ipl-logo

Stolen Vehicle Case Study

2417 Words10 Pages

Assessment title: Case Study
What would be the potential evidences that could prove or disprove the 3 suspect’s involvement in the robbery and of the stolen vehicle? What evidence may have been available but may not be any more due to the circumstances of the scenario?
Scenario:
In this scenario given, 2 men robbed a bookmakers with another man waiting outside in a getaway car (Red Ford Focus) which had been stolen earlier that day. 2 balaclavas, a sawn off shotgun and 2 pairs of marigold gloves were recovered from the getaway car.

Car Break-in and theft:
For the crime of the theft of the car, there is a large amount of evidence that could/would be collected, if it is available. This could have been damaged or destroyed in the time after either …show more content…

This shows that a gun has been fired in close proximity to the clothing recently. Unless the suspect had another reason for being in close proximity to a weapon being discharged, it is good evidence against the suspect.

Evaluation of evidence:
In this scenario, there is a huge amount of evidence that could be collected. The evidence could be only related to one of the crimes (e.g. Shotgun) or it could be related to both of them (e.g. suspects clothing). Although there is many different types of evidence (Fingerprints, Fibres, Hair, DNA etc.) that could have been found at these two crime scenes, the majority of it could be used to provide a conviction, if it could be found.
However, if the evidence is not found, it does not however mean that the suspect did not commit the crime. To quote Carl Sagan, “Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence” (1996). This means that although evidence that would be expected to be found, that is not, does not mean that the crime was not committed as such, just that the evidence was not found or recovered. This is assumed due to Locards principle in which when two objects touch, each leaves a trace on the other (Erzinclioglu, 1997) which has since become a fundamental law for

Show More
Related

Evidence Surrounding The Serial Podcast: The Case Of Adnan Syed

940 Words | 4 Pages

His fingerprints were found on a map that was in the glove compartment of the victim's car. The map had the defendant's fingerprints on it, which suggested that he had handled the map at some point. This was used as evidence that he had been in the car around the time of the murder; However it just tells you that he touched a map that was in her car, they were in a relationship so they would have been physically intimate with each other. The presence of his fingerprints on the map found in the victim's car was used as evidence against him at his trial. The serial podcast goes through each one of these outcomes and Sarah Koenig shows that the evidence that they put into the trial should not have been admissible.

Read More

Jamie Rogers Murder Of Nik Pastenek

762 Words | 4 Pages

The only clothing on the crime scene had belonged to Jamie, his yellow cloth from his sweater had been all over the crime scene. The detective, Mattie Gunderson had stated that all the evidence did lead to the investigation of Jamie Rogers, which is why the accused had been charged. The defence had also argued that Devon Moore didn’t think that Jamie was the murder which is an opinionated statement. There is no hard evidence that Jamie isn’t guilty, the evidence all points to Jamie Rogers. The blood found on Jamie's clothing had belonged to Pasternak and given the situation the two were in, there was tension between the two.

Read More

Summary: The Case Of Sabrina Limon

708 Words | 3 Pages

This information is significant because it has provided the prosecuting team with direct insight into the conspiracy and what roles were played by the couple. The strength of this evidence added substantial weight to the case against Sabrina. Generally, physical evidence helps verify one’s testimony within a case, which is evident with Hearn’s testimony because he was assisted by recorded conversations and screenshots of text messages. Overall, the presence of strong evidence was fundamental in the Sabrina Limon case as it provided solid foundations for the prosecution’s arguments which ensured credibility of the witnesses’ testimonies as it would ultimately lead to a conviction that demonstrated beyond reasonable doubt that Sabrina Limon played a role in the death of her husband. This case stands as an indication of the intricate work of the judicial system as it navigates the complexities of a high-profile murder trial.

Read More

Steve Harmon Is Not Guilty In 'Monster' By Walter Dean Myers

476 Words | 2 Pages

Now, one thing that doesn’t help prove his innocence is that we don’t know where he was during the robbery. When asked about his location he states: “ I don’t know exactly where I was when the robbery took place…”And it doesn’t help that the only people who testify to his location are saying that he was involved in the robbery. But as previously stated, everyone who testifies against him has reason to lie and everything they say is within the realm of reasonable

Read More

David Eldridge Quilty Case

683 Words | 3 Pages

For the following evidence presented, please consider that there is reasonable doubt in the case of David Edridge. Mr. Eldridge’s footprints were on the floor near the crime scene, though he had quit that morning, he was the only one to have the key to the restaurant and the code to the safe other than Mr. Armrs, and two important pieces of evidence are that it hasn’t been proven if Mr.

