ipl-logo

Into The Land Of Bones, By Frank Holt: Article Analysis

898 Words4 Pages

The American War in Afghanistan, is not the first time in history that a forceing country has invaded a country in hope of change and peace. There is a sense of high demand behind Into the Land of Bones, in which Frank Holt describes the campaigns of Alexander the Great in Bactria . To understand this demand, it is relevant to note that the author is American. The United States is currently fighting a war in Afghanistan and Holt wants to explain that, although the troops are fighting with "skill, dedication, honor, or heroism", they "simply do not have history on their side" (page xii). The army and war style reflects this axiom.
The present reviewer, who lives in a country that has also sent troops to Afghanistan, fully agrees with Holt that historians have a duty to inform the people of the risks in theater of operation. Whatever one may …show more content…

The lesson is that the troops in Afghanistan today can be the master of any battlefield, and still lose the war. A well tactical win can be a strategic defeat. The soldiers who invaded Afghanistan to liberate it from the Taliban do not have history on their side. This written text will find its way to one of the two audiences for which Holt is writing. The other group he has in mind is the community of scholars. Scholors will find much in the Land of Bones that they already know from Holt's earlier publications, such as Alexander the Great and Bactria. These arguments return in the Land of Bones, but there is a difference in emphasis. Holt stresses the religious factor a bit more, that may have to do with the fact that economic history is less popular than it was twenty years ago. The fact that the United States soldiers are in Afghanistan to fight against extremist living among the native

Show More
Related
1542 Words | 7 Pages

On July 30, 2008, a bloody battle involving Coalition forces took place in the mountainous eastern Afghan province of Nuristan. This was the Battle of Wanat and the devastating amount of Coalition casualties began a vigorous investigation by the United States Army. The village of Wanat, defended by Second Platoon, Chosen Company, Second Battalion, 503rd Infantry Regiment, 173rd Airborne Brigade Combat Team would fall victim to numerous bad decision made by higher command. Although the men of Chosen Company fought hard, they ended up surrounded, vastly outnumbered, and without any Battalion assets. This paper will argue the reasons for the disastrous outcome of the Battle of Wanat; examining the effective company leadership exploiting effective

Read More
1069 Words | 5 Pages

https://doi.org/10.2991/mplg-ia-19.2019.24 Greentree, T. (2021). What went wrong in Afghanistan? The US Army War College Quarterly: Parameters, 51(4), 7–22. https://doi.org/10.55540/0031-1723.3088 Kugler, R. (2007). Operation anaconda in Afghanistan: A Case Study of Adaptation in Battle.

Read More
1805 Words | 8 Pages

Thesis Statement Operation Anaconda was a military operation that took place in the Shahikot Valley of Afghanistan. It occurred during the beginning of the war against terrorism in March of 2002. The intent of this operation was to push enemy Taliban and al Qaeda out of the region with possibility of capturing some of the enemies’ top leaders. The battle was ultimately a success; however, this outcome came only after many significant issues within mission command. Despite careful planning and a strong military force, the failure of the command structure during this operation can be attributed to inadequate communication, a lack of flexibility, and a failure to account for the terrain and enemy capability.

Read More
1782 Words | 8 Pages

In Salvage the Bones, Jesmyn Ward parallels the mythological story of Medea in order to highlight her representation of women. The use of Medea, who is embodied in various aspects within the three main female characters, allows Ward’s work to obtain a sense of universality to her narrative. Also with this incorporation, Ward is able to change the dominant perspective of “blackness” that has plagued southern literature written by African-American authors. Salvage the Bones occurs in Bois Sauvage, Mississippi, following Esch,who has just found out she is pregnant, and her poor family just days before the catastrophic Hurricane Katrina. Medea, an anti-hero, who succumbs to her own decisions and the demons of love represents a dynamic femininity, rather than the stereotypical aspect of which is what being a female is.

