ipl-logo

The Ethics Of Tracking In Schools

940 Words4 Pages

In schools throughout the country, there are certain tracks set in place for students at different academic levels. In some schools, there are simply high and low tracks, while in others, there are tracks for individuals who plan to go to college and for individuals with learning disabilities. Since tracking itself takes on so many different forms, educational theorists have taken many different viewpoints on the subject. Many have agreed that there are faults within tracking, though some believe them to be fixable. In this paper, the thoughts of Maureen T. Hallinan, Adam Gamoran, and Jeannie Oaks regarding tracking in schools will be compared, contrasted, and critiqued. Due to the specific faults presented by each theorist, especially the …show more content…

Tracking can present some benefits if it is implemented in a proper manner. This is the main basis of Hallinan’s theory. If schools work to reduce these issues, students of all levels will be able to benefit. While struggling students are able to get extra help, advancing students will be properly engaged and stimulated so as not to stunt their academic development. High track students will be continually challenged and will not become bored with school. Hallinan states that in order for tracking to be useful, flexibility is needed to “preserve the homogeneity of tracks” (Hallinan 189). She believes that even within “high” and “low” tracks, there will still be students at the top of the class and at the bottom of the class. With flexibility that allows for students to move between the tracks, tracking becomes a tool instead of a hindrance. Gamoran agrees that tracking can be beneficial when used correctly. However, …show more content…

However, as not all students are at the same level of understanding, it is imperative that a different system is put into place. In colleges, there are usually departments for academic success. These departments will organize tutors, for students who require extra help, and they help give accommodations to students. These accommodations can allow for even more added help for students who may need it more, specifically students with learning disabilities, test anxieties, and more. If an academic program were to be placed into primary education, it would help the students who normally would’ve been placed on the low track, while still keeping the academic honesty of each student. It would minimize the bias and social/psychological problems that Oaks presents, yet it would help the lower level students, as Gamoran

Show More
Related
270 Words | 2 Pages

This could affect the amount of learning students are able to obtain. Another interesting conclusion I

Read More
771 Words | 4 Pages

In this chapter, Jo Boaler describes several school systems who do not use “tracking,” filters that separate students into high-level mathematics classes and low-level mathematics classes. She continues with a discussion that reminds us of the harmful effects of “tracking” and the damage it does to students’ mindsets, both those students on the high-level and the low-level track. Ms. Boaler goes on to suggest that heterogeneous groups of students can effectively work together and individual students can develop a growth mindset. The remainder of the chapter focuses on teaching mixed ability groups effectively and includes an in-depth look at how the tasks students complete and the type of instruction they receive can promote growth mindsets.

Read More
2014 Words | 9 Pages

In many places and schools, there are issues with education and how the system operates. Tracking and ability grouping is the practice of putting students in different classes or groups based on their level of knowledge and their ability to learn. This is an incredibly toxic way to teach students and does more harm than good. In Mike Rose’s essay titled "I Just Wanna Be Average," he addresses many different societal issues and emphasizes the need for solutions. One of the biggest issues has to do with education and schools tracking students' progress from the moment they step into kindergarten.

Read More
895 Words | 4 Pages

Children who grow up in poverty are faced with a series of issues which impact their education and social atmosphere. In both the school and home setting these children lack the proper resources which they need to succeed academically. Across the country, people have begun creating programs which aim to help children in poverty succeed, despite their socioeconomic status. These programs range from after-school reading, tutoring services, charter schools, and free summer programs. All of these programs provide children with extra academic help which they may not be receiving in school or at home.

Read More
605 Words | 3 Pages

This is a practice that has been made for a while now, and is now seen over at public schools. Now, a lot of people may see this as a good thing, and I get their reasoning. But as these claims are not without merit, the outcomes wouldn’t be all fantastic.

