ipl-logo

To Kill A Mockingbird Book Vs Movie Essay

594 Words3 Pages

The movie version of To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee has many things in common with the book, as well as some significant differences that changed the story and affected its meaning. A major difference was the fact that Aunt Alexandra never appeared in the movie. It had an impact on the story and its meaning because two themes connected with Aunt Alexandra were growing up and traditional gender roles and expectations for a woman. Not including Aunt Alexandra took away these two themes, and that affected the meaning because it was a lot less about growing up and more about the trial, and its results. The theme of growing up directly correlates with Aunt Alexandra because she came to live with the Finch family for some time, and …show more content…

She didn’t approve of how lenient Atticus was on his children, and as one of the few prim and proper ladies in Maycomb, she tried to “fix” the Finch family into being more proper and fitting into their status quo of being one of the more respected families. Aunt Alexandra was really keen on “family breeding” and how everyone in a certain family followed the footsteps of their predecessor and was a certain way. I think it really changed the story that Aunt Alexandra wasn’t part of the movie because the idea of how people from certain families always acted a certain way was like a status quo that someone just made up, and it reminded me of the racism in Maycomb and how it was a big problem. Even in the book, Atticus says African Americans aren’t all bad and want to do harm; it’s a negative stereotype that was just made up and for some reason people just prosecute others because of their differences or because they don’t live as much of an extravagant life as others. By taking this away from the movie, it took a bit away from the unexplained reason for prosecuting African Americans in Maycomb because the ideas were related. Taking Aunt Alexandra away also changed the story because it took away the theme of traditional gender roles and expectations

Show More
Related
474 Words | 2 Pages

During the 1960's, To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee was a best seller almost immediately after it was published. To Kill a Mockingbird was a book about prejudice and segregation. When the book was made into the movie the creators couldn't fit all the details in the movie leading to some similarities and differences. To Kill a Mockingbird was filled with a lot of details and information. Therefore, the movie left out some important factors.

Read More
986 Words | 4 Pages

TKAM Film Vs. Graphic Novel In the graphic novel “To Kill a Mockingbird” by Harper Lee there were some differences than in the “To Kill a Mockingbird” movie. One major difference between the graphic novel and the movie is there is a character named Aunt Alexandra that was not introduced in the movie. This is a huge difference because Aunt Alexandra has a huge influence on Jem and Scout acting as their mother since Jem and Scout

Read More
1128 Words | 5 Pages

Aunt Alexandra on the other hand, is not a good mother figure. First of all she does not get along with Atticus’s side of the Finch’s. This is supported when Aunt Alexandra is very rude and blunt with Scout and Jem, who are still little children. She also likes to tell Atticus that he is parenting wrong, and tries to get Scout to change the way she acts. The second reason I do not think that Aunt Alexandra would be a good mother figure is that she does not let the family be themselves.

Read More
916 Words | 4 Pages

Aunt Alexandra is a conservative woman who is conscious of propriety and class. So she wanted Jem and Scout to live in a certain way especially Scout, She was worried Scout was too much of a tomboy. Aunt Alexandra was also concerned that Atticus was too careless in his parenting. He allowed his kids to do whatever they wanted. She was also concerned that Calpurnia had too much say and authority over the lives of the children with the absence of their mother.

Read More
1031 Words | 5 Pages

To Kill A Mockingbird Comparative Essay To Kill A Mockingbird was published in 1960, immediately grabbing the public by the ear and showing them the dirty and racist underbelly of the deep south. Only two years later, the movie is produced, showing even more people the uncomfortable truth. As you may have heard before by the reviews of so many stories, the book is better than the movie. This claim will not come as a surprise to many, for the book is taken as a godsend to a large chunk of the population, where the movie, despite the outstanding quality for the time, is not so well regarded when stacked up against one of America’s favorite pieces of classic literature.

Read More
1987 Words | 8 Pages

The citizens viewed Aunt Alexandra as a real prim, proper lady as she had the characteristics the ladies were taught to have but could never master had they had no role model who exhibited these traits. Aunt Alexandra became the vision of a “perfect” lady, which goes to show how Maycomb lived when compared to Aunt Alexandra. Without this glimpse of perspective, the film lost an interesting take on how the ladies in Maycomb were expected to be. While Aunt Alexandra gave the reader a feeling of how Maycomb viewed ‘outsiders’, Aunt Alexandra also gave the reader insight as to how ‘outsiders’ viewed Maycomb. This is illustrated when Aunt Alexandra is discussing with Scout the ways of different citizens of Maycomb.

