ipl-logo

Psychotherapy Vs Weak Theism Summary

1479 Words6 Pages

Article Summary
People’s belief in God and supernatural forces have triggered psychologists to include theism in psychotherapy. The imperative role of spirituality in shaping people’s lives has led to the introduction of prayer, moral values, and reading scriptures in addressing various mental conditions in the belief that there is a sturdy relationship between naturalism and theism. The article Including God in Psychotherapy: Strong vs. Weak Theism by Slife et al. (2010) discusses Gods involvement in psychotherapy. The authors believe that the two aspects of theism can be combined and used complementarily in psychotherapy. Nonetheless, some scholars have been incredulous on the use of the theistic approach to psychotherapy due to the presumption …show more content…

Naturalism is inclined to the autonomous physical natural process that can explain any given phenomena (Slife et al., 2010, p.163). Conversely, theism supposes that the natural laws are not sufficient on their own and that God is important in providing a more comprehensive understanding.
The patent difference between the two, therefore, is that while naturalism holds that God is not necessary for psychotherapy, theism recognizes him as central to understanding the different mental challenges that people face. Although such glaring differences exist, the authors are critical that most of the professional work with a large number of people who believe in God. Therefore, they presume that it is possible to conceptualize naturalism and theism to work complementarily.
The authors indicate that deism and dualism have been used to reconcile to two antagonistic approaches. Deism acknowledges the role of God in creating the universe and the natural forces but distances him from any form of consequent control. Therefore, science can proceed without considering the role of God in making it flourish. Dualism, on the other hand, holds that humans would not be incomplete without the body and soul (p.164). The two approaches offer a ground to talk about God when referring to …show more content…

First, God’s activity may not be limited to a particular time or sphere. Secondly, God should not be viewed as an add-on to the naturalistic therapies but a permanent core component to guide research and practice. Also, the peripheral aspects of theism such as prayer and meditation are insufficient on their own and can only be theistically meaningful through the recognition of an active God. Finally, God’s activity should be reflected in all levels of theory and practice in psychotherapy.
The article further provides the characteristics of weak theism that delineates it from the psychotherapy approach that acknowledges the role of God. Such practice is focused on compartmentalized theism whereby a practitioner delineates his beliefs from the practice. They also embrace the aspect of peripheral theism whereby the activities that are introduced in the context of therapy including prayer and forgiveness do not require an active God. Moreover, weak theism is inconsistent due to its attempt to combine both naturalistic and dualistic approaches, making the role of God

Show More
Related

Summary Of 4-Mat Review Mcminn

1368 Words | 6 Pages

McMinn 4-MAT Review: Psychology, Theology and Spirituality Toya V Mitchell Liberty University Review The text Psychology, Theology and Spirituality in Christian Counseling written by Dr. Mark McMinn brings psychology, theology and spirituality together within the counseling office. Throughout the book McMinn presents several challenges that counselors face within their profession, spiritual relationship and personal self (McMinn, 2011). These challenges include areas of competence, blurred personal-professional distinctions, training difficulties, dominant views of mental health, lack of scientific foundations and ethical standards.

Read More

Mark Mcminn's Psychology, Theology, And Spirituality

282 Words | 2 Pages

Summary In the book, Psychology, Theology, and Spirituality, Mark McMinn commences by providing the groundwork for the Christian worldview about counseling. He indicates that the book is crucial for individuals interested in looking into the aspect of intra-disciplinary integration (McMinn, 1996). In his exploration of the intra-disciplinary integration frontier, McMinn (1996) focuses on the challenges that Christian counselors face in their practice. As McMinn (1996) discusses the aspect of integration, he disregards religious interventions as well as foundational perspectives, indicating that they might not apply to the identified frontier.

Read More

Upton Sinclair's The Teapot Scandal

148 Words | 1 Pages

The Teapot Scandal When senator Fall became secretary of the interior, in 1921, he handled the public oil reserves, which both Republican leaders and Democrats accorded for future Naval use. And, therefore, they banned their private exploitation. Nevertheless, he leased those lands; which contained the prohibited domes and reservoirs, in California and Wyoming, to the companies that repaid his favour with loans and gifts. And, though he tried to silence his steps, he and his friends failed to dodge investigation.

Read More

James Hal Cone Book Report

865 Words | 4 Pages

He received a B.A. degree from Philander Smith College in Arkansas in 1958, a B.D. degree from Garrett-Evangelical Theological Seminary in 1961, and M.A. and Ph.D. degrees from Northwestern University in 1963 and 1965, respectively. He taught theology and religion at Philander Smith College, Adrian College in Michigan, and beginning in 1970 at Union Theological Seminary in New York City, where he was awarded the distinguished Charles A. Briggs Chair in systematic theology in 1977. He taught theology and religion at Philander Smith College, Adrian College in Michigan, and beginning in 1970 at Union Theological Seminary in New York City, where he was awarded the distinguished Charles A. Briggs Chair in systematic theology in 1977. The thesis of this book is that one's social and historical context decides not only the questions 2 we address to God but also the mode or form of the

Read More

Elie Wiesel The Book Night

319 Words | 2 Pages

Two main themes –struggle of maintaining faith in god, the “silence” are well developed in this section of the

Read More

Summary Of Christian Counseling By Mark Mcminn

275 Words | 2 Pages

Summary Mark McMinn (2011) is a clinical psychologist, who wrote the book Psychology, Theology, and Spirituality in Christian Counseling, that was published by Tyndale House. In the new addition of this wonderful read McMinn (2001) brought alongside of him some of his pass students that added a different outlook. It is evident, that McMinn (2011) aim was to teach Christian counselors the importance of incorporating psychology, theology, and spirituality in the counseling office.

