ipl-logo

The Pinochet Case Study

1342 Words6 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Re: pinochet's case

1. Introduction and case overview. The Pinochet case was a media sensation in the end of the 1990s, well known by the general public as well as by jurists and vigorously celebrated by human rights advocates. It is claimed to have been an example of the successful use of universal jurisdiction and a twist in the understanding of immunity granted to state officials. Why is it considered a milestone? On which grounds did the court based such an unprecedented decision? This paper is an attempt to briefly address these questions. In the next paragraphs, I will, first, examine the circumstances of the case, second, the grounds and arguments of the court’s decision and last, the significance of the case to international law. In 1998, a quarter of …show more content…

The relevance of the case in international law. The Pinochet case established and important legal precedent. It made the world aware of Pinochet’s crimes and inspired new legal efforts against dictators and human rights violators all over the planet. One of the most famous cases said to have been inspired by the Pinochet case was the one of the former Chadian dictator Hissène Habré In addition to that, another great relevance of Pinochet’s extradition requests in Europe, was creating a political will for prosecutions at home, finally giving visibility to decades of militancy of victims, human rights advocates and lawyers in whole Latin America and in other parts of the world. In Chile, According to Stacie Jonas, the perception that the international community considered Pinochet a criminal, brought human rights issues back to the headlines and gave victims back their voices. His arrest motivated people to submit an avalanche of new cases against the former dictator. The Chilean courts removed many of Pinochet-appointed judges and promoted a reinterpretation of the country’s amnesty law. Shortly after Pinochet had arrived back home, Judge Juan Guzmán requested the courts to destitute the former head of state of his parliamentary immunity and ordered him to be placed under house arrest. Pinochet’s arrest in London also paved the way for the prosecution of other Chilean military officials and inspired new accountability efforts in Argentina. President Kirchner, in 2003, ratified the UN Convention on the Non-Applicability of Statutory Limitations to War Crimes against Humanity and in the same year, the Argentinean Congress annulled the country’s amnesty law, what

Show More
Related

Miranda's Confession, Injustice In Pheonix, Arizona

364 Words | 2 Pages

In 1963, Ernesto Miranda was arrested in Pheonix, Arizona for the kidnapping and raping of a woman. When questioned by police officers, Miranda would eventually give a confession, and sign it, which wasn 't the case.. Before the court, this confession would be used against Miranda, and with it, the implication that it was received voluntarily and with the convicted knowing his rights. Miranda was convicted with a 20-30 year sentence. Upon eventually learning that his confession was obtained unlawfully, Miranda would appeal to the Arizona Supreme Court, asking for an overturn, and when that fell through, would turn to the United States Supreme Court, filing a habeas corpus.

Read More

Summary Of The Massacre At El Mozote By Mark Danner

698 Words | 3 Pages

The Massacre at El Mozote by Mark Danner summarizes one out of numerous mass executions that occurred during the Salvadoran Civil War. This particular book discusses the Massacre at El Mozote in 1981 led by the Atlacatl Battalion. This rapid response counter insurgency battalion was trained at the U.S. Army’s School of the Americas once located in Panama. Danner’s book highlights the Reagan administration’s response when photographs of the multitude of victims killed in this massacre were published in the United States. The Regan administration determined that the pictures were propaganda and decided to overlook the major massacre going on around them.

Read More

Summary Of Marbury Vs Madison Case Brief

419 Words | 2 Pages

Extending the jurisdiction to cases like Marbury’s exceeded original jurisdiction. Dissenting opinion(s):

Read More

The Significance Of The 1992 Mabo High Court Case

702 Words | 3 Pages

To grasp the historical context leading up to the Mabo decision

Read More

Magnotta's Case

429 Words | 2 Pages

1. Most people found the Magnotta decision to be justified. Why do you think this was the case? Especially given the similarities between the cases….

Read More

The Case Of Ernesto Miranda

484 Words | 2 Pages

A man by the name of Ernesto Miranda was taken to custody in 1963 for kidnapping and rape. Then was sentenced 20-30 years in jail. He was interrogated for two hours by two police men, every individual should have their own rights to ask and answer questions unless told to Mirandize by a police man or the judge. Ernesto was being asked questions during the interrogation and the thing you’re supposed to do when they ask you questions is answer the questions, so Ernesto should have the right to talk during the interrogation. Ernesto didn’t know he should have a lawyer present during court when they discussed about his case of kidnapping and rape.

Read More

Guantanamo Bay Case 9/11

1134 Words | 5 Pages

In studying the power of a wartime President, a great case study of the expansion of power is the opening of Guantanamo Bay for detainment of foreign suspects. Guantanamo Bay has made many headlines for its practices of the inhumane treatment of detainees, some of whom turned out to be innocent. This negative coverage was well justified as more was learned about the conditions and formation of the camp. This paper will look at the how the expansion of wartime presidential power in response to September 11 attacks led to the formation of Guantanamo Bay as we know it today. Guantanamo Bay had a relatively quiet history before its detainment centers were open in the early 2000s.

