ipl-logo

Arguments Against Affirmative Action

1313 Words6 Pages

Jared Gatchalian
Phil 186
Section 18A
Final Paper
Taking into consideration the arguments for and against affirmative action presented in ‘A Defense of Programs of Preferential’ and ‘Affirmative action on campus does more harm than good’, do you think that affirmative action programs are morally justifiable and socially beneficial? Explain and support your position In institutions, workplaces, businesses, colleges and universities, affirmative action programs are policies that provide equal opportunity to education or work for groups that have been historically excluded or underrepresented, such as members of minority group: women and nonwhite citizens. I agree that in the past, affirmative action has been beneficial to the country because …show more content…

There are a lot of African-Americans, Hispanics, and women that are successful in business, science, and agriculture. Now, affirmative action is neither morally justifiable nor socially beneficial. Affirmative action divides the workplace, institutions, and universities into groups because race and sex are taken into consideration. In any institutions or universities, there should not be any minorities. Gender and race should not matter. Being called a minority, alone, is intellectually demeaning even though that so called minority is equally or more qualified than a member of a majority group. As stated by Richard Wasserstrom in ‘A Defense of Programs of Preferential’, “Opponents of preferential treatment programs sometimes assert that proponents of these programs are guilty of intellectual inconsistency, if not racism or …show more content…

It is unreasonable and does not validate present discrimination against white Americans from the past discrimination of minority groups. John Rawls explained that justice is a virtue of social institutions, measured by fairness in allocating benefits and burdens. Hence, giving equal opportunity to all the citizens and not giving any edge to the minorities. Another bad effect of affirmative action is that meritocracy is not the number 1 requirement in admissions and hiring procedures. Instead, race is one of the main factors. It should be based on skills, grades, test scores and moral values. The quota system is also one of the policies of affirmative action. This implies that a certain number of women and minorities are chosen regardless of qualifications. A lot of white Americans lose their jobs and college admittance to less qualified minorities. This is bad for universities and society because universities produce less knowledgeable degree holders and employers gain incompetent and incapable employees, thus resulting in lesser productivity in businesses. It is also not good for the students or workers because it lowers their self-esteem. Affirmative action emphasizes racism because of this. If people are being hired because of affirmative action, knowing that they are not capable of performing the requirements for the job, it implies that all people of that race are stupid and that they

Show More
Related
1786 Words | 8 Pages

Critics of affirmative action frequent describe the policy as being unfair, asserting that it contravenes a conserved system of meritocracy in the country by basing selection decisions on demographic characteristics at the expense of ability and achievement (Thernstrom & Thernstrom, 1997). Defenders take a different position that can be explained by two facts: racism and sexism are still present in the United States society and affirmative action is the most efficient and effective way of reducing discrimination than the present alternatives. However, affirmative action increases fusion and fairness in employment and in education because it works as a proactive observing system. As Crosby and Smith (2005) consider, “such policies may help ensure that patterns of bias—including selective system bias— are uncovered and

Read More
758 Words | 4 Pages

Is race based affirmative action policy morally wrong? I will start by explaining why applicants to the University of Michigan who identify themselves as white deem race-based affirmative action wrong. These applicants believe that race being regarded as a qualification for admission is morally wrong that’s because they consider standardized test scores and high school and college GPA is what determine the qualifications of an applicant. Hence, they are not going to be treated the same as other races.

Read More
181 Words | 1 Pages

I want to know if you paraphrase the red Area I highlighted, and make it into first person. First person as if I am doing the task. Use personal pronouns i.e I am doing it. just use your imagination make it sound in context with the rest of the Article. Please also Paraphrase the purple area I highlighted and remove quotation.

Read More
508 Words | 3 Pages

Affirmative action in the United States I believe that affirmative action negatively affects on both minorities and majorities. From a minority’s perspective, the idea that minorities can receive benefits from others due to their race, ethnicity, or gender can cause them to feel segregated against anyway. Since the term, ‘minority,’ no longer applies to every females or person of color today, female students or students of color with affluent backgrounds may feel segregated and devalued even when they did not get any special benefit from affirmative action policies. Majorities, in this case, male or white students, will also get discouraged because this can be regarded as a form of reverse discrimination, especially with racial affirmative action programs.

Read More
845 Words | 4 Pages

“Affirmative Action may not be a perfect system, but there should be no doubt that it has endangered many successes. It has opened the doors of America’s most elite educational institutions to minority students, granting them unprecedented opportunities” (Ogletree 12). Thanks to Presidents John F. Kennedy and Lyndon B. Johnson a policy that prohibits employment and education discrimination based on race, color, religion, national origin, and sex is offered today to those who suffer from said discriminations (A Brief History). Affirmative action has opened abundant openings for minorities, allowing the cycle of going to college to be passed down generations and provided job opportunities that otherwise would not be considered by most. Affirmative

Read More
1480 Words | 6 Pages

Since the very group of words “affirmative action” is in total contradiction with the amendment fourteen which guarantees people equal protection under the law. But coming to affirmative action, we have to remark the sad history behind it, which is once again to disadvantage a group for another one. Therefore we can clearly say that affirmative action is not only illegal but it is also unconstitutional since it violates clearly the fourteenth amendment. Not only that, we need also to notice that affirmative action goes against this American ideal which is equal opportunity, the ability for someone to use whatever wealth and/or talent he/she has to reach his/her fullest potential. Due to affirmative action, we will notice down in the paper how affirmative action prevents people to use their fullest

