ipl-logo

Sullivan Vs Florida Case Study

466 Words2 Pages

Sullivan vs. Florida was a very high profiled case in 1989. Joe Sullivan was a 13-year-old African American boy, who was also mentally disabled. Joe was accused of sexually assaulting an elderly white woman hours after he and 2 other juveniles robbed her for her jewelry and coins. Joe was the youngest child to be sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. He was tried as an adult because he a prior felony conviction on his record (Sullivan v. Florida). The jury only took 35 minutes to convict Sullivan. Even though there was no physical or biological evidence linking Sullivan to the crime, as well as the lack of testimony from the victim, who was unable to identify her attacker; poor Sullivan was sentenced to life without parole (Agyepong, children left behind …show more content…

Sullivan has tried several times to appeal his conviction, due to the argument that life without parole is unconstitutional. In May of 2009 the U.S Supreme Court will hear his case. During the United States Supreme Court session Sullivan argued that his sentenced was breaking the Constitution of the Eight Amendment of cruel and unusual punishment (Sullivan v. Florida, 2008). Sullivan referred to the Roper v. Simmons (2005) case thought his trial, by saying that life without parole is very similar to the death sentence and even then those offenders at least are offered parole (Sullivan v. Florida, 2008). In a desperate plea to show the difference between juvenile serving life without parole and juvenile death sentenced, Sullivan justified that juveniles who are sentenced to life in prison without parole “constitutional vice involved in punishing children with death was the impropriety of passing a final, condemnatory judgment on a still unformed human being” (Roper v Simmons, 2005, p. 570). Sullivan also pointed out that some laws on children being able to do things without being a certain age such as voting, driving, marriage, tattoos, and the purchasing age of alcohol (Sullivan v.

Show More
Related
835 Words | 4 Pages

Kennedy vs. State of Georgia Kennedy v State of Georgia 172 Ga. App. 336 S.E.2d. 169 (1984) Facts Appellant Henry Xavier Kennedy was charged with first degree arson in September 23, 1981. He appealed this case stating that there was not enough evidence for the jury to convict him. The building that he was found guilty of burning down was his own home, he had two mortgages out on his home and just renewed a home owners insurance policy five days prior to the cabin being burnt down that was a total of forty thousand dollars.

Read More
1281 Words | 6 Pages

Case: South Carolina v. Christopher Frank Pittman (Findlaw, 2008) Facts: That Pittman, shot and morality wounded both his grandparents, Joe Frank and Joy Pittman, with a .410 shotgun. Appellant was 12 years old at time of alleged incident, he was abandoned by his mother, and his relationship with his father was abusive. Prior to moving in with grandparents, appellant had been committed to an inpatient facility, where he was on the antidepressant Paxil, soon he was released and permitted to live with grandparents (Findlaw, 2008). .

Read More
383 Words | 2 Pages

A comparison study of two murders in the state of Ms which are Jones v. State of Mississippi (2009) and Parker v. State of Mississippi (2011) and both of these cases have a lot in common. Brett Jones and Lester Parker are currently in jail for a heinous crime. Not only were they 15 years old juveniles doing the time but they both their grandfathers several times for different reasons and because of that they were charged with first and second degree murder and was sentenced to life without parole. Brett Jones Jr. v. State of Mississippi (2009) Brett Jones stabbed his 68 year old grandfather to death and was sentenced to life without parole but because he was a juvenile at the time he was sentenced to life without the possibility of parole because his 8th amendment was violated.

Read More
406 Words | 2 Pages

In the quiet town of Florida City a robbery took place at Seminole Bank. The robber wore a mask, carried a gun, and got away with $20,000 in cash. Witnesses were unable to identify the robber by his physical appearance because he was wearing a mask. However, the witnesses recognized his voice and identified the robber as Mr. Smallwood. In the case of Smallwood v. State, Mr. Smallwood was accused of armed robbery of Seminole Bank in Florida City, Florida.

Read More
620 Words | 3 Pages

In Turner v. Safley (1987), the Supreme Court ruled in favor of restricting prisoners Constitutional rights. According to the ruling, the restriction of rights is Constitution if “reasonably related to legitimate penological [i.e. safety] interests.” Jeffs communicates sermons and regulations from prison, and limiting the community between Jeffs and the hierarchy of Short Creek attempts to severe ties between Jeffs and the FLDS. Satinder Singh, an ACLU attorney, said “…prisoners can limit communication, including mail and visits….However, the prison can’t suppress Jeffs free speech rights just because it doesn’t like what he has to say (Singh).” While Jeffs ideologies continue to dictate the infrastructure of Short Creek, minimizing communication enhances the chances of stopping the theocratic rule in Short Creek.

