ipl-logo

Moving Beyond The Critical Synthesis Summary

964 Words4 Pages

Article Reviewed: Hurd, R. W. (2013). Moving beyond the critical synthesis: does the law preclude a future for US unions? Labor History, 54(2), 193-200. doi:10.1080/0023656X.2013.773147. The article, “Moving beyond the critical synthesis: does the law preclude a future for US unions?”, by Hurd, R.W. seeks to give a better understanding of how certain laws limit or restrict unions from being effective. Unions have been around for decades, but with new laws essentially being passed, unions are restricted on what they actual want to accomplish. This article details the decline of unions as a result of those specific laws and how unions will continue to suffer in the future. The author wanted to show how laws and certain boards that are formed …show more content…

Better wages, work environment, and hours available to work are what most unions fight corporations over. These three things take their toll on employee morale as people need to work to provide for their family, but a safe and efficient work environment with decant wages is significantly high on the priority list. There are two bargaining strategies, distributive bargaining and interest-based bargaining (IBB). Distributive bargaining is defined as a negotiation process that has the goal of coming to an agreement over how resources should be allocated. IBB is a mutual gains or win-win approach that looks for logical trade-offs and is referred to as an expanded-pie approach (Study Guide …show more content…

In this situation either the employer or employee will have positive gains. For one to be successful the other has to lose significantly. The goal of distributive bargaining is to get as much of the limited resources for your side as possible. For example, if the union wins higher wages and better healthcare, company executives and shareholders will see decreased wages and benefits. IBB is when both sides can garner wins, but not at the expense of the other side. IBB allows both sides to come away with positive gains in many cases but everything that was negotiated may not have been achieved. When using the IBB to negotiate there must be a list of topics to discuss, otherwise there will be one side walking away

Show More
Related
508 Words | 3 Pages

Philip Dray and his book “ There Is Power in a Union: The Epic Story of Labor in America” provide many information about the vital accomplishments of organized labor evangelists to draw upon. He show us the illuminate its central role in social, economic and political. Throughout his book, the security and dignity locate this struggle in all its various setting from union halls to the halls of Congress and the White House. He demonstrates the urgency of the contest between labor and capital still remains and influences today. Philip Dray offers us with an historic account of the labor-management relations in the United State.

Read More
185 Words | 1 Pages

In Chapter, 5, an intercalary chapter, the tenant farmers suffers from the payments that were unable to be paid mainly due to the decreased crop production. The quote describes the owner’s situation where they were also struggling to pay for the debt they made. Steinbeck uses personification (metaphor) such as the ‘bank monster’ avoiding eating side-meat and ‘breathing’ to describe the bank’s desperate situation where their business would not be able to survive without the reliance on the landowners. Like the monsters, who break the peace and show their wickedness from their unconsciousness, the bank became a source of suffering and pain of the tenant farmers and transformed into ‘money-demanding machine’ when they got into a desperate situation.

Read More
1505 Words | 7 Pages

Unions are formed to give a united voice to the workers in an attempt to create equality and collective security between the corporations and their employees. For example, on August 3rd, 1981, PATCO (Professional Air Traffic Controllers Organization) went on strike in an effort to get better pay and safer working conditions. Two days later, taking the side of business, Ronald Reagan fired 11,345 workers for not returning to work. With these examples, one can see how through

Read More
721 Words | 3 Pages

The ability of unions to rapidly expand amidst crises like the Great Depression provides "important historical background on the relationships of power between labor, the state, and the economy. " Just as legislative changes enabled 1930s activism by reforming anti-union policies, so too have modern reforms enabled tactics like unionization efforts at major companies today. And mirroring how economic desperation drove militancy before New Deal relief, recent strikes have emerged from frustrations over stagnant wages and pandemic

Read More
1205 Words | 5 Pages

Conflicts between workers and employers are prevalent to this day. From fair wages, to better working conditions, and even to appropriate healthcare, there is always some form of questioning that needs to be addressed. Dating back to the late 1800’s the economy and labor market of the United States underwent massive changes which mainly revolved around people of all different racial and socioeconomic backgrounds becoming wage laborers. Due to these previously unheard-of changes, a conflict between the employees and employers began. Therefore, in order to resolve labor issues, through great difficulty workers created unions and protested against their employers.

Read More
623 Words | 3 Pages

A union or a labor union is an association that help workers bargain for wage increase and better working conditions. The appearance of a union is an advantage for the workers, but it becomes a real worry for the business owners because unions are the reason of increasing labor costs. According to the film, one of the factors that generated income inequality is the decline of unions. Several restrictions on labor laws and the effort of employers to reduce labor costs by eliminating unions caused the middle-class workers trouble. The middle-class wages seem to be unchanged, or even lower over time.

