ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of Building A Border Wall In The United States

1660 Words7 Pages

“Build a wall” was the symbol for the political platform of the presidential hopeful Donald Trump during his campaign in the 2016 US election. After winning the election Trump is now facing the realities of building a border wall between the US and Mexico. While Trump works on his wall other methods of keeping undocumented immigrants from entering and working in the United States already exist. Current legislation in Texas has allowed police officers to ask if someone is a legal US citizen (Ghosh), and a proposed E-verify system will give employers the option of checking if a worker is legally in the US before hiring them (Seminara 17). With the effort being put out by local police and legislators already showing promise of a solution a …show more content…

There are, as of 2016, 46 million B-1/B-2 Visas currently being held by foreigners (Seminara 17), while these numbers on their own would not be an issue if everyone on a visa returned home when the Visa mandated them to do so, but since 2008 illegal border crossings have been outnumbered by visa overstays (Seminara 17). The blocking of land borders will only put a small dent in the numbers of illegal overstays because of the amount of crossing not done by land. A US tally conducted in 2016 found that 739,000 foreigners have come to the United States through means other than over land borders and 545,000 are thought to be still residing in the United States as of January 10th 2017 (Seminara …show more content…

The border states of Texas and California who are reliant on migrant workers produce 23 percent of the United States gross domestic product (Gosh). These states along with several others being large producers of agricultural goods are experiencing worker shortages caused by recent immigration crackdowns that have lead to large agricultural losses. In 2011 the state of Georgia decided to crack down on the states illegal immigrants in the workforce which lead to the state losing $140 million in agricultural goods when there weren't enough workers left to harvest the crops. (Gosh). Rumors of the upcoming wall have already started to change foreigners opinion that the United States is a land of opportunity for them and a place to come to work and live (Gosh). The increasing discouragement from the US have all ready lead to work shortages in several border states (Gosh). Some may find relief with this fact but replacing these missing workers with American workers has proven problematic with farm manager Glen Gernetz summing up the issue nicely saying “Though the state had enough unemployed residents nobody wanted to work. It's too damn hard.”

Show More
Related
486 Words | 2 Pages

He claims that the U.S. border control has increased the number of hired agents and improved the strength of border barriers during the past few years. These improvements are critical to illegal immigrants because crossing border becomes much more difficult than before. It is more likely for illegal immigrants to be blocked, detected and arrested. On the other hand, Krikotian writes that the federal government develops several law statements to forbid illegal immigrants. For example, the federal government invents a smart system to scan immigrants’ fingerprints and match them in a public database.

Read More
668 Words | 3 Pages

In 1872 and 890 Congress passed laws restricting illegal immigration of people, criminals, prostitutes, mentally ill and unstable people. Over the years the immigration scale has been broken and is trying to be restored. Even though the U.S border is well secured. Today the U.S has over 42.1 million immigrants. The Western Frontier and Immigration have a few similarities and differences.

Read More
911 Words | 4 Pages

Per capita, we now consume about three gallons a year, triple what we drank 50 years ago” (2). If H-2A visa workers seized to exist, the crops would not get harvested, the vineyards would deteriorate, and vintners would be unable to produce wine. Between the years 2010 and 2015 there was a recorded increase of 14% in wine production making Napa and Sonoma counties the top producers of American wines –producing 85% of America’s wines (Gordon, 3). Production that without the assistance of H-2A visa laborers, would not be possible. And with Napa county wineries’ contribution of $60 billion to the state’s economy annually, the state of

Read More
1177 Words | 5 Pages

The H-2A program affects farmers, as this process is risky, very expensive, comes with a long list of responsibilities and has proven not to be a timely process for the employers of H-2A migrant workers. Although immigration has become necessary to the U.S. agriculture industry for numerous reasons. The effects of the H-2A policy are damaging to this already diminishing empire, these effects are high-risk factors for employers, multiple exorbitant expenses and an unprogressive-timing process. For farmers, once an H-2A worker is officially employed the employer is 100 percent liable for the actions of that worker within a local, state and international

Read More
972 Words | 4 Pages

The issues involving agricultural workers have surrounded me for as long as I can remember. Being able to hear about these problems and then experiencing them myself has sparked my interest for change. Improving these conditions is important because these workers are providing this country’s produce. This category consists of mainly immigrants who are the only ones willing to work in unskilled jobs. The US must protect these workers in order for them to continue working and providing these necessary crops for America.

Read More
631 Words | 3 Pages

The population in the United States is increasing every year. Hundreds of thousands of immigrants, legal and illegal from around the world, come into the United States. Some immigrants have many different motivations, such as hoping to get a chance to a better life, escaping persecution and civil wars in their home country. However, the large number of immigrants is affecting the native-born citizens of the United States. As the result, the President Trump decided to get an executive order that is about protecting the nation from foreign terrorist entry into the United States.

