ipl-logo

Opinionated Vs. Problem-Posing: A Comparative Analysis

701 Words3 Pages

Leonardo Muro-Garcia
Professor Benjamin Dally
English 5 (Section 2)
September 30th, 2015
Opinionated vs. Approachable
The “Banking Concept” is an unreasonable method for teachers to use when it comes to educating students. It creates an environment where teachers feel like they are the "almighty-god" of knowledge and students do not know anything. In contrast, "Problem-Posing" is where teachers pose problems, and then the students and the teacher work cooperatively to find solutions for the problem. The Banking Concept is used to serve the status quo of education. Meaning it will only meet the basic needs of education. It is usually used in areas where poverty is really high and the government does not regulate what the teachers have …show more content…

In problem posing, the “educator constantly re-forms his reflections in the reflection of students” (Freire 263). Meaning it allows the students to learn from the teacher, as well as the teacher from the students. It does it by breaking the barrier from the banking concept that says that the student is just a listener and that the teacher is the talker. Freire also said that in Problem Posing, “it affirms that men and women are beings who transcend themselves” (265). Since it does not oppress people from reality, it proves that people and reality make up one. This helps to build a better future because it grants people the right to become critical thinkers, to have a voice, and it allows them to be aware of the problems happening around them. In addition to all this, it helps students to be better informed on problems or issues whether it be “historical”, or “present”. This is because when teachers allow students to give their opinion, students have the opportunity to question anything and everything the teacher says. For example, if a teacher says its’ “blue”, the student can ask “why” without running the risk of getting in-trouble. Overall, Problem Posing is the best method for educating students because it shapes students to become critical thinkers who become committed to lifelong

Show More
Related

President Jackson's Policy Toward The Second Bank Of The United States

1718 Words | 7 Pages

Banking system is essential in our economics to maintain an effective circulation of money. The bank has functions for regulation of currency to aid strong economy. Distribution of the money is crucial to promote construction of the nation and prevention of bankruptcies. In our modern economic structure is supported and developed by the banking system. However, there was a period that the national bank was shut down by the government the consequence of the bank war.

Read More

The Banking Concept

834 Words | 4 Pages

This role requires the students to take an active role in their education. The “student” must think critically and use reason to solve problems, not merely recite the answers. I do think that Freire’s idea of problem-posing education is superior to the banking method. A comingling of ideas and the flow of thoughts in both directions is the best for both parties involved. Freire makes excellent points in favor of his method over the banking method, for example, the idea that the banking concept can be and is used for the oppression of the students.

Read More

Summary Of Never Say Anything A Kid Can Say Reinhart

606 Words | 3 Pages

Problem Solving Essay Shamyra Thompson Liberty University Summary of Author’s Position In the article “Never Say Anything a Kid Can Say”, the author Steven C. Reinhart shares how there are so many different and creative ways that teachers can teach Math in their classrooms. Reinhart also discussed in his article how he decided not to just teach Math the traditional way but tried using different teaching methods. For example, he tried using the Student-Centered, Problem Based Approach to see how it could be implemented in the classroom while teaching Math to his students. Reinhart found that the approach worked very well for his students and learned that the students enjoyed

Read More

Psy 270 Week 8 Checkpoint

954 Words | 4 Pages

Also, by writing on the board the student’s answer will help students look back on the answers. When working on their group they could have gone back to the example, and refocused themselves on what they should be looking when thinking of the characters viewpoint. Being visually creating in the beginning of teaching the lesson would have avoided students to become confused when working with their group

Read More

Summary Of Response To Living Like Weasels

555 Words | 3 Pages

In the “Problem-Posing” concept students and teachers engage in dialogue and activities that teach one another. After reading this essay, I am convinced that this style of teaching is the proper one, as it allows students to recognize the relationship between them and the real

Read More

Argument Analysis: Hi Yohan

197 Words | 1 Pages

Hi Yohan, I can see where you’re coming from in this discussion. I agree with you on some of your points. For example, I agree that Freire had an overreaction when he said that the banking concept had a “necrophilic” quality. Also, I agree that, due to their expertise, teachers should have more control in the room. The main fault I find in your post was when you said, “It is not the teacher’s job to spoon feed the information to the students and wait for them to understand the information, but instead to provide them the tools necessary to be successful in the future”.