Read More
1326 Words | 6 Pages

A labor union is responsible for protecting and furthering the rights of the employees who belong to them. There is a case that is currently challenging the constitutionality of Abood, which could potentially eliminate the mandatory dues. In Charles Lane’s article, he argues that public unions have lost touch with those who are part of the union and that if they fail, they have no one but themselves to blame. The second article, written by George Will, discusses

Read More
624 Words | 3 Pages

The history of American unions was particularly tumultuous between 1919 and 1946” (Brucher 1). The NLRA allowed “employees to have the right of self-organization, to form, join, or assist labor organizations, to bargain collectively through representatives of their own choosing, and to engage in concerted activities” (Brucher 1). Still till this day unions have a strong bearing on the workforce.

Read More
847 Words | 4 Pages

In contemporary society, the NLRB continues to keep union and employer disputes in check. Collectively, these pieces of legislation would lead America out of the Great Depression and down a new path of

Read More
1233 Words | 5 Pages

President Franklin Roosevelt’s Wagner Act, also known as the National Labor Relations Act addressed relations over the right to unionize between employer and employee. Since President Roosevelt enacted the law in 1935, the battle between the “right to work” and unionization continues to present an issue amongst workers across the nation. The National Labor Relations Act protects unions and their members, as well as the right for employees to negotiate with their employers. However, legislation varies by state, with some states more sympathetic to the unions than others. Protection of unions by individual states fluctuates based on the salary of workers in the union or whether or not the state has a right-to-work policy or a closed shop policy.

Read More
823 Words | 4 Pages

The Knights of Labor and the American Federation of Labor are just two examples of labor unions. Working in such poor conditions with little pay was a harsh reality. Labor unions provided at least some hope of change for workers. A worker in Hollitz explained that the reason he went on strike from George Pullman’s “model” company was because, “five reductions in wages, work, and in conditions of employment…” The railroad strike of 1877 grew violent, as workers demanded better wages.

Read More
656 Words | 3 Pages

In the past, the treatment of workers was unfair and frequently cruel. Labor unions changed that. Pushing for better working environments, union laborers arduously fought for justice in the workplace, resulting in the passing of many laws and Federal acts protecting workers and improving life for the average working man. In an article from the Economic Policy Institute (EPI) illustrating the benefits of unions for everyday people, authors Walters and Mishel state: “Unions make a substantial and measurable difference in the implementation of labor laws.” A variety of necessary laws were passed, including child labor laws and acts granting compensation for employees injured in the workplace.

Read More
617 Words | 3 Pages

In Practical Ethics, Peter Singer successfully refutes objections to his argument that take only the actual characteristics of the foetus into account in determining the morality of abortion and not its potential characteristics. While some opponents of abortion recognise that on the basis of the foetus’ actual characteristics, the foetus compares unfavourably with many non-human animals; They claim that it is when we consider its potential to become a mature human being that membership of the species Homo sapiens becomes important, and the ‘foetus far surpasses any chicken, pig or calf’. The common argument for the potential of the foetus can be stated as follows: First premise: It is wrong to kill a potential human being. Second premise: A human foetus is a potential human being.

Read More
210 Words | 1 Pages

Despite their long decline over several decades, labor unions increasingly find themselves as the reoccurring subject of controversy in the American public. Examples include topics such as income inequality, benefits, and wages for lower income employees in the fast food industry are of great public interest. Moreover, as the American economy for workers has shifted from one based on manufacturing and the production of hard goods to a service based economy, the labor movement confronts current challenges. As a result, labor unions and business enterprises maintain their disagreement on the proper role of team dynamics and the usefulness of guidelines targeted at the workplace segment. Be that as it may, labor unions members earned above average

Read More
1464 Words | 6 Pages

The topic of Labor Unions has been the focus of many political debates in recent years, with these discussions having people advocate for and against the unions. Labor Unions are an organization that represent a collective group of employees to protect and further theirs rights and interests. Labor Unions were first introduced in the eighteenth century with increasing numbers around the United States and the world, but unfortunately during the past decade these numbers have drastically decreased, resulting in less education and achievement of solidarity among employees. Solidarity is the unity or agreement of feeling or action, especially among individuals with a common interest. Workers in the United States would benefit more through labor

Read More

More about Moving Beyond The Critical Synthesis Summary

Related Topics

Open Document