ipl-logo

Comparing Kitcher's Acceptive Truth And Ideals Of Progress

1271 Words6 Pages

Truth is paradoxical- a mixture of advantage and loss. Despite the “good” or “bad” label on the truth, knowledge can progress and/or hinder an individual or society. The overall solution to this argument remains uncertain- as the value of knowledge is indeterminable. The battle between logic and sentiment has invoked countless debates. There is no clear answer to the benefit or harm of truths, considering scientific knowledge does not normally pertain to emotions. Scientific knowledge results from obtaining truths. However, these answers potentially benefit or obstruct the value of the raised questions. Increased knowledge contains the potential progression or hindrance of an individual or society. Both Philip Kitcher’s “Subversive Truth and …show more content…

This work analyzes Thomas Huxley’s statement “truth is better than much profit” (______). Kitcher responds to this expression by attempting to defend and refute it. In response to Huxley, Kitcher interprets his statement to signify that truth is relevant to progress. This progress can be individual or of a society. Essentially, Huxley believes that knowledge, in regards of the unknown, is more significant and valuable than remaining in a shadow of ignorance. Kitcher, in agreement with Huxley, suggests that discovering the truth, even if could be considered negative, overall induces progression- which in return, benefits that person or group. Despite human comfort or happiness, definite answers about the unknown generate further progression than persisting in ignorance. Ultimately, Kitcher rejects Huxley’s idea by questioning the value of scientific knowledge. Towards an individual, scientific truths do not necessarily benefit his life. If this truth were to fundamentally disrupt his lifestyle, would his newfound knowledge altogether “benefit” his life? For example, an individual discovering he has an incurable, …show more content…

More so, to Sanders, in Martin’s short story, “With Morning Comes Mistfall,” discovering the wraiths are merely a myth would be devastating. The mysterious allure of Wraithworld would diminish, as would the visitors. Unfortunately, since the travelers only find the beauty of the planet after they come to search for wraiths, no one would discover the peaceful elegance that is Wraithworld. Furthermore, Sanders thrives off the mystery of the wraiths. To discover his wraiths were imaginary or inferior animals would ruin the enjoyment that stems from exploration and wonder. Contradictory to the hindrance of truth, scientific knowledge can lead to progression. Occasionally, obtaining truths can be beneficial, just as Huxley insists. Even if the truth itself is not positive, it can eventually produce favorable outcomes. Following Matin’s story, Dubowski desires the truth about the wraiths, as he is head of a research team. He comes to Wraithworld to determine the existence of the creatures, which he later shares at a press conference. Originally, he does not think the wraiths exist because there is no evidence. After searching, Dubowski confirms a lack of proof for the wraiths, thereby

Show More
Related
410 Words | 2 Pages

For the final paper, the topic I will pursue is ‘Getting to Know the Truth!” Using the book “The Things They Carried” by Tim O’Brien, I plan on making an analysis of truth. In the paper the importance of both the happening truth and the story truth and the difference between them will be concluded. From there, a conclusion of which truth is most important will be made. Along with analysis of the pervading truths and the Greek quote by Aeschylus.

Read More
616 Words | 3 Pages

Science is loved and feared by humans. In several texts, people are afraid of science and science benefited people. In Shelley’s and Stevenson’s text, people are discouraged by science. Both Bensch’s and Mackenzie’s text indicates people’s love for science. Depending on how science is applied, it both helps people, and causes difficulties.

Read More
1052 Words | 5 Pages

Facing the unknown is risky because it produces an outcome that is or is not expected, which is why many people in the modern world tend to avoid it. In contrast, author Anne Morrow Lindbergh supports the idea of exploring the unknown, stating that “its disappointments and surprises that are the most enriching.” Exploring the unknown is seeing and taking on ideas or topics that is not understandable, and finding something new from it. She believes that the unknown will be the only way people can improve and advance as a society, and she is correct. By exploring the unknown and discovering new ideas that has not yet been addressed in the past, society can improve, develop, and obtain major revelation in studies that can profoundly change lives,

Read More
625 Words | 3 Pages

He even doubts himself stating, “Where my very senses reject their own evidence.” However, he ends his paper with optimism and hope that one day someone, much more intelligent than he, will be able to understand his horrors as simply “nothing more than an ordinary succession of very natural causes and effects.” In doing so, the author is causing the reader to feel sorrow and sympathy for a story that might not even be believed, but by ending the paper with hope that others will be able to cure this madness as simply ordinary circumstance of human nature. The author’s usage of diction provides evidence that this narrative may cause consequences that are unforeseen.

