ipl-logo

Was Andrew Carnegie A Hero?

1300 Words6 Pages

Was Andrew Carnegie a hero? Many people have asked this hotly debated question. Andrew Carnegie was an incredibly influential businessman. He was one of the richest Americans at the time, using the money to fund his philanthropy. He donated millions of dollars to various organizations, leading people to view him as a hero. Andrew Carnegie was a poor man growing up. He started with a house that cost 20 dollars to rent, and throughout his life, he had to work his way up the social ladder and eventually ended up living in mansions and castles. Carnegie used a business practice he invented called vertical integration, which lowered costs and effectively made better quality products. Carnegie was a well respected boss and provided equal pay for …show more content…

Andrew Carnegie is heroic because he donated 350 million dollars to various charities (Document 12). His work has single-handedly made him a hero because no matter how you think of Carnegie, he still donated half a billion dollars to these charities. He helped America tremendously with donations to public spaces such as donations of church organs and free public libraries where he constructed 2811 of them. Words cannot describe how many people he’s helped with these donations some of which like the public libraries, we can still see today. These libraries provided free education and helped so many people learn. He is a hero for this because he went out of his way to help others; by donating this money, he has helped so many people. (Document 10) This part where the author says that “Not even 10,000 Carnegie Public Libraries” would compensate for the direct and indirect evils resulting from the homestead lockout sticks out to me because Carnegie has already donated a 5th of what they asked. This shows how many people Carnegie helped because of this hyperbole that the author made that we shouldn’t take seriously. Carnegie had already done a 5th of what was asked. To publicly attack Carnegie’s philanthropy is uncalled for and I think it just proves how well he has done in providing his service. Thinking about it, 2000 public libraries probably inadvertently caused more good than harm done at the homestead lockout. Just as he has harmed, he doubled that in his good deeds. Carnegie's philanthropy was good for the economy because it helped students get a great education which helped the schools. These students who ended up becoming successful would also help the economy. Carnegie's philanthropy was a result of his steel company; from working diligently to being the cheapest and most affordable steel carnegie could invest in this work of

Show More
Related
379 Words | 2 Pages

“ The Philanthropy of Andrew Carnegie” was written in the second half of the 19th century. During this time railroads, oil, flour, and tobacco were being introduced. Nothing was more successful as the steel industry that Andrew Carnegie introduced. Andrew Carnegie is known as being a “hero” to many people during this time of period. Carnegie has courage, concern for others, and charisma.

Read More
207 Words | 1 Pages

Andrew Carnegie was one of the industrial leaders who produced most of the steel in the U.S. He could be considered a Captain of Industry due to the steel and the monetary contributions. Carnegie produced steel that helped the expansion of the U.S. Carnegie created the process of adding scrap metals to molten iron to molten iron making the production more efficient, and he also had vertical integration making the production more efficient. With these different methods of making production more efficient, the U.S. could expand and grow more easily with new railroads and buildings. This was a positive contribution to the U. S. Later in life, Carnegie donated 90% of his wealth to charities and projects.

Read More
323 Words | 2 Pages

Andrew Carnegie Andrew Carnegie was a captain of industry because he gained a lot of money, but didn’t save all of it for himself. He gave his money to charities and different causes that benefited others. Carnegie believed in the “Gospel of Wealth”. This was an article that Carnegie wrote about how wealthy people should give their money to others instead of keeping it for themselves. He supported education and reading because he loved to read and he thought it was important for new generations.

Read More
549 Words | 3 Pages

Once he was sixteen Andrew was famous for being able to decode dot-dot dash-dash messages (morse code) and was paid $4.00 a week. In 1872 Andrew met Henry Bessemer, the creator of the steel mill, Andrew decided to adopt Bessemer's idea and bring the steel mill to the United States. This would be Called the J. Edgar Thomson Works (Pre-DBQ). This evidence helps explain why Andrew Carnegie was a hero because he had the courage to work hard to get to where he was at the nearing end of his life.

Read More
677 Words | 3 Pages

Andrew Carnegie, born 1835, was an industrialist and philanthropist who soon became an influential entrepreneur. In 1848, he and his family immigrated to the United States from Scotland with little to no money in their pockets. They settled in Pennsylvania where he later worked as a secretary and telegraph operator at the Pennsylvania Railroad Company. From there, Carnegie slowly moved his way up the social ladder and became superintendent of the Pittsburgh Division of Pennsylvania Railroad. Andrew Carnegie is an entrepreneur because he saw an opportunity to create and run a business, despite the risk and responsibility he would have to assume.

