More handpicked essays just for you.
An essay explaining why lizzie borden is guilty
Why lizzie borden is guilty essay
An essay explaining why lizzie borden is guilty
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: An essay explaining why lizzie borden is guilty
The truth is, Mary Surratt should not have been hanged for her “crimes.” She was innocent because she didn’t do anything
The following evidence is what proves Lizzie is not guilty. First, all cases like this must include evidence to find the killer, but none was found against LIzzie to make her guilty. According to Source #1 , “There was no physical evidence linking her to the murders. A hatchet had been discovered in
“THE LIZZIE BORDEN CASE” On August 4, 1892, Andrew and Abby Borden were murdered in their home in Fall River, Massachusetts. Lizzie Borden convicted of the murder and arrested on August 11, 1892. It seems obvious that Lizzie committed the crime due to the evidence provided, family problems and, the brutal nature of the murder. Lizzie and her family had problems, which means this could have led Lizzie to murder her parents.
Why Lizzie Borden Was Not Convicted It is almost completely sure that Lizzie committed the murders, but yet she was not convicted. Fall River’s nativism, gender stereotypes, and Lizzie’s wealth all contributed to Lizzie going free. In 1892, there were many immigrants coming to Fall River, so when the murders happened the police assumed it was an immigrant. So, right away they arrested an innocent Portuguese man working on the property. This clearly shows that the people of Fall River did not think that Lizzie, a Catholic, white, rich, and a woman could ever commit patricide.
Lizzie Borden is guilty of homicide of Andrew and Abby Borden because Lizzie’s investigations were never done correctly, Lizzie was doing peculiar things days before the murders, and Lizzie and her stepmother had bad blood. Lizzie Bordens investigation was never done correctly. Lizzie's room was never searched for any evidence. According to Bio.com, back then during
The first reason I believe Lizzie is guilty of the murders of Andrew and Abby Borden is because she lied about her stepmom Abby Borden receiving a note from a friend being sick on the day she and her husband were murdered. “The Crime” stated, “Andrew asked Lizzie where Abby was, and Lizzie told him Abby had received a note that someone was ill and that she had left the house.”
Lizzie Borden is guilty of the murder of her parents. For example, “Lizzie had no alibis other than her own statements and unfortunately for her, her statements changed each time she made one…”(45). Police and witnesses believe she was just trying to cover for someone or she was just put under pressure when asked for an alibi and had to come up with a story in the spur of the moment. However, if Lizzie were innocent she wouldn’t have changed her story.
Other family members could be guilty of the crime, not just Lizzie. The first possible suspect that comes to mind is John Morse, Lizzie’s uncle who, after supposedly being made aware of the horrible murders, is said to have “ambled” into the back yard and proceeded to “eat pears in the shade” (King 27). The next possible suspect would have to be Emma, who, being out of town that day was sent a telegram telling her about the murders, but she “did not catch the next train,” or the next, in fact she did not “return” home “until after seven that night” (King 27). Doesn't that seem a little odd, seeing as her father was just killed; unless she had something to do with it and couldn’t get home until then, but we will never know. Another possible suspect is Bridget Sullivan, the maid who happened to be in and around the house at the time of the murders (“The Lizzie Borden Story”).
Even though the wounds were most likely from an ax, any other person could own an ax like used for the injuries. No weapon was found with any blood or evidence to make Lizzie guilty. Lizzie’s personality and emotions play a big part in the case. Lizzie was always a kind-hearted person. She taught Sunday school to little children.
Even though it is unexpected, there is a ton of evidence that goes against Lizzie Borden. First of all, when the incident happened, Lizzie provided an alibi that was unreliable and inconsistent. However, everyone else in her family was
There were lots of loose ends and unsolved questions. I am here to convince you that Lizzie did not do it and, that she is innocent. Firstly, imagine being accused of killing your parents. How would that make you feel?
When Lizzie was growing up, she was not outgoing, and because of this she happened to be very shy with few friends (Criminal). The loneliness in her childhood could have been one factor leading her to become a part of such an evil crime. Leading into her teen and young adult years, she was accused of shoplifting a couple times, although there is no charges against her in those years. Having a suspicious past in criminal activity makes it reasonable to understand that she could have committed another crime later on in her adult life (Criminal). This leads up to the extremely strange and bizarre behavior that was exhibited by Lizzie the week of the murder.
So the confused answers that she gave may not have been because she was guilty, but because she was in shock. Although police at the time were to aware of this so when she was not able to give a convincing story and her stories continued to change, Lizzie became the prime suspect in her parents murder. Due to the fact that she could not keep her story straight and her distressed state led to her arrest. Two days after she was questioned about the murders, Police Chief Hilliard arrested Lizzie. The next day she pleaded “Not Guilty” to her charges and then was transported to a rail car to be taking to the jail in Taunton, which is eight miles from her hometown.
In the early 20th century women were not considered to be murders. This changed in 1982 when Lizzie Borden became publically known for killing her stepmother and father in their home located in Fall River, Massachusetts. Many people believed this murder was the most notorious murder in America due to the abundance of press. Countless people were not so much surprised at the crime committed, but at the person that did the crime. The article Forty Whacks, Forty Whicks stated, “This murder was so significant because of the brutality of the crime and the fact a woman was accused of it, most people do not associate this kind of bloody crime with a woman”(HittJ,1).
For the duration of her trial Lizzie Borden was seen as a bane, a murderer, and would be treated like one for the rest of her life. Sarah Miller recognized the wrong in this and aspired to give Lizzie another chance to clear her name by giving nothing but the facts about the case since, during her trial, evidence was left out or overlooked. In her book “The Borden Murders: Lizzie Borden and the
