ipl-logo

Arguments Against Animal Testing

942 Words4 Pages

The debate of whether or not animals should be used to test humans’ scientific advances has for centuries. Opponents of animal testing argue that animals have a capacity to suffer so it is therefore unethical to use them as tools while proponents argue that testing animals is necessary for the advancement of saving human lives, and although it seems a middle ground has been reached for now, extremists on either end of the argument are still pushing their ideology.
Proponents to testing animals argue that it is necessary to continue advancing the sciences and saving human lives, and proponents often attack the argument of opponents of animal testing. It should be noted that this side of the argument does not promote animal cruelty. Proponents …show more content…

It should be noted that only a small fraction of opponents to animal testing want to outright ban using animals as test subjects. The majority of opponents advocate for harsher regulations to prevent malpractices on animals and to reduce the amount of animals for testing while searching for alternatives so that, in the future, animals will not have to be used as tools. Most opponents cite the Three R’s of animal testing. The first R is Replacement Alternatives which refers to methods which replace the use of animals in an area where animals would otherwise have been used. The second R is Reduction Alternatives which means that attempts should be made to use fewer animals to gain sufficient data to answer the question presented. The third R is Refinement Alternatives which refers to the husbandry and care of an animal to reduce its pain in the time it is used in the laboratory (http://3rs.ccac.ca/). Opponents argue that although there are regulations on using animals as test subjects, they are either not regulated enough or are not respectful to the rights of the animals being tested. For example, the Animal Welfare Act, the largest animal testing regulation in America, does not regulate testing on birds, mice and rats (Hope Ferdowsian). Therefore only 767622 animals fell under the Animal Welfare Act, and

Show More
Related

Animal Testing Is Bad Science By Noah Berlatsky

1092 Words | 5 Pages

However when successful, animal testing can have many benefits for humans and animals. This author does not address the other side of the argument and has some biased statements which can lead to polarization in the United

Read More

Argument Essay: 11 Facts About Animal Testing

887 Words | 4 Pages

According to one of the largest organizations for social change with 4.3 million members: Do Something, the article “11 Facts About Animal Testing” states, “92% of experimental drugs that are safe and effective in animals fail in human clinical trials because they are too dangerous or don’t work.” Even after scientists force innocent animals into excruciating pain, the results are proven to be meaningless. This delineates how impractical animal testing is. By the same token, according to Pro-Con, a nonprofit public charity that provides research on more than 50 controversial topics, “Paul Furlong, Professor of Clinical Neuroimaging at Aston University (UK), states that ‘it's very hard to create an animal model that even equates closely to what we're trying to achieve in the human.’” This demonstrates how distinct animals and humans are and proves we should not use animals as a representation people.

Read More

What Are The Pros And Cons Of Ebsco Animal Testing

666 Words | 3 Pages

Animal testing has been a controversial topic over the years. Animal testing (also known as animal experimentation) is experiments used with animals for research purposes. Some people think animal testing help benefit scientists and advances medical/scientific research. Others believe that the pain and suffering that animals go through during these experiments isn’t worth it. The EBSCO article “Animal Testing” the World Book article “Animal Experimentation and the EBSCO article “It’s time to go cruelty-free because they’re worth it” show different perspectives of animal testing.

Read More

Arguments Against Animal Testing

621 Words | 3 Pages

Since the emergence of bio medicine, animal testing has been a focal point of controversy. Those opposed to the use of animals in scientific studies believe that it is important for humans to treat all living things with the same respect. Animal rights activists make the argument that we should not do anything to a piglet for example, that we would not want done to our own infants. In spite of these points, animal testing is a crucial part of advancing biology, medicine and the overall welfare of human life. It is justified for scientists to have a more invasive form of research ethics towards animals as opposed to humans as the benefits far outweigh the consequences.

Read More

Persuasive Essay Against Animal Testing

649 Words | 3 Pages

There are over 26 million animals being used for scientific and commercial testing each year in the United States. Animals are being used for developing medical treatments, checking the safety of a product, and seeing the toxicity of medication before human use. Animal testing has contributed to many life saving medications, however animal testing is inhumane and cruel. Animals used in testing are put in experiments where there is force feeding, food and water deprivation, the infliction of wounds, physical restraint, decapitation, and many other inhumane acts. Alternative testing methods now exist that can replace the use of animals being used for scientific and commercial testing.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Animal Testing

1787 Words | 8 Pages

The Cruelty to Animals Act was passed in 1849 in Great Britain, and the Animal Welfare Act (AWA) was passed in 1966 in the United States (Evans 4). The Cruelty to Animals Act restricted the use of animals for research purposes while the AWA called for all research facilities funded by the government and using mammals to have a trained veterinarian, minimize animal pain wherever possible, and be inspected by an Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee―IACUC (Evans 8). IACUC’s judge whether or not animal use is necessary and can reject, accept, or modify protocols. Although IACUC’s are said to be impartial, some disagree. According to Scott Plous and Harold Herzog, ninety-eight percent of the proposals were approved by IACUCs of the institution (Lee 3).

