ipl-logo

CSI Effect Essay

499 Words2 Pages

As a big fan of television shows such as CSI Miami, Law and Order: SVU, and Criminal Minds, I can definitely understand why these types of shows can be an issue within the criminal justice system, due to their fictional investigations and how they make their task of solving crimes by using high tech equipment seem so easy. Even though I’m a big fan of the entertainment of these types of shows, I know the difference between reality and over exaggerated fiction. In the research, I found a term that is used called The CSI Effect. The CSI effect is “a belief held primarily among law enforcement personnel and prosecutors that forensic science television dramas, such as CSI: Crime Scene Investigation, influence American jurors to expect more forensic evidence in order to convict defendants of crimes” (Roberts, 2016).
In speaking to my brother in law, who is the Lieutenant of Investigations, at our local police department he made me aware that when a crime is committed, forensics are not always needed and if forensics are needed the department has to call in forensics, due to not having one on hand (Lt. R. Mitchell, 2016). I …show more content…

After the results of the survey, jurors should be educated on how the criminal justice system really works. In doing so, I believe that jurors will get a better understanding and will be able to provide accurate decisions based on the findings of the court, not what has been influenced by television. No, I do not believe that juries should expect a higher level of capability from law enforcement. The reason being is that each department is set up differently, some like my local police department are smaller and have a smaller budget, but within a larger city, they may have the capabilities of having forensic units on site. I believe that each department should be expected to do their job

Show More
Related
1163 Words | 5 Pages

They also explained how investigators and the detectives investigated the Peters car in quadrants where they take a wet swab and then dry swab to find any prints on or int the car. In addition they fumigated the car and wear orange goggles that help them find more prints and evidence that the human eye can't see. All of these scientific investigative evidence procedures can seem to be detrimental to Herring. However, we learned in class that the CSI effect has no meaningful impact between forensic science show viewers and non-viewers when it came to convict or acquit a defendant. Research suggests that the CSI Effect benefits the prosecution is a myth.

Read More
1731 Words | 7 Pages

Television shows such as CSI gives them the belief that any type of evidence is prominent to coming to a conclusion. Jurors are accustomed to the idea that evidence does not lie, since that is what’s showed on television. From watching television shows and court cases movies gives jurors conception that judges, lawyer, and evidence are what bring to concluding their verdict. Jurors expect the evidence to be conclusive since the technology is so advanced. Law & Order, not pertaining to any specific case usually have witnesses, and at times jurors expect the eyewitness to have solid facts as to applying it to the verdict.

Read More
1892 Words | 8 Pages

A positive aspect of this is that forensic scientists only need a small amount of a sample to get the results they need (“Forensic Science” 12). These samples can come from many other forms of identification other than fingerprints and bloodstains. A few moderate examples include strands of hair, tiny beads of sweat, and a saliva specimen (“Forensic Science” 12). Forensic Science Technicians stated that “crime scene investigators may use tweezers, black lights, and specialized kits to identify and collect evidence.” They also stated that examining autopsies prove to be beneficial in a crime investigation (“Forensic Science Technicians”

Read More
641 Words | 3 Pages

The CSI effect describes the way CSI is exaggerated on crime television shows such as CSI: Crime Scene Investigation and Sherlock which influences public perception. As a result, Jurors have come to have unrealistic expectations about the quantity, quality, and availability of scientific evidence, thereby raising the effective standard of proof for prosecutors. As technology improves and becomes more prevalent throughout society, people may also develop higher expectations for the capabilities of forensic technology. The csi effect creates unrealistic expectations of the public and has raised the juror’s expectations of the crime investigating field.

Read More
1592 Words | 7 Pages

While the depiction of what CSI’s do and how they do it isn’t the most accurate part of the show, that isn’t the point. The goal and point of the show is to create something entertaining that keeps people wanting more, so they keep coming

Read More
1008 Words | 5 Pages

Forensic science needs to be very careful when handling the evidence and interpreting what it means. The evidence can help find the culprit or victim’s DNA or fingerprints, these evidence can identify both the culprit and the victim so that we can solve the crime easier because we already know the people and just need to find the

Read More
3048 Words | 13 Pages

A Detective Portrayed and Reflected EmilyAnne Smith Troy University Forensics In the Media Dr. Dautartas 4/22/24. Introduction The forensic science field has many aspects that are reflected in the media in different ways. These variations of reflection can lead to a mistaken understanding of the field and present a false confidence in not only the forensic science field but also the criminal justice system and law enforcement. Through television shows, podcasts, social media platforms, etc., the reflection hits a wide audience, and that painted view can affect our criminal justice system.

Read More
250 Words | 1 Pages

“CSI: Crime Scene Investigation” was not the first crime show to hit the TV screens and it certainly is not the last. In response to its popularity and growing franchise, a controversial term was introduced in courts and through the media. It is called the CSI effect. The CSI effect has been closely defined as a trend that claims, through watching crime-related programmes such as “CSI” or “Law and Order”, the public, mainly people completing jury service, have their views about forensic evidence influenced. This primarily creates preconceived beliefs which allegedly affects the criminal justice system in many ways.

Read More
1263 Words | 6 Pages

CSI, NCIS, and Bones. These are all shows in modern day pop culture that involve forensic sciences to solve murders and bring justice to victims. But what is forensic science? By dictionary definition, forensic science is the application of scientific principles and techniques to matters of criminal justice especially as relating to the collection, examination, and analysis of physical evidence. It includes many branches, one of which is forensic toxicology.

Read More
1455 Words | 6 Pages

As Malcom X said the media can make an innocent man guilty and a guilty man innocent. The media attention affects the case from the very beginning, as early as choosing the jurors for high profile cases. A very big factor in aa court choosing a juror is for that juror to be impartial, but with the media coverage most people who have seen the news will have developed some biases. ““Social science research has found that “exposure to the various media had a prejudicial impact on people, as they were unaware of their biases. ” (Ogloff & Vidmar, 1994)””

Read More
444 Words | 2 Pages

Every day forensic investigators use tactics just like the ones that were discussed throughout the paper. It’s more than just looking for an admission of guilt, and interrogating potential suspects until they

Read More
743 Words | 3 Pages

The effect is described as “The CSI effect is a belief held primarily among law enforcement personnel and prosecutors that forensic science television dramas, such as CSI: Crime Scene Investigation, influence American jurors to expect more forensic evidence to

Read More
1469 Words | 6 Pages

The study also found that those who had more fear of crime had less faith in the justice system. Viewers of crime dramas also misjudge the amount of law enforcement officers and attorneys in the total work force. When the shows “CSI” and “Law and Order” first became popular, the “CSI effect” was observed. Bernard Knight, formerly one of Britain’s chief pathologists, said that “because of television crime dramas, jurors today expect more categorical proof than forensic science is capable of delivering”(Knight). There have been several different studies to prove that the “CSI effect” is indeed real.

Read More
1634 Words | 7 Pages

Or it could possibly be that law enforcement do not deem the evidence collected at a crime scene crucial to the case and do not send to the forensic labs in the first place (6p4). I believe that perhaps more extensive training for law enforcement could help in providing them with a more in-depth understanding of how to collect evidence as well as deciding on whether it is relevant to their case. Also, more funding needs to be provided to either open up more forensic lab and/or provide a larger

Read More
752 Words | 4 Pages

If crime scene investigators find something at the scene of a crime they hand it over to the officers and from there, the officers securely

Read More

More about CSI Effect Essay

Related Topics

Open Document