ipl-logo

How Would Utilitarians View Human Cloning

482 Words2 Pages

1. To what extent do you feel that genetic experimentation should be allowed, especially experiments that involve the creation of human life in the laboratory and the cloning of human beings?
I’m not sure if I agree with cloning at all. I believe that when it is a person time to die then it is their time and no one should get favors. Cloning can create genetical defects and nowhere does it specify that the diseases you already have wont transfer over to your clone.

2. How would Utilitarians view human cloning?
I believe they would not like most of this because most of these clients just want to be cloned for their own benefit and not to help others. They would be very picking for the use of these clones because if it is not helping a mass majority of people then what is the point.

3. Could there be an overall benefit for humanity here?
There could be if the disease that they had did not pass through to the clones and I would need more information like, do the clones …show more content…

If it will transfer the disease then I would not see the point in cloning anyone with a disease because they are just going to pass away eventually just like the original. I would not pick Arthur Williams because of age if the clone does age as well, I would also not pick Philip Taylor because he has a terminal illness, nor would I pick Janice Caldwell. I would not pick Janice only because she wants to have her clone for selfish reason to only benefit herself and only herself, but she claims her writing will help others which no one can every certain. I would have to go with the couple since they want children but cannot have any children and it would be a very interesting trail to study over the course of the clone’s lives. If age and disease was not an issue then I might pick Arthur Williams because he only wants to help others medically and has a very experienced smart

Show More
Related
1357 Words | 6 Pages

For the sake of this essay, we will be concentrating on human cloning for reproductive reasons. I will be analyzing the views of David B. Hershenov in An Argument for Limited Human Cloning and presenting objections brought to us by the Presidential Panel for Bioethics. Hershenov will be taking the affirmative stance against the Presidential Panel who provides the objections to the question “Is human Cloning

Read More
1552 Words | 7 Pages

Cloning is an idea that is often portrayed in science fiction as a way to essentially duplicate another living being. It has been making an appearance in the real world as something that could be useful in the medical and scientific fields as a way to bring back animals or to save peoples’ lives. Due to how unique cloning is, it was portrayed in famous parts of the media such as Jurassic Park. Although cloning does sound promising, it does possess a darker side to it, which does raise both moral and ethical issues. There are articles that do discuss cloning in which they either list the benefits of it or tell us about what moral and ethical issues that do come out of cloning.

Read More
703 Words | 3 Pages

Creating clones for the sole purpose of infecting them with diseases so that medicine can advance quicker is a common theoretical use for human clones, along with creating them for organ or limb transplants (Aurelia, 2011). With the purpose of creating a clone to be to serve another person, this takes away consent of

Read More
1325 Words | 6 Pages

Many believe cloning is a perversion of science, and some are even concerned with a real life Frankenstein situation: “Reproductive cloning… could lead to a Dr. Frankenstein’s vision of lab manufactured humans. To me this is a perversion of science” (Ford 1). Furthermore, in Frankenstein, Dr. Frankenstein detached from the world as he became obsessed with his studies, diminishing his health. A similar thing could happen to scientists who clone if they decide that they are “playing god,” which can be dangerous for the scientists and the clones. Cloning is so controversial and causes an overbearing amount of stress for it to be befitting to the human mind, as Victor Frankenstein puts it, “If the study to which you apply yourself has a tendency to weaken your affections, and to destroy… those simple pleasures in which no alloy can possibly mix, then that study is certainly unlawful… not befitting of the human minds” (Shelley 50).

Read More
1307 Words | 6 Pages

Is it ethical to create human clones for our benefits, notwithstanding those clones area unit whole entities with hearts, souls and wills? McHanan points out, “one potentially valuable use of cloning is to supply a source of tissues or organs for transplantation. the foremost vital objection to the present use of biological research is that a person's clone would be the kind of entity that it might be seriously wrong to kill” (77). Willgoose says, “Many worry that the clone won't be treated as a valued individual, however rather as a possession or commodity” (106, 107). underneath the establishment, clones area unit doubtless to be made for another to human testing of assorted researches or as surgical process donors.

