ipl-logo

Pros And Cons Of The Ashley Treatment

943 Words4 Pages

1. The Ashley Treatment, or growth attenuation, is a procedure to inhibit the growth of a child with disabilities to make it easier for their parents or caregivers to take care of them. The side that is for the Ashley Treatment says it will be easier for the parents to take care of their child if they use the growth attenuation treatment to inhibit her growth, as she will be easier for them to move around at a smaller size. They also say that Ashley has the mind of an infant, and since this makes her dependent on her caregivers, it is best to make her easier to carry (Freeman, 2007). Additionally, they say that this treatment will make it less likely that caregivers will sexually abuse her. Also, they say that keeping her this small will allow her to still ride many of the children’s rides she enjoys (Jordan, 2009). The pro-Ashley Treatment side say that removing her breast tissue will prevent her feeling any …show more content…

My stance on the issue is on the side against the Ashley Treatment. I feel that the cons of the treatment far outweigh the possible pros. In my opinion, the arguments on the con side are stronger than the arguments on the pro side. One bias that may be affecting my opinion on the issue is confirmation bias. When I first started reading about this issue, the first few sources I found were either neutral about or for the Ashley Treatment. However, I felt that I was probably against the treatment, and wanted to find out more from the side against the treatment. Because of this, most of my sources lean towards being disapproving of growth attenuation. Another bias possibly affecting my judgment is that when issues like this arise with one side mainly being parents of people with disabilities and the other side mainly being people with disabilities, I side with the people with disabilities. I believe that people with disabilities have a deeper understanding of these issues because these issues impact their whole lives and affect their experience of the

Show More
Related
973 Words | 4 Pages

Her mother, Lauraine, had Ashley when she was only seventeen

Read More
458 Words | 2 Pages

Following, meeting Ashley Samsonite for his first time at Local 16, he searched for her Facebook. Evidently, Josh was extremely excited to meet her and was adventurous to find Ashley. “Five Ashley Samsonite’s had accepted my friend request,” (Sundquist 325). Josh transitioned; accordingly, he took more risks and gained confidence as he learned he was the only individual pertaining to an issue with his leg. He felt apprehensive to receive rejection from the women he liked.

Read More
8617 Words | 35 Pages

It is important not to stereotype a child with a disability, as this can lead to low self-esteem, for example a child with specific learning needs might be expected to do poorly in all subjects at school not just the ones affected by the learning need and this is not always the case. Since I have worked in our setting I have been introduced to quite a few children which have different types of disabilities. We aim to make sure that each individual is treated the same and included in all activities by adapting the activity to the child's individual

Read More
266 Words | 2 Pages

The facts are probable about her condition. Making this the best choice for her. Ashley is brain dead and is not able to make any decisions of her own. Ashley’s parents chose to do this based on the facts that the Doctors gave them. They already knew that their child would never say mama, walk, eat on her own, or even go to school.

Read More
618 Words | 3 Pages

The Use of Language and Rhetoric in the Gettysburg Address Christopher Warren Colorado State University Global Campus February 4, 2023 The Use of Language and Rhetoric in the Gettysburg Address President Abraham Lincoln delivered a powerful and patriotic speech to his constituents on November 19, 1863, which came to be known as the “Gettysburg Address.” Lincoln delivered few public speeches during his time as president, with his inauguration addresses, the Gettysburg Address, and his final speech on April 11, 1865 (Arthur et al., 2003). Lincoln’s speech barely lasted two minutes, yet it had a lasting impact because it touched on themes of freedom, equality, and the purpose of government, which resonated with his audience (Schnall, 2014).

Read More
1151 Words | 5 Pages

Hershey feels that there is evidence in society that the majority feel that people with disabilities need to be “fixed” or “cured”. Hershey also feels that the majority feel that the problem should just “go away”. The passage that best supports this, she goes on to say “one of my major objections to the telethon is the way it reinforces that attitude.” Hershey goes on to explain that some people with disabilities keep quiet instead of demanding their basic human needs to be met. I was struck by Hershey stating “we’ll never recognize them if we stay focused on curing individuals of disability, rather than making changes to accommodate disability into our culture.”

