ipl-logo

Supreme Court Cases: Obergefell Vs. Hodges

1241 Words5 Pages

Amanda Stevenson
Dr. Woodiwiss
PO 101
30 November 2015
_______________________________
On June 26, 2015, the United States Supreme Court ruled any state ban against gay marriage unconstitutional with the case of Obergefell v. Hodges. Ruling in favor of Obergefell, the court’s decision shook what was thought to be the “stable ground” of the United States. Stemming from similar cases presented in Ohio, Michigan, Kentucky, and Tennessee, Obergefell v. Hodges illuminated two objective questions: “Does the Fourteenth Amendment require a state to license a marriage between two people of the same sex?” and “Does the Fourteenth Amendment require a state to recognize a marriage between two people of the same sex that was legally licensed and performed …show more content…

Dissimilar from the financial influence of the legislative “purse” and the authoritative, executive “sword”, the Supreme Court derives its stature from public opinion and the acceptance of its rulings. This passivity results from the fact that the Supreme Court only acts when questions need to be answered, which is exercising the power of judicial review. The Supreme Court can only answer those questions posed by the public concerning the constitutionality of a law by expressing what is called the “opinion of the court” (Hamilton). The answer, or decision made by the court is not always black or white. As an example, the Obergefell v. Hodges case not only serves as a demonstration of how the Supreme Court works, but also potential consequences to misinterpreted judicial …show more content…

President Bill Clinton signed a federal DOMA in the following year, which permitted states the right to ban same sex marriage and also prohibited the federal government from officially recognizing any same sex marriage. Although both of these signings prohibited gay marriage, they were actually counterproductive, because they made the issue more public, making them major steps in achieving marriage equality. As of 1995, thirteen states had official statutory bans on any homosexual marriage. That is a small number compared to the thirty seven that were indifferent to the topic at that time. According to the Pew Research Center, Massachusetts become the first state to legalize marriage in 2003. This decision of Massachusetts also initiated a shift in the nation with the introduction of the Federal Marriage Amendment to the United States House of representatives. Massachusetts remained the only state legally allowing gay marriage for five years, until Connecticut joined in 2008. Discounting indifference as a decision, all fifty states of the United States had not taken an active stance on gay marriage until 2013. At this time, seventeen states had legalized gay marriage, four states had statutory bans on gay marriage, and twenty-nine states had constitutional bans on gay marriage. Obergefell v. Hodges finalized in June of 2015, which forced the then withstanding fifteen states to enact

Show More
Related

Summary: Obergefell V. Hodges

646 Words | 3 Pages

Obergefell v. Hodges is one of the most important Supreme Court rulings to date. This case, by a 5-4 decision, legalized same-sex marriage and established that the 14th amendment, by both the Due Process Clause and Equal Protections Clause, guarantees this right. The Supreme Court for a long time exercised judicial modesty in terms of cases involving same sex marriage by allowing the decisions to be made by the states. However, with some states recognizing same-sex marriages and others not, things began to get complicated when couples would move to other states and not get the same benefits as married couples and other similar situations that caused issues. However, when the Supreme Court took this case and ruled that same-sex marriage was legal in all 50 states, it was a prime example of the court using judicial activism.

Read More

Case Study: Obergefell V. Hodges

478 Words | 2 Pages

Obergefell v Hodges first originated when same-sex couples sued the state governments of Ohio, Michigan, Kentucky, and Tennessee in disagreement to the constitutionality of those states ' bans on same-sex marriage and refusal to recognize any legal marriages that took place outside the jurisdiction of the state. The couples argued the Equal Protection Clause and Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment was violated by the state 's’ exclusion of same-sex marriages. In the trial courts of the fourth, seventh, ninth, and tenth districts, state level bans on same-sex marriage were declared

Read More

Obergefell V. Hodges: A Landmark Supreme Court Case

685 Words | 3 Pages

Obergefell v. Hodges was a landmark Supreme Court case that took place in 2015. This case legalized same sex marriage across the United States. It is a significant moment for the LGBTQIA+ rights as well as equality movement. The case has challenged state bans on same-sex marriage, where they have argued that they violated the Fourteenth Amendment which grants citizenship and equal civil and legal rights. Before the case took place “over 70% of states and the District of Columbia already recognized same-sex marriage, and only 13 states had bans” (HUSL Library: A Brief History of Civil Rights in the United States: Obergefell V. Hodges).

Read More

Supreme Court Law Pros And Cons

3225 Words | 13 Pages

INTRODUCTION Given what I have learned about the functions and characteristics of the Supreme Court of the United States and the Conseil Constitutionnel of France – in the context of their respective systems of civil, criminal, administrative and constitutional adjudication – I will discuss the relative strengths and weaknesses of each system in offering meaningful remedies for possible violations of constitutionally protected individual rights from the frame of reference of a United States law student. As a Founding Father, I plan to adopt a body of law founded upon the strengths of both bodies of law. In doing so, I will consider, in order, what characteristics of each body of law is best suited to rule on issues of constitutionality, taking

Read More

Lawrence Vs Texas Sodomy History

1525 Words | 7 Pages

This effectively nullified all remaining homosexual sodomy laws, allowing LGBT relationships in the United States. This was the first of many law and policy changes toward LGBT people during this time, including the addition of gender, sexual orientation, and disability to hate crime laws; the repeal of Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell; the active and public promotion of LGBT rights worldwide; the inclusion of gender identity and sexual orientation to factors that cannot influence federal employment; and lastly, the decision in Obergefell v. Hodges. Obergefell v. Hodges was a case that attempted to decide many things, but there was one core question to the case: should same-sex couples be allowed to partake in marriage throughout the United States? For this question, the court ruled in favor of Obergefell, allowing same-sex marriage on 14th Amendment grounds. This was a key moment for the LGBT community, clearing a major hurdle for equal rights.

