Johnny is justified in what he did and is not guilty because he was protecting Ponyboy. He was protecting himself. He was also terrified from the previous attack from these guys.
In a statement released by the police last night that they are charging Johnny Cade with manslaughter. Ponyboy Curtis is to appear in juvenile court next week, for running away. Where it will be determined if him and his brother SodaPop Curtis will be able to remain together with their other brother Darryl(Darry) Curtis, or if Ponyboy
At the beginning of chapter 4 on November 12, 1963 the tragic death of Bob Shelton occurred. Johnny Cade is put responsible for the death, he states him and his friend Ponyboy got into a tussle with the Socs which lead to the unexpected death of Bob. The leading argument is between if Johnny is guilty or innocent for the killing. Johnny’s Defense Attorney Kenidy Shows believes Mr. Cade is innocent and was using self defense.
Johnny Cade was forced to kill Bob Sheldon in order to save Ponyboy Curtis’s life. This incident began when Bob Sheldon and four other Socs came to the greasers’s territory (the East side of town) intoxicated. They were upset that Cade and Curtis were associating with their girlfriends. The Socs insulted Cade and Curtis, and Curtis insulted them back. This led to the Socs drowning Curtis’s head in a water fountain.
Johnny Cade should not be convicted of murder. One reason why Johnny Cade is innocent and should not be charged of murder because he killed bob in self defense. Before Johnny killed Bob the Socs were drowning Ponyboy in a fountain and they were drunk and weren’t in a good state
Why Is Johnny Guilty Johnny Cade was fatally wounded and killed by Bob, the leader of the gang who drowned Ponyboy Curtis in a nearby fountain. One night Ponyboy Curtis and Johnny Cade ran away from home and were jumped by a group of socs. Bob the leader told David to "give him a bath" directed toward Ponyboy. David was aggressively drowning Ponyboy and as a reaction, Johnny stabbed and killed Bob and ran away. Johnny is guilty because he did not kill the aggressor and he had malice and aforethought.
Ponyboy and Johnny used to be not as close as now. Therefore, now, they become the closest friend. They become closer and share the same unforgettable experience, they have same situation and same social class. They also rely each other, console each other. Finally they became best friend.
Johnny, deceased by this point, was convicted for manslaughter, which is less culpable than murder due to the mitigating circumstances. In Johnny’s case, he stabbed Bob with the intentions of severely injuring him to defend Ponyboy. Based on the lack of intent, provocation from the Socs, and Johnny’s goal to defeat Ponyboy, the murder should be excusable homicide. Cherry, a Soc girl, testified on Ponyboy and Johnny’s behalf. Had Johnny been alive to testify, the outcome may have been different.
People believed Johnny was a great young man different from the rest of the gang. However, some people may think Johnny is not a hero. Some people may not think Johnny is a hero because he ran into a burning building without thinking about himself. When Johnny saw the burning church he ran inside without hesitation, in the process he did not think about how he could be hurt or even killed.
The character Bob, a Soc who belongs to the other gang, is both a villain and a hero. Johnny, a teenage boy in a gang, is a hero. He is a shy boy who doesn't talk much. Unfortunately, Johnny is always ignored by his parents. He says this to Ponyoby, “I walk in that house and nobody notices.
Johnny is Guilty of this crime that he has do because It is for these reason why Johnny Cade Is guilty for killing Bob. He bought himself a pocket knife because he had been “they had beat him half to death” (33 Hinton). By the socs. So the next time a Socs would try to harm him
Even though some people may think that Johnny is not guilty of killing Bob, Johnny is guilty of killing Bob because Bob didn’t do anything to harm him at the time. This is why Johnny is guilty of killing
Bob and his friends attacked Ponyboy and Johnny in a violent and unprovoked manner. Johnny acted out of fear for his safety and the safety of his friends when he stabbed Bob. In a situation where he was outnumbered and facing serious harm, Johnny had no
Johnny is innocent for the murder of Bob because he was trying to defend himself and he was trying to save Ponyboy. While some people think that Johnny is guilty for the murder of Bob because he fled the scene and changed his identity. He is innocent because he didn’t mean
This is the biggest reason because it interferes with the reasons to say he’s guilty of committing a crime and committing a Mortal sin. Ponyboy and Johnny hadn’t wronged the Socs. They were simply hanging out with some girls and the Socs got jealous. The Socs came up to them and wanted to pick a fight. On pg.
