ipl-logo

Herodotus Analytical Essay

1634 Words7 Pages

As a historian, we are often forced to express evidence from one point of view because there are no accounts for the other side. One of the famous historians is Herodotus, a Greek historian who is known for being the ‘father of history’. He is famed for his records of the clash between the Greek city-states and the Persian empire in the Greco-Persian war. Although he is a historian who wants to tell the tales of the Greco-Persian war, his accounts of history are biased. On the other hand, some literature like The Silk Roads by Peter Frankopan attempts to present history in a neutral light. Discrepancies between truth and half truth often leave misinterpretations of empires, rulers, people, and the quality of the life of that time period. This leaves behind an “us vs. them” mentality that would last for centuries. When the words, “Persian Empire” comes to mind, we often think of the greatest empire known to mankind, an empire that was strong, successful, and tolerable to religion, traditions, and cultural values. However, from Herodotus’ book, The Histories, he portrays the Persians as monsters, and rulers like King Xerxes I were unfair, cruel, and a monster to the outside people like the Greeks and even to his own people. An example of this is when Pythius the Lydian asked Xerxes to spare his …show more content…

The Silk Roads: A New History of the World. London: Bloomsbury, 2015.
Herodotus. "Herodotus: Xerxes Invades Greece, from The Histories." Ancient History
Sourcebook. August 2000. Accessed September 21, 2017. https://sourcebooks.fordham.edu/halsall/ancient/herodotus-xerxes.asp.
Introduction: Darius' Titles and the Extent of his Empire." Behistun (3) - Livius. 1997. Accessed
September 21, 2017. http://www.livius.org/articles/place/behistun/behistun-3/.
Marcellinus, Ammianus. Ammianus Marcellinus, Roman History. London: Bohn (1862) Book
31. pp. 575-623. Accessed September 21, 2017.

Show More
Related
1790 Words | 8 Pages

This book has given me a greater understanding on the Classics as a whole. The book touches on a plethora of classical topics in chapter 2, and often compares the western civilization to our west. The author also gave me better understanding of the time periods. I didn’t know slaves had better treatment than the free people in Persia at the time, or that war was an enormous role in Classics age. From the western civilization class I’ve took earlier this year, this books discuss the importance of money in a war, when Sparta beat Athens, or when Rome beat the Carthaginians because of the new money they received to build ships.

Read More
758 Words | 4 Pages

The first source that will be discussed in this essay is an extract from a book by Procopius, a prominent Byzantine scholar, entitled Secret History. Written circa 550 AD, the book itself heavily criticises the emperor Justinian and his wife Theodora, and its disparaging, subjective, and almost anecdotal tone is reflected in the source. The author of the book is of significance- not only was Procopius potentially the most well-known Byzantine historian, but he had previously written another book, History of the Wars, which was extremely complementary of Justinian and Theodora. This means that, because Secret History took such a vastly different tone, the authorship of the book has been brought into question, especially since it was published

Read More
1422 Words | 6 Pages

“Its power clearly surpasses that of all its known contemporaneous rivals; it is not clearly inferior in economic or military strength to any other power on the planet, known to it or not; and it projects its power over so immense an area of the globe and over so immense a population that it breaks the bounds of mere local or even regional preeminence.” (Chua, pg. XXII). When Mrs. Chua introduced the Achaemenid Empire, she provided a strong argument for including this empire in her book. She reasons that “the Achaemenid Persian Empire was, even by today’s standards,, one of the most culturally diverse and religiously open empires in

Read More
1427 Words | 6 Pages

Written in Classical Greek, it has been translated into dozens of languages, including Old English and modern English, and kept the ancient traditions, morality, and stories alive centuries after the author’s passing. As the “Father of History”, Herodotus holds a status of academic immortality, and through his work we have a foundation for how to keep record of history for future generations to know and almost place themselves in those times. What reading Clio has reminded me of is the importance of history to the world, and how this book and its eight brethren were the blueprints for all future historical writings. It shows how well recordkeeping can stand the test of time, and how keeping information and knowledge of the past can continue to teach and shape the

Read More
829 Words | 4 Pages

Darius’s attacks on Athens were later carried out by Xerxes as a revenge plot of unfinished conquest, although he was reluctant (Lecture 4/27). Darius also portrayed himself as the mightiest king and the most important one of all places in his inscriptions (Susa, Statue of Darius), inflating his self-representation. Therefore, with his portrayal as a great king, and his religious and political decisions, he made a lasting impact on Persian ideology, as can be seen in the reign of his successor,

Read More
726 Words | 3 Pages

In the reading of Xerxes war, the Persian are described and portrayed as sort of the “bad guys” in a way. For example the first way we see the Persian people portrayed is with a sense of revenge and greed for power. In the text we see the Persian leader Xerxes, resemble this when he states, “I tend to bridge the hellespont and take my army straight through Europe and into Greece, to punish the Athenians for what they did to the Persian and my father.” Here we see Xerxes trying to claim revenge over the Greeks because they defeated his father in an earlier preceding battle. “I have pondered how not to fall short of the standard of honor my ancestor have set, and how not to diminish the power of the Persians.”

