ipl-logo

Jane Elliott's Argument Analysis: The Blue Eyed Experiment

724 Words3 Pages

The blue eyed – brown eyed experiment in my opinion is indeed ethical. The issue at hand with this experiment is will it cause permeant future psychological damage. Jane Elliott conducted this experiment with her third-grade students which some would say it is too harsh of an exercise for a group that young; She wanted to teach her student that discrimination is wrong which have been a topic they discussed from the first day of school but felt the student would become confused with the fact she just honored Dr. king in the month of February and now she had to explain to them that he was assassinated because of discrimination. Jane Elliott agreed that this exercise can do Psychological damage if not conducted correctly but the benefits are remarkable. …show more content…

Jane Elliot Split her 3rd grade c lass into two different groups brown eyed group and the blue eyed group; before splitting them she asked them is being discriminating to others right and they answer the way she expected them to answer because it has been taught to them since they have been in her class, she then proceeded to ask them why was it wrong and they could not give her a clear answer she also ask them would they like to know how it feels to be discriminated against and they all said yes. She conducted this exercise for a total of two days she started the first day off letting the children know that the brown eyed students were more smarter and all around better than the blue eyed student. She then withness some of the sweetest kids turn into nasty discriminating adolescence they tease the blue eyed children every chance they could. The brown eyed student had such a boost of confidence their academic score was up and they were trying harder to hold to the title of having brown eyes. On the other hand, the blue eyed students grades were down and they kept this sad era throughout the day. The next day Mrs. Elliott toke back what she about the blue eye students and put it onto the brown eyed students; Mrs. Elliott realize that now that the blues were the more superior they were a lot kinder to the brown eyed students their grades and sprites were lifted and she couldn’t believe the sufficient of change of the students. Although, Mrs.

Show More
Related

Anne Anderson Argumentative Essay

502 Words | 3 Pages

A seemingly uncorrelated death of a child becomes an attack on two businesses that brought forth unwanted attention. It reveals how corporations can truly neglect their surroundings and the safety of citizens without remorse. In the quaint town of Woburn, Massachusetts, the death of Anne Anderson’s son due to leukemia quickly transformed from a personal tragedy to an extensive lawsuit. Anne Anderson approached Jan Schlichtmann, a personal injury lawyer, to tackle the case. From the beginning, Anne makes it clear that she does not want money, she simply wants an apology.

Read More

Mac Donald's Argument Analysis: Hard Data, Hollow Protests

450 Words | 2 Pages

Hard Data, Hollow Protests I highly disagree with majority of Mac Donald’s argument. Firstly, her inclination that officers “have more to fear from black men than black men have to fear” from the officers does not sit well with me. Although blacks may make up the highest percentage of cop-killers, blacks are more likely to be shot than whites. I suggest that since both facts are true to an extent, social culture and biases have become the driving force for both instances to play out as they are: Black men are more likely to kill cops, cops are more likely to kill black men.

Read More

Melissa Hoebee Argumentative Essay

719 Words | 3 Pages

Some students tend to forget their teachers when they are done with school. Melissa Hoebee, a teacher who currently teaches in Southern Middle School, shares about her life in teaching and life experiences from her childhood to today. She chose to be a teacher because she wanted to help people learn in school. These life experiences and events before in her childhood helped her become the teacher she is today. Her greatest inspiration was her grandmother.

Read More

A Rhetorical Analysis Of 'The Argument' By Eliza Stacey

844 Words | 4 Pages

The struggle of being financially unstable and in a vulnerable state is something many people have experienced. In 1847 men could go out and get jobs to support themselves and their families, but what about women? Women back in that time still hadn't joined the workforce so they could not help themselves, especially a woman that is pregnant. Eliza Stacey, after her husband was arrested due to an unpaid debt, decided to write to her wealthy father-in-law in hopes that he would help pay the debt of 100 pounds. Eliza Stacey uses multiple persuasion techniques to convince her father-in-law to help them once more, including rhetorical questions or her remorseful diction.

Read More

Nobody Left To Hate Summary

691 Words | 3 Pages

The article Nobody left to hate is explains a social techniques done to help with the communication of children who are of different backgrounds sharing the same class. Consequently, the class consisted of children of different races and ethnic backgrounds in which they group themselves accordingly. The white children were viewed as smart, competitive and “winners”, while the Black and Mexican- American children were viewed as lazy, unintelligent and “losers”. What Aronson and his graduate students did is create an eight week program to aid in the interactions among the students. The Jigsaw classroom is a designed intervention that requires students to all work together and to form closer bonds and reinforce better interactions.

Read More

Discrimination In Ms. Elliot's Assassination

1002 Words | 5 Pages

Once someone knows how it feels to be put down because of their eye color, ethnicity, or how much money they have, or whatever the circumstance may be, they would not ever what to be put in that predicament again. It can be all fun and games until the person doing the discriminating gets hurt too. She also tried the experiment on adults, which showed the same behavior as the third graders. I thought that was pretty interesting, because that basically said that age doesn’t mean anything, we all can be infected with this evilness. If this was taught to people more often, I honestly think that there would be less of this problem in the world.

