ipl-logo

What Are The Four Stages Of The Heinz's Dilemma

725 Words3 Pages

Lawrence Kohlberg, a moral theorist, believed that there are three levels of moral development that consist of two stages each, leaving a total of six stages. According to the notes presented by Professor Squires, the six stages are heteronomous morality; individualism, instrumental purpose, and exchange; mutual interpersonal expectations, relationships, and interpersonal conformity; social contract or utility and individual rights; and universal ethical principles. By interviewing individuals about the Heinz Dilemma and analyzing their answers, a person can determine which moral stage he/she is in. The Heinz Dilemma is a scenario created to test an individual’s morality by the answers they give to the following situation. The Dilemma is, …show more content…

After explaining the situation, Tyler believed that Heinz should steal the drug because he thought the poor man would be sad if his wife had died and it all could have been fixed with the drug. I asked to Tyler to explain why the poor man would want his wife to live. He replied with “well they are married they have to love each other!”. Tyler’s response show that he is in stage 2: individualism, instrumental purpose, and exchange. As we discussed in class, Squires told us that in stage 2, an individual begins to think about both sides to determine what is morally right. Tyler knew that stealing was bad, but it was for a good cause and the poor man did try to pay, but the druggist rejected him. The poor man had good intentions in the beginning, but he was left no choice. Tyler thought that the poor man needed to steal the drug that way he still had someone to love, and this represents the instrumental purpose. There is also exchange is this by the poor man saving her life, he gets her love in return. Ultimately this shows that Tyler is in stage 2, but Tyler is not stuck in this stage for a person progresses through stages as a person solves conflict and gains new life …show more content…

I asked my dad to answer the same scenario. He is 56 years old. His answer to this dilemma was that the poor man should steal the drug because even though it is wrong to steal, life is more valuable than the drug. He explained that if he were in this situation with my mom, he would steal the drug to save her life. My dad fits into stage 5 of Kohlberg’s stages. Within this stage, an individual is an advocate for the values and rights that go beyond the laws created by man. My dad believed that someone’s life is more important than a law. Therefore, he thought that the poor man should steal the drug to save his

Show More
Related
1052 Words | 5 Pages

The Good Life Project, Part 3 Racquel Davis PHIL 103 Centralia College The Trolley Problem stands as a seminal ethical puzzle, inviting individuals to confront the complexities of moral decision-making and grapple with profound questions of ethics. Rooted in hypothetical scenarios involving life and death decisions, the Trolley Problem compels individuals to confront the fundamental moral dilemma of whether it is justifiable to sacrifice one life to save many others. This essay aims to embark on a comprehensive exploration of the Trolley Problem, analyzing its implications through various ethical lenses, including utilitarianism, moral intuition, theories of moral psychology, and Kantian deontology.

Read More
641 Words | 3 Pages

He then lists the five foundations of morality: harm/care, fairness/ reciprocity, in-group/loyalty, authority/respect, purity/sanctity. To explain how much these five foundations of morality change as individuals grow, Haidt shows the results of a questionnaire taken by nearly thirty-thousand people that he and his colleagues posted on www.yourmorals.org. After viewing the results, Haidt explains that, in most societies, individuals do not disagree on harm/care and fairness/reciprocity, even though they may disagree on what is harmful and fair, they disagree on in-group/loyalty, authority/respect, purity/sanctity. He goes on to explain that “cooperation decays without punishment.” He describes an experiment by Fehr and Gatcher published in the magazine Nature in which individuals played a game in which they could put money in a pot and that money would be divided among all the players.

Read More
865 Words | 4 Pages

It is of the utmost necessity to analyze all pieces of evidence in order to reach a valid conclusion on one’s nature. If just one component is removed, then the entire decision is altered. 2.2 presents the audience with the final piece of insight on the true intentions of the characters that is needed to fully define their

Read More
606 Words | 3 Pages

In this level is stage four, which is an authority and social-order-maintaining orientation. At this stage people do things based on rules that have already been set up or come from a place of high importance, for example, the government. Kohlberg said this was “...based on fixed rules, maintaining order and obeying authority” (2). He also said that there is “...a respect for rules [and] laws” (2). A person reflecting this stage will not make up rules to replace ones that already were there, or disobey rules that were already made to be followed.

