ipl-logo

Montagu Human Nature Essay

1768 Words8 Pages

The biggest issue on which Ashley Montagu and E.O. Wilson disagree is the fundamental nature of humans. Montagu believes humans have no instincts, but that they have been socialized to act aggressively towards each other. His evidence is based on science (evolution). For example, our canines are not for fighting, as previously thought, rather they are for eating plants. Montagu theorizes that before the agricultural revolution, humans were relatively peaceful nomadic hunter-gatherers who did not engage in catastrophic wars. Hunter-gatherer communities developed and survived because of mutual aid and reliance on one another. However, this changed during the agricultural revolution, which separated people and created a person versus person ideology; …show more content…

Humans are rational - meaning they show aggression to protect themselves and their “clans” (their family, country, etc.). Rational beings consider the continuation of life their number one goal. Therefore, this theoretically means humans will not go to war if they think they will lose, as this would put the very thing they were fighting for, life, in danger. Howard’s theory has some merit, no one goes into a war knowing they will ultimately lose. There could be a perceived possibility of lose, but mostly groups think the conflict is something they can win. Why precisely because of the reason howard gives, humans are rational and want to protect their own lives at all costs. Engaging in a large scale war one know they will lose is not something a rational person does. Howard uses the example of Britain participating in World War II in order to maintain their status as The World Power. Power also factors into this theory, as Howard states many times that wars are fought for power. Britain thought they could win WWII because they had a lot of power, and they went into WWII to maintain their power. Though E.O.Wilson is critical of what he would call religious ideology, he relies on Kwame Anthony Appiah’s The Honor Code: How Moral Revolutions Happen which states: “…it takes a sense of honor to drive a soldier beyond doing what is right” but “to make such choices is to live a life of difficulty, even sometimes of

Show More
Related
326 Words | 2 Pages

“One Flew over the Cuckoo's Nest”, written by Ken Kesey is set in a mental hospital in the 1960s. The antagonist, Nurse Ratched, takes the reins of the hospital and dictates everything that happens inside it. In Kesey’s novel, Nurse Ratched abuses her authoritative power and uses it to manipulate and restrain patients to maintain what she calls order in the hospital. Being overly protective is an understatement for her because she pays no regard to the patient's mental and physical health. She focuses on shaping how they act to meet her own standards.

Read More
1376 Words | 6 Pages

They don’t want to be the losers. But to be successful, the military have to come up with strategies that will help them win the battle. Just like the game, the U.S. military places their ships and tanks in strategic places and tries to beat their enemy before the enemy beats them. In the article, Watters goes on to say, “That we in the West develop brains that are wired to see ourselves as separate from others may also be connected to differences in how we reason.” (Watters 501).

Read More
1258 Words | 6 Pages

Sometimes countries go to war for no reason, an example of this is the War of Mexico. The United States was not justified in going to war with Mexico because, they did not organize borderlines with Mexico, Manifest Density was not believed by everyone, and all the US wanted was California. The first reason the Mexican War was not justified is

Read More
442 Words | 2 Pages

This is evident in any war, whether over religion, political views, or just wanting to show why you’re the strongest. Humans want to be right, and in every scenario,

Read More
1156 Words | 5 Pages

Wars should only be fought in self-defense and to stop those that seek to destroy; a war should never be waged with the intention to seek power or dominance over the oppressing party.

Read More
812 Words | 4 Pages

The hunter-gatherer way of life highlighted equality and the sharing of resources. They depended on intense cooperation and sharing, along with a strong egalitarian focus. With egalitarianism being so vital, they believed that all members of their society were equal and should have equal rights. This approach to life deeply benefitted the members of these tribes. The main benefits of this type of society are a balanced power dynamic, a selfless sense of community, and preservation of resources through sharing.

Read More
659 Words | 3 Pages

War is not only a fight between countries, but it is the reason for destruction on Earth. An example of that is World War I, it is one of the worst wars that the U.S. was not included in, but after the actions of the RMS Lusitania and the actions of Germany, the U.S. had to do something. The U.S. had made a wrong choice in joining the war, because it caused the death of many people and the destruction of many lands. The RMS Lusitania was a famous ship in the early 1900s, however it had been taken down by the Germans, and that is what caused the U.S. to enter World War I.

Read More
547 Words | 3 Pages

The Neolithic community started the agricultural revolution in many ways. The process of cultivation and domestication helped the Neolithic population to survive through the harsh weather conditions. They started to make settlements instead of migrating from place to place. When they had gotten a surplus in the food stock they had more time to do things they wanted to do. Gender roles also played a part in the cultivation and domestication process.

Read More
506 Words | 3 Pages

Even without war the loss of human lives is catastrophic. On average 1.8 people die every second. So many lives are lost from illness and accidents for example the highest mortality rate among people is caused Cardiovascular diseases. So if we as people have so many reasons as to why we are dying why would we send people to war send them to die for this warped belief of nationalism. They belived that they needed to fight to solve the worlds problems yet do we ever stop to think is there another way.

Read More
769 Words | 4 Pages

Thus with militarism the fear of being attacked was such a factor that it forced countries to attack

Read More
838 Words | 4 Pages

Nomadic societies never needed to build irrigation systems, and face invasions for there were no such idea of private property. Pastoral and nomadic societies were rather egalitarian, for women and men and all people had equal importance in the group’s survival and ‘shared’ wealth together. The conflicts that pastoral, nomadic societies faced were food shortage, and environmental issues such as climate. These conflicts helped the idea of an egalitarian society to continue on until people started to

Read More
813 Words | 4 Pages

In the novel, Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, Robert Louis Stevenson explores the complexity of human nature. He uses characters and events in the novel to present his stance on the major theme: “man is not truly one, but truly two” (125). Branching from this major theme are many more specific views on the idea that human nature is divided into good and evil. Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde are two very different people who occupy the same body. Human beings struggle with good and evil and Stevenson goes to the extreme to to show this relationship.

Read More
494 Words | 2 Pages

Individuals or groups of people have always had one thing in mind and that is surviving. Surviving means able to expand themselves without losing their traditional social structure and trying to fit in a larger network. Keeping track of who you are and come from holds the cultural meaningful by holding the group together. The Neolithic Revolution has been able to evolve and become a crucial part of being human by lineage exogamy, patrilineal, and matrilineal descent, and kinship and new reproductive technologies. Lineage exogamy means that lineage members must look for their marriages partners in other lineages.

Read More
974 Words | 4 Pages

There is a saying about honor that goes “Honor isn't about making the right choices. It's about dealing with the consequences.” Honor can be seen all throughout literature works: The Wave by Todd Strasser, “Charge of the Light Brigade” by Tennyson, and Much Ado About Nothing by Shakespeare. The Wave by Todd Strasser is about a classroom history experiment that gets out of hand causing history to repeat itself. “Charge of the Light Brigade” by Tennyson is about British soldiers going off to fight a battle they have no chance of winning.

Read More
667 Words | 3 Pages

Yet other historians believe that certain challenges (possibly environmental) forced humans to develop an organized and civilized society. Overall, however, all theories agree on the fact that civilizations were a response to sustain the needs and beliefs of growing human societies. For example, these establishments allowed for an emphasis on a distinct religious structure, a social division based on affluence, as well as an economy that focused largely on trade with neighboring peoples. Such aspects would not have been present in prior small agricultural settlements, since they are much smaller (in size comparison) and less complex. 2.

Read More

More about Montagu Human Nature Essay

Related Topics

Open Document