ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of A Sustainable Immigration System

893 Words4 Pages

Before seeking a sustainable immigration system, it is important to know how the current immigration system functions and its faults. People want to come to the United States; some want to be here temporarily, while others wish to live here permanently. Economic and political circumstances force families to move out of their home countries. Unauthorized immigrants who enter the United States through the southern border face dangers along the way. Local and federal policies criminalize undocumented immigrants, placing them at a social and economic disadvantage. This criminalization situates undocumented immigrants in disastrous circumstances due to the risk of detention and deportation. Those who manage to live in the United States without being …show more content…

In this paper, we analyze the proposed changes from S. 744 to see which ideas are sustainable compared to those that are not. Though we pay particular attention to visa regimes and immigrant integration through education, we know that the conversation about comprehensive immigration reform must include other aspects such as stratification and equity for all. Nevertheless, the highlighted topics in this paper are significant and relevant because they address issues relating to the three points in the immigrant’s journey: reason for departure, access into the country, and integration into society. Sustainability in this framework is not to be confused with the ecological concept of environmental sustainability. Sustainable open borders, as proposed within this paper, seeks to promote a viable and continuous immigration system that eliminates the suffering and inefficiencies tied to the current …show more content…

744 addresses the issues of border security, the oversight of the border, and goals that must be met before other provisions of the bill are implemented. The outlined goals regard the surveillance and effectiveness of the Border Patrol. Tackling surveillance, the bill provides the use of the National Guard to strengthen helicopter fleet and deploy additional mobile, video, and portable surveillance systems and unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) to achieve operations 24 hours per day, seven days per week. Aside from surveillance, the proposal allocates upwards of $30 billion to double the amount of Border Patrol Agents (BPA) to at least 38,405 and add an additional 700 miles of double border fencing. To vet the effectiveness and integrity of the proposed security measures, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) is required to report to Congress on the effectiveness rate for each Border Patrol sector, the number of miles along the Southern border under persistent surveillance, resources and staffing at Ports of Entry (POE) (MPI, 2013). Although the sweeping measures provide an outline for a reformed border, the bill’s failure to address the environmental impacts produced by the proposed security devices, its economic efficiency and the international relationship between the U.S. and countries south of the border jeopardizes its intent of being truly

Show More
Related

The Pros And Cons Of Secure Fence Laws

294 Words | 2 Pages

The border between the United States and Mexico is nearly 2,000 miles long. Over the past few years, the United States had form a policy called Secure Fence Act to prevent drug sellers and terrorists out of America (Clifford). The act constructed fences to cover about one third of the border between Mexico and America along California, New Mexico, Texas and so on. Unfortunately, there were less environmental considerations when making the policy. The Los Angeles Times reported that in additional to build the fences, the United States government has been eluded over thirty environmental and cultural laws (Campbell).

Read More

Case Study: What Is The Fourth Amendment Only As It Pertains To Secure The Border

1511 Words | 7 Pages

The challenges that come from facilitating legal border crossing while trying to maintain secure borders can be seen when taking a closer look at the U.S northern and southern borders. The northern U.S border that neighbors Canada can be described as an open border with more relaxed regulations and security. This has been great in the past for transportation and trade, however there is an open border paradox that lax regulations and security, let in unwanted illegal activity in too easily. On the Southern border along Mexico, the U.S has more of a closed border, that has a fence along part of it, active border patrol patrolling the area and security checkpoints that make entry much more difficult. The paradox with the closed border is that it encourages and contributes increased migrant and narcotics smuggling and the level of corruption and organized crime is more prevalent.

Read More

Did Barack Obama Use The Power To Change The Us Immigration Policy

539 Words | 3 Pages

The first changes being made focus on securing the border. The President’s actions will concentrate on border security command-and-control. They will better the chances of catching people trying to cross the border and sending them back. Furthermore, it will decrease the

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Immigration System

126 Words | 1 Pages

Our current immigration system is broken, harms our economy, and does not reflect our values as a nation. Without true immigration reform, we suffer severe economic, cultural, fiscal and political strains in communities across America. Immigration has become an urging issue in legislation on both the national and state levels. Immigration legislation made the policy agenda in all 50 states in 2007, with 46 states enacting into law a total of 240 immigration-related bills. This proposal of the “Fairness for High-Skilled Immigrants Act of 2015” (H.R.213) stands out as the most promising measure to fix part of the problems.

Read More

Review Of How Many Is Too Many? By Philip Cafaro

956 Words | 4 Pages

As a person coming from a family that immigrated to the United States to live the American dream, Philip Cafaro himself has seen some valuable factors in the effects that immigration plays in the economic and overall growth of the country. His background and emotional connection relating to coming from an immigrant family, has helped him understand that many people usually come to the U.S. to have better lives. Nevertheless, Cafaro never claims he has never had any compassion for the immigrants, but as unemployment is on the rise, this is hurting the American people. A hard-working Mexican immigrant named Javier talks with Philip and says that he himself believes that immigration policies should be enforced but America should be more lenient to the good people who are wanting to escape, due to push factors in their home countries. Javier has been living in the US for years and brings up, if the nation enforces policies then this will split my family apart and all he wants is to have a good life.

