ipl-logo

Mexico Vs Canada Research Paper

826 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Impacts of 9/11 on airport security

Mexico or Canada, which Border should We Defend Most? There is a clear difference between how the two international borders of the United States are managed. Canada, as one of America’s top trading partners, has a visa-free agreement with the United States, meaning a Canadian citizen may cross the border with a passport, ID, and border crossing card. For a limited time, Canadians need no visa inside the United States. Contrastingly.The International Boundary Commision referred to the border as an “open and trusting relationship” (Sullivan). However, after the 9-11 terrorist attacks, the view of the Canadian border changed. The border with Mexico, similarly, saw a peaceful relationship in the past, but tremendous amounts of illegal aliens have …show more content…

After the notable boundary disputes between the United States and Canada in history, such as the Aroostook War along Maine’s international border with Canada, and the Oregon Question, the boundary between the United States and Canada saw little conflict. Communities on both both sides of the border even shared public buildings, especially the famous Haskell Library and Opera House that is divided by the international border. However, after the terrorist of September 11, 2001, increasing attention was given to the Canadian border. An investigation found that drugs, firearms, human trafficking, violence, and even terrorism was coming across the United States northern border with Canada. Therefore, the need to secure this border was clear and protect American Territoriality is clear. Drones, surveillance towers, and heavily guarded border crossings and now increasing along the United States-Canada border. The United States Customs and Border Protection is responsible for securing international borders, and have consistently placed more security and protection measures along this border. Individuals crossing the border with Canada have reported being handcuffed, questioned, and then released. The United States border with Canada has never been more secure than it is …show more content…

Illegal aliens began crossing the border in the 1920’s to fill the need for cheap labor, and later the Bracero program brought more foreign workers in the United States, who were expected to only temporarily live in and work in the United States. However, after the program ended, many of the workers involved in the Bracero program with only temporary status, staying in the United States as illegal workers. This eventually led to President Eisenhower’s “Operation Wetback,” which resulted in tens of thousands of illegal aliens being caught and deported. “Operation Wetback” restored the American labor market, resulting in a drop of illegal immigration of nearly 95% by the end of the 1950’s. Nonetheless, the 1965 Immigration Act abolished the national origins quota system, resulting in a wave of illegals due to chain migration. In an attempt to slow the amount of illegal immigration into the United States, the Immigration and Reform Control Act of 1986 gave “blanket amnesty” to nearly three million illegals, but this law only resulted in more illegal immigration (). With amnesty showing to be in-effective, drones, fences, and armed guards dot the southern border of the United States, while billion of the federal budget go to border security, much of which specifically to the United States-Mexico border. Regardless of amnesty’s failure to slow illegal immigration in the 1980’s, still today

Show More
Related
387 Words | 2 Pages

• • President Polk proposed setting the boundary between the United States and British Canada at the 49th parallel, a proposal that was accepted only after Polk threated war to take the border farther

Read More
73 Words | 1 Pages

In "Migra! A History of the U.S Border Patrol", By Kelly Lytle Hernandez, she explores the controversial issue today known as the dissension that surrounds our border with Mexico. Hernandez also outlines the policies and ideology of the U.S Border Patrol that were discovered and really brought out in the early 1920s to the late 1920s. She does a detailed research on the beginning to what becomes the authorized United States Border Patrol.

Read More
672 Words | 3 Pages

She than moves on to state, similarly to Gotlieb, that the United States primary concern at the moment is security, thus having Canada prove to the US that they pose no threat. Therefore, is it really Canada’s foreign policy if our main focus is external relations with the US. Welsh suggests that we must build upon other relations among the international community, as “the United States will not be the world’s only superpower forever”. Additionally, a recent report from a UN high level panel on collective security, state “today’s threats know no boundaries and must be addressed at the global and regional levels”, thus leading Welsh to suggesting that Canada follows the UN report, and create a foreign policy that “actively address these threats, in collaboration with other actors on the international stage”, compared to Gotlieb suggesting we stay away from UN ideas. In conclusion, though both authors have a different view on how Canada should approach their foreign policy, both Welsh and Gotlieb agree that in order for Canada to continue to grow in the international community, they must rethink their foreign

Read More
294 Words | 2 Pages

The border between the United States and Mexico is nearly 2,000 miles long. Over the past few years, the United States had form a policy called Secure Fence Act to prevent drug sellers and terrorists out of America (Clifford). The act constructed fences to cover about one third of the border between Mexico and America along California, New Mexico, Texas and so on. Unfortunately, there were less environmental considerations when making the policy. The Los Angeles Times reported that in additional to build the fences, the United States government has been eluded over thirty environmental and cultural laws (Campbell).

Read More
613 Words | 3 Pages

This is not the case; it may be the most vulnerable to terrorist infiltration, partly because much of this area is unsettled. The USBP has begun to turn their focused towards securing the Canadian Border. Deploying new technology and interacting closely with Canadian officials through the creation of International Border Enforcement

Read More
1634 Words | 7 Pages

Customs and Border Protection are among the federal government’s younger entities, however many of its roles and responsibilities can be traced back before all the original states had ratified the U.S. constitution. The origins of border patrol go back to 1904 where these men were called “Mounted Guards,” they were called upon to patrol border in an effort to prevent illegal crossings. They were used in the El Paso, Texas area as well as far west of California. The “first patrolman” was Jeff Milton in 1879 (Border Patrol History). U.S. Border Patrol first established in 1924 a few years after Prohibition was put into effect which called for prohibiting the manufacturing, storage in barrels, bottles, transportation and sale of alcohol including alcoholic beverages.

