ipl-logo

Socrates Vs Euthyphro Research Paper

738 Words3 Pages

Socrates Question Versus Euthyphro

The famous Socratic question: Is something holy because it is loved by the gods or is something loved by the gods because that something is holy?

This Socratic question not only had Euthyphro puzzled around 470 B.C.E., but many on end are puzzled ‘til this very day. How? Well, a dilemma arises. Which end will you take: the first or the latter? With flaws in both answers, Socrates forced Euthyphro to choose one of the two options.

Let us start with the answer Euthyphro chose: Something is loved by the gods because it is holy. It sounds alright at first until you look a little closer to the word “holy.” This choice not only makes holy independent from the gods, it also reveals that there is a standard of holiness God/the gods must react. So why is god and holiness being separate problematic? From a monotheistic point of view, God and holiness are supposed to be one. Holiness is defined as an …show more content…

Well, instead of Socrates allowing Euthyphro to be complacent with this alternate answer, he picked it apart as well. In doing so, he used a biblical example. In this parable, Abraham was instructed by God to kill his only son Isaac. Interpreting this literally and assuming that this really happened, many would ask why would God instruct a faithful servant to do such an unloving task, especially since God specifically says the most important commandment is to love one another? Somethings will always be wrong and unjustifiable: killing just so happens to be one of them. Therefore, this second option suggests anything commanded by God is holy, whether it be right or wrong in anyone else’s eyes. In response, many would suggest God would never command anything evil, but in the same breath we see God telling his people to start wars, kill, and many other things that seem unholy at the very

Show More
Related

Euthyphro And The Crito Analysis

529 Words | 3 Pages

Not completely satisfied by Euthyphro’s definition that, “Piety, then, is that which is dear to the gods”, Socrates pointed out that gods were known to disagree and argue; therefore, they may not have had unified opinion on what is holy. To further frustrate Euthyphro, Socrates continued his argument by asking the following question, “Holy is beloved by the gods because it’s

Read More

Socrates Piety And Impiety Analysis

499 Words | 2 Pages

Socrates and Euthyphro ran into each other outside the court of Athens. Socrates is there because he is charged for impiety by Meletus, while Euthyphro is there because he is prosecuting his own father for an unintentional murder of a household slave. After listening to the reason of Euthyphro’s presence at court, Socrates is flattered by him, as he thinks surely a person bringing charges against his own father must have great knowledge on piety and impiety. He thinks no one will do such a thing unless they are absolutely sure it is the right thing to do so he asks Euthyphro to teach him what holiness is and what piety and impiety is, so that it might help him in his trial against Meletus. In reply at first Euthyphro says that piety is what he is doing, prosecuting the person who offended religion by murdering, even though he is his own father.

Read More

Piety: The Argument Between Euthyphro And Socrates

1175 Words | 5 Pages

It became clearer for Socrates when Euthyphro replied “What is dear to God is pious, what is not is impious.” It was showing that for Euthyphro piousness is related to the

Read More

Difference Between Euthyphro And Socrates

221 Words | 1 Pages

pious vs. impious Euthyphro – going against his father for murder Meletus – against socrates for corrupting the youth. Accuses him of being a neologian, makes new gods, denies old ones. Ministration – the provision of assistance, or care Husbandman – person who cultivates land, a farmer Does god say things that are good, or do things become good because god says them?

Read More

Socrates And Euthyphro Argument

1310 Words | 6 Pages

For the individuals who are searching for a tasteful meaning of devotion, the discourse is a failure, for no conclusion has been come to concerning the exact idea of that goodness. It has now and again been kept up that the genuine motivation behind logic isn't to answer addresses yet rather scrutinize the appropriate responses that have been given. Anyways, this is precisely what Socrates has been doing in this back and forth. Euthyphro has displayed a few speedy and prepared responses to the inquiry "What is devotion?" however upon magnification, each of these questions has appeared to be unsuitable.

Read More

Definition Of Piety In Plato's Euthyphro

1080 Words | 5 Pages

In this paper I will discuss and evaluate the definitions of piety in Plato’s Euthyphro. Plato wrote this dialogue shortly after Socrates death. The Euthyphro is one of Plato’s early philosophy dialogs in which it talks about Socrates and Euthyphro’s conversations dealing with the definitions of piety and gods opinion. This dialogue begins when Socrates runs into Euthyphro outside the authorities and the courts. Socrates is there because he has been charged with impiety, and Euthyphro is there to accuse his father for the death of a man named Meletus who was a farm hard.