Read More
806 Words | 4 Pages

But think about the setting like this: To Kill a Mockingbird takes place in the fictional place of Maycomb, Alabama during the Great Depression, but what if it took place in Antarctica during the ice age? That would change pretty much the whole novel (but it would make for an interesting story). Therefore, it was vital that the movie depict most scenes as accurate as it could-and oh, it did, but it the film also messed up. For instance, in one scene, Jem and Scout stumble upon Tim Johnson in the book. They play around and then decide to go and alert Calpurnia, who, in return, flips out over the fact that the kids could have gotten hurt.

Read More
1138 Words | 5 Pages

Finch women aren’t interested in the sort of people” (Lee 300), is one of the many remarks that Aunt Alexandra made that shaped her as a very judgmental person. Knowing how important Aunt Alexandra is, it would almost feel abnormal for her not to be in the storyline of To Kill a Mockingbird. In the movie however, it seems as if the director must have thought otherwise. To make the film inferior to the novel, Robert Mulligan created neither character in place of Aunt Alexandra nor one to act like her. Without Aunt Alexandra, there are still strong feelings toward racism in the movie, but not enough compared to the novel.

Read More
519 Words | 3 Pages

The novel portrays the characters in greater depth and tone than the film version. One example is that, Scout's father, Atticus Finch, who is portrayed as a strong, morally upright character in both the novel and the film. However, the novel provides readers with a more in-depth understanding of Atticus' beliefs, values, and struggles. For example, Atticus's speech to the jury during Tom Robinson's trial in the novel is more detailed and powerful than in the film.

Read More
455 Words | 2 Pages

As one would expect, the movie version of To Kill a Mockingbird contains many dissimilarities from the original novel, by Harper Lee. From the very beginning of the novel, two specific characters are each marked with a different, dominant trait, furthermore affecting how the audience should justifiably view their actions. However, in the 1962 film, it is apparent that these traits were significantly altered, or even wholly changed. The presented characters are Jean Louise (Scout) and Calpurnia, as their traits that are unalike from those of the novel considerably affect the utmost view on these distinct characters.

Read More
805 Words | 4 Pages

With the influence of Aunt Alexandra, you can see how Atticus changes from being a person of reason and listening to the kids, to trying to listen to his sister's advice on how to raise them. Aunt Alexandra's main goal in raising the children is that she wants Scout to grow up quickly, and act more ladylike, and stop being a boisterous child. Jem and Scout's classmates and fellow townspeople's opinions affect their innocence, as they are being unfairly criticized. An outside source states, “The town of Maycomb, whose inhabitants have been presented thus far in a largely positive light, suddenly turns against the Finches, as the ugly, racist underbelly of Southern life exposes itself”

Read More
746 Words | 3 Pages

To Kill A Mockingbird by Harper Lee is a classic story about the trial of a black man being accused of raping a white woman. This novel is so important because some of this is still relevant in our society today. Although racism today is not as harsh as it was in 1935, it is still one of the issues in our country. To Kill A Mockingbird shows younger generations how different things were back then. The book is better than the movie because the book digs deeper into detail and explains every little thing that the movie did not explain.

Read More
431 Words | 2 Pages

The Movie “To kill a mockingbird” Directed by Robert Mulligan, based the movie off the novel written by Harper Lee. The film and the book has the same plot but there are some difference within the plot of the book. In the movie it showed a scene about the mad dog. Firstly, in the film, it showed Ms. Maudie only calling Mr. Finch to tell him there’s a mad dog on the streets.

Read More
1201 Words | 5 Pages

With both kids, no longer at home, her aunt Alexandra cares for Atticus in her absence. Her lack of presence in her hometown has proved to

Read More
689 Words | 3 Pages

There are many types of love in the world. Some are portrayed in A Midsummer Night”s Dream. They are used multiple times by William Shakespeare. Almost all of the characters get involved in some type of love. Just to sum up , they are forced love, romantic love, and fake love.

Read More

More about To Kill A Mockingbird Book Vs Movie Essay

Related Topics

Open Document