ipl-logo

The Explanatory Gap Theory By David Chalmers

660 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Reflection about Neuroplasticity

Many philosophers have debated the nature of the mind and its relationship to the physical world throughout history. They have used many different ways to describe the mind from behaviorism, functionalism, and identity theory. I will be arguing that the most justified theory about the mind is the dualist theory because of consciousness. Consciousness is key to this debate, as it opposes reductionism and supports the reality of mental states without physical form. It shows what makes a human really human.
The first argument I will make is the explanatory gap theory by David Chalmers. The explanatory gap explains the complexity of understanding how physical processes in the brain create a conscious experience. It shows the complexity of understanding …show more content…

Physical observations alone would be insufficient to distinguish you from your zombie counterpart from an outside, third-person perspective. The fact that you have subjective conscious experiences while the zombie twin does not, however, emphasize the explanatory gap in understanding how physical processes alone can give rise to subjective awareness. All the other theories seems to fail at this rational.
Behaviorism, for instance, suggests that mental states can be reduced to observable behaviors and external stimuli-response patterns. However, this approach neglects the subjective experience of consciousness. Consider the scenario of two individuals displaying identical behaviors but having entirely different mental states or conscious experiences. Behaviorism fails to account for these qualitative differences, highlighting the limitations of purely physical …show more content…

While behaviorism, functionalism, and identity theory provide compelling arguments in favor of understanding the mind in purely physical terms, they face challenges in fully accounting for the subjective nature of consciousness. Dualism, on the other hand, offers a framework that acknowledges the distinctiveness of the mind and its capacity for conscious experiences. Despite the critiques leveled against dualism, its ability to accommodate consciousness provides a justifiable alternative to purely physical accounts. Further exploration and interdisciplinary dialogue are necessary to advance our understanding of the mind and its relationship to the

Show More
Related
308 Words | 2 Pages

In Lonely Souls: Causality and Substance Dualism, Jaegwon Kim argues againist Cartesian dualism which are the main argument points that Cartesian dualism cannot reasonably explain just how two things so all in all different as unextended souls and extended bodies can casually interact. Cartesian dualism is developt on properties can be divided into two which they are mental, such as wishing anything or being in pain while physical properties are being in certain weight, shape or mass. No intimate association between physical and mental properties condensed of identity; therefore, Jaegwon supports that whereever we find a mental property that is logically sufficient for a physical effect. Related to his argument topics Jaegwon reassess the

Read More
1476 Words | 6 Pages

However, advancements in the field made it possible to better understand that not only was psychology more complex than concepts of consciousness, but also that there were many other mental aspects at play. Consciousness has since been redefined to express the idea of awareness – both of personal being and the environment that exists around it. It is through cognitive neuroscience, which is the study of the brain in relation to its mental processes, that scientists can better understand the level of consciousness. Knowing how the body reacts at various levels, what human control exists in each and how they contribute to the activities of the brain can likely explain a lot about human behavior. Within cognitive neuroscience, the latest research is able to the show the ways in which brain activity centered on imagined thoughts, personal ideals and concepts and the inner working of this organ direct behavior among individuals of varying backgrounds and physical

Read More
1328 Words | 6 Pages

And the three perspectives i would be discussing in the paper will be: What is Behaviorism? this perspective mostly differs from other approaches because it views that both people and animals are controlled by their environment and specifically that we are the result of what we have learned from our environment. in other words, that it is shaped by our experience. Behaviorism is

Read More
524 Words | 3 Pages

Gertler’s argument defends naturalistic dualism. Naturalistic dualism is the idea that the mental state is existentially separate from the physical state. Dualism’s opposing ideology is physicalism. Physicalism is the idea that the mental and physical state are one in the same. Through this she rejects the identity theory which claims that mental states are ultimately identical to states of the brain and/or central nervous system.

Read More
725 Words | 3 Pages

This would obviously rely on the claim that our mind is our brain or that the brain is our mind. The view known as Dualism argues against this belief. Dualism is the view that there are two types of reality that exist; material (physical) and immaterial

Read More
1919 Words | 8 Pages

Conclusion: The mind is substantively different from the body and indeed matter in general. Because in this conception the mind is substantively distinct from the body it becomes plausible for us to doubt the intuitive connection between mind and body. Indeed there are many aspects of the external world that do not appear to have minds and yet appear none the less real in spite of this for example mountains, sticks or lamps, given this we can begin to rationalize that perhaps minds can exist without bodies, and we only lack the capacity to perceive them.