Read More
1342 Words | 6 Pages

Illegal immigrants evidently have had the ability to leach off of the American government, due to Obamacare. Illegal immigration is without a doubt one of the most attention needing problems the United States faces. The adversity devised from the jobs that illegal immigrants have apprehended from US citizens is formidable. President Trump has promised that he will reform the immigration laws and following his presidential campaign promise, building a large wall that separates Mexico and The United States. Building the wall reassures the population that we are indeed safe, we are a powerful country and there is no free ride in the land of hope and possibility.

Read More
135 Words | 1 Pages

We have the Bridge of the Americas, known as the Cordoba Bridge or Free Bridge in borderland parlance, carries more than just commercial trucks and routine travelers between the northern Mexican city of Ciudad Juarez and El Paso, Texas. Over the years the border crossing over the Rio Grande has also served as a bridge between social movements and political ideas with transcendence in Mexico, the United States and across the globe. Those of us that have work in the countryside confront a grave economic crisis. The prices for electricity, diesel, gasoline and fertilizers what we use for producing food for the whole population are very expensive. This situation affects all of us who plant and produce food, the transporters, and those of us who

Read More
1633 Words | 7 Pages

The U.S. political landscape is influenced by the debates over immigration and the pros and cons associated with it. It is necessary for policymakers to construct a compatible secure, economic, and humanitarian environment in this country. It has always been a challenge for Congress to formulate comprehensive immigration reform that support the country regarding security and economic issues. The Congress was also unable to incorporate the implication of vital policy decisions into the judicial and executive branch of the government that would enable the whole system to take certain actions against illegal immigration, which somehow was causing scarcity of resources. This issue also causes a severe effect on the economy and security of the United

Read More
574 Words | 3 Pages

Christopher Samaras March 1, 2015 BUS 102-OL Immigration Law Paper The Immigration Act has been developed to limit the number of immigrants by having them legally enter the U.S. Due to this, many illegal immigrants are being sought out and deported back to their country of origin. Though many immigrants look to America as the land of opportunity, in reality it can be as strict as any other country. Even though there was a “census form” developed from Ronald Reagan’s “immigration bill” in 1986, which provides a sort of “amnesty”, illegal immigrants still cross the border instead of filling out the necessary documentation (Kenny, 38) Like most laws, there are advantages and disadvantages to this immigration law. When it comes to

Read More
386 Words | 2 Pages

In only one area, seasonal agricultural jobs, is there a case where we need more temporary workers, and we already have a federal program to fill those jobs legally. . .” Many other Americans would agree with this statement. On the other hand many articles talk about how many farmers are demanding a law to fill jobs that are needed for growing season. This author may be correct in the fact that Americans and legal immigrants fill most of the jobs needed, but for seasonal agriculture we are in need of many more

Read More
526 Words | 3 Pages

Despite the multiple attempts at creating a well-rounded immigration reform the United States has failed to achieve the full capacity of the reform. The United States first failure at the reform was in 1986 when congress passed the “Immigration Reform and Control Act”. The purpose of this legislation was to amend, revise, and re-assess the status of unauthorized immigrants set forth in the Immigration and Nationality Act. The content of this bill is overwhelming and is divided into many sections such as control of unauthorized immigration, legalization and reform of legal immigration.

Read More
1111 Words | 5 Pages

Nowadays about 11 million illegal immigrants resides in the US. Their number is many times higher than the quota of immigration policy indicators allows (Institute for Democracy and Cooperation 2010). . The problem established immigrants recently acquired a new quality.

Read More
513 Words | 3 Pages

The high unemployment rate is not only a result of stressed market factors, but it has also been created-and prolonged-by our illegal immigration problem (Confer B, 2012). The number of illegal immigrants in the United States ranges from 9 to 20 million with

Read More
1789 Words | 8 Pages

Among the illegal immigrants currently living in the United States, continuously crossing the borders and remaining in the United Stated with expired visas each year. Unlawful immigration once an issue of border states such as Arizona or Texas is now impacting all states around the country with problems. Illegal immigration affects all aspects of civilization, from the cost of education, government assistance, and public safety. There is also the matter of when local law enforcement who make it a personal mission to seek out undocumented immigrant 's harassment demanding documents. Although the Federal Government has all authority over the regulating of migration into the United States, the State and local law enforcement and communities are an essential role in improving on the immigration law, and it is effectively enforced.

Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of Building A Border Wall In The United States

Related Topics

Open Document