ipl-logo

Who Is Sherlock Holmes Really Responsible For Dr. Roylott's Death?

537 Words3 Pages

Sherlock Holmes had not been culpable for Dr.Roylotts death. The story “The Adventure of a Speckled Band”, written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, portrayed a mystery story. Throughout the story, Sherlock Holmes had to defend himself from the swam adder. In addition, Holmes was not able to predict that Dr. Grimsby Roylott could be bitten by the snake. Lastly, Sherlock Holmes was certain that Dr. Roylott killed Julia Stoner and wanted to murder Helen Stoner due to money. In summation, Sherlock Holmes was not responsible for Roylott’s death. Sherlock Holmes confronted the venomous swamp adder from India, with a vigorous incident that had occurred. Sherlock Holmes decided to spend the night in Helen’ s room with Dr.Watson to observe the mysterious whistling noise Helen and Julia claimed to hear at nightfall. Later that evening, there came a ephemeral gleam from the ventilator, which connected Dr. Roylott as well as Julia and Helen’s room; moreover, a precipitous reticent whistle noise. This allowed Holmes to immediately light the match. The passage states, “It is a swamp adder!. . . The deadliest snake in India.” This statement supports Sherlocks fear of this deadly animal. The doubters may believe Sherlock meant to kill Dr. Roylott due to …show more content…

Roylotts’s death by a toxin serpent. The story mentions, within Dr.Roylott’s room was a safe, worn chair, leash, and a milk bowl. The milk bowl was the snake’s reward; therefore, the snake was trained to return to the specific location. According the the passage, the ventilator was the only point at which the two rooms had connected. As a result, he could not situate the exact placement of the snake. To support, there was no imaginable way to gather information on Roylott’s location. It might appear that Holmes purposefully guided the snake to that room. Nevertheless, Holmes could not adumbrate Dr.Roylott was about to perish. Ergo Sherlock Holmes was not the culprit to this

Show More
Related
1812 Words | 8 Pages

At the same time H.H. Holmes was running rampant and carrying out his killing spree, London also had a

Read More
813 Words | 4 Pages

Watson and Holmes ways of investigating were very different. Watson went inside and observed many things in the house while Holmes was outside and investigating outdoors. When they went into the room with the dead body of Enoch Drebber, Holmes turned it around and a women's ring fell off and rolled on the floor. They also saw the word Rache on the wall written in blood. The detective at the scene thought it was the name Rachel just that the murderer did not have time to finish writing it.

Read More
473 Words | 2 Pages

Mr. Bennett told authorities that he touched the puddle of spilled coffee when he knelt by Mr. Adams to check for a pulse. If Mr. Bennett did kill Mr. Adams, he would not have checked the pulse of the dead man because he already would have known that he was dead. Finally, Mr Bennett is not guilty because a box of rat poison was found in the lounge kitchen cupboard right next to the box after the murder. A coffee cup was on the floor near Mr. Adams. The cup contains rat poison residue.

Read More
161 Words | 1 Pages

In the story “The Adventure of the Speckled Band”, Sherlock Holmes is not responsible for the death of Dr. Grimbsy Roylott. One reason why Holmes is not responsible is because the snake is uncontrollable. Roylott was stupid to believe that the wild snake could be trained so easily. Furthermore, Holmes attacked the snake in self defense.

Read More
536 Words | 3 Pages

The author does not say this outright, but it is implied through implicit and explicit evidence. The author reveals information in a way that makes the reader slowly begin to fear and suspect Holmes, which builds suspense. Explicitly, the author states facts about Holmes’s personality. For example, as a child, Holmes is described as “small, odd, and exceptionally bright.” At this point early in the book, we are not yet led to suspect the true nature of Holmes, but we know that there is something wrong with him.

Read More
923 Words | 4 Pages

After Holmes finds Watson, they hear “a prolonged yell of horror and anguish,” which “burst out of the silence of the moor,” so Holmes “sprung to his feet…. He had started running swiftly over the moor,” (185–186). Holmes knew there was a murderer, but still courageously ran towards the screams to possibly save the victim and catch the killer.

