ipl-logo

The Women's Brains By Stephen Jay Gould Summary

952 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Gender differential in schooling

The Women’s Brains essay was first published in Natural History in 1980 by Stephen Jay Gould, a geology and zoology professor at Harvard University. In this essay, Paul Broca, a respectable and influential professor of clinical surgery at the Faculty of Medicine in Paris, concluded from his research on brain sizes that women “could not equal them [men] in intelligence”. Despite the prevalent acceptance of this conclusion in the nineteenth century, Gould refused to concede and argued against Broca’s claim through a scientific filter, where historical information, quantitative numbers and experts’ opinions were used to present an objective and credible counterargument. The clever manipulation and usage of the evidences effectively substantiated …show more content…

By doing so, Gould demonstrated exactly his claim as readers saw how Broca’s belief was being continuously agreed upon or challenged by many individuals, and even experts. The diverse opinions on Broca’s research and conclusion proved that the seemingly “scientific truth” were merely based on his own …show more content…

According to Broca, the average weight of 292 male brains was 1,325 grams and 1,114 grams for 140 female brains. Hence, the average weight difference between male and female brains were 181 grams. The explicit statistics Gould provided may shock his audiences and evoke their curiosity of the reason behind this dramatic difference. Gould then went on to point out the loophole in Broca’s argument that, he “made no attempt to measure the effect of size alone” and claimed that height “cannot account for the entire difference.” Evidently, Broca’s research lacked consideration towards confounding variables that have affected the results and the conclusion he drew from it, and hence his claim of women inferiority was inaccurate. Using convincing quantitative numbers and identifying the defects of Broca’s conclusion, Gould effectively proved that “numbers, by themselves, specify nothing. All depends upon what you do with them.” The science that Broca claimed was merely his own inference from the set of numbers and it did not represent the truth. Gould went on to illustrate the drastic impacts that size and age have on the datas with more quantitative numbers. After correction for height and age, Broca’s measured difference of men and women brain of 181 grams reduced by more than a third to 113 grams. Gould

Show More
Related
456 Words | 2 Pages

He points out that the Bible cannot be taken literally because sometimes it can be interpreted in different ways. The Bible was written for the common people and illiterate to understand, and to prove his point he mentions that the Bible gives God a body like ours while theologies believe God has no such features. He moves to his main point about who has the authority to determine what is true and untrue. He argues that what is scientifically proven will to understand the Bible true meaning.

Read More
560 Words | 3 Pages

In “The Talking Cure” by Margaret Talbot the author argument is very good and is evaluated through the many different ways. One way Talbot’s argument is evaluated is by the amount the of research she has done to support her argument. In the story, it states that “In all, Hart and Risley reported, they analyzed more than 1,300 hours of casual interactions between parents and their language-learning children” which shows the great amount research Talbot did find out how each social class has an effect on their children’s intellectual development because doing more than 1,300 hours of listening and recording the data would weeks and months to do. In addition to the vast amount of research Talbot had done to get her information she also gave many

Read More
532 Words | 3 Pages

Although some inherent distinctions between the sexes exist, Orenstein mentions Eliot’s findings on neuroplasticity to suggest that nurture supersedes nature in determining a child’s behavior. A child is most impressionable during the earliest stages of life, when his or her brain is still developing. That is why learning various concepts such as language, for example, is most easily acquired before the age of puberty. Thus, an individual’s upbringing is fundamental in the development of traits and therefore, gender

Read More
971 Words | 4 Pages

In “The End of the Women’s college?” by Brian Burton, Burton engages the reader by positioning his thesis, “[a]s women continue to advance in society and the detrimental effects of gender discrimination continue to fade, women’s colleges will continue to decline in number and in purpose” (1). Burton’s thesis conveys the reader, believing that the decline in same-sex institutions for women will decrease for a good cause; therefore, it will provide better opportunities and exclude gender discrimination. Burton asserts his beliefs by defending them with past statistics and then correlates them with the present. “In the 1960s and 1970s, a combination of social changes, legislative decisions, and increased demand for higher education among baby

Read More
1326 Words | 6 Pages

Marie Meurdrac was a French scientist who wrote Chemistry Simplified for Women. In the foreword of this book, she stated that she herself thought that it was not a lady’s job to teach. But instead of remaining silent, she broke through the social barriers and decided that the minds of men and women were equal, and published her book (Doc 2). Another woman who derived from societal norms and continued to study science was Marie Thiroux d’Acronville, a French anatomical illustrator who wrote Thoughts on Literature, Morals, and Physics. She wrote in the preface of her book that women should not study medicine and astronomy.

Read More
193 Words | 1 Pages

1. Do you agree with Brooks claim about Boys and Girls reading differently? I do agree that boys and girls read differently, the brain processes things differently. Boys want to read something that will hold their interest and girls will read books that are more desirable to them.

