ipl-logo

Reasons For Why The Queensland Government Decided To Let The Mining Company Monitor Itself

954 Words4 Pages

Provide two possible reasons for why the Queensland government decided to let the mining company monitor itself. Use material to illustrate your argument?

The Queensland government decided to allow the mining company Xstrata to monitor the Mount Isa mine by itself due to government legislation. This legislation was passed in 1985 by the Joh Bjelke-Petersen’s government. It allowed the mine to emit triple the emissions permitted under the national environmental regulations. The mining company was also given the power to monitor its own operations a task often left to the EPA. The government also allowed the mine to to monitor itself due to the size of the town, as Ian Wilson points out that in the past Mount Isa was not considered “a big enough …show more content…

Whilst the industry has “brought jobs and prosperity” employing 4000 people and another 5000 indirectly. It has lead to a deterioration in basic human rights “a survey completed in 1994 found excessive lead in 36.4 per cent of the town’s children.” Both Xstrata and the QLD government must ensure that adequate health procedures are put in place. Turley describes Xstrata’s 15 air-quality monitors as “the most intensive monitoring system in Australia. Although Xstrata provides key job opportunities it must also be held accountable for its disregard to human health an issue the government must aim to address.

Provide three issue related factors in ethical decision making to explain the resident’s unwillingness to act against the mine company. Use case material to illustrate your arguments:

Moral intensity is a construct that relates to issues in terms of their perceived moral significance. Individual’s perceptions of moral intensity should impact their recognition of issues as posing moral dilemmas and should affect ethical judgements and behavioural intentions regarding issues. These include social consensus the degree to which people agree over the ethics of a problem or action “they say don’t bite the hand that feeds you. Whilst on the other hand “will she be able to have her own children or hold down a …show more content…

A qualitative questionnaire can be used to gather facts about an individual’s beliefs, feelings and experiences. For example, asking a resident if they think lead is dangerous can get answered with both a positive and negative response. A positive response is “I’ve lived here for 37 years, raised two healthy sons…” contradicted with a negative response “I’ve lived here for 35 years as well, but now I’m the one with a child whose blood level is 31.5…”. Therefore, a qualitative questionnaire is appropriate when trying to understand an individual’s

Show More
Related
550 Words | 3 Pages

SAT PRACTICE ESSAY: JIMMY CARTER Whether or not the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge should be developed for industry is a national concern. In this passage, Jimmy Carter builds an argument to persuade his audience that the Refuge not be developed for industry. Cater effectively builds a persuasive argument using various rhetorical strategies, however his argument may be made stronger in several ways.

Read More
1013 Words | 5 Pages

To resolve this conflict of interest, I would like to use Thomas White’s Framework. Thomas White’s framework for ethical decision making should be more useful to deal with situations in dilemma. White’s framework states: • Analyze the consequences and collecting necessary information. • Analyze the actions. • Making the final decisions.

Read More
1150 Words | 5 Pages

4. Comment on each of the ethical issues mentioned in this case. Rank them

Read More
1882 Words | 8 Pages

This is my Final Exam Essay, for Intro Qualitative Research Analysis Fall 2014. This paper will discuss the qualitative research, and its probability to be legitimate and reliable. I see this as an important discussion to any debate. The center inquiry of this essay is can qualitative research be properly legitimate and reliable? It is worth specifying that there are more than one response to this question, this nonetheless, in my perspective is one of 5 the wonders of social science that there can be more than one conceivable response to an addressed question; Not looking for a yes or no

Read More
901 Words | 4 Pages

Semi-structured interviews were conducted as part of this investigation. (See Appendix 3). Qualitative research is usually concerned with meaning, and in particular how people make sense of the world and how participants experience events from their perspective. In order to be meaningful, then the project of psychology has to have some means of theorizing within in the contexts in which they live. Qualitative researchers have demonstrated that qualitative methods, especially within longitudinal studies involving a series of informal semi-structured interview can reflect inconstancies and contradictions within and between individual’s accounts as an important focus for analysis, and this has been one of the advantages for discourse analysis (Willig,

Read More
847 Words | 4 Pages

In the world of business, there are also ethical situations where manager’s judgment and ethical concepts are put to test, and it is of the utmost importance that the right call is made.

