ipl-logo

Helen Eckmann's Theory Of The Great Man Theory

860 Words4 Pages

The Great Man Theory

One of the early century ideas of leadership, which is still favoured in certain groups/circles of today, is that leadership is a natural characteristic that one are born with.
This is the Great Man Theory which claim that general and great leaders in particular are born and not made. (Helen L. Eckmann, N.d).According to the theory, leadership consist of certain qualities like charm, authoritative, reliable instinct, judgment, courageous, intelligence and action orientation which cannot be learnt or taught. (Helen L. Eckmann, N.d).
One either has the trait or not. It is said that these leadership qualities run in the family (genes) (Anon, N.d).. In other words, you are born with it, or carried from generation-to-generation. …show more content…

One can say that there was something in their physiology, anatomy, and personality which made them “unique” compared to the average citizen.
Implications of the Great Man Theory (saying leaders are born and not made)

Leaders are seen as gifts of God to the human race. A part of divinity is assigned to leaders and their actions. (Helen L. Eckmann, N.d). The theory ignore the belief that someone can be trained for roles and leadership positions. Leadership characteristics cannot be addressed through exposure and education. (Helen L. Eckmann, N.d).
Critique of the …show more content…

Zaccaro, he says that “leader traits can be defined as relatively coherent and integrated patterns of personal characteristics, reflecting a range of individual differences, that foster consistent leadership effectiveness across a variety of group and organizational situations. I believe that a con of this theory is that the theory only focuses on the traits when it should also consider how the traits are implemented and work together to influence performance. Another con is that it should also include internal and external factors that shape a person such as values and social skills…”(Monique Padilla,

Show More
Related
872 Words | 4 Pages

Another thing about leadership is its an art. People can’t just become a leader, it’s inside of them just waiting for an opportunity to reveal itself. “Educators, health professionals, and parents all agree that as society grows more complex, young people are in greater need than ever for grounding in the basic values that determine character”(Hirschmann 12). This shows that the higher ups in

Read More
1379 Words | 6 Pages

“Although Americans are accustomed to thinking about the Constitution as a miraculously well-constructed and farsighted document, its writing was the result of significant conflict and compromise” (Castner, The Constitutional Debates). The Constitutional Convention was a meeting of state delegates in 1787 to revise and edit the Articles of Confederation. The original Articles of Confederation caused politicians to meet and revise the government. The process the delegates went through included debates on slavery, legislature, and state representation. The effect of the convention is obvious: a strong republic that stood the test of time and still governs the US justly and fairly.

Read More
726 Words | 3 Pages

This is a valuable trait of a leader that I embody. Another trait that is vital is responsibility. To keep up with my busy schedule that includes schoolwork, sports, service, as well as being social, I stay very organized and responsible. This helps me greatly in my endeavors as a leader, as do the other qualities I

Read More
815 Words | 4 Pages

Wherever human beings are accumulated together in large numbers, they need leadership. Even a school needs a principle to mentor and escalate the school’s rank. Armies need generals to lead them to a courageous victory. Civilians need governments, captains of industry and intellectual leaders of thought as well. However, There are characteristics common to most great leaders that can be picked out.

Read More
657 Words | 3 Pages

In life I have noticed leadership to be a key attribute of mine. This was not a quality I would seek to obtain, it was more like one bestowed upon me. Growing up I was the second oldest and only daughter of four children. Though we were rich in spirit, financial hardships made it difficult and at times impossible to fulfill the basic needs and wants of most kids. With the odds stacked against us, I began at a young age to realize that I had to take charge, I had to make a change, I had to lead.

Read More
1357 Words | 6 Pages

All these characteristics of a great leader are found in

Read More
760 Words | 4 Pages

Those individuals who were believed to have these inherent skills were people of very influential status, wartime heroes and those of great wealth. The people who emerge or are most picked to lead have distinctive drives and character profiles (Nicholson, 2013, p.16). Leadership Thought Development from 1900 – 1970 The thought of leadership evolved from the Great Man Theory to Trait Theory and Behavior Theory. The trait theory focuses on identifying distinctive personality traits and characteristics that are associated to successful leadership.

Read More
860 Words | 4 Pages

Trait theory states that leaders are born, and they are not made. Everyone has the personality that can give them leadership positions. With the right condition, anyone can be a good leader (Colbert, et al.

Read More
183 Words | 1 Pages

Dr. Gardner, research suggests that genetics account for approximately 30% of the variance leadership role occupancy. Another 10-15% is related to external work and life events (Arvey, Avolio, Zhen, & Krueger, 2007). Some environmental variables that influence leadership emergence and development include educational, family, and prior work experiences (Arvey et al., 2007). The remaining comes from learned behavior. Leaders are ultimately developed through experience, new knowledge, reflection, and time to practice (Ruvolo, Petersen, & LeBoeuf, 2004).

Read More
1238 Words | 5 Pages

Probably one of the most infamous and controversial ideologies of the 16th century, the prince by Machiavelli has been a reference for many great leaders and academicians since it was published. The book provides historically tested and proven principles of leadership. The prince has been described as a manual for those who want to win and retain power. While some may argue that leadership is an inherent trait in human, leaders are made, not born. Making a great leader out of a person is not just a matter of identifying the leadership traits, skill and talents of the individual, but harnessing the traits, develop them and eventually mastering how to be leader.

Read More
1000 Words | 4 Pages

Critical Review of Leadership Theories There have been a variety of theorists who have tried to understand how good leaders acquire their skills and whether the components which make up a successful leader are hereditary or learned. Many Studies have been made using twins to identify that about forty percent of differences in personality are hereditary. (Vernon et al., 1998) From this we can see that it is not only a matter of whether a person in born with these skills but one must also build on them to become a successful leader.

Read More
1369 Words | 6 Pages

From the mainstream perspective, he has shown different types of leadership. It also includes several theories like trait, skill, behavior, contingency and transformational. Trait theory states that the personality of a person would determine if he or she will be able to lead. In case of Steve Jobs, his personality was radiant and flamboyant. He was confident, committed and charismatic to take any leap or risk with the support of his team and customers to pursue his aspiration (Katzenbach, 2012).

Read More
1818 Words | 8 Pages

This paper will examine the three leadership theories, identify how they apply to my practice, and explore how these theories interact with each other. The Trait Leadership Theory is based on the belief that a person is born with special traits contributing to natural leadership abilities. Studies of famous historical leaders have been used to identify various traits for this theory. Although the list of traits differs from study to study, there are five major traits that are consistent throughout most studies.

Read More
1000 Words | 4 Pages

In theory leadership is focused on the personal qualities and traits of a person. Trait theory is based on the model of the Big Five personaliti. For an example, Extraversion is one of the characteristics of the most common and most important in the way leaders to ensure their effective leadership. Next, we can distinguish between effective leader and ineffective.

Read More
1465 Words | 6 Pages

Individual Reflective Paper Introduction Leadership, a controversial concept, has been studied for centuries. Scholars who study leadership have argued with the insight of leadership for many decades and finally promote a wide range of understandings of it. This course “values and leadership” introduces the basic principles and concepts about leadership, and provides us with some conceptual knowledge and practical approaches to be an outstanding leaders. I chose to take this course because I am interested in the topic about leadership.

Read More

More about Helen Eckmann's Theory Of The Great Man Theory

Related Topics

Open Document