ipl-logo

Haiti Earthquake Case Study

1706 Words7 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Disaster risk reduction essay

In this essay I will discuss the risk management in the Haitian earthquake 2010 and the Japanese earthquake and tsunami 2011. I will compare the risk management and mitigation procedures each country had in place and how the natural hazard impacted on their society. I picked Japan and Haiti as it allowed me to compare how a developed and undeveloped country coped when faced with a natural hazard.
United nations office for disaster risk reduction (2007) defines disaster risk management as ‘the systematic process of using administrative directives, organizations, and operational skills and capacities to implement strategies, policies and improved coping capacities in order to lessen the adverse impacts of hazards and the possibility of disaster.’ …show more content…

Even though the earthquake in Japan was significantly stronger than the Haitian earthquake about 14 times more people lost their lives in Haiti than in Japan. The cost of the earthquakes to each nation was extremely different also. The cost to repair the destruction was approximately 38 times more in Japan yet the World Bank estimated that they would recover in 5 years (BBC, 2011) unlike Haiti whose debt was reduced by the World Bank to aid their recovery due to the poverty of the nation. Haiti’s recovery was and still is very much dependent on aid. In the first 7 days after the earthquake Haiti received $274million in donations whereas Japan received $87million (Dickler, J., 2011). This was primarily because people recognised Japan was a developed country with infrastructure in place to deal with natural hazards unlike …show more content…

The humanitarian response to the disaster faced many obstacles such as a lack of transportation, a limited communication system and damage to government buildings and hospitals. People who were to play a key role in the recovery of Haiti were missing or dead for example Haitian government officials, UN personnel and international aid workers. This put the emergency response on the back foot immediately. On top of that there was no electricity or clean water. Efforts by international aid agencies to enter Haiti were also disrupted because all major transport routes were damaged; the Port au Prince Airport tower and the main port were destroyed. (Margesson, R. and Taft – Morales, M., 2010) Unlike Japan who led the way in their own recovery, Haiti depended on foreign organisations to create a plan for their recovery and emergency response because there was no procedure in place prior to the earthquake. Before the earthquake, the World Bank was in the process of creating a disaster risk management plan in conjunction with the Haitian Government. However, the plan was still in its early stages and hurricanes were the main focus, because they are the most common natural disaster experienced on the island. (Margesson, R. and Taft – Morales, M., 2010) Therefore this plan was not of any benefit to Haitian authorities in their emergency response to the earthquake. A month after the earthquake, the Haitian government released

Show More
Related
1066 Words | 5 Pages

Emergencies are best managed on the lowest possible level. Homeland Security Presidential Directive - 5 set the precedent for collaboration in responding to emergencies whether they are man-made or natural disasters. Resiliency creates a community that is able to come back from a crisis stronger and wiser than they were before. Although all aspects of the U.S. emergency management system are essential, the most important aspect is the whole community approach comprised of the public – private partnership and personal preparedness.

Read More
896 Words | 4 Pages

Personnel and equipment come into the devastated area from all over the country, as well as Puerto Rico and the U.S. Virgin Islands” (Bell, 2006, p. 26). 2005 brought the largest national response to natural disasters. Hurricane’s Katrina and Rita affected numerous states. The states affected were unable to help themselves, as would be responders were now victims. In addition to the lack of responders, the local infrastructure was decimated and local and state officials were unable to respond.

Read More
633 Words | 3 Pages

Hurricane Katrina shift the position of the Department of Homeland Security from making natural disasters an equally as important as terrorism. This even showed that disaster planning requires a great deal of collaboration. The Department of Homeland Security who swallowed up FEMA where not quick to react to Hurricane Katrina because all their focus was spend on planning for a prevent terrorist attacks. The failure of the disaster response system resulted in over 1,200 lives lost in Louisiana and Mississippi. FEMA failed to work closely with its State and local counterparts and communications between these partners and the public were strained at best.

Read More
1383 Words | 6 Pages

The government was more concerned about how it would cause problems with public services, showing that they did not care about helping Haitians but rather cared more about the causes people with their families were having. In episode 2: “You Left Persecution… The Solution is Not to Put You in Jail”, Danny Rivero says, “Most of the Cuban refugees who arrive in the US during this time are immediately processed and released into the community. Some of the Cubans are kept in jails or detention centers for months or even years on end. But the vast majority were quickly released.

Read More
1679 Words | 7 Pages

In the article Poverty and The Gospel: The Case of Haiti written by Dieumeme Noelliste, the author states that “Although situated in a region of the world classified as middle income, Haiti has never moved remotely close to that status during its life as a nation” (Noelliste). This is due to the fact that the unorganized government has never made a constant effort to help its citizens with the limited resources they have. There are little to no laws to protect the nation from poverty, the justice is completely obsolete. According to the article Haiti Sees Drop in Poverty Rates, but Inequality Remains written by the journalist Jaqueline Charles, relief efforts have been attempted by the government and social programs of Haiti, over 47 percent of households reported receiving some type of aid. However, the government and social programs cannot continue to provide this small aid, “The problem now is as aid declines, how do you sustain that?”