Read More
2970 Words | 12 Pages

The United States Border Patrol, USBP, has acted as the country's first line of defense against unauthorized migration throughout history. Border Patrol's primary focus and mission is to prevent as well as detect the entry of any and all weapons of mass destruction, terrorists and illegal aliens into the country while also working to interdict drug smugglers and all other criminals along the border (Haddal, 2010). The Homeland Security Act of 2002 did away with the Immigration and Naturalization Service and instead placed the United States Border Patrol in the Department of Homeland Security. USBP, in the last couple of decades, has begun to receive a drastic increase in funding in response to incidents, which could have been prevented if the terrorists had been stopped at the border (Haddal, 2010). The United States has some of the world’s longest land and sea borders and securing them is both a national security priority and logistical challenge.

Read More
326 Words | 2 Pages

As the U.S election results are revealed, many Canadian citizens fear the impact Mr. Donald Trump could cause upon Canada. Trump has promised to pull away the U.S. from any international climate agreements, saying that he will “shred” Obama’s greenhouse gas policies. Moreover, this will greatly affect Canada since Canada has numerous climate projects with the U.S. Having Trump as president could permanently damage the trade that Canada has maintained with the U.S., since Mr. Trump is pledging to overhaul U.S. trade relations, especially since approximately $51 billion in goods cross the Canada-U.S. border per month, according to TD Economics. Trump has demanded multiple times to have a renegotiation of the American Free Trade Agreement.

Read More
980 Words | 4 Pages

Canadian/American relations have always been much like that of a brother and his younger sister. They are dependent on one another, and their bond is built off of friendship and trust. When battles occur, they ride in together, and when one is in need, support is given. In 1917, the Halifax Explosion devastated a section of Nova Scotia, and the size of the accident destroyed a large amount of both people and homes. The medicinal and reparation costs were more than the surrounding cities could afford.

Read More
984 Words | 4 Pages

The initiatives highlighted throughout this paper do not even come close to discussing all of the joint programs between Canada and the US in terms of cross-border security. What the BTB Action Plan has accomplished is to closer align policies and practices through combined regulations and legislation. A study conducted by Leuprecht, Hataley, & Skillicorn suggests that greater bi-national cooperation will not necessarily make either country any safer, but it will make the rest of the world safer because North America will be harder to exploit as a market of opportunity in the global terror supply chain (Leuprecht, Hataley, & Skillicorn 2013, 170). This is precisely the meaning of “beyond the border” - extending the security perimeter as far as possible. Through the sharing of information and intelligence, integrated law enforcement, and shared responsibility for mutual resources, Canada and the US can continue with the long standing mutually beneficial trade and security relationship well into the

Read More
505 Words | 3 Pages

40% to 50% of illegals are set to enter this country legally on visas and stayed past their expiration (Andreas, 5, 100). The American Free Trade Agreement may it difficult for a closer border crossing control. It allowed Mexican and U.S immigrants to cross borders to work. This became a thin line between enforcement and facilitation (Andreas, 5,

Read More
761 Words | 4 Pages

The United States of America is one of the only superpowers in the world. America is loved, however, hated at the same time. There has been an ongoing controversy throughout America and the world for many years. The decision of whether or not to have America’s borders open or secured has stumped many throughout the years. This problem has caused so much controversy that America has done nothing to make a difference regarding border control.

Read More
259 Words | 2 Pages

Facilitating legal border entry and exit crossings of people and goods while maintaining secure a border infrastructure is rife with challenges. First, there are the costs associated with highly secured borders. In the post 9/11 period over $100 billion dollars has been spent on securing the southwestern border of the United States, while there has not been another major terrorist attack on the US, there is little to show for the hardening of borders (Thurston, 2009). The US is still experiencing record high illegal immigration and drug trafficking while continuing to add more expensive military grade hardware and technology in an attempt to better secure the border. Additionally, there is the training and recruitment cost associated with

Read More
999 Words | 4 Pages

Border security truly is Canada’s first line of defence for Canada’s safety. There are over 1200 border crossings in Canada and they protect the entire country and are the first line of defence on terrorism and illegal activity. The CBSA (Canadian Border Security Agency) does a whole lot more than what people see in their encounter with the border security. The CBSA is a federal agency that is responsible for immigration enforcement, border enforcement and customs service. Today I’ll go into detail about what the border security actually do besides just checking your passport.

Read More
778 Words | 4 Pages

The article focuses how the U.S. government relies on interdiction at the US-Mexico border to stop the flow of drugs by disrupting the supply, which is thought to decrease availability and demand from the price increases. Although there is multiple layers on the topic, this article focuses strictly border and it's effectiveness. The article also explains how the number of border officers and the financial cost have only increased by the decades without any statistical evidence showing a relationship between border enforcement positively and effectively decreasing the price of illegal drugs or stopping the supply that goes into the

Read More

More about Mexico Vs Canada Research Paper

Related Topics

Open Document