Read More
2113 Words | 9 Pages

Psycho functionalism bases the identity of mental states on underlying cognitive mechanisms in (scientific hypotheses about) the brain as well as the

Read More
1185 Words | 5 Pages

There is a variety of different sports, including cheerleading. Imagine playing a sport such as basketball or football, with nobody to cheer athletes on or motivate players to win. Most high schools with football or basketball teams also have cheerleaders. Whether cheerleading is a sport or not is a well known issue, likely to be discussed. The enthusiastic girls with pom-poms, white shoes, and skirts, those are cheerleaders.

Read More
1372 Words | 6 Pages

Dualism is a Cartesian thesis that is most typically understood as the separation of two opposing forms of being, the separation of the mind (conscious state) and the body (Simons, 2016). The concept of dualism is elaborately illustrated throughout the film titled ‘Ghost in the shell’ (Sanders, R., Hall, J., Masamune, S., Moss, J., Wheeler, W., & Kruger, E. (2017). Dualism plays a role in developing the story of the protagonist and is essential in building the narrative of this film, it also provides visual examples of the realistic functioning of dualism, however presented in an abstract way. The main story throughout the film follows the protagonist ‘Major’ later named ‘Motoko’ who’s mind was placed inside a robotic shell after her body was damaged, she functioned as a human mentally, but, as something inhuman physically. A) How the film utilizes Dualism to

Read More
785 Words | 4 Pages

In the realm of Philosophy, different views about the definition of the mind and its interactions exist. Among the many, Dualism stands as one of the most debatable, thanks to its position about the relationship of the mind and body, and its repercussions. This assignment discusses the dualist relationship between the mind and the body, as well as its impact on the individual free will. It asserts Interventionism as an extension of Dualism, as well as an alternative to Determinism. The objective of this endeavor is to present the Dualist approach to Mind and Body as an alternative or possible solution to the dilemma of Determinism.

Read More
1861 Words | 8 Pages

However, due to the limitation of skills, most of the researches done are not well designed. A main limitation of psychology as a field of study is that it never captures the nature of consciousness (Willig, 2013), as human mind is bound up with meanings and interpretations which differ from one individual to another

Read More
526 Words | 3 Pages

Various philosophers and scientists have inquired about the mind and body issue for a long time. The mind-body philosophies try to explain the way a person’s mental state and processes are linked to the physical state. The core of the mind and body is that individuals have a biased experience of an inner life that appears detached from the physical world. Although they are separated, they need to work together in some way. Individuals may appear to have physical properties and mental properties.

Read More
1104 Words | 5 Pages

In addition, the causal role for mentality is removed. So it could be argued that theory that the mind causes behavior is equivalent to theory that the mind is behavior. The behaviorist theory solves the inverted qualia theory by the defining mental states in reference to their associated behaviours instead of of by reference to their conscious qualities thereby avoiding the inverted qualia problem altogether concluding that if two people behave as If they both see the same color then they probably do. (Jessica Lerm, personal communication, April 9, 2015).

Read More
703 Words | 3 Pages

This paper will critically examine the Cartesian dualist position and the notion that it can offer a plausible account of the mind and body. Proposed criticisms deal with both the logical and empirical conceivability of dualist assertions, their incompatibility with physical truths, and the reducibility of the position to absurdity. Cartesian Dualism, or substance dualism, is a metaphysical position which maintains that the mind and body consist in two separate and ontologically distinct substances. On this view, the mind is understood to be an essentially thinking substance with no spatial extension; whereas the body is a physical, non-thinking substance extended in space. Though they share no common properties, substance dualists maintain

Read More
1457 Words | 6 Pages

What is the Mind? Introduction To try and explore the ‘mind’ it is necessary to examine if the mind and the brain are separate or if the mind and body are distinct from one another? Is the mind and body separate substance or elements of the same substance? Is consciousness the result of the mechanisms of the brain, wholly separate from the brain or inextricably linked?

Read More

More about The Explanatory Gap Theory By David Chalmers

Related Topics

Open Document