ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of Humanitarian Intervention

1530 Words7 Pages

Humanitarian intervention is an emerging norm that was born out of a desire to prevent past horrors, such as the Rwanda genocide and Srebrenica massacre from reoccurring. The concept was further enumerated in the formation of the responsibility to protect doctrine (‘R2P’), which infers that countries have a duty to interfere with the sovereignty of others in order to protect human rights. Since their inception into international relations, both humanitarian intervention and R2P have struggled with disunity between its proponents and those who suggest it is merely being used by the West to strengthen their hegemonic power. There are many arguments as to contend that humanitarian is merely a disguised form of Western imperialism, such as: the …show more content…

Thus it could be said that Western states engage in opportunistic humanitarianism (Rigstad 2007) only where their interests are at risk. This is shown by France’s commitment to halting the Cote d’Ivoire civil war. Adeyeri suggests that Cote d’Ivoire is “of maximum economic and geostrategic importance to France. Cote d’Ivoire is the economic powerhouse of Francophone West Africa…” (2015, pp. 65). Further, there was concern by Western powers over Gbagbo’s encouragement and facilitation of Chinese, Indian and Russian influence and access to the region (Bush, Martiniello, Mercer 2011). Hence, by using UN support and humanitarianism intervention as a cover, France was able to avert protracted violence from impeding on its interests. Similarly, intervention in Libya was engaged more on national interests than altruistic motives. Whilst many contend that oil was a significant factor for US engagement, a more decisive consideration was that Libya is in prime position to stifle African immigration from flooding into Europe (Bush, Martiniello, Mercer

Show More
Related

The Theme Of Cultural Ignorance In The Poisonwood Bible By Barbara Kingsolver

1174 Words | 5 Pages

On the macro-level, Kingsolver portrays this through the West-Congo conflict -- namely, the conflict between the U.S.' strategic interests and the Congo's. Rachel explains, "... this Devil One person was going to get one million dollars from the United States to pay soldiers to do that, go against the very person they all elected..." because "...in their locked room, these men [Western politicians] put their heads together and proclaimed Patrice Lumumba a danger to the safety of the world." (Kingsolver 294, 319) The West didn't want an independent leader, they wanted a puppet government -- hence the CIA-sponsored coup that replaced the democratic leader with a despotic puppet dictator.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Iraq War

283 Words | 2 Pages

The United States fought unnecessary wars in Vietnam and Iraq. The war on communism, in Vietnam, severed the United States compared to the war on terrorism, in Iraq. During both wars the U.S. Military spent millions to billions of money, deaths were extremely high, and both failed to accomplish their purpose. Firstly the Iraq War dealt massive harm to the United States in multiple ways.

Read More

Effects Of Imperialism In Rwanda

1889 Words | 8 Pages

“An in-depth analysis on effects of Imperialism on Rwanda” Nowadays, European countries such as England, France, Germany, Belgium, and many other countries possess a colossal clout throughout the world. It is an impeccable fact that such countries, indeed, have served as a rudiment pivot and step for the world to be advanced to the point where we are since the Industrial Revolution. Such countries, because of it, without a doubt, have a crucial status globally and become the superpower and commercial hub on our planet. On the back side of their gleaming growth, however, there is an invisible part left behind their luminous development: the Imperialism. The term “Imperialism” refers to a policy of extending a country’s authority and political clout by using its military forces and diplomacy.

Read More

Summary Of A Problem From Hell: America And The Age Of Genocide

1189 Words | 5 Pages

The author expresses that the government used several logical fallacies in order to provide reasons to stay away from Rwanda. Power states, “Most officials… define the decision not to stop the genocide as ethical and moral.” (155) U.S. officials provided a slippery slope that claimed involvement in Rwanda would lead to “…getting involved everywhere.” (155) However, this is a false dichotomy, involvement in one country does not guarantee involvement in another. Power uses this as an example to show how she feels the government wrong and again prove her point that they were avoiding involvement.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of US Military's Occupation Of Iraq

788 Words | 4 Pages

There is no doubt that the United States government made mistakes during the military’s occupation of Iraq. Outside of the fact that they should not have been there, the actions taken there were irresponsible and proved to be fatal. Once the nation was offended by US military presence, the society went into chaos. About 4,000 Americans died in Iraq alone. The United States proved to act on impulse during this tragic event.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Iraq War

433 Words | 2 Pages

Since 2001 when the war began, there had been many casualties. According the article “U.S. military casualties and the costs of war” on Journalistsresource.org, during the Iraq War, 4,475 U.S. service members were killed and 32,220 were wounded; in Afghanistan, 2,165 have been killed and 18,230 wounded. As a result of battle injuries in the Iraq War, 991 service members received wounds that required amputations; 797 lost major limbs, such as a leg. In Afghanistan, 724 have had to undergo amputations, with 696 losing a major limb.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Iraq War

