ipl-logo

Is John Brown Insane Essay

1594 Words7 Pages

John Brown is the man who famously lead the Harpers Ferry raid and was captured and hung for his failed attempt. He was attempting to free the slaves in a town where they did not want to be freed. His failed attempt lead to the deaths of many of his own men and innocent townspeople. Why would anyone attempt such a task? Is John Brown Insane? Historians have argued both sides for years. John Garraty, in a popular college survey text, described John Brown as “deranged.” Yet many argue that Brown was sane like Stephen Oates, a Brown biographer. To decide whether Brown is truly insane or not one must look at his life and motives to decide.
At the age of five Brown left his home in Connecticut to move to Ohio with his father and mother. After arriving …show more content…

His friends and family thought so. In fact, many of his friends and family testified saying he was insane. It was also noted in the proceedings of the trial that Brown’s maternal grandmother, numerous uncles, aunts, and cousins, Brown’s sister, Brown’s brother, his first wife, and two of his sons were mentally insane. It is likely however that the friends and family who claimed Brown to be insane would rather see him in an asylum rather then hung for his crimes. Psychologist Kenneth Carroll looked in depth into the physiological state of Brown. After much research Carroll concluded that Brown exhibits symptoms that make it safe to assume him bipolar but not mentally insane. For example Brown exhibits inflated self esteem, increase in goal-directed activities, and periods of mood disturbance to name a few of the symptoms of a bipolar person that Brown possessed. Brown exhibited inflated self ego in his many failed business attempts accepting help from no one. This inflated self ego is also to blame for his belief that he was on a quest from God that could only be fulfilled by him. His increase in goal directed activities can be found in his obsession of ending slavery and willingness to murder if it meant reaching his goal. Lastly, periods of mood disturbance occurred throughout his life like when he lost his marble. Brown admitted to taking years to recover from the loss of a single marble. The court like Carroll found that Brown was not insane. Brown was sentenced to death and hung on December 2, 1859 in Charles Town,

Show More
Related
164 Words | 1 Pages

When Brown was 55 he moved with his sons to Kansas territory after the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854 overrode the Missouri Compromise, which resulted in the strict ban of slavery above a certain latitude. This was a huge deal to both pro-slavery and anti-slavery fighters for before this act was passed the United States only consisted of twenty-two states which were divided among the two groups of fighters. Winning this territory for slavery, or for those against it, could really make a statement. During the settling of Kansas the events of violent acts that occurred during the period (1855) is referred to as “Bleeding Kansas”. Violence pursued throughout the year 1855.

Read More
688 Words | 3 Pages

His father, Owen Brown, who was “a committed pacifist”, was passionately opposed to slavery, which heavily influenced John Brown to become an abolitionist (Horwitz, 2011, p.19). John Brown is described as “a warrior at heart”, who was focused on the task to “undermine slavery (Horwitz, 2011, p.19, 31). This obsession to terminate slavery was his inspiration throughout all the skirmishes he fought in and slaves he helped free. The most infamous battle was his raid on Harper’s Ferry, where he was captured, trialed, and later hung. This battle is believed to be a major

Read More
474 Words | 2 Pages

John Brown was an abolitionist who was a part of the anti-slavery movement. He led the Harpers Ferry Raid in hopes to ignite a spark in slave uprisings. Brown was not insane for his plans of raiding and supplying slaves with guns from the arsenal. The plan for the raid was not a spontaneous attack.

Read More
1600 Words | 7 Pages

The Civil War was fought during 1861 through 1865 between the Southern and Northern parts of the United States. The North, or the Union, wanted to abolish slavery, but the South, called the Confederates, wanted to keep slavery as well as secede from the Union. This war started at Fort Sumter and was won by the North. Hostility between the North and South grew noticeably after the year of the Missouri Compromise, 1820 (“Civil War” 1). In 1852, Uncle Tom’s Cabin, a book about slave life, became the second best-selling book in 19th Century America, behind the Bible, and opened the eyes of Northerners.

Read More
762 Words | 4 Pages

Did you know that the whole age of injustice towards individual groups of people spanned over 345 years? The injustice started in 1619 when 20 individuals came from Africa on a ship which they were sent to Jamestown to be sold as slave workers. After over 200 years, in 1865, slave was finally abolished with the 13th Amendment after 4 years of fighting in the Civil War. Even after this, injustice was still to be found in America although slavery had been abolished. People were still treating colored people different and they had different rights than a white person until 1968 when the Civil Rights Movement finally gave the same rights to each and every person in the United States.