Read More

Fred Koreatsu Case Analysis

786 Words | 4 Pages

In this case, the court ruled that the evacuation order which was violated by Korematsu was valid, and although “The constitutional issues should be addressed… it is clear that the “martial necessity arising from the danger of espionage and sabotage” warranted the military evacuation order.” As stated by Justice Frankfurter. In opposing thoughts, The Dissenting opinion written by Justice Jackson reads, "Korematsu ... has been convicted of an act not commonly thought a crime. It consists merely of being present in the state whereof he is a citizen, near the place where he was born, and where all his life he has lived.” Although this court case was finalized with Fred Korematsu being guilty, this case has sparked interest in the minds of thousands and whether they agree or disagree I will always agree with the second ruling.

Read More

Miranda Vs Arizona Essay

794 Words | 4 Pages

In this paper, we'll talk about the background facts and information surrounding the case, the specifics of the case, the case's resolution, and whether the resolution was constitutionally sound. We will also look at how this case has affected history and how it will continue to do so in the future. For allegedly kidnapping and raping a woman in Phoenix, Arizona, Ernesto Miranda was detained in 1963. He was not made aware of his constitutional rights, such as the right to remain silent and the right to counsel, by the police when they were questioning him.

Read More

Commentary On The Book Night By Elie Wiesel

699 Words | 3 Pages

The world sat by in silence, as crimes against humanity were being committed. “Every man for themselves,” is what the world responded, to those who were enslaved, tortured, and discriminated against. The book, “Night” by Elie Wiesel, recalls the details of the torture he endured. Elie lost his family, friends, faith, and will to live, in a matter of 2 years. Imagine how others, who were in the same position as Elie, felt.

Read More

Latin American SOA Analysis

704 Words | 3 Pages

As described by author Lesley Gill, The School of the Americas now the (Western Hemisphere instate for security cooperation) is a US military center utilized for the training and instruction of Latin American military officers in the realm of war combat skills, tactics, and counterinsurgency doctrine (6). Repressive tactics such as torture, psychological warfare, and varying methods of violence have contributed to the onslaught of violence within Latin America. Such violence is linked to many of the school’s graduates such as General Hugo Banzer of Bolivia, officers working with General Pinochet of Chile, and countless more officers and generals spanning across all Latin American nations. As asserted by author Gill, the SOAs purpose was never to help Latin American governments, but to utilize the school as a vehicle for US imperialism.

Read More

The Communist Experiment: Oppressive, Brutal, And Totalitarian Regime

162 Words | 1 Pages

The communist experiment generated oppressive, brutal, and totalitarian regimes because an elastic concept of the enemy came to be not only surviving remnants of the old pre revolutionary elites, but also, high-ranking members and longtime supporters of the Communist Party who had allegedly been corrupted by bourgeois ideas. As a result of Marxist thinking, these people became social enemies and were seen as betrayers of the revolution. They were engaged in a vast conspiracy, and were often linked to foreign imperialist, to subvert the socialist enterprise and restore capitalism. In an effort to combat capitalism and instill socialist values , communist regimes promoted the communist party 's penetration of all levels of society in ways that

Read More

Compare And Contrast United States Vs Texas

719 Words | 3 Pages

This case highlights how important the Supreme Court is to setting legal precedent and preserving the states' and the federal

Read More

Human Rights Violations In The Hooded Man

1761 Words | 8 Pages

During the 2000s it was a time of war and tension for the American public and the government . America was seen as a glorious nation that was fighting back against the terrorists to try and better the world buSgt.t, Ivan Frederick decided to expose the American government to the public. Showing them the truth of what America was really doing overseas to thIraqiaq nationSgt.t, Ivan Frederick helped comment on the idea of violating human rights by using the photograph The Hooded Man. The background of the 2000s helps one understand the violations of human rights during this time.

Read More

Dirty Wars In Guatemala

977 Words | 4 Pages

However, the trial was not to have Generals Videla and Bignone go to jail, since they were already there, it was for the fifteen thousand people who where kidnapped and lost their lives, when only about fifteen percent of them were actually a threat, and it is for the Grandmothers who lost their children and the chance to see their grandchildren become adults. Thankfully, Generals Videla and Bignone were convicted with the National Security Archives assistance, the United States Embassy in Buenos Aires “declassify a full version” of the Abrams Memorandum. The National Security Archives, Latin American citizens, foreign countries, and even sole individuals are fighting to bring the hammer of justice upon those responsible. Another example, is the case of “Los Quemados”, the burned one, which is a gruesome crime against two teenager’s Rodrigo Rojas de Negri and Carmen Gloria Quintana. The Chilean army officer and his subordinates set Rodrigo and Carmen on fire and then left them in a ditch to die because they had attended a street protest against the military control.

Read More

More about The Pinochet Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document