ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of GCC And SIP

585 Words3 Pages

When evaluating the options for GCC and SIP, the Commission on Public Service should examine each policy using the strategic triangle alongside traditional cost/benefit analysis. The three options - status quo, closing GCC and funding SIP, or forming a coalition between the two and Belltown - all have different public value they aim to create, operational capacity, and public/private support (Moore, 2003) and, thus, result in different pros and cons for the city.

The simplest option with the clearest outcome is maintaining the status quo. This supports GCC’s public value of “serv[ing] the poor and marginalized of the city of Seattle” while still allowing SIP to build on its own. The capacity to serve is clear as GCC and SIP can both continue …show more content…

The recent 20% increase to 4,500 homeless in 2016 makes it clear that the status quo is not a long-term solution. Additionally, tensions between activists and those looking to gentrify the neighborhood will continue to grow over time unless action is taken.

A more contentious policy with less clear outcomes would be revoking GCC’s permit and supporting SIP, creating public value through boosting the economy. The capacity to do so is clear as more funding to SIP’s job training programs, removing homeless populations from the neighborhood, and allowing new businesses into GCC’s building each support economic growth.
However, there is no guarantee these projected economic boosts would occur. This is because homelessness is a wicked problem, and its increase in Seattle does not mean the status quo is failing (Moore, 2003). For instance, without GCC more homeless will be relegated to the streets. This could in turn hamper SIP’s job training efforts and make the neighborhood less desirable for future investment, counter to the whole goal of the policy! Additionally, this policy only has a small handful of support as it is an example of running government like a business, perhaps increasing efficiency, but at the cost of economic inequality (Box,

Show More
Related
615 Words | 3 Pages

The problem, however, is the effect the revitalization has on the homeless community. The project is already underway; new “trendy” stores have been built alongside the luxury high rises located near the waterfront. While this improvement should be happily received by residents, one must question what will happen to the current residents and, more importantly, the homeless population that rely on establishments that have been around for decades. This change

Read More
1841 Words | 8 Pages

There has to be a realistic solution that can be put into motion to benefit everyone involved. Referring again to his article “Is Gentrification All Bad?” Davidson argues that urban renewal, if done right, is not a monstrous custom that it is painted to be; nevertheless, he reasons that gentrification depends on who does it, how they do it, and why they do it. As a resident in New York, a city where gentrification is as widespread as the common cold in winter, Davidson speculates that those who go into a neighborhood with the intention to renovate houses, or abandoned buildings ought to have a good reason for it. The author points out that “Gentrification does not have to be something that one group inflicts on another…” (Davidson 349), rather, he suggests that everyone, the gentrifiers and the locals, be on the same page when it comes to developing their

Read More
754 Words | 4 Pages

According to the text, “In the late 1980s, Bass and other local community organizers founded Community Coalition, an organization with a mission to help transform the social and economic conditions in South Los Angeles that foster addiction, crime, violence, and poverty by building a community institution that involves thousands in creating, influencing, and changing public policy.” (Wikipedia) This means that Bass is using her Community Coalition organization to positively change the bad economic conditions in Southern LA. This is significant because the organization has given homeless or less fortunate people resources to provide for themselves and their families. In conclusion, the Community Coalition is playing a key role in helping end

Read More
128 Words | 1 Pages

Living on the streets has become a misfortune for numerous residents around Phoenix, Arizona. Being homeless on their own with no family, nowhere to live, and the least bit of hope or faith in the lord and savior Jesus Christ. Some of these people even believe that it is Grand Canyon University fault that they are homeless now. Considering that before GCU started to expand the area was exceedingly low living and living in the area is what was affordable for people and their family. The GCU mantra is to “Build the Community” as a result of them building their own community people have been kicked out of their homes.

Read More
900 Words | 4 Pages

A statistic that led D.C Mayor Muriel E. Bowser to vow to manage the endemic homelessness in the city. The seriousness of the situation can be evaluated by anyone who roams the streets of the city, especially during winter, when homeless men and women amass in parks, Metro stations or any other places where they can stay relatively warm. Washington D.C. has one of the highest rates of homelessness in the United States, with 120 homeless people per 10,000 residents, keeping in mind that the national average is about 18. The council’s study also revealed a shortage of living-wage jobs which calls the attention to the lack of affordable

Read More
111 Words | 1 Pages

In recent years, the Long Beach homeless population has unfortunately increased. This includes an increase of children living in tents, cars and homeless encampments. By working together, the city, state, and federal governments can enact policies and programs that will more effectively serve homeless people. Although current policies are already in place, the laws and regulations can be re-defined to include more affordable housing and services. Everyone has to keep in mind the homeless people don’t always choose homelessness it is often a forced situation.

