ipl-logo

Filmmakers Should Not Be Villainized For Movie Violence Summary

438 Words2 Pages

The counterpoint, "Hollywood Filmmakers Should Not be Villainized for Movie Violence", is the more persuasive article and is better supported by evidence. For example, filmmakers should not need to take into consideration the behavioral changes in people due to the violence portrayed in their movies. According to the strong evidence in the text, "Violent behavior is an extremely complex issue that cannot be reduced to a simple cause-effect relationship" (Counterpoint para. 3). Violence seen in movies is certainly not the one and only cause of violent behavior, especially in children.
Additionally, the text points out a judicious verdict about parenting. It is not the fault of the filmmaker if a child watches his or her film. The parent of the child should be monitoring the media he or she allows the child to view. In the text, Freedman explains how filmmakers are not to be blamed for the violent content they put in their movies. He asks, "How can we hold filmmakers responsible for putting children at risk when it’s a parental duty to monitor what children are watching? Parents must teach their children appropriate behaviors" (Counterpoint para. 4). Parents have a duty to communicate with their child and explain the difference between movie violence and violence in real life. …show more content…

This is because when one is busying his or herself by watching a movie, he or she is reducing violence by not partaking in violent actions. Based on the data in the text, "crime rates have dropped steadily since 1993. . . violent movies may actually play a part in this reduction in violent crime. Children who are watching a movie are taking part in a nonviolent activity" (Counterpoint para. 5). Watching violent movies and films also satisfies ones desire to engage in real life violence and controls the urge to do something

Show More
Related
997 Words | 4 Pages

“Media Violence” is an article written by Christina L. Lyons. Lyons is a journalist who lives in Washington, D.C., and she has a primary focus on U.S. Government and politics. She began her career in Maryland as a newspaper reporter. She has contributed to several different articles published by CQ Press and Bloomberg Press, and has a master’s degree in political science from American University in Washington, D.C. The article explores whether or not children have too much access to violence via movies, television, video games, and social media.

Read More
200 Words | 1 Pages

All children are different so it is the parent’s responsibility to determine whether or not their children can handle the different media. Some media critics believe that violent cartoons, video games, movies etc. are good for children. Gerard Jones gives an example in his essay “Violent media is good for kids” which he explains how violent media can be good for children, Jones explains his point by giving an example of his son. Jones tells how he exposed his son to marvel comics which helped him in his kindergarten experience. The marvel characters gave Jones’s son the desire of “transforming himself into a bloodthirsty dinosaur to embolden himself for the plunge into preschool” (373).

Read More
321 Words | 2 Pages

13. In your “Course Pack” read Children, Violence, and the Media: A Report for Parents and Policy Makers” (pages 62-77) and answer question 4 on page 80-81 (typed, double spaced, a minimum of 150 in total). I.

Read More
367 Words | 2 Pages

In Gerard Jones’ essay “Violent Media is Food for Kids,” he forces the reader to decide whether the argument that there is a direct correlation between violent media and violent children is valid, or if that by denying children the freedom to experience violence through media, society is harming a very important foundation of finding one’s self. I find it similar to the Jude Priest case because two parents banded together to sue a band for allegedly putting subliminal messages in their heavy metal music that caused their sons to commit suicide. While most of the expert witness concluded that there was not enough scientific research to prove that subliminal messages can truly influence someone, nor can Vance or Belknap could really be considered

Read More
965 Words | 4 Pages

To analyze this piece we should look at the title of the piece: “Violent media is good for kids”. This headline catches the eye because it gives an unexpected answer to something people have heard for many decades now. Most articles that talk about violent media are usually against them and have a way to persuade the audience in why they shouldn’t expose their kids to video games like Call of Duty or Halo. However in this article, just by looking at the title the

Read More
813 Words | 4 Pages

In “Violent Media Is Good for Kids”, written by Gerard Jones, the author argues that violent entertainments have positive effects on children’s lives beyond their violence and juvenility. In his article, Jones uses a cause and result relationship between violent media and their importance to inform the positive impact of violent media. In addition to informing, Jones tries to persuade parents, teachers, psychologists, and others who are skeptical of the importance of violent media by giving evidence from his own life story and from his research. Furthermore, by informing and by persuading his readers, Jones encourages his readers to experience the significant part of violent entertainments. Even though Jones purpose is to convince about the