Read More

Integrative Approaches To Psychology And Christianity Chapter 1 Summary

912 Words | 4 Pages

Because of the division of science in religion discussed in chapters 1 and 2, there is very little room for interaction among psychology and religion, especially in the earlier years of psychology. Going into chapter 4, the author gives a comprehensive overview of different worldviews while discussing what they are and the importance of a Christian entering into the counseling profession to have a Christian worldview. Worldviews are learned through various influences and shape our understanding of the world, which gives both insight and distorted thinking. It is vital for counselors to have the proper worldview that is aligned both with empirical scientific evidence and sound theological doctrine to properly guide and direct others into truth, insight, awareness, healing, and

Read More

Interventions That Apply Scripture In Psychotherapy Case Study

899 Words | 4 Pages

This review is on the article Interventions That Apply Scripture in Psychotherapy, by Fernando Garzon. The article is in a case study approach and analyzes the use of the Bible within the “psychodynamic, psychoeducational, theoeducational, cognitive, behavioral, and affective experiential therapeutic” (Garzon, 2005 p.113) approaches of counseling. The example used in the case study is George who is a 30 year old white male construction worker, whose issues include “depressed mood, low self-esteem, suicidal thoughts, and trouble sleeping” (Garzon, 2005 p. 113) and has been dealing with these issues for approximately 10 years now. George had a very traumatic younger life with abuse both physical and mental by his father. Being that George is a Christian, he wanted that included within his therapy.

Read More

Travis And Ryan's Wellness Workbook

1671 Words | 7 Pages

While I have no desire to seek any other god, force or energy for healing and balance in my life I do believe that the theory could be used if applied through the premise of Christ. Seeking Christ for direction before I assist any client is the way I would always approach each session because having the guidance of Christ along with other factual knowledge is

Read More

Integrative Approaches To Psychology And Christianity Summary

537 Words | 3 Pages

When looking at integration, the book tells us, “If Christ lays claim to all of life, then the work of integration becomes not just feasible, but imperative, as we attempt to understand the essence of unity” (Entwistle, 2010). The author tries to explain to the readers how psychology and theology may have conflicted with one another through history due to psychology being based on the opposite of

Read More

Christian Counseling Book Review

852 Words | 4 Pages

Psychology, Theology, and Spirituality in Christian Counseling was first authored by Mark McMinn in 1990 (McMinn, 2011). This is a review of his most recent publication in which he left mostly the same and added reflections and additions of gained knowledge from the bast 20 years at the end of each chapter. McMinn (2011) opens the book buy explaining that integration is very complex because everyone has different views of Christianity, spirituality, and psychology. It is key to understand that all theories, even tested psychological interventions operate using a worldview that may not align well with Christianity. Integration asks each person to consider what they believe and strive to become trained in all areas so that integration can be

Read More

Just What Is Christian Counseling Anyway

1062 Words | 5 Pages

The other is a new group of mental health professionals that belong to the Society of Christian Psychology or SCP. These members “ attempt to found their work on the ancient truths and wisdom embedded in and derived from the Bible, as well as other classic Christian texts, written throughout centuries” (McMinn et al., 2010 p. 393-4). It is important for clients to be aware of the methods used by their Christian therapist so they can decide if it is the

Read More

Suffering In Nicholas Wolterstorff's Lament For A Son

1002 Words | 5 Pages

Most people in the world have an idea of who or what God is. Whether they believe in Him or not, people have thoughts that they use to define God. A lot of people have an imagine of God being all-powerful and happy, but do they really know that God suffers along with us? In the book “Lament for a Son” the author Nicholas Wolterstorff goes through the emotions he encountered while facing the loss of his twenty-five-year-old son who died in a mountain climbing accident. Wolterstrorff questions the role of God in life and is unsure on how to deal with his grief.

Read More

Implicit Integration Of Counseling

966 Words | 4 Pages

The integration of counseling practice and theology can take two forms: explicit and implicit integration. Explicit integration occurs in the interaction between the counselor and client, which

Read More

Biological And Psychodynamic Approach

636 Words | 3 Pages

The main aim of this assignment is to find out the strength and weakness, similarities and differences between the different approaches of psychology such as biological approach, behavioural approach and psychodynamic approach. I have chosen mental illness to evaluate these approach. The biological, behavioural and psychodynamic approaches of psychology are connected to the nature and nurture argument. The biological approach highly talks about nature side of the argument and states that all behaviour is biological and is treatable.

Read More

More about Psychotherapy Vs Weak Theism Summary

Related Topics

Open Document