386 Words | 2 Pages

“Going to war was the only unselfish thing I have ever done for humanity,” said David Niven. In Iraq, March 2003, the U.S went to war with ISIS. George W. Bush said the Iraqi dictator, Saddam Hussein, was hiding nuclear weapons to kill a lot of people. When Barack Obama was elected in 2008, he brought the last U.S troops home. He then took the rest of the troops out in 2011 because it cost too much money for too many deaths.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The US Invasion Of Iraq

975 Words | 4 Pages

Should the United States have attacked Iraq?       Introduction: On the 20th of March 2003, the United States commenced a war against Iraq and destroyed Saddam Hussein’s regime because they thought Iraq was a threat to the world. According to Presidents, Historians, journalists, and Politicians, it was not a necessary attack and it was a big mistake from The United States, that war was inequity and they declared war to take advantage of Iraq’s land.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Iraq War

1305 Words | 6 Pages

The word jihad does not only mean “a struggle or fight against the enemies of Islam”, but also mean “a spiritual struggle against one’s sin”. The definition of a crusade is: “to take part in an organization concerning a social, political or religious issue. There have been many points in history when a holy war has been waged. The Holocaust and WWII have not been called a Holy war, but millions of Jews died because the Nazi party thought their religion was wrong. Today, America is suspicious of all Muslims and we call them terrorists.

Read More

Violence In Sierra Leone's Brutality

307 Words | 2 Pages

“Sierra Leone’s Brutality” Sierra Leone was famous for brutalizing humankind in the recent past. The nature of cruelty surprised the entire world. The problems called for a demand of hands-on and emergency response. In Sierra Leone, nation’s world-wide in several communities had the ability to stop the violence. According to Kumar (2010: 303), the United Nations Mission in Sierra Leone exemplifies a successful though prolonged UN peace intervention in Africa in the changed global power structure.”

Read More

Congo Crisis Research Paper

772 Words | 4 Pages

The Congo Crisis was a conflicting time when Congo became independent from Belgium that led to a series of civil wars as well as a proxy war between the Soviet Union and the United States. In addition to these two powerful countries, China and Cuba’s role in the Congo Crisis are not only strategic, but are often forgotten. Furthermore, these two communist countries perceived the Congo Crisis as a way to not only help African’s struggle against foreign domination, but as a way to distance themselves from the Soviet Union and achieve power and success throughout the world. The Congo Crisis faced not only political upheaval in the newly, independent state, but rather a worldwide struggle against the common enemy.

Read More

Why Did Humanitarian Intervention Take Off In The 1990s

1611 Words | 7 Pages

The creation in 1993 of the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY), and the subsequent creation of similar entities in Rwanda, Sierra Leone, Cambodia, and East Timor, paved the way for the formation in 1998 of the International Criminal Court (ICC), which had “unprecedented powers to prosecute individuals for genocide, war crimes, crimes against humanity and crimes of aggression. ”27 The humanitarian crises of the 1990s also triggered debate as to the limits of state sovereignty. Historically, unconditional state sovereignty has been regarded as a crucial element of the international order.28 However, incidents such as the Rwandan genocide led to arguments that state sovereignty need not be absolute, such as Kofi Annan's assertion that the “evolution in our understanding of State sovereignty” represented by HI is “is an evolution that we should welcome”.29 Such a position was further codified by the adoption of the Responsibility to Protect (R2P), which maintains that sovereignty is conditional on a state's willingness or ability to protect its citizens, and which explicitly states in the introduction of its initial report by the International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty that it is motivated by the view that “[w]e want no more

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of R2P Initiatives

737 Words | 3 Pages

INTROCUTION To translate the R2P principles to deeds will require serious commitment from all the governments who unanimously affirmed at the 2005 World Summit Outcome that “each individual State has the responsibility to protect its populations from genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity” (UN world summit, 2005). To relies a credible implementation, it is necessary that Paragraphs 138 and 139 of the Outcome which goes to the real issue of operationalizing the responsibility to protect (widely referred to as “R2P” in English) is sincerely adhered to by all. This brief paper will cover current R2P debate and the complex issue of implementing the R2P pillars which are: Pillar one the protection responsibilities of the State (sect. II).

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Foreign Aid

1498 Words | 6 Pages

The consequence of wars, the political turmoil in countries or simply a country in debt; these all warrant a need for foreign aid. Although it may seem like the obvious act to do, is it really the right thing to do? It is firstly important to note what is the fundamental characteristic of foreign aid and what it entails, both for a country providing and the country receiving it. The aspect of aid can take many forms, ranging from goods and services or capital from foreign country to country in need. As situations in different countries continue to take new forms, aid can also be provided concerning military, economic means, etc.

Read More

Humanitarian Aid Role

1100 Words | 5 Pages

The overall objective of the paper is to examine the role of humanitarian aid in fuelling the conflict in the DRC. However, the three specific objectives of the paper are as follows: - To analyze how DRC’s mineral resources have led to the continued conflict. - To examine how humanitarian aid by Western powers (Global North) exacerbates conflicts in the Global South. - To interrogate how humanitarian aid has prolonged the conflict in the DRC.

Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of Humanitarian Intervention

Related Topics

Open Document