The Senate in Canada should be abolished Introduction: Canada senate is a part of legislation institution in Canada, which represents the interests of upper class people. Different from America, it is not produced by election but directly-nominated by the premier and appointed by governor. Senate, governor, and the House of Commons are like three legs of a tripod which constitute the congress and legislation system in Canada. Senate undertakes the responsibility of proposing expostulation to governor and cabinet, which acts the role of supervision and restriction. Senate played critical role when Canada established federal government in 1867, the diversity of senators warrants the smooth convey of popular will to governors and legislators coming from different ethnic group and social status.
Introduction The Canadian Senate has been an institution of the country since the multiple negotiations that made possible the establishment of the federation. Section 17 of CA 1867 states that Canada is to have a Parliament comprising a House of Commons (lower house), a Senate (upper house), and the Crown. However, from the parliamentary institutions aforementioned, only the elected members of the House of Commons could claim to have a democratic mandate: the position of the Crown is hereditary, and the governor general that represents it, as well as senators, are appointed (Malcolmson et al. 2021). The. Despite Canadians’ general dissatisfaction with the Senate and ongoing criticism around its undemocratic model, patronage appointments and
To ensure that all Canadians are truly equal, the "Triple E" Senate was created. It stands for effective, equal and elected. Since the Senate is not elected it represents the worst of partisian, political patronage, it lacks all legitimacy. Also, if they are elected they would be accountable to the regions they represent. Overall, some people believe the Senate will never be a legitimate part of the lawmaking body, unless it's members are accountable to the people of Canada through a democratic election process.
Power to make treaties (what role does the Senate play?)- This allows the president to make treaties with foreign nations. The senate must approve these decisions with a ⅔ vote. Veto Power- Presidents can reject any pieces of congressional legislation. Commander in Chief-
The U.S. Senators is the senators that represent the whole state. Also, U.S. Senators is the office of the U.S. Congress which does not represent single-member districts. The Senate will have a formulate of 2 senators from each state who are elected by people which are the citizens. They will be elected for 6 years. The relationship to the Virginia plan who create was James Madison and the Virginia Plan was to shape up the way how our united states government operates today.
Nancy Zhou Social 11A Mr. B September, 17th, 2017 Q: Should Canada keep, change or abolish the senate? The Reason Canada Need to Change the Senate Canada should change the Senate because the senate is useless, undemocratic and costly today. However, the principle of Senate is a good idea, so it is still needed and important. The Senate is a legislative body of the government, which has the almost the same power as the House of Common.
Article I described the powers of the legislature which were the ability to (page 35) ratify treaties, collect taxes, borrow money, regulate commerce, to print money, declare war, to establish a post office, declare war, build roads, to maintain a Navy and Militia. It also gave special responsibilities to each body. All bills regarding revenue must originate in the House. The Senate has the ability to approve presidential appointments and would preside over any possible impeachment trial of a sitting President. Article I allowed each body of the legislature to establish its own rules and elect its own leaders.
The state senators serve in the state legislature, and the U.S. senators make up a chamber of Congress. U.S. senators represent their own state and at the same time they represent the nation as a whole. Meanwhile state senators are responsible for legislation which affects their state. The terms they serve are also different from each other the U.S. senator’s serves a term of six years while the State senators serve from two to four years.
This paper will look at how the Canadian Senate should not be reformed. Intent at confederation, its role in parliament and its role as a final check and balance are all reasons the status-quo of the Canadian
The functions of the Senate is to cautiously examine legislation that are proposed by the House of Commons, to suggest changes or adjustments. The Senate can reject a bill, and recommend changes and improvements to be made. They can introduce new bills however, most bills are introduced by the House of Commons. A bill cannot become a law in Canada without the Senates approval. This is also the only reason that the Senate is a useful institution in Canada today as it represents the interest of the provinces in federal legislative.
One becoming a senate must be: over 30 years old, been a US citizen for 9 years, and length of the term is 6 years. There is no limit on how many terms one can serve in either or. From looking at the qualifications, it is fascinating that Representatives have more relaxed qualifications compared to the Senate. These qualifications and the total number of members allowed could be a way to promote sociological representation, representation of group through similar race, gender, ethnicity, and religion as the group.
The Senate is responsible for protecting the rights and interests of Canadians in all of its regions, especially minority groups or people who do not often get a chance to present their opinions to Parliament. Before a bill can become law, it goes through three stages, called "readings," in both Houses. The bill is debated, adjusted and then voted on by each House. Once approved, the bill is presented to the Governor General for royal assent and is made law. Another role of the Senate, not plainly provided for in the Constitution, “is to act as a non-ideological, routine revising chamber that picks up flaws in legislation that have avoided notice during a bill’s passage through the House of Commons.”
The Senate and House of Representatives comprise the two chambers of the United States Congress. While both houses are representative bodies and jointly oversee the executive branch, both must approve all bills before the president, but both chambers have different roles according to the Constitution. The House of Representatives has 435 members apportioned to the house from across the United States. States with larger populations receive more seats within the house.
To qualify as a senator, one must be at least 30 years old, be a U.S citizen for at least nine years, and have achieved the requirements for residency in the state he/she desires to represent. Together the House and the Senate form the United States Congress. Legislative Branch checks the Executive Branch of; having the authority to impeach officials, override presidential vetoes, approve treaties and ambassadors, approve the replacement of the Vice President, the power to proclaim war, and the power to enact taxes and assign funds. Additionally, the Legislative Branch checks on the Judiciary Branch with the right to approve federal judges, as well as impeach federal judges, initiate constitutional amendments, set the jurisdiction of courts, and alter the size of the Supreme Court. Legislative Branch also has a check on itself because it is bicameral or composed of two chambers.
The Senate is almost similar to the House of Representative, but has two roles that are different, President of Senate and president Pro Tempore. The President of Senate is the Vice President’s job. He or she doesn’t vote unless there is a tie. The President Pro Tempore job is to take over for the President of Senate if he or she isn’t present. The best part about Congress is that they have care about what the people ay and care about protecting the freedom of everyone that lives in the United States.