Read More

Is Euthyphro Pious In Prosecuting His Father

715 Words | 3 Pages

The second, Socrates asks Euthyphro, have you known what a piety is if your attitude is confident that you indict your father for a crime. (Plato (1997), p.77.). Socrates tries to look for one standard definition of piety. Let, have a look at what piety means to Euthyphro. He comes up with the several suggestions about piety: “to prosecute a wrongdoer is pious and not to prosecute is impious”; “what all the gods hate is impious, and what they all love is pious”; “where there is piety there is also justice” (Plato (1997), p.88.).

Read More

Evaluating Socrates Claim In The Apology

835 Words | 4 Pages

Euthyphro tries to explain him that he was doing the same as Zeus did to his father and therefore being pious. But Socrates argues that it is just an example and not an explanation. He tries again and says what gods like is pious and what they dislike is not. But Socrates points out the fallacy in that argument that one god might not agree with another to which he replies in his third attempt what all gods like is pious and what they all hate is impious. Here, in this example we can see that how he searches for a concrete and complete definition for being pious.

Read More

Analysis Of Euthyphro And Socrates

484 Words | 2 Pages

HUM2225 Dr. Hotchkiss September 30, 2016 Moral Insight Plato’s Euthyphro is based on a lesson between Socrates and Euthyphro outside of the Athenian court about the definition of pious or impious. Euthyphro was surprised to see Socrates there and even more curious to find out why he was there. Socrates explained that the court was persecuting him for impiety because Meletus was spreading rumors about him corrupting the Athenian youth. Euthyphro explains to Socrates that he was there to prosecute his father for murdering a farm worker named Dionysus.

Read More

Comparing Plato's Allegory Of The Cave And Book X

960 Words | 4 Pages

Socrates notes that evils which attacks the soul, cowardice and the like, clearly do not destroy it. Injustice, for instance, never kills souls by itself, though the unjust man may be killed in body by others. We must forsake the study of the soul in the prison of the body and use philosophy to truly study it. Socrates returns to the theme of justice to determine how the unjust and the just will be in relation to the gods. They will love the just and hate the unjust.

Read More

Euthyphro Vs Socrates

578 Words | 3 Pages

Socrates asks Euthyphro “is the holy, holy because it is loved by the gods?” or “is something loved by the gods because it is holy?” Euthyphro was charging his father with murder. Not that he physically put his hands on one, but while another was awaiting the decision, his father left the man to die of starvation and lack of water. In Euthyphro’s eyes, his father was the murder of this man. The reason he is prosecuting his father is because he believes in the Gods and that no matter if someone is of kin if it is not right then it just isn’t right.

Read More

Euthyphro Argumentative Essay

996 Words | 4 Pages

Marcus Schimmelfennig – Euthyphro Essay – Philosophy 150 The argument Euthyphro and Socrates go about talking about is a murder case Euthyphro is about to be a part of. Euthyphro is prosecuting a man who is being prosecuted for murdering a murderer. It begins as such, the man murdered was caught in a murder and the second murderer tied him up and threw him in a ditch, but forgot about him so the first murderer died of hunger and the cold weather. The second murderer was Euthyphro’s very own father so, with this in mind, he is having trouble determining if he should prosecute his father to be guilty or not guilty for the action he committed was indefinitely an illegal act, but, I this time period of the case, the murderer would have been facing a death sentence in the end anyways if he would have been caught by an authority.

Read More

Socrates And Euthyphro's Argument Analysis

893 Words | 4 Pages

Socrates clearly states, in support of this opinion that that according to Euthyphro’s account,

Read More

Morality In The Euthyphro, By Plato

951 Words | 4 Pages

In the Euthyphro, Plato sets the stage for what will turn out to be one of the most pondered questions in philosophy. Plato first begins by setting the stage – Socrates and

Read More

In Defense Of Socrates's Reputation

2117 Words | 9 Pages

Anyone familiar with Socrates’s reputation would emphatically declare that he was wrongly accused and prosecuted. He was a philosopher of the most pious and truthful nature. He sought truth, with no regard for the material world, and without any hidden agendas. How could a man whose life’s mission was the attainment of knowledge and the pursuit of a just life, be convicted of harming his society? A conviction, punishable by death.

Read More

More about Socrates Vs Euthyphro Research Paper

Related Topics

Open Document