ipl-logo

Similarities Between Romeo And Juliet And Catcher In The Rye

765 Words4 Pages

We are making decisions every second, and emotions are always involved, but too much is not right. Making emotional decisions leads to negative outcomes. From The Catcher in the Rye written by J. D. Salinger and Romeo and Juliet written by William Shakespeare, we learnt that making decisions with only emotion is fast, but it is not thought enough; often based on bias opinion; and the result is not considered. Making decision with emotions is too fast that it is not thoughtful enough. The logic part of the factors is often not included. In The Catcher in the Rye, when Holden decided to fight Stradlater, he didn’t think before he did it because he was under the hatred emotion of what Stradlater might have done with Jean. Sometime, the decision …show more content…

Just like when you decide where to eat, you will most likely based on what you like to eat more than the price, but is it the best is another question. Always against something when making a decision is not a good thing. In The Catcher in the Rye, Holden is always against phonies, which is responsible for him not being able to make friends and have trouble with other people throughout the story. Making decision based on bias without understanding the situation will cause a lot of trouble. For example, in Romeo and Juliet, “O, he’s lovely gentlemen.” Referring to Paris, indicates that the Nurse told Juliet to marry Paris and forget about Romeo because she favor Paris. Ignored the fact that Juliet was in love and married Romeo. This led to losing Juliet’s trust and might have avoided the tragedy with more people knowing what was happening or helping. A quotation from Romeo and Juliet shows us how not to interfere with decision with personal opinion, “Some shall be pardoned, and some shell be punished.” (IV, III, 315) Despite the Prince lost his kinsmen, Paris, he still judge according to the law to put an end to the tragedy as nether the Montague and Capulet was responsible for the tragedy except those who hid Romeo and Juliet’s marriage and Friar Laurence was also not responsible because of his service. Bias opinion often lead to emotional decision and eventually a bad outcome, therefore, we must consider all the factors to

Show More
Related
585 Words | 3 Pages

She knew Juliet was just 13-year-old but still decides to go and do everything Juliet tells her too, like to talk to Romeo and ask him when they’re getting married and what time. The nurse also tells Juliet she wants, wishes to see Juliet get married someday. For example, it states in document B lines 8-10, “Thou wast the prettiest babe that e’er I nursed. An I might live to see thee married once, I have my wish”. The nurse is the one to blame she knew that Juliet mother wanted Juliet to get married with Paris and no one else but she did the opposite and took her to Romeo so they could get

Read More
2020 Words | 9 Pages

He states that the nurses decision was impulsive which is not true. It would be a completely logical decision to vote for Paris and not Romeo since he’s been banished. The only way Romeo and Juliet could be together was if Juliet left Verona forever which is something both the Nurse and the rest of the Capulet’s oppose, so choosing a more stable husband would be the smarter choice. Also, the Nurse knows that Juliet has to get

Read More
902 Words | 4 Pages

Friar Laurence should have planned for all possibilities when having Juliet's life in his hands. Nurse had always been there for Juliet, she was like her mother. Nurse Could never give Juliet up because she loved her. Juliet talked with her father and he told her if she does not marry Paris, Juliet will have to go live on the streets with no money. Juliet decided to not marry Paris

Read More
273 Words | 2 Pages

I agree with the Nurse when she says that Juliet should marry Count Paris. Juliet does not agree with any of this and believes that Romeo is her better option because he loves her back. This will cause the relationship that Juliet has with the nurse to be damaged. For example, at the end of Scene 5 of Act 3, Juliet is on her way to the Friar's cell when she says, "I'll to the friars to know his remedy. If all else fail, myself have power to die.

Read More
1221 Words | 5 Pages

In consideration of the numerous conflicts in the William Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, the outcome of the deaths of the two main characters were provoked by Juliet’s nurse. Without this character in this play, much of the tragedy would have not have occurred. The nurse is like a mother and basically raised Juliet like a daughter, which means that she is a mentor for Juliet’s exclusive love life. Firstly, the nurse pressures Juliet various times throughout the play to go after Paris, but that is not what Juliet wants. The nurse relays information to Juliet in a negative way consistently, causing Juliet to become irritated and even causing suicidal thoughts.

Read More
536 Words | 3 Pages

So who was to blame you ask? In all honesty I think that the nurse was the one to blame for Romeo and Juliet's tragic end. the reasoning behind my saying Is When Juliet's father try to force Hurt into marriage the nurse was there to also say that Juliet should marry Paris. After that Juliet decided not to speak about her problems or anything she was thinking about what the nurse.