Read More

Persuasive Essay: The Ethics Of Animal Testing

1942 Words | 8 Pages

Animal testing is a very controversial topic. People use animals in our everyday lives and don’t think of how it affects the animals. The makeup people wear, the food people eat, and the chemicals that are used to clean people’s houses. It all started in the 1950’s with the development of Laboratory Animal Science. They used Russell and Burch's three R's which are replacement, reduction and refinement.

Read More

Arguments Against Animal Testing

1494 Words | 6 Pages

The “Three R’s”, introduced in The Principles of Humane Experimental Technique by zoologist William Russell, are focused on using animals in research humanely, and stand for Replacement (using alternate methods if possible), Reduction (minimizing the amount of testing), and Refinement (reducing suffering and improving animals' living conditions). They are the basis of many animal welfare laws, and have even been incorporated in the AWA. (Source$) Here lies the second problem: these principles are not entirely international, which means that one could look for a place where they do not apply, and freely do any experimentation whatsoever. The same flaw applies to The Guide, which claims that “the avoidance or minimization of discomfort, distress, and pain when consistent with sound scientific practices, is imperative.” (Spurce4)

Read More

Persuasive Speech On Animal Testing

1152 Words | 5 Pages

Animal testing simply means the use of non-human animals in experiments, which indeed arouse great controversy in recent years. More and more people think that human being’s benefits can’t outweigh animals’

Read More

Persuasive Essay Against Animal Testing

852 Words | 4 Pages

However I wish to argue that animal testing should be acquiesced in society as it is the only way forward. Furthermore, I would like to stress the fact that I’m a firm supporter of animal testing but never an advocate of animal cruelty as there is a fine line between them. Moreover, I would like to open your minds to the unassailable fact that animal testing is not a want but a need,

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Animal Testing

398 Words | 2 Pages

Researchers estimated over 26 million animals were used for scientific tests and commercial testing subject every year in the United States. Over the years animals were used to be tested on medical treatments, products for human uses, health care, and etc. The practice of researching on living animals has started since 500 BC. Opponents of this act say that it is cruel to experiment on animals, there are other methods available to replace the cruel act of experimenting on living animals, and that the human bodies and animal’s bodies are totally two different features and the research often yields irrelevant results. The federal Animal Welfare or AWA passed the animal testing act in 1966 and amended in 1970, 1976, and 1985.

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Animal Testing

2097 Words | 9 Pages

The rights of animals and their use in biomedical research have been controversial topics with huge societal implications over an extensive period of time (Gannon, 2007). Many animal rights activists claim that all research involving animals should be abolished (Gannon, 2007). On the other hand, countless scientists insist that some experiments require the use of animals and any eliminating or regulating animal testing would impede on their research (Gannon, 2007). Furthermore, It has been estimated nearly 100-150 million vertebrate animals, including mice, rats, birds, fish, rabbits, guinea pigs, farm animals, dogs, cats, and nonhuman primates, are used in animal testing annually worldwide (“Soundearth.com,” 2010). These animals are used in an effort to test for the safety and efficacy of products for humans.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Animal Testing

1067 Words | 5 Pages

Imagine an enraged animal rights activist charging toward a scientist in a white lab coat, desperate to free the little mice that are being used as test subjects. Although comical, this scene may be quite accurate when describing the passion that animal lovers have when it comes to the touchy subject of animal testing. For centuries, animal testing has been used in the medical research field, however many are now beginning to question whether it is ethical. Millions of animals are killed per year due to animal testing, so is this practice worth banning? Animal testing is a controversial subject, with supporters pointing out the medical advances that have stemmed from animal research and animal rights activists declaring it cruel and immoral.

Read More

Why Animal Testing Should Not Be Banned

796 Words | 4 Pages

The Animal Welfare Act (AWA) of United States gives some protections to warm-blooded animals used in research laboratories, which only cover 5% of animals normally used for testing. Under AWA, all testing on animals which are covered must minimized the pain on animals and provide appropriate veterinary care. The AWA should make further improvements which cover as much animals as possible. In UK, the Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986 defined regulated procedures as animal experiments that could potentially cause "pain, suffering, distress or lasting harm”. It prevents animals from unnecessary suffering.

Read More

Should Animal Testing Be Banned

967 Words | 4 Pages

Animal testing is a phrase that most people have heard but are perhaps still unsure of exactly what it involve. Whether it is called animal testing, experimentation or research, it should be defined as all testing methods on animals including, medical exploration, cosmetics, toxicology trialing, and psychological examination involving animal subjects. It is used to assess the safety and effectiveness of medications and beauty products as well as understanding how the human physiology works. While supporters believe it is necessary practice, those against animal testing believe that it involves torture and suffering to animals. Medical research is the hardest case of proposition in the debate whether animal testing should be banned or not, since it has previously yielded substantial benefits for humanity.

Read More

More about Arguments Against Animal Testing

Related Topics

Open Document