Read More

Was Holden A Tragic Hero

624 Words | 3 Pages

In math gives students a chance to share different methods and angles for solving mathmatical equations. In english, students can analyse characters from different points of view. In every class, students will learn to work together efficiently to gather and organize ideas. Sadly, some students believe "it is a waste of time listening to peers compared to listening to teachers.

Read More

Chapter Summary: In The Norton Field Guild

582 Words | 3 Pages

I believe that this is important because, now days no one likes to ask questions because they feel that people will judge them. But it’s important to ask questions especially if you don’t understand what the teacher is teaching or what you are reading. I also agree that we need to be curious and learning. I agree with this because I feel that if you are curious about learning then you will learn better and that you will retain what you are learning. This is why I believe that this is important

Read More

Soc/100 Final Book Reflection

858 Words | 4 Pages

The topsy turvy practice where teachers try to put themselves in the students shoes, can be very effective because it can help teachers relate to student through their culture and language which can help student learn more effectively. The trouble is for our society is that linguistic racism fails to provide an education for students to come and understand one another in this troubled democracy that favors only the intelligent groups or people that they perceive as

Read More

Banking Concept Of Education Essay

1193 Words | 5 Pages

In my freshman English class, I was terrified to ask questions, to point out typos and inconsistencies, to do anything that might seem like an accusation of incompetence, because all such inquiries were invariably met with our teacher’s universal snappy comeback “Who in this room has a degree?” However efficient it is in discipline, this type of academic domination is useless in seeking understanding because it prevents challenges and emphasizes authority over logic. According to Paulo Freire’s “‘Banking’ Concept of Education”, this is what education has always looked like: the teacher wields absolute unceasing power over the student and the students meekly accept their own subjugation. However, with the increasing commercialization of the education system, the newer consumer model, described by Frank Bruni in “In College Turmoil, Signs of a Changed Relationship with Students”, has emerged in which the students as the consumers wield ultimate power over the teachers to the detriment of their education. Ultimately, the two models disagree on the proper balance of power in the classroom: the banking model empowers

Read More

Pedagogy Of The Oppressed Chapter 2 Analysis

314 Words | 2 Pages

Problem-posing method allows communication among teachers and students. It also allows the students to discover, recognize relationships and express their creativity, leading to transformation. Freire first introduces

Read More

Social Norms In The Mathematics Classroom

280 Words | 2 Pages

Socio-mathematical norms, distinct from social norms due to their specification to aspects of a mathematics classroom, (Yackel, E. & Cobb, P. 1996) are evident in the above transcript. The socio-mathematical norms present included the use of subject specific terminology, such as theoretical, independent and probability, teacher questioning, validation and explanation, student justification, problem-solving and the inclusion of both independent and collaborative work. Seen throughout the transcript the teacher constantly questions the student’s beliefs and asks them to justify their ideas before stepping into either validate their answers or explain the correct concept. This method of drawing out the conversation, and getting students involved,

Read More

Paulo Freire The Banking Concept Of Education Analysis

1168 Words | 5 Pages

We must be consciously considering our existence amongst other people and nature. Problem-posing education will only succeed if the teacher-student relationship is amended (Freire 323). That being said, teachers must realize that they can teach and be taught while the students can learn and teach through current

Read More

Paulo Freire The Banking Concept Of Education Summary

907 Words | 4 Pages

Paulo Freire argues that the relationship between a teacher and a student is a system of oppression. Where a teacher has absolute and total control over their students’ way of thinking. Freire refers to this as “The Banking Concept of Education,” where teachers teach and students listen and don’t question what they are being told. In the banking concept, teachers are depositing and students are the depositories. To Freire the banking system of education is destroying creativity and individualism in student.

Read More

Strengths And Weaknesses Of The Banking Industry

976 Words | 4 Pages

I would frame the banking as an industry that is built on trust. Trust that is reaffirmed by the governments, and regulators. Banks have an imperative role in our economic growth, and development. Correspondingly, without the bank industry, there is no industry to replace them as the conduit for social and economic policy. Equally important, there is no industry to replace them as the key performer in creating our economies multiplier effect.

Read More

More about Opinionated Vs. Problem-Posing: A Comparative Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document