Read More
477 Words | 2 Pages

Tracking is the norm in our nation’s schools. People expect it, welcome it, and rarely question it. Tracking is supposed to benefit students by having them work with other students of a similar ability level, rather than a mixed group of students all with different ability levels, that way content and pacing does not leave some students far behind while other students are miles ahead. And this system works, doesn’t it? Actually

Read More
856 Words | 4 Pages

These tracks are relabeled as “remedial”, “special”, “advanced”, and “gifted/talented”. In Tracking in the School focus subtly mention that lower track perpetuates the endless cycle of disparity in education and income. Tracking was originally used to reduce the achievement gap between minorities and majority by bring them up to their standard grade level and enhancing the skills of higher tracks students. Disruptive and low socio-economic students fall short in this track based on the ‘self-fulfilling prophecy’. The level of tracks affects the influence and expectation of teachers and the outcome of the student’s success.

Read More
627 Words | 3 Pages

Adam Pawson October 18 2017 Dr. Bennett RELA 8-5 Facts, Quotes, and researched information in this article has been brought to you by: https://www.deseretnews.com/article/865578403/Sorting-kids-at-school-the-return-of-ability-grouping.html Ability Grouping In the 1980s, Ability Sorting in school systems was depicted very badly, but what is it really? I hope to give Ability Sorting a rejoinder into teaching methods, and show it in a new light. School classes have many special students, but not every student is where the class may be. It’s a well-known problem of the faster-paced kids are bored, and possibly failing due to lack of stimulation, and some kids are struggling to understand the course being taught. So what can be done about this?

Read More
460 Words | 2 Pages

I chose to do this reading response on Nieto’s piece about structural and organizational issues in schools. This chapter begins by talking about how many policies and practices that are currently in place in schools tend to become very difficult to change once they become set in the school system. The first policy that is discussed is tracking. Tracking is when students get placed in a group with other students who have around the same ability. The next policy that is discussed is retention.

Read More
289 Words | 2 Pages

At school X, assessing the children is very important. They have many ways of monitoring the children’s progress which helps them to complete work of their ability. One way is by assessing children against early years outcomes for the progression into reception, on something known as a baseline tracker. (Glazzard et al., 2010) define this as presenting practitioners with a list of skills and areas of development, which is used to measure children's level of achievement. A similar form is a Foundation Stage profile, which is used to ensure that schools are meeting the learning requirements for early years foundation stage(EYFS); as (Rose and Rogers, 2012) explains it provides benchmarks of performance but has caused problems due to the expectations

Read More
916 Words | 4 Pages

The policy has produced more honor students, raised the average GPA, and improved teacher morale.” This is an example of how the study hall has ben beneficial in a school. With the effects of study hall in schools, most all are positive responses. Not only are the students achieving more, but the school and teachers are happy and the parents are thrilled by their student’s

Read More
1686 Words | 7 Pages

This can but a lot of pressure on students. Wouldn't

Read More
495 Words | 2 Pages

Did you know that Pixar started off as, “Graphics Group,” in 1979 as a computer division of LucasFilm, and in 1986 it was spun off as Pixar with funding from Steve Jobs, which became a majority stockholder? Walt Disney then bought Pixar for 7.8 billions dollars, and Steve Jobs became the largest single shareholder of Disney of all time. Pixar is famous for some of the most amazing animated films; 13of their films are on the list of 50 most grossing films of all time, with Frozen coming in at 1.27 billion dollars. Does that put some perspective on the company that just came out with Inside Out? Which, by the way is currently at $363,000,000.00.

Read More
500 Words | 2 Pages

This will save schools a lot of money they could put towards things for the students. But the negatives outway the positives. It will be a huge change for educators and their students, and push students to learn faster than ever, which can cause stress, not to mention the stress to meet the standards, and to adapt to these standards. It also is nearly impossible to tailor this kind of education system to all students.

Read More
835 Words | 4 Pages

At the same time, it will allow teachers to cater for mixed ability

Read More

More about The Ethics Of Tracking In Schools

Related Topics

Open Document