Read More

S. 744: The Immigration Reform Act

1228 Words | 5 Pages

S. 744: The Immigration Reform Act The Border Security, Economic Opportunity, and Immigration Reform Act -- or Senate Bill 744 -- was introduced into the United States Senate in April 2013 and since then, it has been a highly important significant bill for both immigrants and nonimmigrants alike. In June, it was passed and it then went on to the House of Representatives. Currently, no formal decision has been made on it, even though millions of undocumented and potential immigrants are waiting for its approval. If the act was passed, border security around the US would become tighter, but all the illegal immigrants currently in the country would have a chance at citizenship. While it would take over a decade after the bill is passed for them

Read More

Mexico Vs Canada Research Paper

826 Words | 4 Pages

In an attempt to slow the amount of illegal immigration into the United States, the Immigration and Reform Control Act of 1986 gave “blanket amnesty” to nearly three million illegals, but this law only resulted in more illegal immigration (). With amnesty showing to be in-effective, drones, fences, and armed guards dot the southern border of the United States, while billion of the federal budget go to border security, much of which specifically to the United States-Mexico border. Regardless of amnesty’s failure to slow illegal immigration in the 1980’s, still today

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of United States Border Patrol

2970 Words | 12 Pages

The United States Border Patrol, USBP, has acted as the country's first line of defense against unauthorized migration throughout history. Border Patrol's primary focus and mission is to prevent as well as detect the entry of any and all weapons of mass destruction, terrorists and illegal aliens into the country while also working to interdict drug smugglers and all other criminals along the border (Haddal, 2010). The Homeland Security Act of 2002 did away with the Immigration and Naturalization Service and instead placed the United States Border Patrol in the Department of Homeland Security. USBP, in the last couple of decades, has begun to receive a drastic increase in funding in response to incidents, which could have been prevented if the terrorists had been stopped at the border (Haddal, 2010). The United States has some of the world’s longest land and sea borders and securing them is both a national security priority and logistical challenge.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of US-Mexico Border Patrol

1781 Words | 8 Pages

The Border Patrol is also harming the environment because the fence is disrupting the migrations cycles of animals. The Border Patrol’s enforcement operations is harming the environment. The Criminal Trafficking Operations are attracted to places where there are no border patrols because it guarantees them a journey without interruptions (“Securing Our Border...”). These Criminal Trafficking Operations target national parks and forests along the U.S.-Mexican border, which are becoming extremely dangerous for people to walk in. Theses parks are becoming dangerous because Drug Trafficking Organizations smuggle in drugs through National parks and forests.

Read More

Why Do Illegal Immigrants Negatively Affect Our Economy

320 Words | 2 Pages

This is only encouraging more immigrants to travel to the U.S. illegally.

Read More

Border Patrol Dbq

1762 Words | 8 Pages

Also, the bill would bolster border security a little further, by adding 20,000 Border Patrol agents. It required completing 700 new miles of new fence along the United States-Mexico line and using $3.2 billion in additional security technology. Texas had taken a more aggressive approach. “The Texas legislature, with the support of state leaders, has dedicated substantial funding over the last several years, and the Department of Public Safety has dedicated a significant amount of resources, technology, equipment and personnel for border security,” Texas Department of Public Safety Director Steven McCraw stated in an email interview. The staff for the state legislative board had estimated a total spending on the border security of about $452 million from 2008-2013.

Read More

United States Border Patrol

997 Words | 4 Pages

The United States Border Patrol has seen an ever increase in funding, especially since its collaboration and indoctrination into the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). Through the history of the “War on Drugs” brought on by the Nixon Administration, it is clear that the ever expanding costs in order to combat an ever increasing thirst for illegal drugs, and weapons. Border Security is most definitely detrimental in order to continue increasing homeland security, along with keeping the citizens of the United States not only safe from harm, but safe from legal and economic implications direct towards the legal citizens at the cost of illegal immigrant behavior. It takes the works of all forms and sources in order for the nation to be

Read More

True Immigration Reform

1882 Words | 8 Pages

The reform policy is allowing undocumented aliens, who are here illegally in United States to continue to live here in this country without any penalty. If we are able to keep that rather large percentage lower than what it has been in the past 5 years, then the United States will be able to focus on the real problems of the border, such as illegal drug and sex trafficking, kidnapping, etc. ‘’The last time our government measured border security, only 13 percent of our borders are under “operational control. ”(TRUE Immigration Reform: A Policy that Serves the Interests of the American People) The undocumented aliens living in the U.S. will keep hiding and won’t get legal papers if they think they will be sent back across the border them if they come out of hiding.

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Immigration Reform

526 Words | 3 Pages

However the reform did nothing about removing the immigrants who remained illegal. The reform was also unsuccessful because during the draw up of the bill, the bill's sponsors ended up watering down the sanctions on employers to attract support from the business community. Under the final law, all employers had to do to avoid sanctions was to make sure their workers had paperwork that "reasonably appears on its face to be genuine. " If the documents were decent fakes, that wasn't the boss's problem. So with there being such an easy way out of punishment employers continued to do as they pleased.

Read More

Reflection On A Meeting At The Arrowhead Church

951 Words | 4 Pages

The meeting I attended took place in Union Hills on Thursday at 6:00pm. The meeting was held in a church called The Arrowhead Church. There were around 10 or 11 people there for the meeting. There were people of all ages, men and women. It was a very diverse group with a mixture of people from all walks of life.

Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of A Sustainable Immigration System

Related Topics

Open Document