Read More

Adnan Syed's Disappearance Physical Evidence

1406 Words | 6 Pages

1, p. 6). She explains how the investigators did not find any physical evidence because usually in a murder investigation, there has to be some physical evidence because it helps the investigators identify the killer of the victim. Even though some prints lead back to Adnan, it still doesn’t mean that those prints were from that day because Adnan has been dating Hae and Adnan probably touched Hae’s car. To add on, Sarah claims that when she interviewed the students from Hae and Adnan’s school, no one said that they saw Hae leave school with him, and that he wasn’t even near Hae’s car. Sarah Koenig explains, “Okay, so no one actually testified at trial that they saw Hae and Adnan leave school together.

Read More

Who Was Mr. David Eldridge's Guilty?

449 Words | 2 Pages

Mr. David Eldridge is guilty because there is no sound evidence. A strong piece of evidence presented was that Mr Eldridge had in his possession the stolen spatula with Mr Arm’s blood on it. Also, police noted that a spatula had been stolen from Mr Arms by Mr Eldridge and was never returned. But, it was then found in Mr Eldridge’s house with his fingerprints along with Mr Arms’s blood on it. Then, the police reported that Mr Arms had bled from a cut along his neck from a metal spatula.

Read More

Research Paper On Amanda Knox

1160 Words | 5 Pages

They also found that Kercher's DNA had not been present on the knife found at Soleccito's flat.(Amanda Knox 2). This proof implies that Knox and Sollecito cannot be guilty unless further investigation proves the previous claim wrong. There were many controversial evidences that turned out to be supporting that Knox is not guilty. The knife that was the supposed "murder weapon" had no blood on it, it didn't match any of the wounds made on Meredith's body, and the knife couldn't have made the bloody imprint that was on the bed. Forensic Scientists never stated that the luminal indicated that it was blood, nor was there any blood found in the apartment that connected the two to the murder, therefore this is also an unreliable source to use for the

Read More

Court Case Of Melissa Barthelemy

1624 Words | 7 Pages

This case lacks evidence because the only evidence law enforcement recovered was victim’s bodies, how they are connected, and several pieces of cheap jewelry on the toddler’s body. All the bodies were placed in the burlap sack or wrapped in plastic sheet. No other DNA was recovered besides the ones of the victims. It is very difficult to prove who is responsible for these murders because of lack of evidence which could link to the killer. Also, the cell phone calls could have been credible evidence, but it did not help because police could not trace phone calls to the suspect.

Read More

Columbine By Dave Cullen

1243 Words | 5 Pages

With ballistics, they observed the ammunition and could project where the victims where, when they were shot and where the criminal was placed. They can also check the ammunition and weapons and trace them to their exact location of the sale and who sold it. Well the only testimonial evidence was all the interviews that happened after the crime, which helped the sheriff’s office put together what had happened. They could not be used to convict the criminals because they committed suicide before they were arrested. The only evidence that was used to convict someone was the ballistics report which helped the police see who sold the guns to Dylan and

Read More

Summary Of The Lyle And Louise Case

904 Words | 4 Pages

The arson evidence relates to the car crash and how the car was burned to hide the evidence. The evidence from the bite mark cleared up my client, John’s story who stated he was in a bar fight the night prior to when being questioned. The use of blood spatter helped investigators determine where the victim was killed in the cabin and how many possible killers there were. Blood detection helped discover what killed the

Read More

Police Operational Strategies

1267 Words | 6 Pages

Doing this, helpws protect the evidence and prevent cross contamination. The crime scene is the physical area where a crime is thought to of occurred and where the evidence of the said crime is thought to reside. Vital evidence to a case, can be found at a crime scene. This includes, fingerprints, DNA, foot prints, bullets, bullet casings, fibers, etc. It is important to determine if a crime has in fact been committed, if so, the officer must initiate enforcement action, by arresting or pursuing the offender or dispatching apprehension information.

Read More

Physical Individual Evidence Paper

525 Words | 3 Pages

Scenario 1: A torn T-shirt was found in the backseat of a suspect’s car. Two pieces of torn cloth were found at the scene of the crime. The type of evidence described is Physical Individual Evidence. The evidence falls under the physical category, because the torn T-shirt was physically found at at the crime scene and in the backseat of the suspect's car. It also falls under individual, because The torn T-shirt led back to one person.

Read More

Murder Of Gaven Brooks Essay

444 Words | 2 Pages

Every day forensic investigators use tactics just like the ones that were discussed throughout the paper. It’s more than just looking for an admission of guilt, and interrogating potential suspects until they

Read More

Pamela Foddrill Tragic Abduction Case Study

2482 Words | 10 Pages

The former being defined as the evidence collected in order to convict or rule out suspects, and the latter being defined as the way the investigators developed the investigation and how it evolved throughout the ensuing years. In order to evaluate these two different subjects, one needs to examine the similarities and differences between this investigation and theories about how investigation of this type develop, the nuances of this investigation not able to be explained by theory, investigatory elements that

Read More

More about Stolen Vehicle Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document