Read More
1590 Words | 7 Pages

The article mentions that is a common belief that most violence in younger adults, or teens comes from the violence that is seen on media. Many of the people who do the violence, are people have been exposed to violence at a young age it; Whether it be the media, or their own household. The article talks about how there are movie clips of violence, and fighting videos openly posted on social media that eventually become viral, exposing kids to violence making them believe that what they are doing is not as bad

Read More
681 Words | 3 Pages

In his essay “Hate Violence? Turn It Off,” Tim Goodman argues that if parents or other adults object to a television program, they should change the channel or just simply turn off the TV. I disagree with Goodman’s argument. Violence is not uncommon activity happening in our modern society, it is portray in the media, entertainment, and also human interaction with each other. Turning off the TV or changing the channel could not prevent violent influences.

Read More
946 Words | 4 Pages

Families and parents across the United States of America fear that their child will ultimately grow up to be a violent and merciless teenager or adult. Therefore, leading parents to become helicopter parent or take away anything that remotely relates to violence, gore, or guns. However, according to Gerard Jones, Comic book writer and author, parent should embrace controlled violence, and expose it to their child. Exposing violence to a child will ultimately help them in the near future, causing them to express who they are and learn what they want to be. Through Mr. Jones’ logical reasoning and past experiences, his sympathetic and empowering stories, and his extended research with Melanie Moore Ph.D., Gerard Jones is able to argue why its

Read More
993 Words | 4 Pages

Where this fits in this conversation is on the side of supporting censorship on the grounds that the parent censors what ever the parent sees fit. However, the article minimally discusses how responsible the parents will be when they censor what their kids will see and hear as well as how they will treat sudden exposure to ideas and images. The writer, here, is on the side of the common, fearful parent who wants to help other parents censor their kids. Unfortunately, this article does not discuss the treatment of censorship when kids are exposed to what the world has. Article 2 Discussion () Even though this article is on the side of pushing for censorship without questioning it’s effects, this article paints the perspective of the reason why censorship exist in the first place; to make sure ideas that are nuanced, very descriptive, and depicts a portion real life through the eyes of mature human beings.

Read More
752 Words | 4 Pages

Bruce Joel Rubin’s “Ghost the Musical” was performed at American High School, by the American High School Performing Arts department, directed by Troy River. The cast presented an incredible performance that made the audience instantly fall in love with Molly and Sam. Richard Wong whom conducted the orchestra uplifted the music of each scene. The remarkable acting of the cast along with the many special effects was an incredible way to bring the script to life. “Ghost the Musical” takes place in modern day New York City and is a story of the strength of love between the main characters Molly (Natalie Dunn) and Sam (Marcus Bautista).

Read More
975 Words | 4 Pages

I disagree with him feeling that criminal behavior is not learned through communication such as movies and now days, social media and video games. While there is no direct correlation to violent video games causing our youth to want to commit crimes, it does show that “exposure to video games can be a significant risk factor for violent behavior” (Regis,

Read More
1861 Words | 8 Pages

Analysis of Gerard Jones’ “Violent Media is Good for Kids” In the article called “Violent Media is Good for Kids,” by Gerard Jones, a renowned comic- book author, is arguing that violent media can be helpful for children, rather than be overly harmful. Parents aren’t taking the time to really look at how helpful violent content could possibly be for their child. Yet, violence can help children learn how to reach for their own inner power that they may have never been able to find before. Furthermore, children as they grow up may even go towards violence that presents justice, rather than the negative types of violence.

Read More
468 Words | 2 Pages

The author did not rule out other possible factors that might stop the pass of the bill. For example, whether the constitution allows the legislator to establish a board to censor the movie? As we know, the constitution guarantees the right of freedom of speech in the United States. Therefore, the reason that the bill failed to pass could be that the bill was against the constitution. Moreover, the author implied that by limiting teenagers from watching movies with violent content can help improve the situation.

Read More
1490 Words | 6 Pages

Media violence has become a controversial topic in the world today. Owing to the rising technology, children are beginning to show increasing violent behaviors. The debates on the effects of media ranging from screen media, video games, and books have a long history. Due to this, there is a speculation over what is the leading cause of the increasing violence in children. Some people argue that there is a relationship between media violence and real-life violence.

Read More

More about Filmmakers Should Not Be Villainized For Movie Violence Summary

Related Topics

Open Document