Read More
408 Words | 2 Pages

Was Andrew Carnegie a Hero During the late 19th century, Andrew Carnegie made an investment in the steel industry that profited into a fortune, but Carnegie’s earlier life didn’t include wealth. In fact, his family immigrated from Scotland to America in the mid 1800s in search for opportunities. After working tirelessly for many years, Andrew Carnegie became one of the most successful businessmen and philanthropists of all time. Although he accomplished many achievements in the Industry there are underlying reasons indicating that Carnegie was not a hero, such as, his wealth management, inconsiderate work conditions, and hypocrisy.

Read More
430 Words | 2 Pages

Andrew Carnegie was a hero because he proved that the rags to riches American Dream is possible, he was also a philanthropist and he mastered the skills of a successful business man. Andrew Carnegie was a hero because he proved the American Dream from rags to riches is a real thing . Growing up, Andrew lived in Scotland with his family." Carnegie and his family of four lived in a garret room above his father's embroiderer shop with another family. Annual rent $20" ( Document 1).

Read More
415 Words | 2 Pages

Many philanthropists around the world are viewed as heroes, so why should Andrew Carnegia be viewed any differently? Andrew Carnegie was a poor boy from Scotland, until his parents moved thier family to America. He is the prime example of a rags to riches story for this time period. Eventually, Carnegie became the leader of the steel industry in America. His most heroic attribute had to have been the funds he put into philanthropy, and continues to put into charities.

Read More
467 Words | 2 Pages

In my opinion, Andrew Carnegie should be deemed as a hero. Sure, he did some things that people frowned upon. But, he also accomplished things that made his communities education better and stronger, but he made his community all around better. To do this, he did things such as provide local libraries for people and students, He claimed that it was disgraceful to die a rich man and give money away to your children, also his total giving overall was 350,695,653 dollars. Carnegie should be seen as a hero because of his good deeds, and providing of libraries to better the community’s education.

Read More
427 Words | 2 Pages

Andrew Carnegie was a hero in some people 's eyes , not so much in others . That’s why everyone has their own opinion. In this essay you will read one reason someone might think he’s a hero , and two reasons why he is not a hero for the rest of the people. What that means is that this paper mostly leans on that Andrew Carnegie is not a hero and you will read why . Andrew Carnegie was a very wealthy man.

Read More
814 Words | 4 Pages

Imagine being the richest person in America & giving away money to people in need. Sounds like a nice thing to do, doesn’t it? This was the case for multi-millionaire, Andrew Carnegie. Carnegie grew up in Dunfermline, Scotland and moved along with his family to the United States in the late 1800s. He worked his way from being a poor Irish immigrant to become one of the most popular and successful industrialists that helped change the US steel industry in the late 1900s.

Read More
689 Words | 3 Pages

He’s an ambitious man that lacks the significant achievement and the care for others. Andrew Carnegie was an ambitious man, who focused mostly on success not the people. He was determined to succeed by using his business skills. Carnegie was one of the first to use vertical integration, which is the control of the production process from raw materials to manufacture and sale of finished product. He owned many properties using vertical integration.

Read More
625 Words | 3 Pages

Carnegie came from humble beginnings and worked

Read More
338 Words | 2 Pages

Andrew Carnegie was one of the most famous and wealthiest American industrialist during the Industrial Age. He was a robber baron who made a fortune in the steel industry and applied vertical integration to his business. Carnegie contradicted his views as a robber baron because he supported, but destroyed many unions. This made many of his views unethical.

Read More
454 Words | 2 Pages

Carnegie was not a hero, because a hero does a deed selflessly, but he thought a lot about himself. 184,400,000 dollars was spent on big-name corporations and associations that would honor him by naming a meaningful belonging after him (Doc C). Carnegie was a man who wanted to feed his ego but should have donated money to help the community, not make himself known.     Andrew Carnegie was not a true hero. Many may say, going from rags to riches makes Carnegie a hero.

Read More

More about Was Andrew Carnegie A Hero?

Related Topics

Open Document