ipl-logo

Sweatshops Morally Defensible Essay

1868 Words8 Pages

Political Theory Home Exam Are sweatshops morally defensible? Discuss the view of sweatshops that follows from Marx and Engel’s critique of capitalism as well as from Nozick’s libertarianism. Discuss the relevance of both views for our moral assessment of sweatshops. Also discuss if the low wages in sweatshops can be justified on Rawlsian terms – as an inequality that over time will benefit the least well off. Sweatshop is a workplace for workers suffering from long hours of work, low wages, and poor working conditions. Sweatshop's ethical and moral impact has been the subject of much debate. From a moral point of view, the labor sweatshop is difficult to defend. Workers often receive very low wages, work long hours, and are affected by …show more content…

Overall, when workers are exposed to exploitative and abusive conditions, they can provide employment opportunities for workers, but it is difficult to ignore the moral concerns raised by the prevalence of labor exploitation. Instead, efforts should be made to ensure that workers are treated fairly and with dignity, and access to quality wages, safe working conditions, and other basic rights. Ultimately, the solution to the problems in the labor field may lie in finding ways to improve working conditions and wages rather than simply accepting the status …show more content…

It is suggested that low wages for workers may be justified if they contribute to the overall improvement of the least affluent members of society. According to this view, if they provide jobs and income to people who would not have had other opportunities, and the profits they produce are used to improve the welfare of the most disadvantaged members of society, they can be justified. Rawls will also argue that workers should provide safe working conditions and fair wages, and that workers should have the freedom to choose whether to work. From Rawls' point of view, one argument against Sweetshop is that they perpetuate the cycle of poverty and exploitation. Sweatshop may offer jobs to the poorest, but they also perpetuate a system in which such workers are poor and have no chance of improving their fate in life. This could violate Rawls' principle of justice by failing to provide a fair distribution of resources over

Show More
Related
176 Words | 1 Pages

Ravisankar begins his essay by focuses on America’s need one finding the lowest prices products. The problem he identified is by addressing the problem of workshop conditions and lack of pay . Ravisankar assumes his readers are consumers in America. His purpose in this essay is to inform America about the horrors of workshops and inform them are doing more harm than good. In order to accomplish, he appeals to Pathos by addressing the lack of humanity towards workshop workers.

Read More
246 Words | 1 Pages

Ravisankar begins his essay by talking about how consumers are constantly emphasizing finding lower prices and that means using sweatshop labor. The problem he identifies is as consumers in Western countries try to find lower prices, we are not helping sweatshop laborers escape their low standard of living. Ravisankar assumes his readers are unaware consumers in Western countries. His purpose in this essay is to educate his readers about the problem of brands’ exploiting their workers. In order to accomplish this purpose, Ravisankar appeals mainly to consumers to pay a higher price to help “improve the lives of sweatshop workers.”

Read More
433 Words | 2 Pages

Through “Sweatshop Oppression,” an essay written by Rajeev Ravisankar, the reader gains insight on the truthful and factual reality of oppressive workplace conditions. Ravisankar seeks to appeal to the morals and values of the audience by having relatable content and using the emotion and logic based rhetorical devices “pathos” and “logos.” In the opening paragraph the author connects with the audience by inclusively saying: “being the “poor” college students that we all are, many of us undoubtedly place an emphasis on finding the lowest prices” (). Through revealing he is a student with mutual financial struggles, the audience quickly picks up on his relatable and likeable voice.

Read More
1871 Words | 8 Pages

Through the lens of intersectionality, we are allowed to see that sweatshop workers experienced double oppressions from structural racism and structural sexism that limited their choices of occupations and class inequality that exaggerated imbalanced power between laborers

Read More
471 Words | 2 Pages

The second pernicious influence is human resource exploitation. Laborers become more like work tools for industrial monopolies rather than human beings. Genders and age do not matter to the authority as they prioritize their benefits over the workers’. Not only do they have to suffer from exploitative boss, the proletariat is also made advantage of by other powers, such as landlords.