Read More
1241 Words | 5 Pages

And in the end, really, there’s nothing much to say about a true war story, except maybe ‘Oh’” (77). We can never assume the truth in a war story. The only way to discover the truth hidden behind the lies is to pull away the many layers or in this case the stories that make up a war

Read More
1217 Words | 5 Pages

HIs speech confirmed the war on terrorist groups in the Middle East while also summarizing the idea that “If war is not pronounced it is the same as self destruction” (9/11, Bullhorn Speech). In the eyes of America war was not a lose-lose, but rather a win-lose situation. Flustered with emotion, Americans forgot to realize the effects of war on a nation, opening their own vulnerbality from a lack of raitonal thinking. The same lack of rational thinking was shown in Tim O’Brien’s “The Things They Carried”. Tim O’Brien is a Vietnam war veteran who documented his time in the war.

Read More
692 Words | 3 Pages

On March of 2003, Lieutenant Colonel Tim Collins gave over a speech to his troops of the 1st Battalion of the Royal Irish Regiment before they left to invade Iraq. It was a powerful address aiming to invigorate and rev his soldiers up to fight. Along with his pep talk, he laced in warning and boundaries for what the troops can and can not do. Lieutenant Collins’ goal was to persuade them to fight and be successful, but not to commit wrongs while fighting. He even sets up the scene to make his words more dramatic and powerful, by placing his right hand on his kukri and stretching his left hand out, showing off his expensive watch.

Read More
2118 Words | 9 Pages

We all grew up thinking what we had learned was true. Now do not misunderstand—we were taught history, just often from specific angles, so some truths are diluted or misleading. Private Joseph Martin was an American soldier who gave us first-hand accounts of this series of events within his

Read More
423 Words | 2 Pages

(page 68). This is why Tim O’Brien writes the way he does. He wants the reader to believe his story and get a sense of what war is truly

Read More
1050 Words | 5 Pages

Accessing Operation Anaconda Case Study Using Mission Command Principles Operation Anaconda was a very pivotal moment for the conflict in Afghanistan and how the American Military structured itself. In the process of learning lessons about the importance of using mission command principles when conducting large-scale operations, the American Military made significant changes to the way they conduct large-scale operations. The operation has several elements that are both good and bad for every Soldier to learn from and understand. Using the mission command principles commanders’ intent, mutual trust, and disciplined initiative. I will analyze what went right, wrong, and what could have been prevented in the 17-day operation.

Read More
664 Words | 3 Pages

In the chapter “Speaking of Courage” and “Notes” of the book “The things they carried” by Tim O’brien, the author mainly expresses two truths. First truth exhibits the phenomenon on the surface that attending war is hurtful. The stories in “Speaking of Courage” and “Notes” perfectly represent the believed truth, which is came up by human based on the combination of facts and imagination. They might not be something truly happened, but they explained the undoubtable truths in the real world. According to O’brien, “ I almost won the Silver Star, he (Norman Bowker) would have said (135)”.

Read More
434 Words | 2 Pages

The lieutenant was charged with delivering an important message to a Cuban general. The book was seen as the perfect portrayal of loyalty and obedience. There are multiple tactical lessons that can be taken from this book/essay, not only to include how individual ethics can create an enormous impact.

Read More
886 Words | 4 Pages

O'Brien shows us that "In many cases a true war story cannot be believed. If you believe it, be skeptical. It's a question of credibility. Often the crazy stuff is true and the normal stuff isn't, because the normal stuff is necessary to make you believe the truly incredible craziness." (pg. 71).

Read More
907 Words | 4 Pages

Chris Hedges, a former war correspondent, has a memory overflowing with the horrors of many battlefields and the helplessness of those trapped within them. He applies this memory to write War Is a Force That Gives Us Meaning, where he tutors us in the misery of war. To accomplish this goal, Hedges uses impactful imagery, appeals to other dissidents of war and classic writers, and powerful exemplification. Throughout his book, Hedges batters the readers with painful and grotesque, often first-hand, imagery from wars around the globe. He begins the book with his experience in Sarajevo, 1995.

Read More
688 Words | 3 Pages

Knowledge of course, is always imperfect, but it seemed to me that when a nation goes to war it must have reasonable confidence in the justice and imperative of its cause. You can 't fix your mistakes. Once people are dead, you can 't make them undead” (38-39). Because O’Brien had witnessed so much death and destruction he knew how important it was to have all the facts first.

Read More

More about Into The Land Of Bones, By Frank Holt: Article Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document