Read More
389 Words | 2 Pages

I believe human cloning interferes with nature in ways humanity will not be able to handle. This source states, " This could lead to a set of problems that we have no ability to handle. " The evidence suggests that human cloning can lead to the fall of humanity, due to clones becoming soverienty. However, some people believe that human cloning can be useful, due to assisting with unlawful interests. I beleive that this will only create misuse of knowledge in trying to correct clones in right paths.

Read More
414 Words | 2 Pages

The outcome of trying to help cure a disease is millions of dead people. Is it worth it? The outcome of human cloning gives people too much power; they can regulate who is in the world and pretty soon, things like what characteristics they possess. I believe that medicine is a gift from God that we can use to try to save people and I think the means of therapeutic cloning are good, but we shouldn’t commit an immoral act like taking someone’s life to try to save another.

Read More
1049 Words | 5 Pages

There are both sides to every argument, in this topic there are people who say cloning is messes with human nature and

Read More
1019 Words | 5 Pages

Human Cloning, an exact replication of an adult human, should be banned in the United States of America because of its possible consequences to society as a whole, as proven by the science fiction novel Frankenstein, by Mary Shelley, and the short story “The Birthmark,” by Nathaniel Hawthorne. Human cloning raises ethical concerns considering how society will react and change due to the clonal population. Subsequently, scientists are forced to ask themselves the question, “If cloning is seen as a way to reproduce the ‘best’ in the human species, who decides which qualities are best?” (Cloning 2). If humans are allowed to clone their offspring, then soon most people would either want their children to look like the idea of ‘perfect’ created

Read More
1021 Words | 5 Pages

With the intention of creating a genetically identical individual which will display most of the same traits as its somatic cell donor. However due to environmental factors the cloned individual is not going to be exactly like its somatic cell donor. Cloning

Read More
432 Words | 2 Pages

Cloning is a something that could really help with humans’ health,but should it be legal. Human cloning should not be legal because it is dangerous because in the past experiments it has not been successful. Which means with no success the clones may not act the same function or do have needed organs to function. Animal cloning should be legal because it will help with human health problems like organs and diseases. As you may see human cloning cannot be legal ,but animal cloning may be legal because the positive solutions to many problems.

Read More
1429 Words | 6 Pages

Since the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights asserts the sanctity of all human life and the necessity to protect it from harm, human cloning also violates international law” (Woodward, Pg.57). With this research, humans have made ourselves the decider of what lives, and what dies, which is not meant for humans as society has deemed that immoral. It directly violates Article three of the declaration where it states that everyone has the right to life, and with that life comes the right to liberty, and security of that person.

Read More
943 Words | 4 Pages

Cloning is a very interesting and debatable topic. It can be very controversial since religion and moral issues are against this practice. On the other hand, science sees it as a huge advance. The food industry think of cloning as an opportunity to produce more and faster. Cloning is not as new as some people may think.

Read More
963 Words | 4 Pages

If you had the choice to start a new life in the same body when you are about to die, would you want to? Well, many people want the possibility to make this choice and is one of the reasons why they are in favor of human cloning. Even though it is tempting to say yes, think about the potential dangerous outcomes and the steps it took to be able to make this choice before supporting the cloning of humans. Human reproductive/therapeutic cloning should be banned everywhere because it disrespects human dignity, there are other alternatives, and most importantly, the low probability of success can lead to endangered potential human life. Human Dignity can be defined as, “...the special elevation of the human species, the special potentiality associated

Read More
1614 Words | 7 Pages

Not only are there many ways in which human cloning can be misused, such as, creating clones for organ donors or replacement children, but cloning has also proved to be rather dangerous (Hoskins). It takes scientists many attempts and many failures before they successfully clone animals and there is no reason to think it would be different with humans (Harrison). Many human embryos would need to be sacrificed in order to protect this practice and many of these children clones who did survive would

Read More

More about How Would Utilitarians View Human Cloning

Related Topics

Open Document