Read More
1087 Words | 5 Pages

As far as the need for diversity is concerned, I agree with Thomas. However, I would also argue that one of the main flaws of affirmative action is that it strives to bring out an immediate change in appearance, while ignoring the factors that lead to and result from

Read More
1176 Words | 5 Pages

An outrage among society today; high school students are not being admitted to their dream colleges based on ethnic background. Adolescents should not be burdened by the thought that they won’t get into the college they deserve to attend just based on their skin color. Affirmative Action is the cause of this appalling injustice in the college admissions process among big universities. There have been several cases where people have fought for their right to be admitted solely based on their qualifications. Universities’ use of Affirmative Action, and racial quotas in their admissions process should be exposed and terminated.

Read More
1169 Words | 5 Pages

Those who are against Affirmative Action do not argue against the values for which its proponents stand; in actuality, members of all sides of the academic spectrum hold the same values to be true. The argument at hand is not with the values, but with the methods and potential negative results of Affirmative Action. It had been suggested that colleges which institute Affirmative Action implement their admissions systems so that minority students are more likely to be accepted that non-minority students. In his model, Professor Qiang Fu demonstrates that college systems are designed to “favor the minority [student] and allow the admissions not to be awarded to the [non-minority] [student]” (Fu 424). Potentially, this can be viewed as a form

Read More
916 Words | 4 Pages

Affirmative Action by definition is “the practice of improving the educational and job opportunities of members of groups that have not been treated fairly in the past because of their race, sex, etc”. (Merriam Webster). Affirmative action was thought of as a remedy towards African Americans who have been discriminated against over generations. While Affirmative Action’s intentions are good, giving the minority a chance and helping them obtain a better life, it does not solve the problem with discrimination or promote equality in the workplace and education. Affirmative Action has only led to reverse discrimination, promotes biasing in colleges and workplaces, and contradicts Martin Luther King, Jr.’s dream of equality between races.

Read More
1082 Words | 5 Pages

When reading all three articles pertaining to Affirmative Action, one can gain a great insight on Affirmative Action, what it means, how its affecting people, and how people view what Affirmative Action stands for. Many generalizations can be made about Affirmative Action and what it means or stands for. Some might say it is unfair that we have Affirmative Action policies and that it only hurts those that actually need it. My personal generalization is that Affirmative Action is creating equality amongst people, which is very important if we as a nation want to succeed. I can also infer that AA creates diversity in the work place and in educational areas because it allows a variety of people to succeed and work or learn together.

Read More
1098 Words | 5 Pages

Ironically, in the present day, the debate over affirmative action is still contested under the idea of fairness. The following essay will identify and analyze the history of American public opinion in regards to affirmative action and the issue of fairness. Obtaining accurate polling information on American views on affirmative action is very complex, in part because the policy means different things to different Americans. Further, the wording and the context in which poll questions are framed have a very clear effect on the responses received. In August, a poll by the Pew Research Center, asking whether affirmative action programs intended to increase the number of black and minority students on college campuses were viewed positively, showed that Americans consider affirmative action programs in general to be good, with 71% agreeing that the programs were a “good thing”.

Read More
1011 Words | 5 Pages

Affirmative action has become obsolete in today’s society. Affirmative action is an active effort to improve the employment or educational opportunities of members of minority groups and women; also: a similar effort to promote the rights or progress of other disadvantaged persons (Merriam-Webster, 2011). Today’s affirmative action will demoralize the very concepts that the policy was implemented to uphold: those of equality for all people regardless of color and discrimination. This policy supports racial multiplicity at the price of distinction, impartiality and experience; it also follows the line of reverse discrimination and sexual bias against white men (Reyna, Tucker, Korfmacher, & Henry, 2005).

Read More
2195 Words | 9 Pages

Affirmative action is one of the most controversial issues between scholars, academics, professionals, and in the forum of public opinion in general. It has been extended to all public services, education, as well as military and private workplace issues. Extreme diverse opinions have been raised throughout many years since the affirmative action took a place. I believe that the core issue might be that there is a general lack of familiarity among the general public what term affirmative action does actually mean. Affirmative action or positive discrimination is a program providing advantages for people of a minority group or who are seem to have been traditionally historically discriminated against.

Read More
1734 Words | 7 Pages

Throughout many of the affirmative action legal cases, one of the main arguments from proponents is that it is necessary in order to right the wrongs of past racial discrimination. Some say that affirmative action is justified because even though white applicants may be more qualified, this is only because they did not face the same hardships as their minority counterparts (Rachels, Ethics, 1973).  Many argue if we do not integrate disadvantaged minorities into mainstream social institutions, they will continue to suffer the discrimination that has plagued our country for centuries and that this is detrimental to not only the minorities but also society as a whole (Anderson, 2002, 1270–71). However, the debate has recently shifted to the benefits of diversity in the classroom which the Supreme Court has affirmed as being a positive thing

Read More

More about Arguments Against Affirmative Action

Related Topics

Open Document