internationally benchmarked means all states and countries have a way of measuring their academic performance. They can use this also as a tool to compile scores and understand the weaknesses to improve students’ knowledge. This provides teachers with various ways to assess their students more frequently through observations and informal assessments to understand the student’s comprehension level of the lesson material. It will help the teachers to strive to improve her test scores by adapting lesson materials to the needs of each

Read More
796 Words | 4 Pages

Now, as a principal moving towards standards –based grading, I have to develop a plan to persuade those types of thinkers into believing that standards-based grading will benefit students and help them grow in their

Read More
902 Words | 4 Pages

Classroom assessment and grading practices have the potential not only to measure and report learning but also to promote it. Indeed, recent research has documented the benefits of regular use of diagnostic and formative assessments as feedback for learning (Black, Harrison, Lee, Marshall, & Wiliam,

Read More
833 Words | 4 Pages

The U.S. grading system has been ineffective for at least six years. For those of you that think otherwise let me make my point understandable. There is an overall grading system in the U.S. This system is “based on a fixed numeric scale” that changes with individual performance; There is nothing wrong with basing the number on individuality. Something that I consider wrong is categorizing.

Read More
1323 Words | 6 Pages

Students are Intellectually Affected by Grading Assessments and Standardized Testing Educators utilize rubrics and grading criteria for assignments so that students educational growth can be taken into consideration for the future curriculums and requirements. There are times, though, when these methods of determining grades can actually cause students to exceed, remain constant, or regress in their educational growth. Mike Rose’s idea in “Achievement of Desire” that highlighted the impact grading assessments and standardized testing have on a student’s capability to learn will be extended to also explore the benefits and drawbacks on a student’s educational growth and development.

Read More

More about Five Obstacles To Grading Reform Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document