Read More
1681 Words | 7 Pages

The Alienist written by Caleb Carr is a historical fiction read through the narration of John Schuyler Moore a reporter for the New York Times. The story starts on January 9, 1919 the day of Theodore Roosevelt's funeral, after the funeral Moore and a close friend Laszlo Kreizler go to dinner. While at dinner Moore and Kreizler start reminiscing about their time with Roosevelt. Moore and Kreizler flash back to the year of 1896 when they were tracking down a serial killer. Moore who lives with his grandmother after a nasty breakup with his fiancee, is awoken one night by knocking at the front door.

Read More
326 Words | 2 Pages

Brown grew up in a house that didn’t like people having slaves and was very religious. So every decision’s he made he didn’t regret because he was doing it for god or for the slaves. Everything he did he believed it was a mission from god.

Read More
208 Words | 1 Pages

John Brown was a man with a strong hatred for slavery who tried to lead a rebellion against it. After this he was called a “misguided fanatic” by Abraham Lincoln. Which leaves the question, was John Brown a “misguided fanatic”? I think John Brown was a misguided fanatic, or according to dictionary.com a, mistaken person with an extreme, uncritical enthusiasm, because he was so set in his rebellion that his mind couldn’t be changed even when told his plan wouldn’t go well, and although he was told his actions would be fatal he went on to do so . In The Life and Times of Frederick Douglass, Douglass states that there was no changing Brown

Read More
863 Words | 4 Pages

By the time he got to his 50's, he saw that slavery was not going to end peacefully. This led to an obsession with the idea of serving justice to black people and slaves. John Brown figured that the only way for it to end was for him to go and use force on white slave owners, which consisted of him killing them or hurting them and forcing them to give up their slaves. During this obsession with anti slavery, Brown planned a slave uprising at Harper's Ferry. John Brown started plotting to raid the town of Harper's Ferry and seize guns from the federal armory.

Read More
1751 Words | 8 Pages

In the United States, during the eighteen-hundreds’, a small group of people believed that slavery was immoral and did many things to abolish it. John Brown, a Caucasian male who was part of this group of people, did two things that many people in United States history didn’t have the passion to do. John Brown’s life was very interesting: His early life and transition to adulthood, his decision to fight for the cause, his actions of violence in Kansas and Harper’s Ferry, along with, the long-lasting effects of these actions led to his hanging. These events were pivotal to the beginning of the Civil War. “John Brown was born in Torrington, Connecticut, on May 9, 1800, five months after the death of George Washington”(Marrin,7).

Read More
981 Words | 4 Pages

The film, Eyes on the Prize: Fighting Back, Central High School in Little Rock, Arkansas is put to the test. During the Supreme Court case of Brown Vs The Board of Education, many people fought for schools to end segregation of the students. This means that black and white students would attend the same schools together. The Supreme Court case made its final decision and made it illegal to segregate students. Central High School was the school that let black students in first.

Read More
856 Words | 4 Pages

Although using violence may not be the most effective way, during his time period, the only way Brown could bring awareness and action was to use violence. Rather than calling him a terrorist, John Brown was more of a political and a religious zealot that took violently planned actions to support his religious beliefs to counter the political issue of slavery. John Brown was

Read More
1056 Words | 5 Pages

On May 17, 1954, the Brown v. Board of Education Supreme Court Case, who was argued by NAACP (National Association for the Advancement of Colored People) attorney Thurgood Marshall occurred. The reason this case took place is because Oliver Brown believed that segregation in public schools was a mistaken act of the school system. The Supreme Court Case was challenging, but what happened before they got to Washington D.C is even more overwhelming. Oliver Brown, born on August 19, 1918 is the father of Linda Brown who was discriminated and rejected a place in Sumner Elementary School which was a near white public school. Other parents along with Oliver tried to apply to put their children in a white school closer to their homes, but the principal

Read More
1339 Words | 6 Pages

Knowledge at the Price of Insanity Throughout William Faulkner’s novel As I Lay Dying, Darl Bundren is never able to have a complete way of identifying himself and experiences an increasing detachment from his family during their trip to bury their dead mother, Addie. . In an attempt to make everything better Darl sets the barn on fire. An act he believes to be very practical, but others see as insane. The connection is completely severed when he is sent away to an asylum in Jackson because of his attempt to end the nightmare journey he and his family were on.

Read More
379 Words | 2 Pages

John Brown, a small abolitionist leader born in Connecticut in 1800 and grew up in Ohio; he was coming from staunchly Calvinist and an anti-slavery family. He has a life of falling in many businesses, which he declared bankruptcy when he's 42 years old. Brown also had related to more than 20 lawsuits but his life changes by attending an abolition meeting. In 1837, Brown publicly announced in the abolition meeting of his will of dedicate to destroy the institution of slavery. Later in 1848, Brown develop a plan for insurrection.

Read More

More about Is John Brown Insane Essay

Related Topics

Open Document