Read More
75 Words | 1 Pages

New York Times v. Sullivan (1964) is a significant United States Supreme Court case which held that the court must find proof of actual malice before it can hold the press guilty for defamation as well as libel against any public figure. This was a landmark Supreme Court decision regarding freedom of the press. Mr. Justice Brennan delivered the decision of the Court. In 1960, The New York Times ran a full-page advertisement paid by

Read More
1549 Words | 7 Pages

Polk County’s school system dates from the 1860’s, when Jacob Summerlin established the Summerlin Institute in Bartow, the seat of county government. In 1893, the Institute became the public school of Bartow then the leading education center of Polk County. South Florida Military Institute was founded in 1894 in temporary quarters by General Evander McIvor Law, a confederate veteran. Enrollment was statewide, and the school received partial funding and was brought into the state’s school program. Homeland’s School had one room, one teacher, nine grades, forty-nine pupils in 1905.

Read More
872 Words | 4 Pages

In Roper v. Simmons there are two issues that must be addressed, the first being the issue of moral maturity and culpability. The defense in the trial phase of this case argued that Mr. Simmons was an at an age where he was not responsible enough to fully understand the effects and consequences of his actions. The majority draws on Atkins v. Virginia to argue that this specific precedent supports their case that the death penalty should not be imposed on the mentally immature or impaired. However, an important point to be made is that the Atkins v. Virginia decision is geared towards the clinical definition of mental retardation: significant limitations that limit adaptive skills. Also, another important question to consider is the competency and premeditation of Mr. Simmons’ crime in this case.

Read More
1175 Words | 5 Pages

The narrative begins in 1993 with the sickening murder of Shirley Crook by seventeen-year-old Christopher Simmons. The Missourian had plotted to, “… commit burglary and murder by breaking and entering, tying up the victim, and throwing that victim off a bridge” (543 US 551, at 556-57). When the disfigured body of Mrs. Crook was located, authorities arrested Simmons who quickly confessed to the killing and was sent to court to be tried as an adult. During the trial, both the prosecutor and defense applied Simmons’ age as a justification for their arguments. The defense stated that Simmons’ age was a mitigating factor, citing several legal limitations on the capabilities of minors and in opposition, the prosecutor argued that it was actually

Read More
416 Words | 2 Pages

The verdict in this case generated an epidemic of outrage throughout the world. I agree with the not-guilty verdict on the murder one and two charges; however, the evidence is not as incontrovertible as some have suggested. I also agree that there was some mischaracterization around the 31 days; yet, to trivialize this behavior as simply immature is inaccurate. The way Casey handled the death was inexcusable.

Read More
964 Words | 4 Pages

This is another dissenting opinion that was written by Justice Stevens. This primary source includes Justice Stevens’ analysis and vote. Justice Stevens also concluded that the petitioner’s rights were violated. In his analysis he concluded that racial prejudice was very probable in the petitioner’s sentencing process. This is another opposing view that I have to take into account.

Read More
1210 Words | 5 Pages

557). To understand this ruling, one must understand exactly why life-without-parole sentences for juveniles are considered to be cruel and unusual punishment. In Jackson’s case, for example, the facts show that Jackson did not kill anyone, did not possess any weapons, and did not take anything from the store, yet he was still convicted of capital felony-murder and aggravated robbery. Jackson, a young boy who was presumably influenced by the older boys, was being held responsible for crimes that he did not actually commit. During sentencing, the circumstances of the case and Jackson’s age could not be taken into consideration; the mandatory sentence was just handed down.

Read More
1033 Words | 5 Pages

Wright was a case on the topic of corporal punishment in schools. James Ingraham, an eighth grade student at a school in Miami got in trouble for acting out in the school auditorium. He was sent to the principal’s office, where the administrator decided to give him five swats with a paddle. The student, claiming he had not done anything wrong, refused the punishment. Ingraham was then held down and swatted twenty times with the paddle.

Read More
1118 Words | 5 Pages

The Eighth Amendment It’s a late Autumn afternoon and a young fourteen year old boy is told that he has to pay $24,000 bail for stealing a bag of groceries. This is an unreasonable price to pay for the crime he committed. Luckily for us, the Eighth Amendment protects US citizens from unfair situations such as this one. The Eighth Amendment’s meaning and purpose has left an enduring impact on the citizens of the United States of America.

Read More
747 Words | 3 Pages

For this essay I have picked symbolic speech and a seditious speech. All of these speeches come under the First Amendment of freedom of speech. This is controversial and generates lot of arguments sometimes on a national level. So, what is freedom of speech in reality? It states that “the United States Constitution prevents Congress from making any law respecting an establishment of religion, prohibiting the free exercise of religion, or abridging the freedom of speech, the freedom of the press, the right to peaceably assemble, or to petition for a governmental ...”

Read More

More about Sullivan Vs Florida Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document