Read More
728 Words | 3 Pages

The novel’s warnings against the dangers of genetic engineering, consumerism, and the potential for technology to be used for oppressive purposes are all issues that are still relevant in today’s society. The novel also raises questions about the potential for technology to be used to create a more equitable and just society. The novel’s implications for a contemporary society still remaining relevant today, serve as a reminder of the potential dangers of scientific and technological advances. Through his novel, Huxley forces readers to consider the implications of a society without freedom and to consider the consequences of unchecked power. According to a website called “Goodreads”, Huxley convinces more people to consider this by saying, “An unexciting truth may be eclipsed by a thrilling falsehood.

Read More
1488 Words | 6 Pages

Science itself has largely been a topic of controversy for the education system; as they argue what of science to teach, and whether or not it will cause strife with the community. Especially if that conflict happens to be from religious, personal, or cultural differences. At all costs the education system avoids conflict. However, conflict or not, science is the fundamental basis of everything around humanity. From the plastic cups one drinks from, to the cell phone at one’s fingertips.

Read More
1850 Words | 8 Pages

Acclaimed inventor and physicist Nikola Tesla once said that “it is paradoxical, yet true, to say, that the more we know, the more ignorant we become in the absolute sense, for it is only through enlightenment that we become conscious of our limitations. Precisely one of the most gratifying results of intellectual evolution is the continuous opening up of new and greater prospects.” In other words, Tesla believes that when man becomes enlightened, he becomes aware of mankind’s limitations both individually and societally. Additionally, the introduction of new ideas and the edification of others enhances the progression of society. This idea of the truth of enlightenment is explored in both “Allegory of the Cave” by Plato, and The Matrix by

Read More
1451 Words | 6 Pages

Throughout history, humanity has strived to find the absolute truth. The truth is acquired through the accumulation of knowledge and knowledge is gained through a complex combination of intuition, emotion, language and reason. Knowledge we have today is a product of an extensive purification process, where new knowledge and information replaces the old and disproved ones. This could be compared to the concept of natural selection. The basic system of evolution involves the survival of organisms, which are better adapted to the current environmental conditions.

Read More
1396 Words | 6 Pages

Frankenstein: With the Advancing of Science Comes Consequences Certain discoveries throughout history have changed the world whether for the good or bad. It is believed there exists many pros and cons to these discoveries. Science is certainly taking off with leaps and bounds as according to bibliometric analysts Lutz Bornmann and Ruediger Mutz “global scientific output doubles every nine years” (Noorden). Scientists continue to do unimaginable things in the science field.

Read More
391 Words | 2 Pages

Everyday knowledge is built on personal experience, authority and tradition, therefore, it can result in inaccurate observations, overgeneralizations, illogical reasoning and selective observation. Scientific knowledge, however, is gained by collecting and interpreting data systematically, i.e. based on logical relationships, and using objective and precise language. In contrast to everyday knowledge, scientific research, the process of gaining scientific knowledge, is conducted in order to find things out, increase one’s knowledge and to resolve the mistakes of human perception and

Read More
315 Words | 2 Pages

Huxley accurately depicts how the later industrial revolution left many questioning the rules of modesty and privacy in a newly interconnected world. He portrays how an expansion of transportation and communication, a new sense of openness regarding sexualty, and an onset of socialism led to this moral revolution. The expansion of transportation and communication in the early 20th Century, made affordable through mass production, brought revolutionary changes as distances grew shorter and privacy rarer. Huxley narrates, “God isn’t compatible with machines and science and universal happiness.

Read More
805 Words | 4 Pages

Searching for knowledge is extremely beneficial; since there is always a good side and an evil side to knowledge, a whole new world is opened when knowledge is found.

Read More
562 Words | 3 Pages

Knowledge: empowering or destructive Knowledge has come into question many times before, whether it is empowering or destructive, whether the acquirement of knowledge is too dangerous to fester on, or the pursuit of knowledge should have no boundaries. Knowledge can be both empowering and destructive depending on the use. Though the fact is knowledge is a two sided coin, with both sides consisting of power and destruction. The novel Frankenstein written by Mary Shelley in depth demonstrates very well the two sides of knowledge, in this first example, shows the very nature of why man seeks knowledge.

Read More
281 Words | 2 Pages

Huxley tried to bring into notion that industrialization would damage society and his prophecy is becoming true. Society relies too much on technology and it has become difficult to live without it. This novel has a very important message that should to taught to students. There are many critics that go against the reading of this book is a classroom setting. Some may argue that is book is centered on

Read More
1001 Words | 5 Pages

The question of truth has haunted mankind for generations. Each and everyone of us on our journey to find truth will have brushed up against many obstacles. Whether it be a child struggling with the legitimacy of their childhood fairytales or a middle aged man fighting for his purpose in this world. Everyone will come across their own truth and be forced to grapple with it at some point in their lives. Through many sources of literature we can attempt to grasp the truth and become enlightened.

Read More

More about Comparing Kitcher's Acceptive Truth And Ideals Of Progress

Open Document