ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of Genetic Discrimination

1062 Words5 Pages

In a like manner, another topic for discussion that pertains to ethical obligations and individuals rights, genetic discrimination. To begin, the Genetics Home Reference website provides a clear definition, “Genetic discrimination occurs when people are treated differently by their employer or insurance company because they have a gene mutation that causes or increases the risk of an inherited disorder.” (Ghr.nlm.nih.gov. 2017, para. 1). A huge advocate in this arena is Karen Rothenberg, in an address to the government Protecting Workers from Genetic Discrimination (2007), she placed a great deal of emphasis on the fact that although scientific advances can open up a world of possibilities of finding causes and cures, something needed to be …show more content…

For instance, if one learned results from genetic testing that the odds were probable that an impairment or handicap would occur in the future, one may be compelled to advise genetically related family members of the results (Van Camp, 2014). Although feeling compelled, one would personally take into consideration the other individuals lives, the extent and severity of the impairment, quality of life, and the prognosis. Meaning, is the impairment so severe that it needs to be brought to their attention or should it be done from the perspective of simply suggesting genetic testing for themselves or going to a physician for a route physical. Personally, it is of the belief that instances can occur in which individuals can be worked up for something little or nothing all, which can lead to health issues as well so, it would be very dependent on the severity and significance of the …show more content…

It is of the opinion that this alone does not justify an abortion to the unborn, there are many more points to consider. The key word in this situation is probability, there has not been any information that suggests genetic testing is one-hundred percent guaranteed. It is believed that in order to make an informed and ethical decision the term probability would have to clearly be defined. The other term to consider a need of clarification is serious, what one may think serious means, another may have a whole different meaning and level of severity. Then there is also the question about a cure, it was mentioned that a cure does not exist, but what is not said is that the fetus can or cannot live a decent life without a cure. For instance, there may be a possibility that medication can help an individual live a so-called adequate life even if there is not a cure. In addition, what someone deems decent life should also be questioned, it is of personal opinion there is a big difference between a missing a limb as opposed to being bed ridden without the ability to function on one’s

Show More
Related

Unrequited Love In The Things They Carried By Tim O Brien

1003 Words | 5 Pages

In many stories, love is the cliche where the boy goes after the girl where they date and then marry. These are “true love” stories. However, in the novel The Things They Carried by Tim O’Brien, he clearly illustrates how love does not need to be romantic to be real. Soldiers bond through war. They all experience the same hardships, survive the same horrors.

Read More

Josef Mengele Research Paper

591 Words | 3 Pages

Josef Mengele “Angel of Death” Did you know that Josef Mengele was the main doctor at Auschwitz? Mengele grew up in a troubled family, performed horrific experiments, and proved just how deadly and inhumane medical experiments can be. Josef Mengele was born on March 16, 1911 and was the oldest of three sons.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Eugenics

1379 Words | 6 Pages

Lastly, I will argue that eugenics and the fundamental reasoning behind the pre-implantation genetic diagnosis' Procreative beneficence' are not morally permissible. Explanation Of The Article Lenz and Carmi's article discusses

Read More

Off Study Violation

784 Words | 4 Pages

Terminally ill patients are given two options: participate in a study or face certain death. However, participating in the study has its own pitfall: they may be given a placebo, in which case they are still facing death. Therefore, the options can be rewritten as accepting death, or putting their lives to chance, where a randomized sorting method decides their fate. Due to the will to live, patients will opt for their only chance at survival, which is participating in the study. However, the researchers violate the formula of humanity in two ways: the participants of the study are being treated merely as a means, and not as an end.

Read More

Arguments Against Prenatal Genetic Testing

699 Words | 3 Pages

Abortion has long been an issue that has been debated surrounding medical ethics. With genetic testing leading to many parents choosing to terminate the pregnancy in the case of a ¨probable risk that a fetus carries a genetic disorder¨ (Rebouché and Rothenberg 988) it lends itself to believe that there is a direct connection between genetic testing and abortion. This is why genetic testing must be done only in necessary cases, to be able to protect the lives of unborn children that have

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Racial Preferences

571 Words | 3 Pages

So, Let’s Talk About Your Racial ‘Preference’ How many times have we heard people say things like “not to be racist, but I don 't find Asian guys attractive”, firstly, if you need to say “not to be racist” before you speak, chances are what you’re about to say is in fact racist. But what happens when these statements are actually challenged? Well you’ll usually get something along the lines of “Well it’s just MY preference”. This makes it personal and thus not about race at all, right?

