ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of Declaring Jerusalem

623 Words3 Pages

Declaring Jerusalem as Israel's capital city could be a bad decision

Aracelys Hernández

On December 6th, 2017, Mr Donald Trump, President of the United States of America, recognized Jerusalem as Israel's capital city and formally announced that he was going to relocate the United States embassy from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem. “This is nothing more or less than a recognition of reality. It is also the right thing to do. It’s something that has to be done,” said Mr Trump regarding his announcement. However, this decision may not be “the right thing” to do. In fact, it goes against the international law; it reduces the possibilities of a peace deal between Israel and Palestine, and it might affect U.S. relationships with other countries.

To begin with, it is said in the Geneva Conventions Protocol that the territories that were acquired by means of war are under “hostile military occupation”. That is the case of East Jerusalem, the Palestinian part of the city. These territories were annexed to Israel in 1967, after the Six-Day War. Israeli government denies the existence of a “military occupation”. However, in 1980, the United Nations Security Council affirmed that East Jerusalem was under hostile occupation.and declared that its annexation to Israel represented a violation to …show more content…

It was considered that taking a unilateral decision could affect peace negotiations between these two countries and break with international consensus. The United States' previous governments, from Bill Clinton to Barack Obama, had followed this policy. Mr Trump decided to go against this formula and, by doing so, he is interfering with peace negotiations between the two nations involved. After the U.S. announcement, Mahmoud Abbas, President of Palestine, declared that the decision represented a setback to the peacemaking deal and the "death knell of any peace

Show More
Related

Fm 27-10 Research Paper

284 Words | 2 Pages

What would be your response to the order? Explain in detail. According to FM 27- 10 appendix A # 382. “Deportations, Transfers, Evacuations Individual or mass forcible transfers, as well as deportations of protected persons from occupied territory to the territory of the Occupying Power or to that of any other country, occupied or not, are prohibited, regardless of their motive.” And MCRP 4-11-8b Article 109 “Unlawful deportation, transfer or confinement of civilians under the control of a military force or government.”

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Nothing Will Change After The Las Vegas Shooting By Steve Israel

1541 Words | 7 Pages

Israel also is not lacking in terms of authority or expertise on this topic either. Israel seems to know what he’s talking about and knows where and when to give credit. Even after all it is taking to get something done he still doesn’t give up on what he believes in. Israel keeps trying to get what he wants done with gun laws even though it is taking forever and is a slow process, he never gives up. Eventually if he keeps on trying Israel will get his wish on gun laws.

Read More

Arab Peninsula Dbq

225 Words | 1 Pages

In November of 1917 a resolution calling for the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine. This resolution caused anger amongst Arab community they believed Palestine would be a free Arab State. This declaration was made for one to influence US Jewish businessmen in supporting war. The Jewish population continued to support Russian involvement,

Read More

World War II DBQ Essay

696 Words | 3 Pages

Israel gained its territory in wars but a big part of it was from the six-day war in 1967 where Israel conquered the east bank including Jerusalem from Jordan, Gaza strip and Sinai from Egypt (after a few years they gave it back to Egypt in order to have peace), and the Golan Heights from Syria (HISTORY: The State of Israel). The idea of a Jewish country was formed a long time before the Holocaust happened, due to the Holocaust the U.N, which made the decision of creating the country, agreed to the idea because of the discrimination of Jews. As a result, they thought that they deserved a country of their own. Since Israel was formed it participated in seven wars and two Intifadas.

Read More

Why Is Truman Called The Balfour Declaration Dbq

1677 Words | 7 Pages

I had familiarized myself with the history of the question of a Jewish homeland and the position of the British and the Arabs. I was skeptical, as I read over the whole record up to date, about some of the views and attitudes assumed by the “striped-pants boys” - the State Department (Truman, 1965). Clearly he did not agree with what his administration wanted to do. Truman would have been happy if the UN would solve the conflict, but that was not tangible. The UN was newly formed, but more importantly, no significant proposal could get past the General Assembly or the Security Council with American support.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Crusades

515 Words | 3 Pages

The Crusades damaged a lot of things, but they also gained back many things in return that have helped us years to come which left them with a bitter legacy. The one major historical question that doesn't seem to have an answer to it yet is “ Where the Crusades more positive or negative” no one knows that correct answer because there is so much evidence supporting both so all we can do is make our own opinion. I believe that that the Crusades did more bad than good. We have many pieces of evidence to support both side but there are some that are a little bit stronger than others like the example that they caused a lot of harm to the empires. For example, according to Document 4 it states that in April of 1204 the