Read More
635 Words | 3 Pages

Researchers have put the reliability of qualitative research to the test by evaluating these four criteria: 1) sensitivity to context, 2) commitment and rigour, 3) transparency and coherence and 4) impact and importance of the study (393). Researchers use these methods to see whether the data is valuable and important, some researchers question the reliability of qualitative research but it is important to note that there are pros and cons of every research

Read More
1230 Words | 5 Pages

The theoretical for a defined construct of moral integrity included three components as follows: Discernment: refer to ability to think about and weights what is morally right from morally wrong. This requires moral reflectiveness on the meaning of good and bad as well as how that meaning applies to self and others. There are included the ability of person to draw conclusions from thinking to develop convictions and ability to think independently to decide what the mosttruly and deeply believes to do the right thing. Consistent act: refer to ability to continue doing on those convictions that reliably across time and situation.

Read More
1193 Words | 5 Pages

There are seven perspectives on ethical theory: consequentialism, natural law, duty, rights, virtue, instinct, and authority. Each of them relate to morality and decision-making. Some, however, are debated more so than others by their properties and which are best to use when solving problems. Among the perspectives there is one that can be applied the best towards morality and solving problems. Virtue is one of the strongest of the seven perspectives on ethical theory that can be used best to solve problems a society is faced with, based on the premise that this perspective is tied in with the importance of character building, is related to the Golden Mean and Aristotle, has concepts that humans naturally prefer, and is a more natural and

Read More
702 Words | 3 Pages

Principles for implementing duty of care in HSC or CYP settings R/601/1436 1. Explain what I t means to follow aduty of care in your work role Duty of Care is defined simply as a legal obligation to: always act in the best interest of individuals and others. not act or fail to act in a way that results in harm. act within your competence and not take on anything you do not believe you can safely do. 2.

Read More
2076 Words | 9 Pages

Punch (2008) adds that qualitative research not only uses numerical and unstructured data but has research questions and methods which are more wide-ranging at the start, and become more focused as the study advances. THE ADVANTAGES OF QUALITATIVE RESEARCH Barbour (2008, p.11-140) brings out distinctive points on qualitative research which are; 1. Answers very difficult questions from those addressed by quantitative research. 2. Can make visible and unpick the mechanisms which link particular variables, by looking at explanations, or accounts provided by those involved.

Read More
1260 Words | 6 Pages

Chapter I: Introduction Moral judgments are made on a daily basis irrespective of whether or not a sense of morality exists, which may or may not be acceptable or ethical. However, what drives one to make such a moral judgments? Scholars are of the view that cultural values, education, intuition, tradition, and religious laws influence moral judgment in rather different ways. Jean Piaget, along with other developmental psychologists, underrated the effect of religion on an individual’s moral development. It was viewed that moral development emerges from the action of people during the adolescent period by constructing and reconstructing their knowledge of the world as a result of their interactions with the environment and society.

Read More
1006 Words | 5 Pages

Morality, commonly defined as, “a system of rules, psychological states, and modes of character development which performs the function of enabling mutually beneficial social cooperation” (Luco 1). Morals arise in many ways. Some morals come through family and childhood upbringing while other morals are provided by the church. Some say that religion is inessential for morality. On the contrary, others provide that religion provides a foundation for moral growth.

Read More
976 Words | 4 Pages

The Need for Religion on Morality Morality, commonly defined as, “a system of rules, psychological states, and modes of character development which performs the function of enabling mutually beneficial social cooperation” (Luco 1). Morals arise in many ways. Some morals come through family and childhood upbringing while other morals are provided by the church. Some say that religion is inessential for morality. On the contrary, others provide that religion provides a foundation for moral growth.

Read More
978 Words | 4 Pages

This study will anchor on the theory that the teaching performance of the teachers in district II depends on the instructional competence as a reflect in the performance rating supported by the following thinkers. The Theory of Performance (Frontiers of Education Volume I, 2006) Theory of Performance Wallace Bacon (2001) considered by many to be the father of performance theory. In his statement, Bacon writes, “Our center is in the interaction between readers and text which enriches, extends, clarifies and alters the interior and even the exterior lives of students.

Read More

More about Reasons For Why The Queensland Government Decided To Let The Mining Company Monitor Itself

Related Topics

Open Document