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Reverse Discrimination

676 Words | 3 Pages

Affirmative action is one of the many controversial topics talked about among the U.S.'s general population. The definition of Affirmative action is “A set of procedures designed to eliminate unlawful discrimination between applicants, remedy the results of such prior discrimination, and prevent such discrimination in the future” (Affirmative Action par 1). This hot topic has place the citizens on one side and on another side: Anti-Affirmative action and Pro-Affirmative Action. The Anti-Affirmative action side believes it does not remove discrimination, instead it creates reverse discrimination against the majority. Secondly, Anti-Affirmative action side declares that the action violates the 14th Amendment.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Eugenics

1420 Words | 6 Pages

English Scientist Francis Galton coined the term Eugenics, which is the study/science of genetic and prenatal influences that affect the outcome of certain qualities in offspring. Francis Galton defined Eugenics as, “the improvement of a population by selective breeding of its best specimens.” Farmers and animal breeders used to employ selective breeding in order to create improved crops and improved strains of characteristics of animals. Many scientists then began studying different variations in plants and animals and were trying to understand how these variations were implemented in future generations. Although Eugenics has been used by farmers in both plants and animals, Galton decided to apply it to the human population which in turn created

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Eugenics

486 Words | 2 Pages

Scientists have made it a goal to purify the human race of genetic defects and remove unwanted preborn individuals before they go through a life of illness or disability. Scientists feel that they know what is best for society and by making the costs more reasonable they have already begun to “purify”. According to a Pediatric Geneticist at Children’s Hospital Boston, “An estimated 92% of all women who receive a prenatal diagnosis of Down Syndrome choose to terminate their pregnancy. Where our ethics and morals when we decide that the baby, who will live a full life, is not enough for the

Read More

Legal And Ethical Issues Surrounding The Abortion Debate

3731 Words | 15 Pages

Kathyrn Butler in “The Hope and Heartache of Prenatal Screening” states families may choose to undergo prenatal screening to prepare for the possibility of a terminal illness or disability in the unborn baby. However, this raises ethical concerns, as prenatal testing can lead to the termination of pregnancies when a genetic disorder is identified. According to the British Advisory Service in “Termination of Pregnancy for Fetal Anomaly,” women may choose to terminate a pregnancy on grounds of fetal anomaly due to factors such as the emotional and financial costs of raising a disabled child, the impact on the caretaking abilities for existing children, and the belief that it would be cruel to bring a child into the world who will require constant medical intervention and potentially live in pain.” Furthermore, Joe Carter in “Should Christian Parents Use Prenatal Genetic Testing?” states that “today, the most common and widely accepted form of eugenics in America is the aborting of children who have genetic defects, especially Down syndrome. Approximately 67 percent of prenatal diagnoses for Down syndrome result in an abortion, according to estimated pregnancy termination rates from 1995 to 2011.”

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Eugenics

2140 Words | 9 Pages

Domesticated plants and animals are an important part of human life, and without eugenics there would be none. However, the validity of eugenics being used on people has been debated from a moral perspective since its creation, but even if it was morally justified eugenics would not work the way people expect it would. According to Merriam-Webster, the full definition of eugenics is, “a science that deals with the improvement (as by control of human mating) of hereditary qualities of a race or breed,” (Merriam-Webster). What must be noted is that, along with the improvement of some hereditary qualities there is detriment to others. Despite its usefulness in developing domesticated plants and animals, eugenics is not a viable option for improving

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Genetic Selection

1767 Words | 8 Pages

It is a natural instinct of human nature to strive for superiority. Since the beginning of our history, we have been known to want to rise to the top. It is ingrained into our culture and everyday aspects of life that we may not even realize: school, sports competitions, careers, politics, and the media. Everyone wants to be smarter, prettier, richer, more powerful, and more athletic. What if this idea of competition was taken a step further and someone’s future was determined for them before they were even born?

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Genetic Testing Disabled People

1377 Words | 6 Pages

Bioethics Essay 1 Sam Vallentine – 430211968 – 2015 Is genetic testing a threat to the rights of disabled people? Genetic testing is not a threat to the rights of disabled people because it does not necessarily imply any negative sentiments towards people with disability. Investigating genetic trait possibilities, diseases or disabilities in unborn infants, children, or adults does not directly threaten the integrity, autonomy, or inherent value of disabled members of society because simply looking for or knowing about such traits is not directly linked to eradicating or ‘curing’ carriers of them. Although medical practice policies and social customs surrounding the use of the information gained from genetic testing can potentially be a threat to the rights of the disabled, they can also be a source of aid and strengthening for disabled people, therefore it is an unsupported assumption that genetic testing poses a direct threat to disabled people’s rights. Many conditions can be tested for by analysis of someone’s

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Eugenics

722 Words | 3 Pages

Eugenics is the science of using artificial selection to improve genetic features of the population. It is thought that improvement of the human race can be seen through sterilization of people who exhibit undesirable traits and selective breeding. Often called Social Darwinism, the concept was widely accepted during the time of World War I. It quickly became a taboo after World War II when Nazi Germany used it as an excuse for genocide. The thought of improving the human race by manipulating who is allowed to breed can either be appalling or compelling.

Read More

Genetic Discrimination Effects

1640 Words | 7 Pages

In the early 1990s, the notion of “genetic discrimination” became established as a way of referring to unfair and borderline dehumanizing treatment of an individual on the basis of what is known or assumed about his or her genetic makeup. According to Somek, many people experience genetic discrimination in relation to insurance or

Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of Genetic Discrimination

Related Topics

Open Document