ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of In Vitro Fertilization

1085 Words5 Pages

Scientific advancement is accelerating but current laws and regulations fail to keep up with its progress. This problem leads to several ethical and legal dilemmas in various fields of biology. This problem is especially prominent in embryology. Laboratories focusing on in vitro fertilization have been growing embryos and then implanting them on the seventh day (Hyun et. al 169). Due to recent advances, research labs are currently able to grow embryos in vitro up to 14 days (Hyun et. al 169). Current policies and laws around the world are preventing scientist from continuing their work past 14 days. The Ethics Advisory Board of the United States Department of Health, Education and Welfare first proposed this rule in 1979. The 14-day rule is a regulatory line that limits in vitro human embryo research (Hyun et. al 170). This regulation prevents labs from allowing the embryo to survive and keep growing after 14 days. The line is drawn at 14 days because it stops growth before the primitive streak appears. In other words, it marks the beginning of gastrulation in humans (Reardon 19). The …show more content…

It is critical to understand there are several disadvantages to allowing the current regulation to change. The first issue with extending the time frame of in vitro embryo research is deciding what the next time frame limit should be. There is a moral issue in deciding a new time frame. An important argument to consider is growing an embryo for an extended period could cause the embryo undue distress. Other groups are against embryo research because they believe life starts at the moment of conception, therefore vitro embryo research should be stopped completely. No matter what is decided in the future the most important factor to ensure the success of the future law is to guarantee that the new policy has a clear and legally enforced stopping point for research (Hyun et. al

Show More
Related

Stem Cell Now Book Report

1212 Words | 5 Pages

Biomedical researchers wanted to use the spare embryos generated by the procedure, and argued that it was morally permissible because their research would hold the potential for life changing results. Opponents to stem cell research objected, arguing that the destruction of an embryo is morally equivalent to murder. The result was a congressional ban prohibiting the use of government funds for research involving human

Read More

Embryonic Stem Research Persuasive Speech

258 Words | 2 Pages

Last, the scientists should respect embryos just like they are human beings. People today are still debating if the embryonic stem cells are the best fit for the unborn. Scientists have used embryos to test on for the use of trying to find cure to diseases. The treatment may not really work but they are still putting people through risks. Scientist are taking humans

Read More

Embryonic Stem Cell Research Persuasive Essay

667 Words | 3 Pages

Over the years, there have been many controversial issues surrounding medical research, but one of the most arguable topics of all time is the use of embryonic stem cells. Some individuals believe that extracting stem cells from unborn babies will be useful to create new medications or, in most cases, help regenerate damaged cells. Although, many people disagree with the process scientists use to obtain these stem cells. By continuing embryonic stem cell research, scientists are denying an unborn child the chance to live, they are not letting nature take its intended course, and they are not adhering to the religious or moral beliefs of many people.

Read More

Embryonic Stem Cell Research Argumentative Essay

1673 Words | 7 Pages

No person has the right to make a decision as to when someone else’s life should end. This is a form of murder because scientists are intentionally destroying a human being. Not only are scientist destroying embryos but they are also trying to take destiny into his own hands which then exposes him to “temptation to go beyond the limits of a reasonable dominion over” (Instruction n Respect for Human Life). Although, scientists are doing this in attempt to help benefit others, it does not mean it is right to end another’s life as well as endangering their own morality by committing an immoral

Read More

Stem Cell Research In Mary Shelley's Frankenstein

866 Words | 4 Pages

“How do you know when an embryo is dead?” (Robin, Barnett). This however, has been solved as scientist began to use already dead embryos. However, they were cautioned by right-to-life campaigners. “In theory if an embryo is obtained ethically and a stem cell can be derived after the embryo has died naturally, then that will remove all ethical

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Embryonic Stem Cell Research

1259 Words | 6 Pages

The issue is specifically in regards to embryonic stem cells due to the killing of the embryo, which some consider to be a form of life. This ethical debate is so important because depending on certain peoples, such as the president’s, view on the matter it impacts many peoples lives both currently and in the future. The main argument is that, as former president Bush said, killing embryo “the taking of innocent human life”. On the other side, people do not view it as taking a life and understand that embryonic stem cells could potentially cure diseases, spinal chord injuries, and many other defects. Also, there is a difference between something being human and something being considered human life.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Embryonic Stem Cells

573 Words | 3 Pages

In this essay I plan to discuss whether embryonic stem cells should be used in the future to regenerate human organs. I will be discussing the advantages and disadvantages of using embryonic stem cells based upon my research. There are many disputes about using embryonic stem cells due to the way they are created. The ethical implications of using embryonic stem cells go against the belief of people who are “Pro-Life” (the belief that a foetus has no voice so living humans need to protect the foetus from preventable harm such as an abortion) Many people believe that culturing embryonic stem cells is basically an abortion due to the embryo dying after the stem cells have been harvested.