Read More

Vietnam War Dbq Essay

1128 Words | 5 Pages

This is seen as Unnecessary killing or destruction which is unlawful. Document 4 says in Article one that you Must make every effort to obtain peace, and once peace is achieved, do not break or breach it. Article two says that a country should Settle disputes so that peace, security, or justice are not endangered. This must stay loyal to the purpose of the United Nations. This goes against what the U.S did as they did not follow these steps of peace which would of maybe helped the war effort and cause less casualties overall.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Ratifying The Constitution

647 Words | 3 Pages

As I have said before, decisions that should be made by an entire country shouldn’t be made by a few, select people from the government. Those few, select people may be making the wrong decision on whether to go to war or not. All of the people want to make peace, but the government wants to attack them. Although this may be true that it’s important to give the voice to the people more, there also a separation of powers between the branches of government. The legislative branch may have representatives from each state that have an idea for a new law that may make the country better, but the executive branch, which is the president, may veto the law and send it back to the representatives until the president gets his/her way.

Read More

Compare And Contrast The Articles Of Confederation

1172 Words | 5 Pages

1. The Articles of Confederation had many problems that arose, especially with the national government. States were only issued to have one vote no matter what their population was, support for legislation had to be kept private, and the states had their own power. The Articles of Confederation did not let the national government ask for money, making it harder to achieve all the responsibilities. Individual state governments did not have to agree with any troop requests and could refuse to raise an army.

Read More

Was Truman A Hero Or A Villain

1637 Words | 7 Pages

Truman’s role in the decision to recognise Israel has persuaded others that he is best viewed as a villain because he really did this as a political ploy to secure Jewish votes in a Presidential election. Following the aftermath of WW2 and the holocaust, many people sympathised with Jewish people and the horrors they faced, one of these people supposedly being Harry Truman, making his opinions known through the support of the creation of Israel and the recognition of it,

Read More

Dbq Essay On The Holocaust

1112 Words | 5 Pages

Israel is a sign of the Jewish transformation from helpless to self independence. '' Three times a day they prayed for the restoration of Jerusalem... These problems will not arise if a home be found for them which will be legally recognized as Jewish” ( Source G). The Jewish people went from praying for the restoration of their nation to being given one recognized as a Jewish state. They were given an opportunity to rebuild themselves, their families, and their religion in a new peaceful country long dreamed of. "...shown during two thousand years of appalling and suffering… the new Jewish state, with its superior institutions had become a reality” ( Source D ).

Read More

Dbq Israel And Palestinian Conflict Essay

492 Words | 2 Pages

A common debate in politics is the discussion of what to do in the middle east as it pertains to the Israel-Palestine conflict. Both groups of religious people, seek one home for their organization of believers. The Israelis believe that they belong there since they resided in the territory the longest time ago, but the Palestinians believe that since they have lived there for the past thousand or so years, they have claim to the land. Quite simply, a two-state solution presents the best chance of achieving peace in the region and putting an end to conflict, because Israel would not be able to overpower Palestine, they have tried to coexist, and failed, repeatedly, and Palestinians would be reimbursed for their losses. In a two state solution the land and landmarks are

Read More

Jewish Lobby Pros And Cons

745 Words | 3 Pages

This foreign policy paper contains little mention of politics outside of the United Kingdom. Thus when the claim of a “Jewish Lobby” influencing former US President George Bush’s decisions to invade Iraq is introduced, it is not well connected with the central argument or flow found within the paper. Rather, the comment reads as unnecessary and provocative. Additionally and perhaps more concerning is the casual usage of “Jewish Lobby”. Within the essay, there is no named lobby organisation but rather a general one based on the religious identity of a small proportion of Americans.

Read More

How Did Bill Clinton Create Peace In The Middle East?

612 Words | 3 Pages

After the failure from the oslo agreement Bill Clinton set out to address the final state issues, This event occurred in camp david during 2000, these issues addressed many problems including border disputes, jerusalem, and refugees. This talk took place between Bill Clinton, Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak ,and PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat. Although there was no agreement, Bill was able to find out that the problem was that Israel offered less than Palestine could accept. Palestine wanted part of jerusalem or “the old city” just to get recognition of the return of palestinian

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Gulf War

198 Words | 1 Pages

But recently, it appears that there is lots of controversy over the decision to leave Hussein in power. Some say it will help keep the region out of a potential civil

Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of Declaring Jerusalem

Related Topics

Open Document