ipl-logo

How To Resuscitate A Dnr In Happily Ever After

877 Words4 Pages

Grey’s Anatomy Grey’s Anatomy is a drama/romance medical TV series. In the medical drama episode “Happily Ever After?”, this episode explores the complex world of medical decision-making where Doctors are faced with a critical choice regarding the resuscitation of Maxine, a patient closely related to one of the hospital’s Residency Doctors. The two Doctors are faced with a decision that could end their career if they take the wrong steps. The scenario revolves around the pivotal decision of whether to resuscitate a DNR (Do Not Resuscitate) and a DNI (Do Not Intubate) patient or not. The survey takes place when the patient Maxine stops breathing and results in her being coded in the hospital bed. Dr. Kawn, is already present with the patient …show more content…

Kahn will be resuscitating and intubating the patient himself, putting the patient in a harmful way, but if Levi helps, he will intubate Maxine. The outcome for the patient depends on the actions of Dr. Kawn and Dr. Levi. Dr. Kawn’s strategy of resuscitating Maxine despite her DNR and DNI directives reflects a decision influenced by his emotions and a potential willingness to face consequences for saving her life. For Dr. Levi, his strategy involves whether to help Dr. Kawn or not. Choosing to help means intervening against orders, but has the possibility to save Maxine. Maxine’s strategy is implicit in her DNR and DNI directives. Payoffs for this game can be ranked based on each situation. If both Dr. Kawn and Dr. Levi both decide to save Maxine’s life, then they would get the highest utility outcome of 3, reflecting the optimal scenario where Maxine’s life is saved with shared responsibility. However, if Dr. Kawn only saves Maxine then he will enjoy a utility of 2 and Dr. Levi with a 1, resulting in him saving Maxine but with potential consequences. If they both decide to do nothing and adhere to Maxine’s DNR and DNI, they will get the lowest payoff of 1. The tree for this game is shown in Figure …show more content…

Kawn, and Dr. Levi. Taking this into two parts, starting at the end of the tree. The second part focuses on Dr. Kawn and Dr. Levi’s choices, realizing that if Dr. Kawn decides to save Maxine by himself, it will result in a confined outcome for Dr. Levi. We see that Dr. Levi’s strategy would be to choose to help rather than not to because 3 is a greater payoff than 1. Now that we are left with two options for Dr. Kawn to help or to not help, comparing the payoff of 3 and 1, we know that Dr. Kawn’s strategy would be to choose 3, resulting in him helping. In this game, the rollback equilibrium reflects the decision Dr. Kawn and Dr. Levi chose in the analysis. Dr. Kawn’s initial decision to resuscitate Maxine triggers a cascade of actions. As we work backward through the game tree, the rational choice for Dr. Levi becomes apparent- to help Dr. Kawn in the absence of the chief or other doctors, resulting in Maxine’s stabilization. The rollback equilibrium, in this context, reflects a mutual understanding between the players that colluding is the optimal strategy here, emphasizing the importance of a collective commitment to Maxine. Based on my analysis of the scenario, it does coincide with the results that happened in the show, too. The rollback equilibrium reflects (Help, Help). This is the most logical option for both Dr. Kawn and Dr. Levi, even

Show More
Related

Case Study Landon Sparks

365 Words | 2 Pages

After agreeing to the surgery, Kenny is informed he has a choice: surgery or “let nature take its course.” Unfortunately, Landon is born with one of the most severe cases of Spina Bifida Hermann Hospital has seen and not all doctors agree to the choice Kenny has made for his son. The Sparks now must explain to the ethics committee why it would be more humane to let Landon die, then to watch him possibility live and suffer.” This is going to sound terrible for a mother to say, but I want him to die.” “If he lives that the way it should be, but

Read More

Karen Quinlan The Right To Die Case Study

295 Words | 2 Pages

A young girl Karen Ann Quinlan on April 15, 1975, slipped into a coma and her case began a major debate about “the right to die”. The defendant’s, in this case, are the doctors and hospital officials and the plaintiffs are the parents Mr. Joseph and Mrs. Julia Quinlan. One night Karen Quinlan hung out with friends and during the night she drank and took tranquilizers that made her pass out. Karen was taken to a hospital in New Jersey that night and shortly after she went into a coma which lasted 10 years. She was placed on a ventilator and a feeding tube to help her stay alive.

Read More

Mat 540 Final Paper

539 Words | 3 Pages

The matrix below shows the respective payoffs of your choice of actions. The first number listed in each cell is the payoff to the row player and the second number listed is the payoff to the column player. [4 points] a) Refer to the scenario on the previous page. This is an example of a: b) Refer to the scenario on the previous page. Do you have a dominant strategy?

Read More

Analysis Of The Dying Dream Of Paul Kalanithi

1764 Words | 8 Pages

In the first section, Kalanithi uses analysis to look at the moral aspect of operating on patients. He says that he needs to learn the identity and the wishes of his patients so he can have more respect to them as he operates on their brains and could take one of those away from the patient. He sympathises with other medical professionals by saying “Those burdens are what makes medicine holy and wholly impossible: in taking up another’s cross, one must sometimes get crushed by the weight” (98). The word play he employs adds to the effect of how serious it is to operate on someone and know a doctor might take a person 's identity away if the are a millimeter away from where they were suppose to cut.