Read More
1187 Words | 5 Pages

Although the video did not show a direct case of a disability, it still represented disabilities in a realistic way. At first I did not believe the video was going to represent children with disabilities at all, but then the speaker, Todd Rose, switched to a focus on student who are weak in areas. The first thing that came to my mind was autism, because sometimes children with autism can be very intelligent in some areas, but lack talents in others. Now that I saw the connection between the video and some disabilities I have learned about, I chose to say the video definitely represented people with disabilities. People with disabilities are definitely not average, but they are talented in their own unique way.

Read More
444 Words | 2 Pages

For most people, it is not easy getting in front of a camera and pointing out insecurities and be positive, yet Graham does that for a living. Young girls have been programmed to want to look a certain way that is praised by their peers. Ashley Graham shows young women to be positive and learn to love the insecurities that may be present. Also, whenever Ashley Graham is live on television, she always have a smile on her face and is generous to her fans. Women need to be positive about loving their body and themselves.

Read More
446 Words | 2 Pages

The Ashley case was about a medical procedure done that went over the line of biological ethicality for many. The scenario has a plethora of factors to consider when questioning its ethicality. Even with all of the facts, both options have negative results It was a highly debated decision made by two parents that was sure to set precedent for future medical practices.

Read More
459 Words | 2 Pages

Being granted the opportunity to study with the McWilliams program will aid in further enhancing my short and long-term goals in Bioinformatics and Clinical Research. To begin, my short-term goal is to deepen my expertise in this field. I aspire to refine my skills in data analysis, project management and healthcare administration, all while actively contributing to the development of healthcare solutions that improve patient outcomes and streamline processes. Primarily, I aim to develop skills and characteristics that are also valuable in real-world settings and particularly relevant within the healthcare bioinformatics domain.

Read More
1178 Words | 5 Pages

Example (quote/evidence) Today, while some counselors still use physical treatments like aversive conditioning, the techniques most commonly used include a variety of behavioral, cognitive, psychoanalytic, and other practices that try to change or reduce same-sex attraction or alter a person’s gender identity. [nclrights.org] Aversive therapy is still used and is damaging, and the psychoanalytical methods though they may not be physically (evidently) damaging, they can have other effects below the surface that do just as much damage as something you might see on the outiside. Like... Example (quote/evidence)

Read More
1267 Words | 6 Pages

1.2 What are the typical impacts of these on children and young people? Majority of the disable people may lead to experience the adulthood transition differently towards the non-disabled peers. It is true that with possible restriction imposed on their routine schedule; especially the ones that are disabled in childhood might be more insulated from peer effects and less towards getting engage in risky actions (Kirk, 2008).

Read More
335 Words | 2 Pages

While disabilities may be embraced and not feel like

Read More
1261 Words | 6 Pages

Paper 1: BEHAVIOR MODIFICATION Becky Templin Clovis Community College February 17, 2018 Introduction The theory behind behavior modification ethics has a reputation for its accomplishments and disappointments. In addition to this, there are many dangers in using physical punishment as behavior modification with the two primary modifiers of behavior being Classical conditioning and Operant conditioning. The outcome of using negative reinforcement has its share of benefits and downfalls in human behavior whereas; positive reinforcement seems to win over.

Read More
765 Words | 4 Pages

The reason for this is because the cause can be very difficult to determine. For socially constructed disabilities, it is important to determine if the cause is actually a disability or if the child is does not fit into the expected norms of society. In other words, is this a true disability or is it considered a disability due to social norms and standards. Furthermore, do these social constructs cause the exclusion of students from general education classroom or other situation that students would normally be allowed to participate?

Read More

More about Pros And Cons Of The Ashley Treatment

Related Topics

Open Document