Read More
478 Words | 2 Pages

Her naivety blinds her to the potential dangers of the clandestine marriage between Romeo and Juliet, leading to a lack of caution in their interactions. Rather than exercising prudence and urging restraint, the Nurse enables their forbidden love affair by facilitating their secret meetings, thereby disregarding the implications of their actions. Her negligence in considering the potential repercussions of their relationship directly contributes to the mounting tensions and escalating violence that ultimately leads to their untimely deaths. Despite her position of trust and loyalty to Juliet, the Nurse's allegiance proves questionable when confronted with conflicting loyalties. In Act III, when Juliet's world collapses following Romeo's banishment, the Nurse advises her to abandon Romeo and marry Paris, betraying the deep bond she once shared with Juliet.

Read More
611 Words | 3 Pages

The Nurse is at fault because she’s the closest thing to a mother that Juliet has, but in her time of need, she goes against Juliet and tells her to marry Paris. “Then since things are the way they are, I think the best thing to do is marry the Count. ”(Shakespeare III, V, 205). Though The Nurse carries the blame for betraying Juliet which started her spiral of lies, Friar Lawrence is still to blame because he failed at spreading the word to Romeo which led to his death by poison and Juliet’s death by grief and killing herself. ”It worked as I planned.

Read More
439 Words | 2 Pages

She never intended to make her kill herself for Romeo. Once Romeo told her the news about the marriage she tried to make excuses and fake an injury when it was time to tell Juliet the news. The nurse believed that Juliet was better off marrying Paris and not a criminal(Romeo). If Juliet wasn’t such a brat and had done what she was told to, no one would have

Read More
817 Words | 4 Pages

Romeo!”(3.2.42-44) Juliet’s nurse, who helped with many of the pair’s sneaking around, turns her back on Romeo. The nurse urges Juliet to marry Paris. Juliet then loses her only supporter of her relationship with Romeo. She is forced to find support elsewhere.

Read More
853 Words | 4 Pages

This exchange of information shows that the nurse wants Romeo to know how Juliet feels because she wants them to stay together. Later, when Juliet is convinced that she is in love with Romeo, the nurse tells her she made the wrong choice. She says, “Well, you have made a simple choice; you know how to/ choose a man: Romeo! / ... he is not the flower of courtesy” (40). The nurse is now saying that she thinks Juliet made the wrong choice choosing Romeo and she should have chosen her family's recommendation, Paris.

Read More
1020 Words | 5 Pages

In Shakespeare’s play Romeo and Juliet, the Nurse tells Juliet to meet at Friar Lawrence’s cell so that she could marry Romeo in secret. Clearly, this instance exemplifies how someone could have one’s best interests in mind, and genuinely want to see others happy in life. In this play, Romeo and Juliet, one of the central ideas is one’s should not make big decisions based on emotions alone. An event that occurred in this play proves why one shouldn't make decisions based off of emotions are the deaths of Romeo and Juliet. While at the end of the day, it is our individual lives, the opinions of others should affect ones choices and destinies because the person giving advice might genuinely want to see others happy, one can be impulsive when

Read More
461 Words | 2 Pages

Lady Capulet and the Nurse weren’t being understanding or supporting either, which caused her to go to Friar Lawrence. Lord Capulet wanted Juliet to marry Paris so the Capulet’s status would increase since now they would be part of

Read More
449 Words | 2 Pages

The nurse knew this was a bad idea because Juliet was already married to Romeo, so this caused Juliet to rebel against her caretaker and go through with Friar Laurence’s

Read More
585 Words | 3 Pages

The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare is a well-known play about two young lovers who take their lives so that they can be together, but were there people who drove them to their ends? Surely there had to be, and characters such as The Nurse, Lord Capulet, and Paris should be blamed for their dramatic deaths, but the characters of Friar Lawrence, Friar John, and The Prince should be pardoned. Being one of the characters that had a substantial part in Romeo and Juliet's marriage, The Nurse made a big mistake and let Juliet down. When Juliet asked for comfort from The Nurse after her father told her she had to marry Paris on Thursday, The Nurse responded by saying, “I think you are happy in this second match, for it excels your first; or if it did not, your first is dead-or ‘twere as good he were as living here and you no use of him.” (3.4.224-227) Because The Nurse told Juliet she should marry Paris since Romeo is banished, she pushed Juliet to think more about taking extreme measures.

Read More

More about Similarities Between Romeo And Juliet And Catcher In The Rye

Related Topics

Open Document