Read More
860 Words | 4 Pages

5. What should the government do about the homelessness crisis? According to Chumir (2008), Canadian governments should “address homelessness and inadequate housing as a national emergency” (p. 11)

Read More
1490 Words | 6 Pages

Homelessness has been on a consistent uptrend over the past couple of years due to the continuous population growth, with the current population coming in at 8.1 billion people. This rise causes issues in many different places, more commonly in already densely populated areas such as cities and more specifically, Sacramento. Amidst the vibrant culture and economic powerhouse of California’s capital, a depressing reality exists of many individuals and families living in unfortunate circumstances who currently suffer to find secure, stable housing. Sacramento has seen a substantial increase in homelessness, and the sidewalks serve as a poignant reminder of the crisis at hand, with tents and camps lining streets as well as individuals seeking refuge in various public

Read More
1182 Words | 5 Pages

As time goes on, the rate of homelessness rises as the population rises. Homelessness then was mostly caused by a family’s history of being homeless, drug abuse, mental disorders, and tyrannical leaders forcing his people into poverty. In modern times, several organizations are now trying to end homelessness by building cheaper housing projects more affordable to the poor and homeless shelters; these projects usually cost a fair amount of money.

Read More
1395 Words | 6 Pages

To expand successful efforts to prevent and end homelessness in communities across the country, the Alliance is devoted to working with the Administration, Congress, and our local, state, and national partners to improve federal policies that will prevent and end homelessness. In order to do this the policy states that the government will cover the cost of renewing and expanding investments in permanent supportive housing. Benefit The benefit here besides getting homeless veterans on the road to recovery via housing, the benefit stemmed from this policy provides monetary assistance to states and counties where homelessness is prominent. They will support this policy by creating 25,500 new units of permanent supportive housing (PSH) to allow communities to end chronic homelessness by the end of 2017.

Read More
1020 Words | 5 Pages

Many of the homeless people today that are on the streets are living in homeless shelters at night and are walking the streets by day. Although the police, benevolent charities, social workers, urban planners, politicians have all tried to make the problem go away, homelessness has stubbornly refused to yield to their interventions. The population may grow or contract, and demographics may change from older male alcoholics to young mothers of color with several children, but homelessness itself remains-a deeply rooted and troubling reminder that even in relatively and prosperous times there are some people who barely scrape by (Blau, J (2014) p.524). In combination with the decline of low-wage jobs, cutbacks in social welfare, and mental health policies that both denationalize the mentally ill and make it harder for the seriously deturbed to obtain care, these policies brought a major increase in both the size of the homeless population and as it scattered throughout the city, its visibility (Blau, J (2014) p.527). Many of the people of the people that are homeless are homeless due to the fact of them not having enough income to be able to afford the necessities and to be able to support their selves and/or their children.

Read More
377 Words | 2 Pages

A growing number of the public is at risk of becoming homeless because of the inability to pay the large percentage of their income for housing (Think Student Canada, 2009). Welfare is among the most substantial investment for Canada’s future as a stable and prosperous society (Jencks, 1994). The increase of funds may seem costly and undesirable; nevertheless, the rights of the homeless should take precedence over the financing of the solution (Hwang,

Read More
2026 Words | 9 Pages

The time has come to move forward and create new laws and new ways to help the homeless population in New York City. One such change that could be made is the idea of permanent supportive housing. Permanent supportive housing is an effective method to combat homelessness permanently because “...The public saves money by getting homeless people, particularly people with the most severe issues, off the streets, and into housing. Even though the housing costs money, they save in emergency rooms, jails and homeless shelters” (Bolan and Tomao). The challenge with this method of combating homelessness is the idea that people do not want housing developed within their residential area as discussed earlier.

Read More
498 Words | 2 Pages

The solution targets the chronically homeless, who cost the health-care and social service systems the most money. The program of providing apartments to the chronically homeless is selective due to limited money, but requirements must be met to be eligible. The program creates dependency under supervision to get people back on their feet. Gladwell assesses the problem by conducting marginal analysis to weigh the cost and benefits. The benefit of spending less money to solve the problem outweighs the opportunity cost of serving all the homeless with a shelters and soup kitchens.

Read More
625 Words | 3 Pages

I live only a few miles away from Seattle where the shining glass skyscrapers protrude out of the landscape of like giant spikes on the back of a great beast, reflecting the light around them. Right before dusk, the towering Space Needle resembles a charcoal sketch silhouetted against the dying sun. Nestled between mountain ranges, the Puget Sound, and Lakes Union and Washington, this picturesque city may look like a beautiful place to live, but underneath the shining overpasses and next to two huge multi-million dollar sports stadiums, lays a three-mile stretch of tents and garbage where thousands of homeless live. With fires and acts of violence breaking out daily, this chaotic landscape earned the name “the Jungle.” Seattle announced this problem a state emergency back in 2014 when the ever growing population of homeless people grew to an almost uncontrollable amount.

Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of GCC And SIP

Related Topics

Open Document