Read More
864 Words | 4 Pages

The possibility of individuals that are not victims of the actual hurricane could come seeking assistance when these individuals were not from or in the area once the hurricane hit. The strategy to discern between who is and who isn’t a victim of such a disaster is a must. The properly trained individuals to assist in scam discernment are necessary. An individual to assist victims with the shock or emotional trauma once they are rescued is needed

Read More
735 Words | 3 Pages

HAITI Samuel chambers Introduction Haiti's main religion is Voodoo. When something happens in Haiti people go to there local Shaman(man) or Mambo (woman). Haiti may not look like much, but it is rich with history from voodoo shaman leading the slaves to revolution to the heat hot enough to kill. Haiti is interesting because of its Geography, weather, plants, animals, people and cultures. Landforms Haiti is a beautiful place with palm trees and beaches it is perfect for a holiday.

Read More
130 Words | 1 Pages

Because of these reasons, Japanese started to look for better and safer countries.

Read More
1266 Words | 6 Pages

Conditions for the small country worsened as a devastating earthquake struck Haiti in 2010, and over 300,000 people were killed, and 1.5 million were displaced, leaving them homeless. Just months after the earthquake hit, Haiti experienced the worst cholera outbreak in recent history, killing thousands, and infecting more than 6% of the population (Cook). Despite efforts from humanitarians and charities around the world, things never seemed to get better as access to clean drinking water and safe shelter became scarce. As the environment became virtually uninhabitable, many Haitians came to the United States, seeking asylum, and an opportunity to better the lives for themselves and their

Read More
1017 Words | 5 Pages

Background Haiti is an island which is located in the Greater Antilles of the Caribbean Sea, the island is 27,750 square kilometers in size and has approximately 10.8 million people, which ranks it the first populous country in the Caribbean. Despite, Haiti vast population 80 percent of the people live below the poverty line hence, half of the citizens are malnourished. In terms of healthcare systems, the island positions last in the western hemispheres and one of the world worst healthcare system due to their lacking sanitation systems, poor nutrition and insufficient health services, which continues to prevent Haiti development. In addition, for generations Haiti has

Read More
529 Words | 3 Pages

In the newly independent Haiti, all Haitians were defined as "black," and the notion of being black in Haiti was not an issue of phenotype but, “of a commitment to the values of equality and freedom and an opposition to colonialism”. Thus, generating a psychological shock to the emerging intellectual traditions of, “an increasingly racist Europe and North America that saw a hierarchical world eternally dominated by types representative of their own somatic images”. In Haiti, all citizens were legally equal, regardless of color, race, or condition, and civic participation was extended to all Haitians, and citizens were encouraged to utilize their freedom by expressing their rights. In the aftermath of the revolution, it became important to Haiti, that emancipation would be permanently maintained for all citizens of

Read More
146 Words | 1 Pages

During the hurricane, all public services were interrupted at the same time. The population has not had access Ieau

Read More
266 Words | 2 Pages

Betty, Hurricane Katrina had a great impact on the city of New Orleans which left the city of New Orleans in search of supplies of water, food, shelter, and personal hygiene products. I would like for you to think Betty what if Hurricane Katrina happened in the year of 2020. It would hardly a surprise to prepare for a Hurricane Katrina, “some of the major problems encountered during the response to Katrina stemmed from breakdowns in the administrative elements of the governmental emergency management system”. This use of strategic management would be totally different; concerns would mainly deal with organization and organizational system McGuire (2010).

Read More
834 Words | 4 Pages

When disaster occurs nothing can be done when the disaster is happening. The aftermath of the disaster is when the recovery process usually begins. Emergency management agencies react right away getting a hold of volunteers and resources needed to provide for the affected communities. However, emergency agencies taking a proactive stance will provide quick response and minimize problems that can occur from natural disasters. In order for emergency management agencies to become more proactive, the three techniques that needed to be taken are: utilizing new technologies, understanding other ‘disasters’, and collaboration & communication.

Read More
520 Words | 3 Pages

FEMA’s mission and priorities were changed so that, “terrorism prevention, preparedness, response, and recovery became central to the emergency management mission” (Haddow 325). As a result of the terrorist attacks on 9/11 the country’s focus shifted completely from natural disasters to an outright major assault on all things terrorism with no second glance at the potential emergency’s natural disasters presented. There might be a possibility that because of the nation’s extreme obsession with terrorists and terrorism that Hurricane Katrina was not given full priority nor given as much thought as it should have been because the whole focus of the government was on terrorism. When an agency and governmental structure, such as the defense agencies, undergoes an extreme shift within the course of a few years brought on so suddenly, there are bound to be weaknesses. Hurricane Katrina was the most challenging threat that tested the DHS as well as FEMA’s preparation and mitigation of natural disasters since the shift of focus.

Read More

More about Haiti Earthquake Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document