Read More
647 Words | 3 Pages

Sweatshirts from Sweatshops: Intellectual Standards and Logical Fallacies The essay “Sweatshirts from Sweatshops” was a persuasive piece that covered the issues of companies overseas that thrive through the exploitations of its workers. The reading selection depicted the behind the scenes activities that actually occurs with the mistreated workers and also the morality of such treatments. Throughout the essay, the reader can assume the writer’s overall objective was to discourage their audience from wearing such attire until their school decides to switch their apparel supplier. The writer also violated a few universal intellectual standards as well as a few logical fallacies.

Read More
1060 Words | 5 Pages

The main goal of businesses, in the growing manufacturing economy, was to produce the most product at the cheapest price. With a large influx of desperate immigrants looking for jobs, companies were able to quickly capitalize on the rights of vain workers. Viewing as them as easily replaceable, owners were easily able to take advantage of the rights of workers and utilize them to their advantage. The desperation prevalent in those willing to take the jobs that nobody else wanted supplied labor to factories, often for a high price. Worker’s rights were often manipulated in the industries exemplified throughout The Jungle.

Read More
181 Words | 1 Pages

In this Socratic seminar I believe that with all the points that have been given I believe that sweatshops make things worse for developing nations. many of these devolving nations want to get ahead sweatshops do provide jobs but the income is very low. As well these job conditions are very poor so these people actually could get worse because of their health in these sweatshops. With the little pay these workers get it 's mostly spent on food which after that leaves them broke or even sometimes not enough to even purchase food.

Read More
1078 Words | 5 Pages

The sweatshop debate began in the 1970s, with an accusation slapped across Nike’s face in the form of of a report published by Jeff Ballinger about Nike’s sweatshops in Indonesia. Since that moment the world has been sparked into a hotly debated topic where clash always results in human rights versus economic gains. What Ballinger and other critics of idealize is the fact that sweatshops represent human rights violations and supporters of sweatshops are cold-hearted people who care for nothing but the increase of their money. However what Ballinger fails to realize is that buying materials from sweatshops fail to realize is that sweatshops have propelled the economic growth of countries

Read More
572 Words | 3 Pages

The article “Where Sweatshops Are a Dream” explains the idea that sweatshops can be beneficial to some places in the world through imagery and other literary techniques. Although the document depicted a less popular opinion it was not any less credible but rather more informed on the current job opportunities in Cambodia and other East Asian countries. The use of imagery supported his views and allowed the reader to develop more connection with the piece. Kristof adopted countless literary techniques to convey his adamant opinion on the development of sweatshops in poverty filled

Read More
705 Words | 3 Pages

When money and profits are the most significant in the capitalist society, the employers treated their workers poorly, such as excessive working hours and received lower wages. The exploitation of

Read More
858 Words | 4 Pages

It is an obvious truth that in order to have a functioning society, there must be workers. In modern, first world countries, labors are paid well and are reasonably treated. However, some third world nations use an economic model harkening back to older times—slavery and serfdom. Between 1450 and 1750, European countries in the Caribbean and in the Old World utilized two forms of cheap labor—slavery and serfdom—to line their coffers and feed their populace. In the Caribbean, slavery was preferred; but in Russia, serfdom ruled.

Read More
822 Words | 4 Pages

The author violates another intellectual standard, the breadth when he takes only his point of view. He does not consider whether workers that work for that company are happy to work there, and the working conditions that we think are horrible are normal for them. For example, working ten-hour shifts is normal in Asian countries, especially Vietnam. In order to fix it, author may add more evidences stating how exhausting it is or at least some workers' testimonies to make sure that workers believe that they are abused, not we believe that working under these condition means abusing the

Read More
705 Words | 3 Pages

Some developing countries with a very low GDP have sweatshop labor. Many sweatshop laborers are forced to work under harsh conditions in a poorly built infrastructure with earnings of low wages. In “True Cost,” some workers that manufacture clothing cannot even earn enough

Read More
653 Words | 3 Pages

Although there are terrible working conditions in sweatshops, workers often choose to work in sweatshops than the other jobs in the area. In the article called, “Where Sweatshops Are a Dream” the author gathers citizens in poverty statements on working in sweatshops. They state, "I'd love to get a job in a factory," says Pirn Srey Rath, a 19-year-old woman scavenging for plastic. "At least that work is in the shade. Here is where it's hot."

Read More

More about Sweatshops Morally Defensible Essay

Open Document