Read More
809 Words | 4 Pages

The author’s organization in The Greco-Persian Wars is focused mostly chronologically and divided into sections based on the events that occurred. The book is divided into 7 parts, and each part includes different events. Greens writing style includes quotes from multiple primary sources. In the beginning of the book I believed that Green had a biased opinion on the subject, but after continuing to read I realized that he is not biased but has just done his fair share of research. I like how the author describes the events that take place.

Read More
1461 Words | 6 Pages

Seth Harper Hist 201 Primary Source Paper I have not used AI to edit this paper. Herodotus paints a vivid picture of the ancient world in The Histories.

Read More
506 Words | 3 Pages

With Herodotus, he seems to write about the culture, diversity and people when telling stories in history. As he was growing up, he was exposed to many ideas of famous figures like Socrates. Also, due to his frequent traveling, he was able to observe many people, which in turn was able to help him in his writing. One example is the book “The Histories”, which had talked about not only the Greco-Persian war, but also the culture and diversity around the Mediterranean, so that he could get insight on not only the origin of the war, but the people around it. Also, since he grew up around the beginning of the war, himself was able to become an eye witness.

Read More
715 Words | 3 Pages

Herodotus didn't seem to speak ill of the Persians but only stating what he found to be true about the them. Herodotus's understanding of the Persian religion

Read More
1226 Words | 5 Pages

“The Histories” by Herodotus, known as the world’s first historian, describes the first real accounts of the Achaemenid Empire as they began expanding and the events that ultimately led to the Greco-Persian Wars. Ancient and modern researchers/philosophers have sparked controversy when it comes to the reliability of his sources. They thought that Herodotus’ interpretation of certain events was so clear that it was hard to tell whether they were factual or not, Herodotus traveled the world and during that time he was able to collect what he called “autopsies,”. He gathered information on the myths and legends of the different lands, recorded oral historic events and made notes of the places and things that he encountered. In this paper, I’m

Read More
1310 Words | 6 Pages

Have you ever heard two people having a discussion about a topic, but they have different opinions? Acknowledging the fact that people could have different opinions based on their own perspectives is very important. In Persepolis, Marjane writes as her 10 year old self, sharing what she experienced in Iran, while they were in the middle of a revolution. Throughout the book, she gets older and her perspective changes multiple times over several different topics. Marjane Satrapi’s perspective affects her presentation of imperialism, religion and loss of innocence.

Read More
536 Words | 3 Pages

I have known that Persia is current day Iran. Other knowledge I have on Greek society is from Greek mythology, like Heracles and Cerberus, and “The Odyssey,” which I learned in this course is written by the same author, Homer, that wrote the poem “Iliad.” The first thing I learned in this course was who the Greek and Persian people were. Greece had been a very advanced country, constructing city-states that had “developed science, mathematics, and representational art in

Read More
446 Words | 2 Pages

One would assume that Herodotus would end his Histories with the Battle of Mycale, which marked Greece’s defeat and the end of the second Persian invasion of Greece, but he ends with three digressions from the main text. One of the digressions that Herodotus ends with includes the Siege of Sestos and the vengeance of Protesilaos. Through this digression, Herodotus maintains the theme of revenge and foreshows the future power and downfall of the Athenian Empire. The vengeance of Protesilaos shows the continuous theme of graphic revenge and its consequences.

Read More
1185 Words | 5 Pages

History had to start somewhere and that one of the earliest record keepers where Herodotus and Sima Qian. Herodotus recording the history of the Greece while Sima Qian recording China’s early history. Thought these men were not the most accurate and unbiased record-keeper, it does shine a light into the mindsets of the people of the time. In these two own way, the do display the events of their time with their own unique view on the their surroundings. These two only have one thing in common, their almost outrageous views on the world around them.

Read More

More about Herodotus Analytical Essay

Related Topics

Open Document