Read More

Embryonic Stem Cell Research Debate

1547 Words | 7 Pages

In an article written by Nancy Frazier O’Brien, she points out the fact that during a United States Conference of Bishops meeting there was a 191-1 vote in favor of a document titled “On Embryonic Stem Cell Research: A Statement of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops”. This document basically stated that we, as a people, have crossed a certain line of morality that causes us to believe it is permissible to use a human being as a research specimen (O’Brien). This idea adds an entirely new level of difficulty when dealing with this particular conflict. If human embryos are thought of as human beings than the conflict deepens with the debate of the morality in killing one thing to save another. The conflict behind embryonic stem cell research is very difficult, and religious groups, such as the Catholic church, present a very firm stance.

Read More

Embryonic Stem Cell Research Argumentative Essay

1341 Words | 6 Pages

Latham illustrates the reason embryonic stem cell research became such a controversial subject: ESC research, “Generally involves the destruction of an early-stage human embryo” (1). People all over the world have different beliefs as to when life begins. There is a huge division in opinion; some believe life begins at conception while other believe life begins at birth. It does not matter what a person’s stance if on the subject because everyone must learn to look at the bigger picture; research saves lives. Scientist Melissa Abramovitz, the author of multiple scientific articles such as "The Controversy over Embryonic Stem Cells", informs everyone what happens to embryos in fertility clinics: “Once a successful pregnancy occurs, the parents may elect to leave any unused fertilized eggs in frozen storage, to dispose of them as medical waste, or to donate them for scientific research” (1).

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Human Embryonic Stem Cell Research

1384 Words | 6 Pages

The issues stem from every side of the sociopolitical spectrum. There is hesitation at almost every phase of the stem cell research process; from the gray area of biological donations, the risks involved in extraction and cultivation, along with the legal and ethical dilemmas that could arise at any stage of research (Parham & Lo 2009). The pros and cons of each stage, as well as the overall human embryonic stem cell research process, should be analyzed in-depth, so that the potential benefits and adverse effects can be supported or avoided,

Read More

Ethical Issues With Stem Cell Research Essay

1587 Words | 7 Pages

The donors must give knowing consent. The scientists must have a strong knowledge of their research. Well, there are a good deal, but some of the most prominent are that embryos cannot be bought or sold, donors must grant knowledgeable consent, and each scientist must have a strong education in the field. In addition, all operations must be reviewed and cleared by a separate board, (par. 7). The FDA

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Assisted Reproduction

1764 Words | 8 Pages

After the Roe v. Wade, 410 U.S. 113 (1973), Supreme Court decision regarding abortion, state legislatures felt it was necessary to pass laws that restricted or banned fetus research. This was done to maintain a respect for human dignity. Twenty-five states have fetal research laws and fourteen cover only research done at the time of an abortion or suspected abortion (Andrews, 1984). In vitro (in the body) fertilization does not fall under these laws because the procedure doesn’t involve an abortion since the gametes are removed first, combined in a lab, then place in the uterus of a woman. There is no removal of the fetus/embryo from the body, there is only implantation.

Read More

Stem Cell Research Ethics Essay

629 Words | 3 Pages

But As America the society we live in further progresses, and advancements continue in the field of science. We must be cautious of compromising the moral standards that define the human civilization. There comes a point at which manipulation of life’s natural processes crosses an ethical boundary. And the boundary that is faced in stem cell research is that of life or death. I do appreciate the effort to discover and develop cures for the benefit of suffering individuals through stem cells, but I think we should be utilizing stem cells that are derived from sources other than human embryos, because such research would not cause harm to another human being eliminating one of the biggest concerns I have with it and that many other people in our society has.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Regenerative Medicine

974 Words | 4 Pages

Destroying these embryos in research would not deprive them of a valuable future. It would be unethical, under whatever circumstances to practice wanted embryos for research. Human animal chimera, an experiment was conducted using the genetic material from human convey to an animal. In addition they argue stem cell research paid minor contemplation to the potential of the umbilical cord. The therapy point out that no medication have been yet produced.

Read More

Argumentative Essay: The Ethics Of Human Cloning

1614 Words | 7 Pages

Many questions arise when discussing such controversial issues (Jaenisch et al.). Some of these questions include "the central, apparently unresolvable issue of the moral status of the human embryo, which raises questions about which perspectives should govern appropriate pluralistic policy" (Jaenisch et al.). There are also questions as to how to weigh the "possible scientific breakthroughs" with the "less quantifiable values and perspectives" (Jaenisch et al.). While there are decent arguments on how the copying of a human being could be

Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of In Vitro Fertilization

Related Topics

Open Document