ipl-logo

Should Drug Testing Be Mandatory

1893 Words8 Pages

Many families receive welfare or cash assistance. These families apply for welfare due to low income and then when they get money monthly for food it is called food assistance. This welfare program is called the temporary assistance for needy families (“Welfare Reform”).
All over America many families are receiving welfare from the state. The welfare money comes out of the money taxpayers pay in. However many people question whether the money is being misused or not. Although people may misuse the welfare assistance for drugs or to support a drug habit, there are many families who make use from the money they are given therefore drug testing welfare patients should not be mandatory.
Historically, many people around the United States have …show more content…

Unconstitutional meaning that it violates the welfare patients human rights. The reasoning behind drug testing the welfare patients is because they suspect something that is unfair to the welfare patients.One of the federal governments in the state of florida required that welfare patients some unwillingly to do mandatory drug testing. Doing this will affect many people all throughout America (Robles). Based off of the evedine many welfare patients in florida felt intimidated by this because there human rights are being violated. This shows why drug testing welfare patients is unconstitutional. This shows that it is unconstitutional because many families around America now may be left with a nervous feeling knowing what some of the governments have began to enforce which is to take a drug test to continue to receive food assistance.“In Marchwinski v. Howard, the ACLU challenged Michigan's across-the-board testing and the district court ruled in September 2000 that it violated the recipients Fourth Amendment rights against unreasonable searches” (Lewis). This quote says that drug testing welfare patients violates the Fourth Amendment right against the welfare patients all around America. This proves that it is unconstitutional because the welfare patients are being drug tested with no suspect of drug use it is unreasonable.This shows that drug testing welfare patients is wrong …show more content…

Although this topic still needs to be resolved. Drug testing welfare patients is not the best option for one it is unconstitutional. Secindly it ends up costing more money in the end. This is because there are so many people in one state and they get drug tested. Well when they do this it ends up being that more people are using the assistance, and less people than they thought are scamming the system. Lastly it could also punish the children more than anything. The children end up going hungry. In order to resolve the problem by resisting. Make it know that this is not what the society wants. It also breaks The Fourth Amendment law. Due to this we need to stick up for our rights as a nation and all the welfare patients need to come together as one and stand their ground.Although it is debatable whether the welfare patients are scamming the system or not, the welfare patients have rights. Saying this it should not be mandatory for the welfare patients to be drug tested.The welfare assistance helps many people around the United States it is necessary it stays available to all of the needy families that have low

Show More
Related
904 Words | 4 Pages

In Why Drug testing Welfare Recipients Is a Waste of Taxpayer Money, Darlena Cunha works to persuade that drug testing welfare recipients feeds the stereotype stigma towards those asking for the extra assistance and is actually wasting the taxpayer’s money. As soon as the page opens, there is a large image of two gloved hands holding a drug test. The picture is dark and the light is focused on a blue urine test for Cannabis and an Anatomical Therapeutic Chemical (ATC). As a result, the image automatically gives the reader a serious and eery tone.

Read More
1102 Words | 5 Pages

That is not what welfare should be used for though, it should be used as an extra last resort support system for an individual until they can get back on their feet. This is why there are so many people on the street and in homeless shelters, because the government is giving them free money. This is why it should in the end be up to private organizations and charity. This is because if it is a small group of people working with the less fortunate they can get to know them individually and try to help them off of welfare or the support that they are getting. Granted there are some things that the less fortunate should have the opportunity to have and that is health care.

Read More
1814 Words | 8 Pages

Drug abuse often is rampant among the lower socio-economic classes. The bill will directly affect families whose benefits are decreased, specifically, the children of the parents who test positive for drugs. This policy seeks to deny aid to the recipients who are using drugs, but benefits will continue for minor children. However, they will continue to suffer because they are dependent on their parents for sustenance.

Read More
984 Words | 4 Pages

The information is completely factual on both opinions. In reality, drug testing would cost even more than us as taxpayers put in for TANF programs, and things of the like. It would only add to the amount we pay. The government wants to keep everyone happy, but they don’t want to raise taxes, and the people don’t want that either. It is still back and forth and not set in stone as to if they should implement drug testing.