Read More

Critical Analysis Essay On 13th Amendment

1228 Words | 5 Pages

The Supreme Court eventually held it was unconstitutional for States to deny same-sex couples the right to marriage (United States Supreme Court, "Obergefell v. Hodges. " 681). However, the States' misuse of the Tenth Amendment to defend its unconstitutional acts is blatant, and those acts will have negative

Read More

Sam Cooke Meaning

984 Words | 4 Pages

Another stride was the Defense of Marriage Act being struck down in 2012, which allowed same sex

Read More

Essay On The Stonewall Riot

874 Words | 4 Pages

On June 26th, 2015, the Supreme Court ruled that gay marriage is a right, and should be protected by the U.S constitution. Therefore gay marriage became legal in all 50 states (Gay Marriage ProCon.org, ProConorg Headlines.). The fight for gay rights can be traced back to 3 a.m on June 23rd, 1969, The Stonewall riot took place on this day. The Stonewall riot was gays and lesbians fighting back to the police for raiding the gay bars, this was during a time period when homosexuality was illegal in all states except Illinois (Gay Marriage ProCon.org, ProConorg Headlines.). There are arguments for and against gay marriage.

Read More

Texas: Marriage Equality In The United States

911 Words | 4 Pages

The federal judge in San Antonio, Texas, “ruled that Texas ' ban on same-sex marriage violates the U.S. Constitution and demeans the dignity of gay couples "for no legitimate reason." Judge Orlando Garcia then granted two plaintiff couples ' request for an injunction barring the state from enforcing the ban.” (Keen 1) One of the couples sought to be married in Texas while the other couple had already been married in Massachusetts, but desired to be recognized by the state of Texas. In Garcia’s ruling, he states that, “the Texas bans violate the guarantees of due process and equal protection of the U.S. Constitution.”

Read More

Equal Protection Clausee Pros And Cons

934 Words | 4 Pages

The fight for equality of American citizens has been a long time running. As of recent, the fight for Gay rights has become a hot topic and a long fight. By the year of 2004, most states had made it illegal for any citizen to marry another citizen of the same sex. Any and all that have ever studied the fourteenth amendment to the Constitution would know that the Equal Protection Clause implements the idea that no state is permitted to deny any person within its jurisdiction “the equal protection of the laws” (LII 1992). Though this particular clause was created to ensure equal opportunities for all people, it does not provide equal outcomes.

Read More

The Four Dissentinions Of Obergefell

1781 Words | 8 Pages

The four dissenting opinions in Obergefell give us a fairly good idea of what a majority opinion would look like if issued by a Supreme Court that still hears and orders its thinking based on foundationalism, objective truth and ordered reason. In other words, what the Obergefell decision would look like if written by justices who still hear the echo. It might look something like this: Marriage, as historically defined in our law and traditions since the founding of this nation and for all of recorded human history, has been understood by the people and supported by the laws of the States as a union between a man and a woman. Even in those cultures which allow polygamous marriage, the heterosexual character of the institution is assumed. Western

Read More

States Rights Vs Federal Power

923 Words | 4 Pages

Hodges of 2015 ruled same-sex marriage to be legal in all fifty states of the United States of America. Prior to the case, same-sex marriage had been a state right. Nonetheless, it was ruled that it is a fundamental constitutional right guaranteed under Amendment XIV of the United States Constitution (http://www.forbes.com/sites/danielfisher/2015/06/26/supreme-court-rules-same-sex-marriage-is-a-constitutional-right/#4b62f8f031f5). “The ruling overrides bans in 13 states against gay marriage, enforcing the law of equal rights all across the United States” (http://heavy.com/news/2015/06/scotus-gay-marriage-ruling-legalized-legalization-14th-amendment-history-facts-lgbt-rights-nyc-new-york-pride-weekend/). The ruling of Obergefell v. Hodges makes gay marriage the law of the land in every state; it was a five to four decision in the court.

Read More

Health Disparities In The LGBT Community

899 Words | 4 Pages

Until recently, many states within the United States did not allow homosexual/LGBT couples to get married. Due to the fact that LGBT couples have not been recognized

Read More

Social Welfare Policy Examples

730 Words | 3 Pages

14–556. Argued April 28, 2015—Decided June 26, 2015 OBERGEFELL ET AL. v. HODGES, DIRECTOR, OHIO DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH, ET AL. The ruling in this case by the Supreme Court indicated that couples under the same sex had the right to marry under the protection of the Fourteenth Amendment at the federal level and that State law did not have the authority to produce or enforce legislation that barred same-sex marriages. The Fourteenth Amendment addresses citizenship law and equal protection under the law.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Being Gay

775 Words | 4 Pages

They explain the many social movements that are happening over the world and also the fight for marriage equality. These complications are compared to the African American civil rights movement. During the 1960s, there were multiple social movements used to target the issue of segregation and discrimination against African Americans, along with attempting to place an emphasis on their rights as American citizens. The article titled, “Supreme Court Rules State Must Allow Same-Sex Marriage,” speaks on one of the primary issues of how those of LGBTQ have been fighting the uphill battle of gaining the right to be legally married. This article explains what the Supreme Court did and how they ruled that couples of the same sex can now be married legally nationwide.

Read More

More about Supreme Court Cases: Obergefell Vs. Hodges

Related Topics

Open Document