Read More
527 Words | 3 Pages

To begin with, Kohlberg’s Theory of Moral Development is a way of “how individuals would justify their actions if placed in moral dilemmas” (Wikipedia contributors. “Lawrence Kohlberg's Stages of Moral Development”). It has three stages and two categories in each of those. There is Pre-conventional which has the two categories of Obedience/Punishment and Self-interest.

Read More
730 Words | 3 Pages

‘Steven, my gardener mixed cocaine with my everyday diet for about a month. I feared that I would die of slow-poisoning very soon. Once I overheard his conversation with Adam, the one who supplied cocaine to him. That very night, I got a mild heart attack. I didn’t inform anyone because; I didn’t wish to put their lives into risk.

Read More
906 Words | 4 Pages

When the Army Materiel Command (AMC) employed me, I served in a variety of roles one of which was the senior technical advisor for architecture and technology (ostensibly the CTO for the CIO). AMC, a 53 Billion dollar year logistics command that serves as the army version of amazon for the army’s current inventory of weapons, supplies and vehicles. I extensive experience in implementing IT and telecommunications technology including hardware, software, and systems design as well as a thorough and up-to-date knowledge of the IT industry and emerging technologies. This experience was gained through the direct the planning, developing and implementing of systems and allowed me as to gauge the capabilities and reasonableness of proposed solutions

Read More
528 Words | 3 Pages

This is the first stage, where people are usually willing to analyze what causes disagreement, and listen the other party. Step two begins with listing alternatives and coming up with possible solutions. Although we did not see Gerry arranging his options directly, we can conclude that he was considering whether to talk to his friend first, or go to one of the Coaches. The next two processes involve evaluating alternatives and choosing the best option.

Read More
410 Words | 2 Pages

Robert J. Sternberg is a professor of Psychology and vice president at Oklahoma State University. Sternberg states, “To act ethical, individuals must go through a series of steps”. He presupposes teaching these 8 steps is just as important as teaching students how to pass a test. Numerous of dilemmas proceeding in establishments are not generated the by absences of knowledge, but because of the lack of ethics. People may apprehend the rules of being ethical but are unable translate into their everyday lives.

Read More
196 Words | 1 Pages

In every day life, we face many situations that require a moral decision. We have to decide what is right and what is wrong? Not always is this an easy task thus, it seems important to analyze how we make our moral decisions. I will start with an analysis of how we make decisions in general

Read More
1565 Words | 7 Pages

The first level of Kohlberg’s model is “preconventional morality” which involves “personal interests in terms of what is good for the individual” (Green, 345). In other words, this first

Read More
1048 Words | 5 Pages

People face many dilemmas in their life from, “oh I’m not going to get to on time if I take a shower.” Five minutes later on your way to work, “oh wait its Saturday,” to “what flavor of ice cream do I want.” Many of this can happen in both fiction or nonfiction and usually end in irony. Dilemmas come in different sizes, forms, and different times in life.

Read More
1276 Words | 6 Pages

The bombing of Japan in World War 2 has had a major impact on economical, social and political impact on Japan. During the second World War in 1945, the United States dropped 2 atomic bombs on the cities, Nagasaki and Hiroshima. These were the first 2 atomic bombs used in warfare as well as the only ones used up until now(The Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica). The bombings had devastating consequences, resulting in a large number of deaths, injuries, and destruction, there were also long-term health and environmental impacts on the people living in the cities. The bombs also had military influence on Japan as well as political changes in the country.

Read More
1634 Words | 7 Pages

People are under in a level of dilemma because sometimes they can do things that are

Read More
916 Words | 4 Pages

In the third stage, the relationship moves from being in a formal to a more of a personal relationship. At this point in time, the couple begins to disclose personal information about themselves. They reveal more aspects of their lives. The fourth stage is called the integration stage. At this point, the couple has put a label on their relationship, and have defined the place they find themselves in.

Read More

More about What Are The Four Stages Of The Heinz's Dilemma

Related Topics

Open Document