Read More
420 Words | 2 Pages

I used to work with a psychiatrist, most of our patients were homeless. One of the things I notice was that it was very difficult for them to comply with the instructions of their control medication. I remember some of the patients were verbally aggressive to the Doctor because her drug test came back positive and through the state of california Doctor are not allowed to prescribe medication to the patient. I really enjoy reading this article. I like how there are people who have the heart to advocate for the people who live in the streets and are being unfairly ticket and

Read More
471 Words | 2 Pages

In Alexander’s words, police officers can pull over anyone they want, and using the pretext of a common traffic stop, they use the opportunity to try to fish out any drugs, which is part of the reason why mass incarceration is such an issue in America, if you stop and frisk enough people, of course you will eventually find someone who is breaking the

Read More
766 Words | 4 Pages

This is not a waste of money, and should instead be considered a responsibility of the federal and state governments. Employers who test their workers foot the bill for the expenses of drug screening. Therefore, the federal government should pay the expenses of drug testing their welfare recipients, since most people on welfare receive assistance in place of a job. Also, supporters of drug testing would much rather pay to make sure people are living productive, and healthy lifestyles (“The Pros and Cons…” para 3). It is unfair for those who work hard everyday to support their families, to have to support those who are not taking the necessary steps to be

Read More
1365 Words | 6 Pages

Welfare recipients around America are not doing anything to get off of welfare. Research shows that they spend more money on things they do not necessarily need, rather than carefully spending their money on the necessities. Welfare is for people who need the extra help to get themselves and their families by. Many people on welfare are wasting their money on drugs and alcohol. Welfare recipients should be required to pass a drug test in order to receive the benefits of welfare.

Read More
1104 Words | 5 Pages

An article from The Washington Post, “The Double-Standard of Making the Poor Prove They’re Worthy of Government Benefits” by Emily Badger, conveys her insights on the double-standard that is put on citizens who receive welfare benefits. We don’t drug-test farmers who receive agriculture subsidies, college students who receive Pell Grants, and wealthy families who cash in on the home mortgage interest deduction (Badger). No one seems to give a second glance when the government hands out money to farmers, college students, and wealthy home-owners because, when compared to the portion of the population on welfare, society has taught us who is more likely to abuse drugs. In most cases, welfare recipients are given a check from the government about once a month. This is a clear-cut, easy to see benefit.

Read More
264 Words | 2 Pages

The question came up whether it's fair to judge an entire system based on the few people who abuse the system? The response was you are not judging the whole system. Instead you are making the system more reliable. By drug testing you are rewarding the honest participants by making the application process easier. By getting rid of the dishonest

Read More
1502 Words | 7 Pages

Thirty-five percent of Americans recieve help from welfare every day, and if we drug test them that number would suddenly drop. Some individuals claim that drug testing would help individuals by putting them into treatment; however, there are several reasons why drug testing would not help recipients. While drug testing could recognize the individuals who need help, problems would be caused such as impacts on the person, the cost, and other impacts such as on children and poverty levels. I A. First, drug testing will cause problems with the money people are receiving. If the test is positive the recipient will have reduced income and they may not get any income at all (US Department of Health and Human Services 8).

Read More
460 Words | 2 Pages

In 2000, a judge from Michigan ruled that drug testing welfare recipients had violated the recipients privacy rights (“Federal Appeals Court Upholds Ban on Testing Welfare Recipients for Drugs,” p. 1). The drug testing method also goes against the Fourth Amendment right to be free of search and seizures by the government without probable cause. People feel that the poor should not have to choose between providing for their family and give up their rights (“Federal Appeals Court Upholds Ban on Testing Welfare Recipients for Drugs,” p. 4). As a result, some states choose not to require drug test, because they feel it is

Read More
805 Words | 4 Pages

To begin with, “It’s a life or death issue. We are losing six people a day from just prescription drug abuse”. (James Mcdonough) reason that we are losing six people a day is because of the prescription drug ads that are on tv. Another thing is that people who see the drug ads feel the need to call for an appointment for their doctors to have them prescribe them a medicine that they want. Some of the people that see the drug ads on tv are thinking that it is ok to ask their doctors for prescriptions which is weakening their relationships between each of them

Read More
579 Words | 3 Pages

In Michigan, there was a law created that drug tests should be used in 2003 and it was found unconstitutional. According to American Civil Liberties Union, this point came up in the case of Marchwinski v. Howard this case took place in the U.S Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit and the policy was deemed unconstitutional. In the United States Constitution, drug testing welfare recipients violate the fourth amendment. Drug testing welfare recipients fall under the category of unreasonable searches. Many welfare recipients can tell their privacy is being striped away from them.

Read More
1702 Words | 7 Pages

In his novel, “1984,” renowned author George Orwell expands on the extent to which an oppressive regime can affect the lives of people. Orwell's experiences with political turmoil during the Spanish Civil War would eventually evolve into a dislike for communists, fascists, and dishonest politicians. Orwell can be deemed a modern Democratic Socialist who urges people to be literate in language; he argued the mastery of language can reflect intelligence. Orwell warns the reader of the dangers of totalitarianism in 1984, through describing a dystopian future state of Oceania that has absolute control over the thoughts, language, and narratives of society and is characterized by perpetual warfare and government oppression. Orwell dictates the

Read More

More about Should Drug Testing Be Mandatory

Related Topics

Open Document