Read More

Summary Of No Woman Born By C. L Moore

720 Words | 3 Pages

Something as simple as saving a human life has put the three of them at a crossroad. The Prevail Scenario states that “humans are picking and choosing their futures in

Read More

Explain Why Did Goldman Say That Decisions Regarding People's Own Futures

1059 Words | 5 Pages

Wanglie Would have desired, there was no reason to doubt her family on that point, but whether the continuation of ventilator support and gastrostomy feeding were among the reasonable medical alternatives that should have been available to Mrs. Wanglie or her surrogate decision maker, whoever that might be. The question, really, was whether the provision of this kind of treatment in this kind of case was outside the limits of medicine and, thus, beyond her power of choice. Mrs. Wanglie’s healthcare providers should have argued that medical practice simply did not include providing ventilator and gastrostomy feeding under circumstances of this case, and that not surrogate decision maker should be able to choose this option”

Read More

The Maze Runner Research Paper Outline

922 Words | 4 Pages

Colin Turner Mrs. Pitts CP English 9 13 March 2023 Outline Thesis Statement: James Dahsner is known for his creative mind and thoughts which led him to creating The Maze Runner book and series and overcoming controversy winning many awards and being very successful over the past decade. James Dahsner is known for his creative mind and thoughts. A.He had always loved writing. B.Dahsners environment growing up inspired him as well as books and movies. Dashner's most famous work was The Maze Runner book and series.

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Daniel Keyes Flowers For Algernon

894 Words | 4 Pages

(Keyes 206) Charlie now is completely certain that he will die, seeing all side-effects and the bad side of the operation. Last, the doctors were not supposed to harm him, even though that they probably knew about the outcome of the surgery, written in the Belmont Report, states “Two general rules have been formulated as complementary expressions of beneficent actions in this sense: 1. Do not harm and 2. Maximize possible benefits and minimize possible harms.”

Read More

W T Vivian Bearing Analysis

755 Words | 4 Pages

Many people would have the assumption that because he is a doctor he must be good, because he wants to save lives. But in the case of Dr. Kelekian, he may have pushed the “saving a life” agenda too far, endangering Vivian’s quality of life.

Read More

How Can Game Theory Determine The Quality And Input Of A Pivotal Vote

311 Words | 2 Pages

to determine the quality and input of a pivotal vote in an election, the mathematical models of game theory come into play. as a result, the outcome of the

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Trolley Problem

2262 Words | 10 Pages

To deal with these dilemmas, utilitarianism and duty ethics theories should be taken into account. For a utilitarian decision maker, who will attempt to maximize the sum of utility for all concerned (Kvalnes, 2015), the third person should pull the switch or push the fat man to reduce the killings from five persons to one person; that is, keeping the number of people died to a minimum. In contrast, in duty ethics perspectives, there are moral considerations more important than

Read More

Analysis: When Living Is A Fate Worse Than Death

859 Words | 4 Pages

In life, we are not guaranteed a long life or even a pain free life. The author talks about a very emotional decision that a young couple must make concerning their critically ill daughter and their journey of choosing to do everything possible to save her life but regrettable not being with her when she died. As the family and the medical team reflect on the life of Charlotte, the young little girl that died, many questions were asked. Did the medical team accurately assess the situation? Did they provide immediate lifesaving treatment?

Read More

Robin Hood Case Summary

773 Words | 4 Pages

This gives him the best outcome options and fits well into his revised strategic

Read More

Strategic Rationality Of Game Theory

880 Words | 4 Pages

Game Theory and the Prisoners’ Dilemma Strategic Rationality In this chapter, Daniel Little indicates that under circumstances of uncertainty and risks, decision-makers attempt to maximize utility through collecting information of the utility and analyzing the probability of each feasible choice. Finally the maximum expected payoff of outcomes is given to the decision-maker since all other decision makers also made the rational decisions. Also strategic rationality is embodied on interactive social behavior that these individual decision-makers make choices regard to predictions about the other decision-makers’ next move in performance, the choices that other agents made lead to the level of outcomes that individual decision-maker would receive. Generally speaking, individual choices are made from strategic interaction and under circumstances of uncertainty.

Read More

Game Theory In Bbc's Sherlock

3830 Words | 16 Pages

BBC’s Sherlock is a modern take on Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s famous sleuth. It is one of the most well plotted shows on television today, and implicitly imbibes various strategic concepts. In this project, we have used our knowledge of game theory to analyze situations from the show. Some of the concepts we have tackled include dominant strategies, sequential games, repeated games, Mexican standoff etc. Our aim has been to derive an equilibrium using game theory and then compare it to the actual outcome on the show.

Read More

More about How To Resuscitate A Dnr In Happily Ever After

Open Document