Read More

Bonnie Steinbock's Argument Analysis

782 Words | 4 Pages

In this paper, I will focus on Bonnie Steinbock’s claim on whether or not we should give equal moral consideration to species outside our own species group. I will first determine what moral concern means, according to Peter singer, and explain how he views the human treatment of animals. I will then outline Steinbock’s argument against Singer’s position and explain how her criticism is part of a much broader issue: that is moral concern. I will finally make my argument against Steinbock as well as address any issues she could possibly raise against my argument. Peter Singer believed that all species, whether it be human or non-human, deserve equal consideration of interests and quality of life.

Read More

Brown V. Board Of Education Case Study

1287 Words | 6 Pages

Segregation caused emotional harm in black students by making them feel that their race was truly inferior. Sociological tests by Kenneth Clark proved that segregated schools made black children feel inferior to white children (“History of Brown v. Board of Education”). Another study also showed black children dealt with psychological harm due to this and segregation (“Brown v. Board at Fifty: “With an Even Hand”). A four year old black child is shown dolls, and he says he prefers the white dolls and selects the white

Read More

Martha Nussbaum's Argument Analysis

1217 Words | 5 Pages

When it comes to Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics, I believe that he has found a common thread in humanity in the fact that humans strive for the moderate in living virtuously. However, I would argue that the thread is varied enough to have no true worth in discerning the aspects of humanity. People have too different moralities and goals. Because Aristotle allows for these “local variations”, as Martha Nussbaum later terms in her defense of Aristotle, he is acknowledging that there cannot be an overarching analysis of humanity.

Read More

Jane Elliot's 'How Racist Are You?'

256 Words | 2 Pages

I consider that it is outrageous that Jane Elliot continues till this day conducting the blue/ brown eyes experiment (with adults). I continue with my argument, Jane Elliot is not presenting the problem properly. At the time of racial segregation I could make an exception to understand her experiment. But what type of excuse she has now. In the video: How Racist Are You?

Read More

Jane Elliot's Experiment

596 Words | 3 Pages

I was shocked that there had been no altercations prior to the experiment but the day of the experiment, the blue eyed children quickly adapted to the idea that they were better than blue eyed students. One of the students said, “I felt like a king,” and continued to state he felt he felt like he ruled the brown eyes(A Class Divided, 1968). By labeling the children and segregating them into specific groups, the

Read More

A Class Divided Documentary Analysis

1170 Words | 5 Pages

The documentary titled, “ A Class Divided” introduces us to the experiment made in an elementary school in Iowa by the schoolteacher named Jane Elliot. The documentary begins with Mrs. Elliot reuniting with the students who she did this experiment with the first time. The students are much older now, and they willingly want to watch the experiment that they were part of when they were elementary kids. The experiment was done days after the death of Martin Luther King Jr. Mrs. Elliot has always thought about doing the eye color experiment, but she was never sure of when to do it. She asked her third grade student if it would be interesting to see what would happen if they were judged by their eye color.

Read More

A Class Divided Analysis

667 Words | 3 Pages

The experiment of ‘A Class Divided’ is a lesson taught by Jane Elliot about discrimination and how it feels to be discriminated against. She first conducted this experiment in 1968 with her class of third graders, she divides people by eye colour and provides collars for them, and she then makes a group of rules separating them and observes how they’re discriminated against in a controlled environment. The experiment breached many ethical guidelines, this is because the experiment wouldn’t have worked otherwise. The rights of the participants was breached in order to achieve accurate results and so that people would feel the humiliation and cage of discrimination.

Read More

Jane Elliot's Essay: The Eye Of The Storm

517 Words | 3 Pages

The Eye of the Storm Jane Elliot was a teacher for a class of eight year olds at a school in Riceville, Iowa. Racism was more of a problem in 1968 than it is today, and Jane was trying to demonstrate to her students what it felt like to be a black person in their society at that time. Her experiment was ran very successfully as her students physically felt how African Americans felt in their society during that time. She separated her class into brown eyes and blue eyes. The first day, the students with blue eyes were better than the students with brown eyes and the opposite the next day.

Read More

Essay On Racism In School

978 Words | 4 Pages

Racism: Why It Should Be Taught To Children Racism has, and always has had, a great effect on American society. Still to this day, even after the civil war over slavery in the 19th century and the anti-segregation movements of the 20th century, countless peoples still face ridicule over the color of their skin or the shape of their face. If it were to be taught in schools that judging someone based on their appearance is bad, then perhaps there wouldn’t be such an integration of racism in modern American society. Not simply learning ‘don’t be a racist’ in a high school social studies course while half asleep or thinking of what’s for lunch, but the concept of just how much it can affect someone’s life in such a negative way should be taught to children throughout their whole school careers. Without outwardly influence, children are proven to be unbiased.

Read More

More about Jane Elliott's Argument Analysis: The Blue Eyed Experiment

Open Document