Read More
660 Words | 3 Pages

In both of Mary E. Fissell’s works, The Marketplace of Print and When the Birds and the Bees Were Not Enough, she discusses the circulation of medical books and their influence on the printing press, economics, and society’s view on household medical practices. While the former discusses medical books as a whole with divisions between authors and types of books, the latter focuses on a specific medical book - a sex manual - titled Aristotle’s Masterpiece. Fissell’s chapter in The Marketplace of Print heavily emphasizes the statistical evidence surrounding the circulation of vernacular medical books during the mid 1600s and 1700s, supported by textual sources from that time period explaining the influence of these books on English society as

Read More
1187 Words | 5 Pages

Sherlock Holmes Argumentative Essay While Sherlock Holmes habitually portrayed a considerate, helpful man, it was certain he felt not a twinge of guilt concerning the death of Dr. Grimesby Roylott. Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s story entitled “The Adventure of the Speckled Band” features the famous detective with a shocking turn of events during the resolution, when it was revealed Sherlock Holmes was responsible for a poisonous snake bringing the end of Dr. Roylott’s hostile life. This event did not catalyze shame inside of him, though, as each man felt harsh despising towards one another. Furthermore, Sherlock Holmes could not have known the snake would kill Dr. Roylott. Lastly, it was the irrational decision of Dr. Roylott that caused his death, arguably more than Sherlock Holmes’ cane did.

Read More
666 Words | 3 Pages

Roylott was bitten by the swamp adder causing his death, Sherlock Holmes cannot be held responsible. Sherlock Holmes was forced to protect himself and Helen Stoner, causing him to agitate the snake in the process, sending it back to Dr. Roylott’s room. Secondly, Dr. Roylott has threatened Sherlock Holmes in his home, causing no guilt from Holmes at his death. Finally, Dr. Roylott was intentionally killing Helen and Julia, in order to keep his monthly income of $750. When Sherlock Holmes agitated the snake causing it to bite Dr. Roylott, Sherlock indirectly caused his death; but, Sherlock Holmes cannot be held responsible due to Dr. Roylott being the killer of Julia, and the attempted killer of

Read More
1202 Words | 5 Pages

Investigation on the Double Murder of Holmes and Dr. Watson The queen of mystery novels, Agatha Christie, once said, “Crime is terribly revealing. Try and vary your methods as you will, your tastes, your habits, your attitude of mind, and your soul is revealed by your actions”. No matter how perfect the crime is, as long as it is man-conducted, there is always a solution. On Saturday May 21, 1892, Holmes and Watson were found dead near Glasgow's shipyards.

Read More
373 Words | 2 Pages

water was still at the back of my tongue and it was the longest five rolls ever to get off my King-sized bed. I stumbled to the bathroom and turned on the hot water; I asked myself, “Why didn’t I just go into the family’s restaurant business? I’d surely have a 9 to 5 job that doesn’t stress me.”

Read More
732 Words | 3 Pages

Holmes and Watson’s antagonist in the novel is the logic aspect of the case. For example, Holmes says “Of course, if...we are dealing with forces outside the ordinary laws of Nature, there is an end to our investigation. But we are bound to exhaust all other hypotheses before falling back to this one.” Also, in the novel, the logical solution and evidence is explained in further detail, for Holmes gives “a sketch of the course of events from memory” in the resolution. There are many subplots in the novel, such as Seldon’s escape, Sir Henry and Mrs. Stapleton, and Sir Charles Baskerville and Laura Lyons, which answered many questions about the case and evidence against Stapleton.

Read More
1227 Words | 5 Pages

In life, we must understand that the truth with always come out despite the time of the matter. In “The Adventure of the Speckled Band” by Arthur Conan Doyle, Sherlock Holmes and Dr. Watson look into the murder of Julia Stoner, whose stepfather is Dr. Grimesby Roylott of Stoke Moran. The Roylott’s were once of very wealthy family, but after gambling with money, all things were lost. Grimesby killed his butler but married Mrs. Stoner, who had two daughters of the name Helen and Julia. Mrs. Stoner soon died, leaving Dr. Roylott in custody of the two girls.

Read More
834 Words | 4 Pages

This case, which Sherlock remarks, ‘looked at the first glance so simple yet [presents] such difficulties’, reveals the very nature of the Sherlock Holmes crime: a diversion of the expected, or, more simply, a mystery. It is no coincidence that St. Clair’s secrets are both aided and revealed by his presence in London. In Kent he is one man and in London another, for London by its multifaceted and complex nature allows for the disappearance, recreation, and re-emergence of man. Had St. Clair’s wife not entered the city, he would not have been discovered in the act of recreation, and Mrs St.

Read More
859 Words | 4 Pages

Discuss the way Conan Doyle presents the characters of Sherlock and Watson in the passage. The short story, ‘The Red-Headed League’ by Conan Doyle follows the adventures of detective, Sherlock Holmes in the perspective of his partner Jon Watson, who documents the cases Sherlock takes on, as they solve the mysterious disappearance of a group of red-headed men calling themselves The Red-Headed League. In the passage Sherlock is presented as quite a peculiar and emotionally abnormal character, while the character of Watson is presented as a very loyal friend. Sherlock is portrayed as a character with some very unique tendencies and a very complicated personality.

Read More

More about Who Is Sherlock Holmes Really Responsible For Dr. Roylott's Death?

Related Topics

Open Document