Read More
402 Words | 2 Pages

From the passage taken from, The Great Influenza, by John M. Barry, Barry frequently uses the appeal to logic and the appeal to credibility to characterize the scientific research as courageous and “moving deep into the wilderness”. With the line “Confidence and strength deeper than physical courage.” Barry uses this line to characterize how going into scientific research requires “Strength” and “confidence” to even go into such a topic. With it he give realization to the reader that it take more than your “physical” strength but mental strength and courage to be able to take on the work take comes with scientific research. The author give credit on work much scientists give and are put through just for their work.

Read More
510 Words | 3 Pages

Life has changed so much since the times of witch trials that it is difficult to believe they are real. The writings of Mary Easty and Tituba are hard for me to take seriously because the stories and claims seem so outrageous to me. I found myself wondering how modern court trails, judges, and lawyers would handle these claims. I also wonder why some people volunteered as being guilty of witchcraft or even entertained the idea of being somehow involved in witchcraft. Tituba’s story really made me wonder why she said everything that she did.

Read More
240 Words | 1 Pages

In Sharon Begley’s article “What Have You Changed Your Mind About?”, Begley discusses how various scientists appear to rarely change their views on issues in their field and how some of the exceptions to this were sometimes quite interesting. For example, Begley introduces the work of Harvard psychologist Steven Pinker. Begley represents Pinker’s work in evolutionary psychology, especially his early work, somewhat hesitantly as a sort of misguidied biological reductionism, noting that Pinker’s belief in male predisposition to killing their stepchildren or female predisposition for monogamy and coyness is only just short of saying that ostensibly male and female traits such as the aforementioned predispositions are “hardwired.” This understanding

Read More
896 Words | 4 Pages

In Alice Dreger’s article, “Track’s Absurd New Rule for Women” she explains how women are subjected to hormonal testing to make sure they don’t have high levels of testosterone. Her purpose is to point of how ridiculous and unfair it is for women who run in the track and field industry. Dreger accomplishes her purpose by using comparisons, sarcasm, and anecdotes to show the the irony of what the I.O.C and I.A.A.F are doing. Dreger uses a serious yet sarcastic tone at moments to show her audience that what she is talking about is important and to prove her point. Dreger uses comparisons throughout her essay; between women and men who play track.

Read More
853 Words | 4 Pages

“In the Trump administration, it’s always ‘A Day Without a Woman,’” written by Dana Milbank discusses the Trump administration's treatment towards women. Milbank argues that President Trump and his administration do not respect women and their deserved rights as much as they should. Milbank furthers his claim by providing defunding Planned Parenthood as his evidence. Milbank states that Planned Parenthood — “the nation’s largest provider of health services for women” — was defunded on International Women’s Day, the eighth day of Women’s History Month, and therefore proves that Trump is ignorant of women’s needs nationwide. To further his argument, Milbank mocks President Trump by stating “what better time to make this dream come true than on

Read More
710 Words | 3 Pages

This is important because it makes it more accessible to the general audience and easier to read, by making an easy to see distinction on which he believes is fruitful science. The use of tonal shifts is effective because it allows the focus to stay on logos, yet still emphasizes Gould’s views, adding personality to the scientific

Read More
925 Words | 4 Pages

In the book authored by John M. Barry, The Great Influenza, formulated about scientists who are expected to research factual theories and observations and their research. Throughout the passage, John Barry explained aspects and qualities of scientists. In addition, he also reveals the unfavorable possibilities of cursory research. The author of the novel explicates his belief of the qualities of a scientist and their research habits, stating that an authentic scientist is depicted as accepting to uncertainty and doubt, willing to explore the unknown, and working diligence. John M. Barry utilizes syntax and amplification, definitions, and examples to augment to his characterization of what a genuine scientist should be and to persuade the reader

Read More
836 Words | 4 Pages

Does it matter?,” Carl Sagan beautifully and respectfully asserts the importance of favoring science over pseudoscience, and makes clear his argument as to why not the other way around. Sagan believes in the rhetorical connection between author and audience, which is why he maintains understanding throughout the essay. Sagan’s compassionate tone informs his polite authority, which in turn

Read More
886 Words | 4 Pages

“Women” by Louise Bogan Louise Bogan married her husband, Curt Alexander in 1916, and had a child a year later. In 1920, Curt Alexander died, causing Bogan to become a widow and left her with no reliable income and an adolescent to care for. After moving to New York City, later on, Bogan met other writers, this sparked her writing career. After writing multiple reviews for periodicals, she later wrote the poem “Women” (Louise Bogan). Throughout the course of this poem, Bogan uses metaphors, imagery, and the setting to show that women are seen as incapable of doing what men do.

Read More

More about The Women's Brains By Stephen Jay Gould Summary

Related Topics

Open Document